Author: Catholic Candle
Should Catholics Pay Taxes, Especially to a Government that Uses Tax Revenue Badly?
Catholic Candle note: Below, a reader asks about paying income taxes.
A reader sent to Catholic Candle the cluster of comments and questions in the following four indented paragraphs (quoted immediately below):
Q. In terms of specifics what can you say about our current situation regarding the payment of annual personal income taxes to the IRS? There is strong evidence brought out in actual legal cases that the tax is illegal and even unconstitutional.
Aside from that, there is the question as to whether it is just in terms of the exorbitance of it in many cases, not to mention the extreme evil that so much of the money goes towards funding. Give to Caesar what is Caesar’s, but if Caesar is an outright thief operating under the cover of the law, however unjust it may be in its actual exercise thereof, is it really fair to say it is Caesar’s in the first place? (The evil “powers that be” already rob the public unjustly in the form of inflation!)
And then comes the crunch on the 1040 that actually calls for our signature to affirm that what we have put down on the form is all truthful! [Would this be] a time for a legitimate use of mental reservation? Ugh!
Just a few thoughts of my own to which I hope you can shed some concrete light on too.
A. Good questions! In substance, these are perennial questions probably asked by people for millennia concerning the taxes levied by their own governments.
We understand that you are asking six questions, which we take to be as follows:
-
Is it immoral, in principle, for a government to require payment of income taxes?
-
Is it illegal or unconstitutional for the U.S. government to require payment of income taxes because income taxes were never authorized by the laws, due to a failure or deficiency in the U.S. Constitution or laws?
-
If income taxes are not evil in principle, is the current level of taxation immoral because it is excessive?
-
If the taxes are excessive, is it moral for us to refuse to pay them?
-
Even if income taxes are not evil in principle, nonetheless, should we not pay them because the government uses the revenue from those taxes to pay for evil things?
-
Is it moral for a person to use “mental reservation” or put falsehoods on his tax return to avoid paying unjust amounts of taxes?
We will answer these questions in order.
1. Is it Immoral, in Principle, for a Government to Require its People to Pay Income Taxes?
Short answer: No.
Explanation:
a.
Government is a Good Institution which is Willed by God.
Various modern thinkers teach that government is a “necessary evil”. For example, Thomas Paine, the American Revolutionary, falsely asserted that government is always bad. Here are his words:
Society in every state is a blessing, but government even in its best state, is but a necessary evil; in its worst state, an intolerable one.1
But that position is false. Government is a natural institution, created by God through the way He created human nature. This means that God wills for there to be government and He created man to be a social and political animal.
God made man a social animal – that is, to congregate and live together like bees, ants, and deer. But much more than that! God also made man a political animal – to use his reason to coordinate and to cooperate on projects which are for the Common Good and in their common interests.
The Great Philosopher Aristotle explains:
A city is a natural production, and … man is naturally a political animal. … The gift of speech also evidently proves that man is a more social animal than the bees, or any of the herding cattle: for nature, as we say, does nothing in vain, and man is the only animal who enjoys it [viz., speech].2
St. Thomas Aquinas, greatest Doctor of the Catholic Church and greatest of all thinkers, teaches the same thing, following Aristotle:
It is evident … that the political community exists by nature, and that human beings are by nature political animals. And those who live outside a political community because of their nature and not by misfortune are either wicked or superhuman, the wicked like those condemned by Homer as unsocial, lawless, and criminal. For such persons are by their nature also bent on war, being free of restraint like birds in flight.
And human beings are clearly political animals more than bees and other animals living in groups are. For nature does nothing in vain, as people say, and only human beings, in contrast with other animals, use speech. Therefore, expressions of sadness and pleasure are signs and so also belong to other animals. For the nature of other animals is such as to have sense experiences of sadness and pleasure and to signify these experiences to one another. But speech indicates what is useful or harmful, and so also what is just or unjust. For, strictly speaking, it belongs to human beings alone, in contrast with other animals, to perceive good and evil, just and unjust, and the like. And communicating these perceptions produces households and political communities.3
So government is natural and is willed by God. Therefore, government, as such, is a good thing (even though it can be abused). Government is not a “necessary evil”, as Thomas Paine and some other modern thinkers wrongly held.4
b. Governments are
Entitled to Collect Taxes.
Because government is a good institution and has operations it must perform (for example, defending the nation or kingdom from invasion), therefore government is entitled to charge taxes – i.e., to collect money to use to do its job. For this reason, Our Lord taught:
Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s; and to God, the things that are God’s.
St. Matthew’s Gospel, 22:21.
c. Well, What About
Government Collecting Income Taxes in
Particular?
Income tax is one way that reasonable taxes can be levied, although it is not the only possible way.
Catholic Candle is not aware of any argument based on reason or based on Catholic teaching which shows that it is unjust, in principle, for the government to tax its people on this basis (viz., levy income taxes).
One argument in favor of income tax (as a proper source of government taxation) is based on government’s duty to protect its citizens’ property. Because it seems plausible that a person who has more income would tend to have more need for the protection of his property (because he has more property or its value is greater), it does not seem unreasonable for the government to use a person’s income level as a rough approximation of a particular person’s need of government services. Looked at this way, a citizen would pay more taxes because he needs more protective services.
d. Conclusion:
It does not seem that it is unjust or immoral in principle, for a government to charge reasonable income taxes and for citizens to be obliged to pay reasonable income taxes.
2. Is it Illegal or Unconstitutional for the U.S. Government to Require Payment of Income Taxes Because Income Taxes Were Never Authorized by the Laws, Due to a Failure or Deficiency in the U.S. Constitution?
As far as the legality of income taxes, one could ask whether the U.S. Constitution’s 16th Amendment (authorizing income taxes) was ever legally ratified. (The U.S. government declared that this Amendment’s was ratified in 1913.) Rightly or wrongly, for many decades, various people have asserted this lack of valid ratification.
For over 40 years, some members of the Catholic Candle Team have been hearing the assertion from various people that Americans have no obligation to pay income taxes because this amendment to the Constitution was not validly or correctly ratified. But these Catholic Candle Team members have never received convincing evidence which supports such assertions, despite encountering many persons who attempted to provide such evidence.
a. Practical Reality
Interposes Itself
However, even if a person were to suppose that the 16th Amendment was never ratified, look at the practical reality of the situation. What is perfectly clear is that the claim (viz., that the 16th Amendment is void) would never win in court. This non-ratification argument has lost so often in court that the judges summarily reject it without any fresh examination, whenever the argument is again presented to the courts. For example, in the 2009 federal appellate case, U.S. v. Benson, the court stated:
[W]e have repeatedly rejected the claim that the Sixteenth Amendment was improperly ratified. One would think this repeated rejection of [the substance of the taxpayer’s] Sixteenth Amendment argument would put the matter to rest. …
We find it hard to understand why the long and unbroken line of cases upholding the constitutionality of the Sixteenth Amendment generally, and those specifically rejecting the argument advanced [by the defendant], have not persuaded [him] and his compatriots to seek a more effective forum for airing their attack on the federal income tax structure [viz., seeking to overturn the tax laws through the legislative branch of government].5
Further, the court’s opinion in the Benson case characterized as a “nutty opinion” that the 16th Amendment has not been properly ratified.6
Clearly, a citizen would never win in court in today’s legal milieu. Therefore, at the time of the government’s choosing, he will be hauled into court for the punishment that the government chooses to inflict upon him.
b. Be a Martyr for
Christ, Not a “Martyr” for Money or Politics
So this non-ratification argument would not protect a person in a practical way from the strong arm of the government enforcing its asserted tax laws (regardless of whatever technically-correct arguments we might suppose there to be).
But we are on earth to save our souls. Even if the government were beyond its rights and authority to collect income taxes, nonetheless, if you are going to be arrested for something, make sure that it is because you are a faithful and informed Catholic rather than because of money.
As the Book of Wisdom declares:
I preferred her [viz., wisdom] before kingdoms and thrones, and esteemed riches nothing in comparison to her. Neither did I compare unto her any precious stone: for all gold in comparison to her, is as a little sand; and silver in respect to her shall be counted as clay.7
Consider this: Suppose a man is walking in a dark alley and is confronted by an armed robber demanding his wallet. Although that robber is acting unjustly, a man’s right to keep his wallet is not the principle for which he should die. At issue is merely money. The robber is sinning. But the victim of the robbery is not sinning by handing over his wallet rather than being murdered.
Similarly, even if it were true that the government is unjust in the taxes it collects, nonetheless, it is not a sin for a person to hand over the money compulsorily demanded of him in order that he avoids incarceration (however unjust). Remaining out of jail would provide a man many advantages for serving God and saving his soul.
So if a Catholic goes to jail for the Holy Catholic Faith, blessed is he! But if he goes to jail to avoid paying money (taxes), that seems imprudent and seems to show his misplaced priorities in life.
c. Regardless of
Technicalities, Citizens Have a Duty to Pay
Taxes
Further, let us recall what we saw above – viz., that government has a right to collect a reasonable amount of taxes – in fairness (equity). This is because God wills that there be government and He wills that this government receive reasonable revenue to use to perform its proper work (e.g., defending the country).
Therefore, even if there were a technical mistake that effectively nullifies all tax laws (so that there is no tax law validly “on the books”), nonetheless, we have a duty to support the government by paying reasonable taxes. This is our duty in conscience regardless of a detail missing which nullifies the law.
To illustrate this equitable principle, suppose the following fact scenario:
Suppose your neighbor hired professional painters to paint his home. Suppose you looked out your window and noticed those painters had parked their vehicles near your home. They set up for work at your home and then began painting your house – (which, suppose, was truly in great need of paint). You could have stopped the painters but delightedly watched while they painted your house – which they did because they mistook your home for your neighbor’s home. Although you do not have a painting contract with them, you still have a duty in fairness to pay them for the benefit you received.
d. Applicability of This
Explanation to Readers in Other
Countries
Although this discussion has been about a claim regarding the U.S. Constitution in particular, readers in other countries would have the equivalent issue if there were any kind of technical, legalistic argument for not paying taxes in their own countries, assuming that the governments of those countries enforced their tax codes as the U.S. does. The physical force of government would still compel them to pay taxes and their equitable duty would require payment of reasonable taxes also.
3. If Income Taxes are Not Evil in Principle, is the Current Level of Taxation Immoral Because it is Excessive?
And:
4. If the Taxes are Excessive, Is It Moral for Us to Refuse to Pay Them?
As we saw above, a citizen has the duty to pay reasonable taxes.
However, it is prudent for a citizen to pay even more than a reasonable amount of taxes if the alternative is to be sentenced to a long jail term.
But how much is reasonable to pay in taxes? That is a question requiring considerable prudence and is a determination very heavily dependent upon the particular facts of the situation.
For example, when the Muslim horde surrounded Vienna in 1683 and laid siege to the city, the government would seem to have had a reasonable claim to levy very high taxes upon its citizens in order to defend the city in that crisis, as compared to the taxes which would be levied in a time of peace.
Further, it would be unreasonable for every citizen to be allowed to act upon his own judgment regarding the correct level of taxes because:
-
He does not have all necessary information and has less information than the government does on the issue of the level of taxes that are appropriate, considering:
-
The level of government services needed throughout the entire realm;
-
The cost of these services under expected conditions;
-
Alternative government payment sources;
-
Competing government expenditure needs; and
-
The expected foreseeable timeframe for the services.
-
Besides an individual citizen’s lack of information, he is also usually less skilled than government personnel in making such a judgment because they are professionals who are usually more experienced in making such determinations;
-
The individual citizen would be “judging his own case” and would be self-interested in making this judgment because he personally benefits depending upon the assumptions he uses and the determinations he makes; and
-
If every citizen made his own judgment, this would result in chaos and lack of uniformity.
Thus, the taxes levied by the government must be reasonable but citizens should consider the range of reasonable taxes to be a broad range and not be quick to substitute their own evaluation in place of the government’s determination.
This is like the fact that the government has the duty to be reasonable in setting speed limits on the roads. But citizens should consider the range of reasonable speed limits to be a broad range. Drivers should not be quick to ignore the speed limit on the assertion that their own judgment on the matter is more reasonable than the government’s determination.8
5. If Income Taxes Are Not Evil in Principle, Should We Not Pay Them Because the Government Wastes Tax Money or Uses It to Pay for Evil Things?
It takes great prudence to determine if (or when) a government is wasting so much money or is spending so much on causes that are evil, that a citizen should refuse to pay his reasonable share of the tax burden.
Let us look at the Roman Empire during the time at which Our Lord told us to “render unto Caesar”. The Roman Empire was not clearly less wasteful or spending less for evil purposes, as compared to our modern governments. In Our Lord’s time, the Romans spent large amounts of money:
-
On foreign wars that were not plainly necessary. (Does this sound familiar?)
-
On grain subsidies and other handouts and freebies to the people. (Does this sound familiar?)
-
On public games and entertainment for the people. (Does this sound familiar?)
-
On building and maintaining pagan temples and in other ways promoting false gods.
Yet, in this context, Our Lord teaches us that we should render taxes unto Caesar.
So, we should at least not be quicker than Our Lord was to jump to the determination that the government wastes so much money or spends it on so many things that are evil, that Caesar should not be paid.
6. Is it Moral for a Person to Use “Mental Reservation” or Put Falsehoods on His Tax Return to Avoid Paying Unjust Amounts of Taxes?
The phrase “mental reservation” can have multiple meanings. Here is one of them from Encyclopedia.com:
Mental Reservation, … in the strict sense it means giving utterance to only part of one’s judgment while retaining in mind or whispering inaudibly another part necessary to make the statement objectively truthful. In the classical example, Titius privately said to a woman that he would take her for his wife, although he had no intention of marrying her. Later, when asked by a judge whether he had said he would take the woman for his wife, he replied that he had not, understanding that he had not spoken the words with the intention of marrying the woman.9
But whatever definition a person uses for so-called “mental reservation”, he should never lie.
To tell a lie is always evil and sinful. No end ever justifies a sinful means. Even if we were to suppose that a person had the very highest of all motives – which is to promote the glory of God – that would still never justify a lie.
Here is the very striking way in which St. Thomas Aquinas, greatest Doctor of the Catholic Church, teaches this truth:
A lie must be shunned to such an extent that, even if it seemed that the lie would increase the glory of God, we should still not tell a lie.10
Let us consider an example: Suppose a pagan were on his deathbed with only minutes to live. Suppose also that we happen to know that he would convert to the Catholic Faith and agree to baptism if we were to tell him a small (so-called) “harmless” lie, such as that the dog he loved would go to heaven. We can never justify even such a (so-called) “white” lie even to save his soul.
Further the Book of Ecclesiasticus infallibly teaches us:
Be not willing to make any manner of lie: for the custom thereof is not good.11
St. Augustine, Doctor of the Church, teaches:
Since every man withdraws from eternity in so far as he withdraws from truth, it is most absurd to say that by so withdrawing one is able to arrive at any good. Or, if there appears to be an eternal good which truth does not embrace, it will not be true; therefore, because it is false, it will not be good.
Besides, as the mind must be preferred to the body, so truth must be preferred by the mind, so that not only does the mind seek truth more than it seeks the body, but even more than it seeks itself.12
Lastly, Pope Innocent XI, in the bull Sanctissimus Dominus, condemned the following propositions:
25. If a man has cause for it, whether it be small or great, he may lawfully swear without an intention of swearing. Condemned.
26. A man either alone or before others, may either when he is asked, or of his own accord, or for his diversion, or any other end swear that he did not do a thing which he really did; having a secret meaning, either of some other thing which he did not do, or of another way of doing it, or of any other truth which he adds to it; in which case he is in truth neither a liar, nor is he perjured. Condemned.
27. A just cause of using those secret meanings is as oft as it is necessary or profitable for the preservation of life, or honor, or saving one’s goods, or for any other act of virtue; so that the concealment of truth seems in that case expedient or desirable.13 Condemned.
Conclusions
-
We have a duty to pay reasonable taxes to our government.
-
It is difficult to determine the amount of tax which is reasonable. This determination requires great prudence and a careful knowledge of many circumstances which are often known better to the government than to an individual citizen.
-
Our Lord taught people that they should pay taxes to the Roman Empire despite a rather high level of government waste and also spending for evil purposes. Our modern governments are not clearly worse than the Roman Empire and we should not be quick to refuse to pay taxes based on government waste and evil expenditures.
-
Even if the government demands taxes which are higher than are reasonable, we should pay them rather than suffer significant punishment (e.g., incarceration) if that punishment would be a serious obstacle to our serving God and saving our souls. If we are martyred, let it be for Christ rather than “martyred” for money or for politics.
-
We must never tell a lie for any reason. If we tell a lie, it is still a sin even if we label our words as “mental reservation”.
1 Thomas Paine, Of the Origin and Design of Government in general, with concise Remarks on the English Constitution, from his pamphlet series entitled Common Sense (emphasis added).
2 Aristotle’s Politics, Book 1, Ch.1, #1253a1–11 (bracketed word added for clarity).
3 St. Thomas Aquinas, Commentary on Aristotle’s Politics, Book 1, Ch.1, #1253a1–11.
4 For an explanation why it is always wrong to revolt and why Catholics are not revolutionaries, read this article: https://catholiccandle.org/2021/02/01/revolution-is-in-the-air/ (Emphasis added.)
5 U.S. v. Benson, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, Cases Nos. 08-1312 and 08-1586, decided: April 06, 2009 available here: https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/us-7th-circuit/1137787.html (emphasis added).
6 U.S. v. Benson, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, Cases Nos. 08-1312 and 08-1586, decided: April 06, 2009 available here: https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/us-7th-circuit/1137787.html (emphasis added).
7 Book of Wisdom, 7:8-9.
8 The civil law is binding in conscience. Read the explanation of this truth in Summa, Ia IIae, Q.96, a.4.
https://www.encyclopedia.com/religion/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/mental-reservation
10 Here is the Latin:
Adeo enim vitanda sunt mendacia, ut etiam si cedere videantur ad landem Dei, non sunt dicenda.
St. Thomas Aquinas’ Lectures on St. John’s Gospel, ch.13, lecture #3, section #1776.
11 Ecclesiasticus, 7:14.
12 St. Augustine, On Lying, ch.7.
13 Bull Sanctissimus Dominus, Pope Innocent XI, in 1679 (emphasis added).
Lesson #61 About the Temperaments – Part XXVII – The Devil Uses Gluttony to Prevent Us from Having a Life of Deep Prayer and Deep Thinking
Catholic Candle note: Catholic Candle published a series of articles on gluttony as a vice and as an obstacle to spiritual progress and to salvation. You can find those prior articles at these links:
-
What is Gluttony? https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/what-is-gluttony
-
Conquering Gluttony Occurs at the Beginning of the Spiritual Life: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/we-remain-at-the-beginning-of-the-spiritual-life-until-we-conquer-gluttony
-
Gluttony is a Most Disgraceful Vice: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/gluttony-is-a-most-disgraceful-vice
-
The Wisdom of Ecclesiasticus Against Gluttony:
https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/the-wisdom-of-ecclesiasticus-against-gluttony
-
The Spiritual Benefits of Not Consuming Sweets and Snacks Alone: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/the-spiritual-benefits-of-not-consuming-sweets-and-junkfood-when-you-are-alone
-
The Leftists’ Defense of the Vice of Gluttony: https://catholiccandle.org/2023/09/27/the-leftists-defense-of-the-vice-of-gluttony
Below
is another article about gluttony, but with a different focus. This
article shows gluttony is a trap of the devil which he uses to attack
our rational nature and our ability to think deeply.
Mary’s School of Sanctity
Lesson #62 – About the Temperaments, Part XXVII – The Devil Uses Gluttony to Prevent Us from Having a Life of Deep Prayer and Deep Thinking
Because the devil does not want any of us to think deeply and to love reasoning, no person of any temperament is immune from the devil’s wily deceits to lure us away from the life of reason. Previously,1 we discussed some tricks that the devil uses to lure our minds away from serious and deep thinking. Now let us consider the devil’s age-old tactics to entice us through our bodies (and passions) as a means to pull us away from the life of reason.
We see the devil using this tactic with Our Lord and we see how Our Lord responds to the devil, returning the focus to the greater and higher importance of spiritual and intellectual matters as compared to food and our bodily needs:
Then Jesus was led by the spirit into the desert, to be tempted by the devil. And when he had fasted forty days and forty nights, afterwards he was hungry. And the tempter coming said to him: If thou be the Son of God, command that these stones be made bread. Who answered and said: It is written, Not in bread alone doth man live, but in every word that proceedeth from the mouth of God.
St. Matthew’s Gospel, 4:1-4.
Below,
in this lesson, we will discuss the devil’s attempt to divert us
from high intellectual and spiritual matters through a common and
rudimentary trap: gluttony.
Fighting Physical Allurements
In both the Old and New Testaments, God plainly tells man to fast because this is such a powerful means of strengthening his will and clarifying his intellect, as well as curbing and training his passions.
Because of the fall of Adam, man has the wounds caused by Original Sin. Concupiscence of the flesh is one of these wounds.2 Also, because man is composed of body and soul, what affects one part of him also affects the other part. In other words, what affects the soul also affects the body – and vice versa. Thus, man’s bodily disorders affect his soul.
St. Thomas Aquinas explains that the effects of intemperance include the dulling of a man’s reason, and the weakening of his will. He further warns us that gluttony leads to lust.3 The devil tempts man to gluttony in order to inflict precisely these harms. This vice weighs down a man’s soul so much, and fills him with a fear so great (often instigated by the devil), that he loses the courage to fight against this vice.
St. Augustine recounts these very harms suffered in his own soul. He was a glutton and the slavery to this vice led him also to the slavery of lust. Addressing God, St. Augustine explains, in the following words, how he was a slave to his lower nature:
Overeating
has sometimes crept up on Thy servant. … [I]t is not any
uncleanness in the meat that I fear but the uncleanness of my own
gluttony.
…4
I sighed and longed to be delivered, but was kept fast-bound, not with exterior chains or irons, but with my own iron will. The enemy held my will, and of it he had made a chain, with which he had fettered me fast. For, from a perverse will was created wicked desire or lust, and the serving this lust produced custom, and custom not resisted produced a kind of necessity with which, by certain [chain] links fastened one to another, I was kept close-shackled in this cruel slavery.5
St. Augustine explained further that the “load of the world agreeably kept me down”6 and so he delayed his conversion and any serious attempts to discipline his passions. St. Augustine describes how he struggled with himself. He was ashamed of himself and yet still did not have the courage to convert. He wrote:
I now was enraged at myself that I did not courageously at once resolve on what my reason convinced me to be so good and necessary to be done. I would … and I would not. I was, as it were, divided between myself and myself; I shook my chain with which I was fettered, but could not be released from it.7
What
St. Augustine is describing here is true for the glutton and
especially one whose gluttony is deeply rooted and has led him into
the vice of lust. As was true of St. Augustine, such a person’s
vices are so entrenched that he tells himself that he cannot give
those vices up. What is really
happening in that struggle is that, because of a man’s passions, he
“lies to himself” that it is impossible to give up his vice. As
with St. Augustine, the man will not change until he ceases to lie to
himself and begins telling his passions “no!”
He must not yield to his passions and must reject their deceptive
siren song. As was true of St. Augustine during this early part of
his life, the vicious man capitulates to the “screaming” demands
of his passions because he does not sufficiently will to let go of
his vice.
Our Fight Against Gluttony – With God’s Help
God, being the Sculptor of souls, helps the glutton to feel more and more embarrassed about his vice. This helps him to begin to seek a way to escape the chains of his vice.
Further, God leads the person to see that he cannot rid himself of his vice without God’s assistance. In this manner the vicious man sees that he must have recourse to prayer. Also, he sees that he must do the penance of fasting to gain strength.
This
is exactly what happened to St. Augustine. When he realized with
humility that he was not going to be able to fight his vices entirely
by his own effort – i.e.,
without God’s help – his fears about converting vanished and he
fully embraced the life of prayer and penance.
Fasting and Temperance Heal the Harm Caused by Gluttony
St. Thomas Aquinas, quoting St. Augustine, tells us how powerful fasting is for the soul:
Fasting cleanses the soul, raises the mind, subjects one’s flesh to the spirit, renders the heart contrite and humble, scatters the clouds of concupiscence, quenches the fire of lust, kindles the true light of chastity.8
We can see from these words how fasting reverses the damage that intemperance causes in the soul. Fasting makes the mind keener and strengthens the will to do good. The devil knows this and does not want us to fast. He does not want our minds to become sharper so that we will enjoy using them more. Likewise, fasting helps to strengthen our resolve to improve – and the devil certainly does not want that either!
With our minds keener and our wills stronger, we incline more towards God. Prayer becomes easier and gradually becomes truly enjoyable. Our hearts grow in love for God. Well does Satan know the truth of these effects in us and does everything in his power to prevent them from occurring!
It is no wonder then that Satan does not want man to conquer his flesh. He fears that a man will think deeply and be able to use his reason well. So, in our busy world, the devil constantly lures people into focusing on food and sensual self–gratification. Consequently, the devil promotes all kinds of “fad” food in order to distract people from their true end, namely, God. Satan even goes so far as to tempt people that they “need” to have certain foods and drinks in order to be healthy. Here are some examples:
-
So-called “protein bars” which are, basically, “glorified” candy bars;
-
Granola bars;
-
Energy bars;
-
So-called “protein drinks” which are, basically, shakes “in disguise”;
-
Sports drinks;
-
Energy drinks;
-
“Plant-based meat”;
-
Frozen yogurt;
-
Yogurt-covered snacks;
-
Veggie chips; and
-
Trail mix.
In
our last lesson,9
we asked ourselves a series of questions regarding our use of
creatures. So here too, we should be aware of how we use food and
drink, which are creatures of God. We should examine ourselves to
see if we have inordinate attachments to them. We should be guided
by the Church’s traditional rules for fasting and abstinence.10
We should faithfully and generously follow those rules to the best
of our abilities.
Encouragements Which Help Us to Fight the Lower Part of Our Nature
We should remind ourselves how fasting will help our souls so very much. Fasting helps us fight our concupiscence which had led us into the bestial vice of gluttony.
Another aspect of this battle to conquer ourselves is to remind ourselves of the rewards, fruits, joys, and the love we gain by winning this victory over ourselves. Not only in final beatitude but even in this life we are rewarded. By penance and fasting, we become more lucid and more reasonable. We have more stamina and strength—both spiritual and physical; our hearts grow warmer in our love of God and neighbor. We find that we better understand the meaning of our prayers. Our interest in, and attraction to, spiritual things grows keener.
We should remind ourselves that this better direction in our lives requires that we have the spirit of penance – generously lived. Daily sacrifices; pondering deeply upon the lives of Our Lord, Our Lady, and St. Joseph; spiritual reading and discussions; all help to make us and keep us as willing soldiers fighting in the “trenches” of the Church Militant and keep us focused on our life’s goal – which is heaven.
Plus,
these practices keep us enthused about being Catholics and living the
Catholic life. In short, all these aspects help us to become and to
remain faithful and uncompromising Catholics who humbly thank God for
His many blessings.
A Preview…
Having considered how the devil tries to lure all souls into gluttony, in our next lesson we will take a brief look into other pleasures and distractions which the devil uses to entice us away from a life of deep thinking and prayer.
Catholic
Candle note:
The above article is Part XXVII of the study of the temperaments,
starting with the Choleric temperament. Here are links to the first
twenty-six parts:
-
Part I: Beginning our study of the choleric temperament: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/08/27/lesson-35-about-the-temperaments-the-choleric-temperament/
-
Part II: A general overview of the weaknesses of the Choleric Temperament: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/09/26/lesson-37-about-the-temperaments-continuation-of-the-choleric-temperament/
-
Part III: A consideration of the pride of the Choleric Temperament: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/10/24/lesson-38-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat/
-
Part IV: A general discussion of anger as a passion – in order to establish a foundation for studying anger in the Choleric Temperament: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/11/26/lesson-39-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat-part-iv/
-
Part V: Concerning the motivations for anger: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/12/30/lesson-40-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat-part-v/
-
Part VI: Concerning what anger does to the body: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/01/27/lesson-41-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-vi/
-
Part VII: Explaining when anger is sinful: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/02/21/lesson-42-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-vii/
-
Part VIII: Explaining how being slighted provokes anger: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/03/27/lesson-42-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-viii/
-
Part IX: Explaining how anger turns into the sin of holding a grudge: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/04/23/lesson-44-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-ix/
-
Part X: Recommendations to help cholerics to overcome pride: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/05/20/lesson-45-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-x/
-
Part XI: Explaining how a person sins by not using his reason: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/06/28/lesson-46-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xi/
-
Part XII: Explaining some reasons why a choleric does not use his reason properly: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/07/24/lesson-47-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xii/
-
Part XIII: Explaining why the choleric fears to use his reason well: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/08/29/lesson-48-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xiii/
-
Part XIV: Explaining generally how Satan targets our fallen and weakened intellects: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/09/24/lesson-49-temperaments-choleric-temperament-the-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xiv/
-
Part XV: Explaining the passions in general, to lay the foundation for our consideration of the passion of fear: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/10/26/3050/
-
Part XVI: Explaining fear as a passion: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/11/25/lesson-51-temperaments-choleric-temperament-the-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xvi/
-
Part XVII: Explaining how fear works in the soul and influences all of the temperaments: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/12/29/lesson-52-temperaments-choleric-temperament-the-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xvii/
-
Part XVIII: Explaining how pain and death are objects of fear for persons of any temperament: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/01/26/lesson-53-temperaments-choleric-temperament-pain-and-death-are-objects-of-fearf-any-temperament/
-
Part XIX: Explaining in what way sin is an object of fear for all temperaments: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/02/26/lesson-54-temperaments-choleric-temperament-whether-sin-is-an-object-of-fear-for-all-temperaments/
-
Part XX: Explaining the causes of fear – applying to all temperaments: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/03/31/marys-school-of-sanctity-3/
-
Part XXI: Explaining the effects of fear in all temperaments: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/04/26/about-the-temperaments-part-xxi-explaining-the-effects-of-fear-in-all-temperaments/
-
Part XXII: Explaining how to order our loves so we can use the passion of fear properly, and how the devil attempts to prevent this ordering: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/05/28/about-the-temperaments-part-xxii-how-to-order-our-loves-so-we-can-use-the-passion-of-fear-properly/
-
Part XXIII: Explanation of sloth in order to analyze this snare of Satan and to combat him: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/06/26/about-the-temperaments-part-xxiii-explanation-of-sloth-in-order-to-analyze-this-snare-of-satan/
-
Part XXIV: Explaining more about how the devil tries to draw us away from reasoning and from the things of God: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/07/29/about-the-temperaments-part-xiv-how-the-devil-draws-us-away-from-reasoning-and-the-things-of-god/
-
Part XXV – Explaining the Devil Attempts to Destroy Our Prayer-Life and How We Should Counterattack: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/08/31/lesson-60-about-the-temperaments-part-xxv-the-devil-attempts-to-destroy-our-prayer-life/
-
Part XXVI – Explaining how the devil uses worldliness to harm or destroy a person’s deep prayer life: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/09/28/lesson-61-about-the-temperaments-part-xxv-the-fight-against-worldliness-which-is-a-huge-detriment-to-a-deep-prayer-life/
1 Read this article: Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #61 About the Temperaments – Part XXVI – The Fight against Worldliness which is a Huge Detriment to a Deep Prayer Life: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/09/28/lesson-61-about-the-temperaments-part-xxv-the-fight-against-worldliness-which-is-a-huge-detriment-to-a-deep-prayer-life/
2 For all that is in the world, is the concupiscence of the flesh, and the concupiscence
of
the eyes, and the pride of life, which is not of the Father, but is
of the world. 1 John,
2:16.
3 St. Thomas explains these points fully in the Summa, IIa IIae, Q.148, a.6.
4 St. Augustine’s Confessions, Book 10, Ch. 31.
5
St.
Augustine’s
Confessions,
Book 8, Ch.5.
6
Butler’s Lives
of the Saints,
vol. 3, entry August 28, quoting St.
Augustine’s
Confessions.
7 Butler’s Lives of the Saints, vol. 3, entry August 28, quoting St. Augustine’s Confessions, Book 8, Ch.11.
8
Summa, IIa
IIae, Q.147, a.1, Respondeo.
9 Read this article: Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #61 About the Temperaments – Part XXVI – The Fight against Worldliness which is a Huge Detriment to a Deep Prayer Life: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/09/28/lesson-61-about-the-temperaments-part-xxv-the-fight-against-worldliness-which-is-a-huge-detriment-to-a-deep-prayer-life/
Use the pre-Vatican II rules for fasting and abstinence which are found here: https://catholiccandle.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Traditional-Rules-for-Fast-Abstinance.pdf
The Devil Inspires Halloween as the Mockery of the Feast of All Saints
Catholic Candle note: All faithful and informed Catholics know that we must be different from the world. If we imitate the world, then we will go to hell. If we imitate Our Lord, then we will not “fit in” with the world. As Our Lord teaches, the elect are not of this world and Our Lord has chosen them out of this world. Cf., St. John’s Gospel, 15:19.
Our Lord is a Sign of Contradiction to the world. St. Luke’s Gospel, 2:34. We must imitate Him and be signs of contradiction too. Regarding this principle, read the article at this link: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/priests/sspx-wants-fit-in.html
Here is one crucial way to apply this vital principle of life: we must stand against the world by not participating in Halloween or other pagan activities – even “just for fun” or “just for the neighborhood children”. Here is a further analysis of the evil of participating in Halloween: https://catholiccandle.org/2015/11/01/reasons-not-to-celebrate-halloween/
The devil always seeks to mock Christ and His Church. Satan would like to be worshipped as God but he is truly a foul parody of God. Satan has always acted this way. For example, seeking to receive Divine adoration from Our Lord, Satan promised to give Him the world if He would adore him:
Again the devil took Him up into a very high mountain, and showed Him all the kingdoms of the world, and the glory of them, and said to Him: All these will I give thee if, falling down thou wilt adore me.
St. Matthew’s Gospel, 4:8-9.
Unlike God, Satan cannot create anything. The Devil merely “imitates” God’s wonderful works – but in a grotesque, repulsive fashion. That is why Satan is popularly called the “ape of God” – because Satan and his works are monstrous and hideous caricatures of God and His magnificent works.
When God permits it, Satan performs pseudo-miracles. For example, in Exodus:
Moses and Aaron went in unto Pharao … and Aaron took the rod before Pharao and his servants, and it was turned into a serpent. And Pharao called the wise men and the magicians: and they also by Egyptian enchantments and certain secrets did in like manner. And they every one cast down their rods, and they were turned into serpents: but Aaron’s rod devoured their rods.
Exodus, 7:10-12.
Because the Church is the true Mystical Body of Christ, Satan “apes” the holy rites and works of the Catholic Church. For example, Satan promotes the “Pentecostals” and “charismatics” speaking in supposed “tongues” of gibberish – in order to mock the true gifts of tongues which God gave to some Catholics in the earliest days of the Church.
In our times of apostasy Satan’s servants are remarkably bold in their vicious attacks against Christ. A dictionary entry for the word Halloween is “the evening preceding Allhallows or All Saints’ Day.”1
Of course, All Saints Day is a great and uniquely Catholic feast which dates back to the beginning of the Fifth Century. Pope St. Boniface IV (550-615 A.D.), when dedicating the Roman Pantheon, as the Church of Our Blessed Lady, and All Holy Martyrs, appointed November 1st as the chief annual festival of this Sacred Building. Then Pope Gregory IV (797-844 A.D.) instituted the Feast for All Saints for the universal Church in the year 835 A.D.2
As early as the sixth century in Spain and Gaul, Catholics prepared for this feast by three days of penance and litanies, fasting and alms deeds.3
In his magnificent work, The Liturgical Year, Dom Guéranger explains to us:
When extended to the entire world, the feast became complete; it was made equal to the greatest solemnities, and widened its horizon till it reached the infinite, embracing uncreated, as well as created, sanctity. [In other words, this feast praised God, His Angels, and all the Saints in heaven.]4
However, the solemn fast and abstinence (in preparation for this feast) was probably fixed at the time when the pope chose November 1st as the date on which this feast would be celebrated in the universal Church.5
What a sharp contrast there is between the traditional preparation for this feast and how the modern world regards the vigil of this feast! The secular world knows nothing about the true Feast of All Saints. This ignorance can be especially attributed to (and follows from) various evils spawned by Vatican II.
Over the decades there has been a constant pull to secularize Allhallows and certainly to divert attention from its religious significance. Instead of knowing even in the remotest way that Halloween is referring to all the hallowed friends of God – the Saints – people only associate this day and evening with dressing up in costumes and having parties. It is utterly disgusting to witness the perversity of the modern world with regard to this great Catholic feast day.
Nowadays, people collectively spend many billions of dollars annually to “celebrate” Halloween. Halloween has become one of the largest commercial “holidays” of the year.6 Indeed the devil inspires society (in a twisted way) to make Halloween increasingly more like Christmas in decorations (such as black “Halloween trees”) and also an assortment of “Halloween greeting cards”. While making the day seem like innocent fun, the devil draws society into his mockery of God, His Saints, the seriousness of death and the horrifying misery of hell.
One only needs to look with an observant “Catholic eye” to notice that the diabolical influence is present on many levels. Of course, as is usual, our society at large is oblivious to such traps (and trappings) of Satan.
If one looks at the colors associated with the secular version of Halloween, one sees black, orange, and purple. The black and orange suggest the darkness of hell and the fires of hell. Black is also a symbol of death.
Recently, a member of the Catholic Candle Team saw some (supposedly) “innocent” Halloween cards which, upon careful reflection, had very demonic sounding greetings. One such card stated: A spellbinding Halloween with moonlight bright and spirits light, may treats and laughter fill your night!
When one considers carefully what this card is actually saying, one should shudder. This card is promoting what might sound like innocent fun but think about the shallowness of such a card: it makes a mockery of spells (something God sometimes allows Satan and his worshippers to do), and encourages one to spend the night eating treats and laughing. Contrast this with the way God looks at the Vigil of the Feast of all of His Saints and then it is easy to see how displeased God is regarding the world’s view of the holy feast day’s vigil. With this vigil being a traditional day of fast and abstinence, one can clearly see how Satan would choose this day to promote the opposite – encouraging people to gorge themselves on sweets and have parties.
This obvious disregard for God’s plan is only the beginning of the evils that occur on this great vigil of the Church. Consider that witchcraft and the occult are real forces of evil in the world. We must not forget that this night is the most important “feast” of the year for Satan’s servants. We must remember that these evils are their so-called religion.
Further, Halloween mocks the seriousness of death. Halloween makes light of the horrors of hell and casts the devil as someone who is “just for fun” or that doesn’t exist. These are grave dangers to society and to our salvation!
We Catholics should not simply shrug our shoulders nonchalantly about this! We must perceive what is happening and warn others about the evil of this diabolical perversion of the great Catholic feast given to us.
We must do penance and make reparation for all the attacks against God and His Divine Majesty that occur on this day. We certainly cannot condone or take part in any of these Satanic practices! For example, we must neither give out candy to youngsters dressed up for Halloween nor decorate our homes with things associated with this perversion of the holy vigil.
As the world is becoming more and more immersed in the enticements of the devil, we see that the devil would have the world become Satan worshippers!
We must also remember that God is in charge and will protect us from the onslaughts of the devil. Trusting in the help of heaven, let us pray with all our hearts to the Blessed Mother who crushes the head of Satan, and also to St. Joseph, who is the Terror of Demons!
Catholic
Candle
postscript: If
there are Halloween “trick or treaters” where you live, we
suggest you print and hang on your door the sign available here:
https://catholiccandle.org/2015/11/01/reasons-not-to-celebrate-halloween/
1
Merriam-Webster
Dictionary, ©1948,
entry: Halloween.
2 Information taken from the New Roman Missal, by Fr. Lasance, ©1945.
3 Dom Guéranger, The Liturgical Year, volume XV, entry: Feast of All Saints.
4 Dom Guéranger, The Liturgical Year, volume XV, entry: Feast of All Saints.
5 Information taken from the New Roman Missal, by Fr. Lasance, ©1945.
Words to Live By – From Catholic Tradition
Husbands and fathers beware! You must answer for the conduct of all members of your household!
St. Basil the Great, Doctor of the Church, gives this warning concerning the husband’s and father’s responsibility for his family’s conduct:
When a house is badly managed, and in it are found passion and screaming, insolence and mocking laughter, wantonness and profligacy, impurity and licentiousness, the disgrace and shame of what happens fall upon him who is its master.
Quoted from St. Basil the Great’s Sermon #13.
Words to Live By – From Catholic Tradition
Prayer of St. Thomas More, composed in the Tower of London while awaiting Execution:
Give me the grace, Good Lord, to set the world at naught, to set my mind fast upon Thee, not to hang upon the blasts of men’s mouths, to be content to be solitary, not to long for worldly company, but utterly to cast off the world and to rid my mind of the business thereof.
CC in Brief – Making Donations During Our Time of Great Apostasy
Catholic Candle note: Catholic Candle normally examines particular issues thoroughly, at length, using the teachings of St. Thomas Aquinas and the other Doctors of the Church. By contrast, our feature CC in Brief, usually gives an extremely short answer to a reader’s question. We invite every reader to submit his own questions.
CC in Brief
Making Donations During Our Time of Great Apostasy
Q. The [Church’s] commandment to contribute to the support of the Church is somewhat challenging, bearing in mind the current situation in the human element of the Church. Any suggestions on where to direct such support?
A. Good question, regarding contributing to the support the Church! The first thing to keep in mind is to make sure that you do no harm. Do not contribute to any compromise group under a misplaced desire to “contribute somewhere” or to donate to the “least bad” group available! Compromise priest and groups are not doing God’s work!
Further, do not contribute to a group that does both good work and also evil, under the rationalization that you are donating to that group “for the good part of the work they do”.
Your donation money is God’s money. Of course, everything we have belongs to God and we are His stewards of whatever He chose to give us out of His largess. He does not need us or our donations in order to accomplish His work. He can easily do everything He wants to do without us. But He wants us to donate to His causes because it is good for us to serve Him in this way.
We recommend that you make sure you always give wisely. Give alms to the needy who are truly needy. Here is an example of persons who do not seem to be truly needy: One of the Catholic Candle Team works in a large city’s business district. He sees beggars near the train station every day who, after rush hour (i.e., when most people are gone), are sitting on the sidewalk smoking and texting on their cell phone that had been hidden. Considering further, that most beggars have access to the state’s myriad government “social services” programs and welfare freebies, it would seem that such beggars are not the best recipients of our alms.
Regarding our giving alms to the truly needy: one example is that we recently became aware of a newly-widowed woman, the mother of a Catholic family with dependent children. Although, of course, we want to do good to everyone, we should especially want to help Catholics, following St. Paul’s teaching: “let us work good to all men, but especially to those who are of the household of the Faith.”. Galatians, 6:10.
The truly needy include, most of all, those with great spiritual need. There is such great spiritual need now! Although we want to relieve bodily needs as well as spiritual needs, it would be infinitely better for one person to save his soul by means of spiritual alms than a hundred people to have their bodily needs met if they were still to lose their souls. So all alms prudently given are great but alms which do important spiritual good are best.
Give away rosaries to those who are interested, along with information on how to pray the rosary. Give away Catholic books, Traditional Catholic Missals, etc. But do this wisely. Give them to those persons whom you think are interested and will really use them or read them. A woman on the Catholic Candle Team intentionally strikes-up friendly conversations with modestly-dressed women when she sees them at the grocery store, to see if they are interested in the Truth. When she finds one that is, she sees how she might help.
Another idea starts with the observation that, when an uncompromising priest becomes available to us in the future, he will need financial help to do the most good. So this idea is that, by setting aside money now (as appropriate) to place yourself in a position to assist God’s work by supporting such an uncompromising priest when God sends him to us. For example, in the past, when God sent us a then-uncompromising priest, there existed an uncompromising Catholic charity which paid for all of his plane tickets to fly around the country and other parts of the world to bring the uncompromising Mass, Sacraments and True Faith to the people. We think that a similar time will come again in the future and we should try to be ready to help financially (as well as in other ways). Thus, creating such a fund and giving funds to it as you are able, would in our opinion, be considered alms in God’s eyes (assuming a person is honest with himself that he is not simply keeping the money for himself).
But rather than creating one’s own fund, you should know that that the particular uncompromising Catholic charity referred to above still exists (and is a tax-deductible public charity under IRS regulation 501(c)(3)). You can still contribute to it if you wish. Some members of the Catholic Candle Team are connected with that charity but, of course, do not receive any of the money themselves. Everyone working for that charity volunteers and donates his time and receives no salary or payment of any type. That public charity is called Traditional Catholic Religious Life, Inc. But that charity does not currently have any priests to support because they have no access to, or information about, any uncompromising priests. Please contact Catholic Candle at CatholicCandle@gmail.com if you are interested in donating.
Lesson #61 About the Temperaments – Part XXV – The Fight against Worldliness which is a Huge Detriment to a Deep Prayer Life
Catholic Candle note: The article below is Part XXVI of the study of the temperaments, starting with the Choleric temperament. Here are links to the first twenty-five parts:
-
Part I: Beginning our study of the choleric temperament: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/08/27/lesson-35-about-the-temperaments-the-choleric-temperament/
-
Part II: A general overview of the weaknesses of the Choleric Temperament: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/09/26/lesson-37-about-the-temperaments-continuation-of-the-choleric-temperament/
-
Part III: A consideration of the pride of the Choleric Temperament: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/10/24/lesson-38-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat/
-
Part IV: A general discussion of anger as a passion – in order to establish a foundation for studying anger in the Choleric Temperament: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/11/26/lesson-39-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat-part-iv/
-
Part V: Concerning the motivations for anger: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/12/30/lesson-40-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat-part-v/
-
Part VI: Concerning what anger does to the body: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/01/27/lesson-41-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-vi/
-
Part VII: Explaining when anger is sinful: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/02/21/lesson-42-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-vii/
-
Part VIII: Explaining how being slighted provokes anger: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/03/27/lesson-42-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-viii/
-
Part IX: Explaining how anger turns into the sin of holding a grudge: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/04/23/lesson-44-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-ix/
-
Part X: Recommendations to help cholerics to overcome pride: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/05/20/lesson-45-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-x/
-
Part XI: Explaining how a person sins by not using his reason: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/06/28/lesson-46-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xi/
-
Part XII: Explaining some reasons why a choleric does not use his reason properly: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/07/24/lesson-47-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xii/
-
Part XIII: Explaining why the choleric fears to use his reason well: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/08/29/lesson-48-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xiii/
-
Part XIV: Explaining generally how Satan targets our fallen and weakened intellects: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/09/24/lesson-49-temperaments-choleric-temperament-the-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xiv/
-
Part XV: Explaining the passions in general, to lay the foundation for our consideration of the passion of fear: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/10/26/3050/
-
Part XVI: Explaining fear as a passion: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/11/25/lesson-51-temperaments-choleric-temperament-the-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xvi/
-
Part XVII: Explaining how fear works in the soul and influences all of the temperaments: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/12/29/lesson-52-temperaments-choleric-temperament-the-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xvii/
-
Part XVIII: Explaining how pain and death are objects of fear for persons of any temperament: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/01/26/lesson-53-temperaments-choleric-temperament-pain-and-death-are-objects-of-fearf-any-temperament/
-
Part XIX: Explaining in what way sin is an object of fear for all temperaments: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/02/26/lesson-54-temperaments-choleric-temperament-whether-sin-is-an-object-of-fear-for-all-temperaments/
-
Part XX: Explaining the causes of fear – applying to all temperaments: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/03/31/marys-school-of-sanctity-3/
-
Part XXI: Explaining the effects of fear in all temperaments: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/04/26/about-the-temperaments-part-xxi-explaining-the-effects-of-fear-in-all-temperaments/
-
Part XXII: Explaining how to order our loves so we can use the passion of fear properly, and how the devil attempts to prevent this ordering: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/05/28/about-the-temperaments-part-xxii-how-to-order-our-loves-so-we-can-use-the-passion-of-fear-properly/
-
Part XXIII: Explanation of sloth in order to analyze this snare of Satan and to combat him: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/06/26/about-the-temperaments-part-xxiii-explanation-of-sloth-in-order-to-analyze-this-snare-of-satan/
-
Part XXIV: Explaining more about how the devil tries to draw us away from reasoning and from the things of God: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/07/29/about-the-temperaments-part-xiv-how-the-devil-draws-us-away-from-reasoning-and-the-things-of-god/
-
Part XXV – Explaining the Devil Attempts to Destroy Our Prayer-Life and How We Should Counterattack: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/08/31/lesson-60-about-the-temperaments-part-xxv-the-devil-attempts-to-destroy-our-prayer-life/
Mary’s School of Sanctity
Lesson #61 – About the Temperaments, Part XXV – The Fight against Worldliness which is a Huge Detriment to a Deep Prayer Life
In our last lesson we saw how the devil sought to undermine and destroy St. Teresa of Avila’s salvation. We saw how her worldliness weighed her down and hindered her desire to give herself completely to God. We will now apply this lesson to ourselves and search our souls to see if we are also inordinately attached to the world (as she had been, earlier in her life). Our worldly attachment can be determined primarily by our use of creatures (i.e., all things created by God). Thus, it is important to examine our use of creatures.
Because
worldly attachments draw us away from prayer and from God, we must
avoid inordinate attachments to the world. In this lesson we will
focus on the creatures that particularly draw our minds
away from God, which imperceptibly also draw our hearts from God.
However, before we delve into the use of creatures, let us remind
ourselves of what Our Lord says about worldliness and keep His words
in our mind as we consider our use of creatures.
Let Us Remember What Our Lord Says About Worldliness
Our Lord explained to His Apostles that they must be “in the world” but not “of the world.” Praying to His Father, Our Lord says the following words:
I have given them Thy word, and the world hath hated them: because they are not of the world, as I also am not of the world.
I pray not that Thou shouldst take them out of the world, but that Thou shouldst keep them from evil.
They are not of the world, as I also am not of the world.
St. John’s Gospel, 17:14-16.
These
precious words of Our Dear Lord should keep us focused on God’s
Will and on our Eternal Good, so that we make a thorough and sober
examination of conscience concerning our use of creatures.
Our Use of Creatures – Including Time
St. Ignatius of Loyola explains in his Spiritual Exercises how creatures must be used to help us to attain our end, namely heaven.1 But how do we know if something is detrimental to the attainment of our end?
We must weigh whether the object (viz., the creature in question) distracts us from God and from the proper service and love that we owe to God. To help us to conduct this careful weighing, let us consider how we use time, which itself is a creature.
Our Lord alludes to the proper use of time when He warned His Apostles that we will be judged on every idle word.
But I say unto you, that every idle word that men shall speak, they shall render an account for it on the Day of Judgment.
St. Matthew’s Gospel, 12:36.
Fr. Martin von Cochem, in his book The Four Last Things, expands this consideration further when he says:
If it is so hateful to a criminal to be brought before an earthly magistrate, well may the poor soul quake with fear when she [meaning the soul2] is introduced into the presence of God, the strict and omniscient Judge, and required to give the most accurate account of all of the thoughts, words, deeds, and omissions of her past life.3
With these quotes in mind, let us investigate the tactics of the devil to tempt us to be worldly, waste time, and not use our intellects.
As we discussed recently in our lessons, the things that the devil especially does not want us to focus on are:
-
Filial love towards God;
-
Deep and careful thinking;
-
Knowledge of God;
-
Knowledge of ourselves; and
-
The purpose for which we were created.
Therefore,
the devil presents his allurements to our souls principally to
obstruct these five focuses.
The Devil First Attacks the Intellect of Man
In
striving to wreak the greatest destruction upon man, the devil seeks
first to attack man’s ability to reason. For in doing this, the
devil can easily conquer the soul of the man by destroying his focus
on the other four areas listed immediately above. As we explained in
a recent lesson,4
the devil first tries to distract man in order to hinder him from a
life of prayer. Below, we discuss this further.
Distractions of Our Minds
The devil uses creatures which distract our minds and prevent us from developing a desire to think deeply. He wants this desire to be weak in us or, better yet, to be entirely absent from us.
He also tries to make us worldly by tempting us to put ourselves and other interests ahead of God – that is, have false gods before God.
Satan wants us to focus on this world and its problems, activities, and allurements, instead of submitting our wills and our lives to God. He wants us to be distracted with the concerns of this world – whether fables such as manmade climate change, or simply seeing the evils all around us, the devil wants us to be so worried about anything except our salvation. He certainly doesn’t want us to trust in God and to turn to Him in prayer.
He
wants us to waste time, especially with entertaining ourselves. He
wants man to lead a life of dissipation. Thus, the devil doesn’t
want anyone to ever use his God-given intellect.
The Gadgets – the Tools of Satan
For decades the devil has used technology and promoted gadgets that are effective tools to lure souls away from God. One could say that the start of many moral perils was the motion picture. After the advent of movies, then came television. Television was fashioned into a highly effective means to corrupt society. What a great many souls have been corrupted by these tools! This corruption came in the form of:
-
Indoctrination with lies – both explicit and implied;
-
Promotion of worldliness;
-
Promotion of covetousness and envy;
-
Promotion of immodesty and impurity;
-
Promotion of passively received sights and sounds which are not filtered by our intellect; and
-
All the while squandering huge amounts of our time.
Then came a more recent gadget: a very portable cellular phone which the devil mockingly (and ironically) inspired to be named “the smart phone”. This tool encourages modern man to not use his intellect and instead to blindly believe whatever he sees and hears on this gadget. This gadget contains all of the dangers of television and many more – all in a device small enough to allow a person to carry it easily and to engage in these evils everywhere he goes.
When one considers all of the ramifications of having and using this gadget often, one can readily see how this tool of Satan is a masterful stroke to sweep souls into hell. From pornography to satisfying one’s idle curiosity – all readily accessible at one’s fingertips. This so-called “smart phone” is a classic trap of Satan!
Adding further evil, the devil presents this gadget as a status symbol. It is widely implied in society that one is “strange” if one does not use a so-called “smart phone” – and indeed, if that device is not a newer-model one. Thus, having a so-called “smart phone” can be a temptation to envy and to pride (unreasonable human respect) because the pressure is so strong to follow the crowd. People do not want this latest fad to leave them behind.
The fact that the world promotes these so-called “smart phones” for use everywhere and for all types of transactions and interactions, shows the devil’s influence is behind this gadget. There is hardly any place one can go without seeing people immersed in their phones. The devil’s servants push so heavily the impression that no one can “get by” without having one of these phones, that our times seems almost apocalyptic.5
These so-called “smart phones” certainly promote the spirit of the world and direct users to the pool (or we could say “cesspool”) of information tainted and twisted to match the prince of this world, namely Satan. What should a person do if he has one of these phones? He should do what would please Our Lord. He should avoid having one of them by trying to retain a land-line even if it is more expensive. If one has a cellular phone, it would be best to try to not get the latest fad or status phone but instead to be poor-in-spirit and not be like everyone else.
Also, it would be best to use the phone very sparingly – rarely, even. Let us look at what St. Bonaventure says when he is addressing the obstacles to the prayer of contemplation. He explains how St. Bernard of Clairvaux describes the fourth obstacle to contemplation as “the phantoms of corporeal images.” St. Bonaventure says,
This last [meaning the fourth obstacle to contemplation] is more difficult to overcome than the others [viz., barriers to contemplation], and therefore solitude is especially recommended in contemplation. It behoveth the man who contemplates to be in some sense dumb, deaf, and blind so that seeing he may not see, and hearing he may not hear, nor take delight in talking; that is, that he may be so withdrawn from transitory things, and so united to God, that he may not, by hearing, seeing, speaking, cease to contemplate, but that he may avoid interruption as much as possible. And if necessity obliges him to break off [from his prayer], he must not lay up in the soul those images of things which have passed through its windows. 6
If St. Bonaventure could say this of the distractions of simple everyday discourse with one’s fellow man, how much more he would say if he saw man’s modern technological gadgetry? Furthermore, if one considers the nature of the so-called “smart phone”, where what one hears and sees on this phone is passively absorbed by the mind, and these images on the screen are constantly flashing from one thing to the next, it is easy to understand how this is disruptive to one’s ability to concentrate.
All of this, likewise, harms one’s ability to focus on his prayers and fight the distractions of all that he has seen and heard. Hence, the use of the so-called “smart phone” is not conducive to the soul’s ability to focus on heavenly things and a deep prayer life. Instead, it distracts and agitates the soul, making it more difficult to settle down into the proper frame of mind to ponder and pour out one’s heart to God. One could also see that the degree of this dissipation one experiences corresponds to the degree in which the will is weakened in its efforts to serve God.
When the mind has been engaged in worldly matters and the allurements of the senses, one is less apt to desire to engage in mental work (including spiritual work). The devil can take advantage of the wounds of Original Sin and can easily tempt a person to believe that intellectual work is so tedious and difficult that he will think that mental work is such a “chore” or a “plague.”
We
can see this attitude in the world around us where most people do not
desire to think carefully or to think independently of the world.
Many simply spend hours mentally loitering, frittering away their day
on their so-called “smart phone.” How often do we find that when
we ask someone a question, he immediately pulls out his so-called
“smart phone” to find the answer? He’d rather trust a worldly
gadget than his own intelligence. In conclusion, it seems prudent to
be very
leery of this modern thought-blocking gadget.
One Can Do a Simple Examination of Conscience to See His Attachment to This Gadget:
-
How often do I use this phone?
-
How long am I on this phone during a single use?
-
Do I ever just leave the phone behind and go about my day?
-
Do I find that I have it with me all day?
-
Do I have it at my bedside at night?
-
Do I check my phone as soon as I awaken in the morning?
-
Do I use my phone in bed?
-
Has my phone been a source of past sins?
-
Does it interrupt my family or social interactions?
-
Do I quickly get onto my phone when I have a “spare minute”?
-
Has this phone really become a strange god before God?
Some Tips on How to Treat a So-Called “Smart Phone”:
-
Never use the phone without real need.
-
Never use the phone for entertainment.
-
Never use the phone for social media.
-
Never use the phone for “window shopping.”
-
Before using a “smart phone”, ask yourself what you specifically need to accomplish on the phone. Do this task and get off of it. Do not expand the scope of your original reason for using the phone.
-
Never forget that the devil’s minions use this tool to keep track of and indoctrinate society.
As
one weans himself off of his so-called “smart phone”, a person
discovers that he has a new freedom. In this way one can see that
the “smart phone” really makes one a slave to a mere creature.
It is Important to Test Ourselves to See How Attached We Are to Objects, that is, to Creatures:
One can ask himself questions similar to the ones regarding the “smart phone” and substitute another object in its place. If one finds he is inordinately attached to any object or person, he should pray to Our Lord to help him to detach himself and to order this creature and all creatures to God and to our final end. As St. Ignatius teaches, we must be indifferent to all objects and persons “in so far as it is left to the choice of our free will and is not forbidden”.
The simple rule-of-thumb to test our attachment to an object, i.e., to a creature, is to recall these words of Our Lord:
For what doth it profit a man, if he gain the whole world and suffer the loss of his own soul? Or what exchange shall a man give for his soul?”
St. Matthew’s Gospel, 16:26.
We
should ask ourselves who really
comes first with us, God or a creature? Do our actions and habits
show this? Here is a strong sign: what comes first with us and what
we love most, tends to be what we seek to spend our time with, when
we are able to do so.
In Conclusion:
This
self-awareness of our use of creatures is extremely important in
fostering a healthy prayer life and Divine Friendship. Also, God put
it in man’s nature for him to take the greatest delight in using
his highest faculty (viz.,
his intellect). This should be a great incentive to improve our
minds as well as to avoid all worldly dissipations. These
dissipations and the creatures that foster them must be avoided if we
are to have the degree of Divine Friendship that the Good Lord wills
for us to have with Him.
A Preview…
Having considered how the devil tries to destroy our desire and likewise our delight in using our intellects, in our next lesson, we can concentrate on how the devil lures us to bodily pleasures, concerns, and desires as a means to draw us away from God and from a life of prayer.
1
In his explanation of the Principle
and Foundation,
St. Ignatius tells us how we should use creatures only as a means to
reach our spiritual end. Here are his words:
All
other things on the face of the earth are created for man to help
him fulfill the end for which he is created. From this it follows
that man is to use these things to the extent that they will help
him to attain his end. Likewise, he must rid himself of them in so
far as they prevent him from attaining it.
Therefore,
we must make ourselves indifferent to all created things, in so far
as it is left to the choice of our free will and is not forbidden.
Acting accordingly, for our part, we should not prefer health to
sickness, riches to poverty, honor to dishonor, a long life to a
short one, and so in all things we should desire and choose only
those things which will best help attain the end for which we are
created.
See the Catholic Candle article about the Principle and Foundation which is discussed in Mary’s School of Sanctity, Lesson #11, which is found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2022/06/27/lesson-11-the-principle-and-foundation-part-ii/
2 The Latin word for soul is “anima”, which is a feminine noun, and therefore this noun is sometimes given a feminine pronoun.
3 This quote is taken from Fr. Martin von Cochem’s book The Last Four Things ©1899 by Benzinger Brothers, p.27 (bracketed words added for clarity).
4 Read about this here: Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #60 – About the Temperaments – Part XXV – The Devil Attempts to Destroy Our Prayer-Life. How Should We Counterattack?: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/08/31/lesson-60-about-the-temperaments-part-xxv-the-devil-attempts-to-destroy-our-prayer-life/
5 Compare this current state of things to the prophesy in the Apocalypse, 13:16-17:
[The Beast] shall make all, both little and great, rich and poor, freemen and
bondmen,
to have a
character in their right hand,
or on their foreheads. And that no
man might buy or sell, but he that hath the character,
or the name of the beast, or the number of his name.
6 Quote taken from St. Bonaventure’s work On the Life of Our Lord, chapter 56 (bracketed words added for clarity).
The Blessing of a True, Catholic Liberal Education – Part XI
Catholic Candle note: Below is part 10 of our exploration of the best type of education – which is a true Catholic Liberal Education. Do not confuse this education with many university programs called “liberal arts” but which are full of fluff, falsehood, and aimless so-called “cultural enrichment” courses and “humanities”.
A liberal education also does not refer to liberalism, nor is a true liberal education an indoctrination into that error of liberalism or political correctness. In fact, a true Catholic Liberal Education is the best antidote to the errors of liberalism.
As context for this tenth part of this article, let us recall what we saw in the earlier nine parts:
Previously, in part 1 of this article,1 we examined the problems we see in modern education:
-
Modern colleges do not improve the quality of their students’ minds (and their thinking ability) much or at all.
-
Most “education” is merely job training, fluff courses, and/or leftist indoctrination.
-
The students are trained to sound like someone in their field but they do more memorizing and little thinking.
-
Grade “inflation” and degree “inflation” are rampant. Grades and academic degrees do not mean much anymore.
In part 2 of this article,2 we examined, in general, what education is. We considered the human soul and the perfection of its highest faculty (i.e., its highest power) – which is the intellect – and which is immaterial (i.e., incorporeal). We saw that our intellects are perfected through knowing eternal, unchangeable truths and the causes of things.
In part 3 of this article,3 after having seen what true education is, we examined the question who should perfect his intellect.
In part 4 of this article,4 having seen that modern universities do not provide a true education, we consider whether there is ever a good reason for men or women to attend them.
In part 5 of this article,5 having seen that women and girls should pursue a True Catholic Liberal Education – just as men and boys should, too – we then considered what the best environment is in which women and girls should do this.
In part 6 of this article, we addressed the objection that, having seen the great value of a true Catholic Liberal Education, we should be afraid that the great blessing of this education would be a danger to our souls because it might foster in us the vice of pride.6
In part 7 of this article, we considered more fully the difference between the education which is appropriate for a free man as contrasted to the education which is appropriate for a slave.7
In part 8 of this article, we considered further how the truth perfects our minds. This shows us that we must really know the truth, not merely believe true opinions.8
In part 9 of this article, we considered more-specifically what studies (sciences) belong in a Catholic Liberal Education.9
In part 10, we explore the motive and the goal of a true Catholic Liberal Education. A Catholic Liberal Education Begins in Wonder and Aims at Wisdom.10
Below, in part eleven, we consider what authors and books we should use in our Catholic Liberal Education.
What Authors and Books Should We Use in Our Catholic Liberal Education?
Part
11
In our recent consideration of wisdom, we saw what wisdom is and that it is a priceless gift from God. We saw that the highest truths and wisdom perfect our highest faculty – viz., our intellect.
But which specific books and authors should we read when studying the various sciences of a genuine Catholic Liberal Education? There are many authors of many books written on the subjects (e.g., geometry) which we should study in a Catholic Liberal Education. Which ones are the best books and authors for us to use in these studies?
In our pursuit of the greatest truths about the objective order established by God, we should use the original writings of the greatest thinkers – who wrote in the Western intellectual tradition which is the foundation and flowering of Christendom. These works must be read not primarily for historical or cultural reasons, but because they are the most successful attempts to understand things as they are in themselves, while attending to our common experience.11
Generally, these works are called the Great Books of the Western World. Here are a few examples of these Great Books: Euclid’s Elements (the greatest work of geometry), and many works by St. Augustine, Aristotle, St. Thomas Aquinas, Fr. Gregory Mendel, Archimedes, and J. Henri Fabre (as well as many other authors).
We should read these Great Books seeking to understand the greatest truths of reality. These books should not be the object of study. The object of study should be the truths themselves examined in those books.
Nor should we read the Great Books in order to learn the opinions of those authors but rather to know what the truth is, weighing and examining what those books say, in order to consider their arguments and explanations and thereby come to the truth.
The opinions of even the great authors are not so important. That is why St. Thomas Aquinas, the greatest of all Doctors of the Church and all other thinkers, rightly teaches that arguments based on human authority are the weakest type of argument and are weaker than arguments based on reason.12 (However, in contrast to arguments based on human authority, arguments based on God’s own authority, are the strongest arguments.)13
It is the truth that is important. So, for example, if we are studying What Time is, the fruit of our study should not be concluding that “In Aristotle’s opinion, Time is the measure of motion”. Rather, by considering Aristotle’s arguments and explanations, the fruit of our study should be the better understanding of the reality of what Time is (not merely an author’s opinion).
Further, students should not read these Great Books as “Humanities”, i.e., as outstanding examples of the creativity of the human mind, although these books are certainly that.
Likewise, students should not read these books to become acquainted with our Cultural Heritage, and the refinement of our Western Civilization (as valuable as that is).
Rather, students should read the Great Books because, more than any other works, when studied under the light and guidance of the teachings of the True Catholic Church, these books can open up our minds to the truth about reality.
There are four reasons for this:
-
The Great Books are the most accessible works for the matters they treat, given the difficulty which is inherent in the matters themselves. For example, understanding what motion is or understanding the Blessed Trinity contains inherent difficulties which cannot all be “simplified away”.14
-
The Great Books have withstood the test of time. Many generations from now, Euclid will still be esteemed as the greatest of all geometers, whereas the authors of the modern geometry books will all be forgotten.
-
The Great Books are shown superior by their effect – because they have convinced the world of their ideas. When an author convinces the world of his ideas and arguments – in the face of the world’s prior, contrary beliefs – that feat shows the book’s greater persuasiveness and intrinsic power as compared to a lesser author who merely writes his text book in the “tradition” of a Great Book (such as the countless math books claiming to be “Euclidean Geometry”).
-
The Great Books help us to avoid being overly-influenced by the prejudices of our time. People blindly assume the errors of our age, e.g., ecumenism and evolution. The Great Books are from prior ages unaffected by the current age which blindly assumes the correctness of positions which are currently in vogue. The Great Books help us to “step outside” our time and to better see its errors and the weaknesses of current fads and transitory “orthodoxies”.
Perhaps some people, moved by misplaced humility, fear going to the authors of the Great Books because those people think those works are only for scholars, not for ordinary people like ourselves. But that notion is false. These works are great because they are so accessible and are the simplest treatment of those ideas, given the inherent difficulty of the matters themselves.
St. Thomas Aquinas is the greatest of all thinkers. His brilliance surpasses all others, in large part, because he excels all others at unlocking the most difficult truths for all of us – laymen included. It is a mistake to suppose that he is too great to be read by “pea brains” like us and so we should instead read the books written by some more recent, lesser authors.
In other words, the great authors are so great that they are accessible even to us ordinary people!15 Here is how Archbishop Lefebvre explained this truth:
Let us not think that Saint Thomas is too
much for the faithful and that he is
distant from their faith, for this is
not true and [is] damaging to the faithful.
The philosophy and theology of Saint Thomas are truth.
Therefore, let us not say that the truth explained in all its
simplicity, and clarity, in addition to its profound logic, cannot be
understood by the faithful. That would be condescension on our
part. This would amount to abandoning and despairing of
communicating to the faithful – a profound tragedy.16
Conclusion
We should spend our lives pursuing the truth, especially about our Holy Catholic Faith. We should do this by reading the great authors of the Great Books.
Looking Ahead
We hear all around us that what is called “academic freedom” is essential to successful learning. But what is academic freedom? And is it good?
To Be Continued …
1 Part 1 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/06/28/the-blessings-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education/
2 Part 2 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/07/24/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-ii/
3 Part 3 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/08/28/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-iii/
4 Part 4 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/09/24/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-iv/
5 Part 5 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/10/26/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-v/
6 Part 6 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/01/26/3129/
7 Part 7 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/02/26/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-vii/
8 Part 8 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/03/10/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-viii/
9 Part 9 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/06/26/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-viii-2/
11 This common experience is the common truths which are the principles of all knowledge and science. Read more about this in part 8 of this article on a Catholic Liberal Education. Part 8 can be found here: Making the Truth “Our Own”, https://catholiccandle.org/2026/03/10/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-viii/
12 Summa, Ia, Q.1, a.8, ad 2.
13 Summa, Ia, Q.1, a.8, ad 2.
14 The undiscerning student might suppose that, on a topic such as proving God’s existence, some modern text book authors (e.g., Msgr. Paul Glenn or Garrigou-Lagrange) are clearer and better than St. Thomas. But that student fails to notice that those modern authors often “cheat” their readers by supporting their statements using only an example in place of St. Thomas’s own universal arguments which really prove those same statements.
But a careful thinker understands that giving an example does not prove the truth of a universal statement. Consider that finding a single example of a tall Eskimo does not prove that all Eskimos are tall. If Msgr. Glenn’s treatments were truly better than that of St. Thomas, then Msgr. Glenn would be the Doctor of the Church, not St. Thomas.
Similarly, in mathematics, the physical sciences, logic, and many other sciences, the modern non-great authors often dodge the difficult arguments and use an example instead, to “prove” their point. This dodging the difficult is a great loss for the student.
15 It might be that now, for the first time, some readers understand that we all have a duty to perfect our minds, especially to study our Holy Catholic Faith. But some of these readers will already be emersed in many essential duties of state which prevent them, at least for now, from dedicating more than small “snippets” of time to this important work. Well, each person should do what he can do and as much as he can do in the circumstances in which God placed him.
As explained in the ninth part of this article on the Great Blessings of a Catholic Liberal Education, it is best that students not begin their studies with the highest truths (philosophy and theology), but rather, approach them through studying the seven liberal arts first. https://catholiccandle.org/2026/06/10/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-ix/ This approach will give the best results of deepest and most lasting understanding.
Further, St. Thomas Aquinas explains in the prologue to the Summa Theologica that the Summa is for beginners in theology. But St. Thomas anticipated that this beginner would already be somewhat adept in the various parts of philosophy. Thus, we see that there is a proper order of studies and of learning: the liberal arts first, then various branches of philosophy and then theology.
But suppose that a person’s duties of state do not currently allow this better approach? We urge each reader to start without delay and do what he can do with the time and the books that he has or which are reasonably available to him. It is better to start and try rather than fail to even start because he wishes his circumstances allowed a more ideal approach. So, start now, in a way you are able. When questions or confusions arise, then ask for the help and explanations of a wise man you know. You could also write Catholic Candle to ask your question.
16 Archbishop Lefebvre, The spirit of our statutes, the fourth conference in a retreat in Écône, in September 1988, (emphasis added).
Read also, the popes praising the Doctors of the Church telling us that we should especially read them. As those popes explain, most of all, we should read St. Thomas. https://catholiccandle.org/2017/12/16/why-faithful-catholics-follow-the-doctors-of-the-church/
September 2026 PDF Issue
Conciliar Betrayal of the Mystical Body of Christ
The
Conciliar Hierarchy’s Removal of
Fasting Obligations
When one compares obligatory pre-Vatican II Church discipline to the laxity after Vatican II, we recognize a main cause of the utter destruction of Catholics’ spiritual and moral strength which the previous Church disciplines had engendered.
Some of the Catholic Candle Team had the opportunity to read Pope St. Leo the Great’s sermons regarding the September Ember Days1 and were struck by the wisdom of his edifying admonition to keep well the Ember Days.
Pope St. Leo the Great, a Doctor of the Church,2 expounded on the Church’s beautiful benefits and the important symbolism of having its members keep these appointed fasts together. He makes several forceful arguments why the faithful should fast on common appointed days.
-
Pope St. Leo the Great tells us that, because man has the wounds of original sin, he is greatly benefitted by wholesome fasting. In other words, fasting is a necessary remedy for man, wounded as he is by Original Sin and his actual sins.
-
St. Leo says that public services (such as this fasting) are of a higher character than private ones. Here is his explanation:
The fast which the whole Church undergoes leaves out no one from the general purification, and God’s people then become strongest when the hearts of all the faithful meet together in one common act of holy obedience3 when, in the camp of the Christian army, there is on all sides, the same making ready for the fight and for defense. Though the cruel enemy rages in restless fury, and spreads all around his hidden snares, yet he will be able to catch no one and wound no one, if he finds no one off his guard, no one given up to sloth, no one inactive in works of piety.
-
This faithful and blessed Leo tells us that the September fast calls us in this public way to self-amendment, “that we may lift our souls to the Lord free from worldly cares and earthly concerns”. St. Leo continues:
Let
us at least on these days, which are most healthfully ordained for
our correction, withdraw ourselves from worldly occupation, and steal
a little time for promoting our eternal welfare. … And the
fullest abolition of sins is obtained when the whole Church offers up
one prayer and one confession. For if the Lord has promised
fulfillment of all they shall ask, to the holy and devout agreement
of two or three, what shall be denied to many thousands of the people
who unite in one act of worship, and with one breath make their
common supplication?
-
This Great Doctor adds that the community of goods and actions is most precious in God’s sight:
It is a great and very precious thing in the Lord’s sight, beloved, when Christ’s whole people engage together in the same duties, and all ranks and degrees of either sex co-operate with the same intent: when one purpose animates all alike to declining from evil and doing good; when God is glorified in the works of His slaves, and the Author of all godliness is blessed in unstinted giving of thanks.
Quoting Scripture, Pope St. Leo tells us:
“Be holy, for I am holy”. That is to say: choose Me and keep from what displeases Me. Do what I love, love what I do. If what I order seems difficult, come back to Me Who order, so, from where the command was given, help might be offered. I, Who furnished the desire, will not refuse support. Fast from contradiction, abstain from opposition. Let Me be your food and drink. None desire in vain what is Mine, for those who stretch out toward Me seek Me because I first sought them.
Thus, St. Leo exhorts his flock as follows:
The four seasons of the year have their allotted time for that same observance of restraint. We continue to know, as the course of the whole year returns, that we are unceasingly in need of purification.
Pope St. Leo is plain in his instruction that we need to do penance for the salvation of our souls. Contrast this with the modern conciliar church which simply strikes from the ecclesiastical law almost all fasting requirements. The post-conciliar hierarchy has betrayed the flock by disregarding what is so crucial for salvation. They contradict what Our Lord said was required to obtain everlasting life. “Unless you do penance, you shall likewise perish.”
The modernists have disregarded the Ember Days and virtually abolished Lenten Fasting, keeping only Ash Wednesday and Good Friday. The devil knows well that he has won a major victory, working by means of his tools – the conciliar hierarchy!
Let us strive to always strictly keep the old rules for fasting and offer up this sacrifice for the restoration of all things in Christ. This is not the time to do only the minimum of penance! Use the pre-Vatican II rules for fasting and abstinence which are found here: https://catholiccandle.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Traditional-Rules-for-Fast-Abstinance.pdf
Let us not be stingy with God! He is never outdone in generosity!
1 The 1917 Catholic Encyclopedia explains:
Ember days (corruption from Lat. Quatuor Tempora, four times) are the days at the beginning of the seasons ordered by the Church as days of fast and abstinence. They were definitely arranged and prescribed for the entire Church by Pope Gregory VII (1073-1085) for the Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday after 13 December (S. Lucia), after Ash Wednesday, after Whitsunday, and after 14 September (Exaltation of the Cross). The purpose of their introduction, besides the general one intended by all prayer and fasting, was to thank God for the gifts of nature, to teach men to make use of them in moderation, and to assist the needy. The immediate occasion was the practice of the heathens of Rome. The Romans were originally given to agriculture, and their native gods belonged to the same class. At the beginning of the time for seeding and harvesting religious ceremonies were performed to implore the help of their deities: in June for a bountiful harvest, in September for a rich vintage, and in December for the seeding; hence their feriae sementivae, feriae messis, and feri vindimiales. The Church, when converting heathen nations, has always tried to sanctify any practices which could be utilized for a good purpose. At first the Church in Rome had fasts in June, September, and December; the exact days were not fixed but were announced by the priests. The “Liber Pontificalis” ascribes to Pope Callistus (217-222) a law ordering the fast, but probably it is older. Leo the Great (440-461) considers it an Apostolic institution. When the fourth season was added cannot be ascertained, but Gelasius (492-496) speaks of all four. This pope also permitted the conferring of priesthood and deaconship on the Saturdays of ember week–these were formerly given only at Easter. Before Gelasius the ember days were known only in Rome, but after his time their observance spread. They were brought into England by St. Augustine; into Gaul and Germany by the Carlovingians. Spain adopted them with the Roman Liturgy in the eleventh century. They were introduced by St. Charles Borromeo into Milan. The Eastern Church does not know them. The present Roman Missal, in the formulary for the Ember days, retains in part the old practice of lessons from Scripture in addition to the ordinary two: for the Wednesdays three, for the Saturdays six, and seven for the Saturday in December. Some of these lessons contain promises of a bountiful harvest for those that serve God.
2 He is also referred to as Pope St. Leo I. He reigned from 440 to 461 A.D.
3 Notice that Pope St. Leo puts the greater focus on the obedience of this public fast rather than the bodily mortification of it. This is because the most important element of fasting (when we fast according to the Church’s rules and schedule rather than at times of our own choosing), is that we are obeying and are being directed by the Church’s commandment, not by our own will and preference.
Even in our times of infidelity and laxness, we can still benefit from this element of obedience (in some way) when we fast on the traditional days of fasting because they were chosen by the Church, not by us, so that we submit our will to the Church’s traditional directives.
This submission of our will is a greater sacrifice than the sacrifice of the food itself which we deny to our bodies, because our submission of our higher power (our will) is a greater sacrifice than is the submission of our lower nature (viz., our body) when we choose our own days on which to undertake a private fast.
Thus, the unfaithful post-conciliar hierarchy harmed Catholics by removing the fasting requirements because (predictably) most Catholics will not fast if they are not required to do so. But even worse is the harm these conciliar hirelings inflicted by removing Catholics’ exercise of virtue and the merit of the obedience by following the Church’s specific fasting requirements.
Words to Live By – From
Catholic Tradition
Mortifying
Our Passions and Desires Helps Us Much More Than Choosing to Perform
Unusual Voluntary Penances
Here is how St. John of the Cross, Mystical Doctor of the Church, counsels us:
One must greatly lament the ignorance of certain men, who burden themselves with extraordinary penances and with many other voluntary practices, and think that this practice or that one will suffice to bring them to the union with Divine Wisdom. But such will not be the case if they endeavor not diligently to mortify their desires. If they were careful to bestow half of that labor on this, they would profit more in a month than they profit by all the other practices in many years.
For, just as it is necessary to till the earth if it is to bear fruit, and unless it be tilled it bears nothing but weeds, so likewise is mortification of the desires necessary if the soul is to profit. Without this mortification, I make bold to say, the soul no more achieves progress on the road to perfection and to the knowledge of God of itself, however many efforts it might make, than the seed grows when it is cast upon untilled ground. Wherefore the darkness and rudeness of the soul will not be taken from it until the desires be quenched. For these desires are like cataracts, or like motes in the eye, which obstruct the sight until they be taken away.
Ascent Of Mount Carmel, St. John of the Cross, Bk.1, ch.8, §4.
August 2026 PDF Issue
The Blessing of a True, Catholic Liberal Education – Part X
Catholic Candle note: Below is part 10 of our exploration of the best type of education – which is a true Catholic Liberal Education. Do not confuse this education with many university programs called “liberal arts” but which are full of fluff, falsehood, and aimless so-called “cultural enrichment” courses and “humanities”.
A liberal education also does not refer to liberalism, nor is a true liberal education an indoctrination into that error of liberalism or political correctness. In fact, a true Catholic Liberal Education is the best antidote to the errors of liberalism.
As context for this tenth part of this article, let us recall what we saw in the earlier nine parts:
Previously, in part 1 of this article,1 we examined the problems we see in modern education:
-
Modern colleges do not improve the quality of their students’ minds (and their thinking ability) much or at all.
-
Most “education” is merely job training, fluff courses, and/or leftist indoctrination.
-
The students are trained to sound like someone in their field but they do more memorizing and little thinking.
-
Grade “inflation” and degree “inflation” are rampant. Grades and academic degrees do not mean much anymore.
In part 2 of this article,2 we examined, in general, what education is. We considered the human soul and the perfection of its highest faculty (i.e., its highest power) – which is the intellect – and which is immaterial (i.e., incorporeal). We saw that our intellects are perfected through knowing eternal, unchangeable truths and the causes of things.
In part 3 of this article,3 after having seen what true education is, we examined the question who should perfect his intellect.
In part 4 of this article,4 having seen that modern universities do not provide a true education, we consider whether there is ever a good reason for men or women to attend them.
In part 5 of this article,5 having seen that women and girls should pursue a True Catholic Liberal Education – just as men and boys should, too – we then considered what the best environment is in which women and girls should do this.
In part 6 of this article, we addressed the objection that, having seen the great value of a true Catholic Liberal Education, we should be afraid that the great blessing of this education would be a danger to our souls because it might foster in us the vice of pride.6
In part 7 of this article, we considered more fully the difference between the education which is appropriate for a free man as contrasted to the education which is appropriate for a slave.7
In part 8 of this article, we considered further how the truth perfects our minds. This shows us that we must really know the truth, not merely believe true opinions.8
In part 9 of this article, we considered more-specifically what studies (sciences) belong in a Catholic Liberal Education.9
Below, in part 10, we explore the motive and the goal of a true Catholic Liberal Education.
What Are the Motive and the Goal of a True Catholic Liberal Education?
A
Catholic Liberal Education Begins in Wonder and Aims at Wisdom
Part 10
In an earlier part of this article10, we saw that the seven liberal arts are important studies by means of which we should begin our study of the highest sciences – which are philosophy and theology.
We saw that the liberal arts are not the only parts of liberal education or even the most important parts, but they are the key beginning of it. They develop our thinking and help make our minds disciplined, vigorous, and animated by wonder, so that we will not only desire, but also have the means to can acquire knowledge and wisdom, especially the highest truths, which are again, those of philosophy and theology.
Here is the motive and goal of the education that all of us should seek, each according to his circumstances:
A
true, Catholic Liberal Education
begins in wonder and aims at
wisdom.
Let us “unpack” that statement by first looking at what we mean by wonder and then let us consider what wisdom is.
What
is Wonder?
Wonder is the proper human motive for true education. Wonder involves two things simultaneously: ignorance and knowledge (in different respects). Man finds himself wondering because, at the same time, he both knows something and also doesn’t know everything.
Let us contrast wonder with mere curiosity. Wonder implies that a person knows a group of facts (i.e., truths) and, knowing these facts, he seeks an explanation of them – viz., their causes. Wonder involves a certain delight and joy, a sort of fascination with the way things are. But at the same time, the person has a certain lack of comfort because he is aware of his own lack of knowledge. So he asks why things are the way they are. Wonder implies that a person has a certain confidence that the world around him is ultimately explainable. When a person is animated by wonder, he goes through his day, week, or month, seeing additional intellectual connections between various things. He goes through life seeing more aspects of the world around him which are interesting and for which he seeks explanations.
By contrast, a person motivated by curiosity is more interested in questions concerning how. When a person is motivated by curiosity, he is not so interested in questions concerning why – and is not so motivated to seek to know why something is true and what its causes are. Rather, curiosity leads a person to focus on seeking to do something and desiring to see if his idea will “work” to achieve a useful practical result or even merely a sensational spectacle. A curious man ultimately seeks power.11 He is more concerned to see how certain generalizations work or how they apply to varying circumstances. In contrast to a person who wonders, a person motivated by curiosity assumes the validity of a principle, in order to see how effectively this principle can be harnessed to exploit a given situation in order to achieve a particular useful result.
This is not to say that the methods of verification in experimental science may not very well be an instrument of wonder of a high order, but when those instruments are employed not in order to understand the truths of Nature, but in order to find what works, then curiosity and not wonder is the immediate motive.
So the man who wonders at the lightning he sees in the sky is considering questions such as what causes lightning and what is the nature of lightning. But the man who sees the lightning and seeks to protect his house from being struck by lightning is curious rather than wondering. He asks himself things such as, if he places a metal pole on his roof, will that protect his house?
The proper satisfaction of a man who wonders is knowledge of the causes of things around us, e.g., what is lightning and what causes it. By contrast, the proper satisfaction of a curious man is seeing that his idea works successfully, e.g., the
lightning rod protected his house from a lightning strike. 12
Curiosity and the practical improvements engendered by it are generally not evil13 and are sometimes even necessary. But they are much lower than the possession of universal, eternal truth. Such curiosity is lower than wonder in a way similar to food for the body being lower than food for the mind. This is because wonder leads to the perfection of our intellect; curiosity leads to perfection of the practical circumstances of our life. The perfection of our intellect is much greater and nobler!
So a man who sees and wonders is spurred on to learn the causes of the things around him because they are interesting and the world around him is explainable by reason. Those causes are worthy of investigation for the sake of the truth because Nature is worthy of investigation (and even more worthy is the First Cause of Nature, Who is God). By contrast, curiosity spurs a man to solve a problem which improves the practical aspects of his life or otherwise helps him, e.g., have a safer home.
Thus, a liberal education begins in wonder, not in curiosity. By contrast (for example), building a better mousetrap begins in curiosity, not in wonder.
So a Catholic Liberal Education begins with wonder and involves the seeking of the truth which is the knowledge of the causes of things. This true education aims at wisdom (as we stated above).
But what is wisdom? Let us next consider that question.
First, Let Us Remember that Wisdom is a Priceless Treasure!
First, let us reflect that wisdom is one of the most important blessings from God. “All wisdom is from the Lord God”.14
Wisdom is incomparably better than fame, prestige, power, riches, pleasures, or comfort. As the Book of Wisdom declares:
I preferred her [viz., wisdom] before kingdoms and thrones, and esteemed riches nothing in comparison of her. Neither did I compare unto her any precious stone: for all gold in comparison of her, is as a little sand, and silver in respect to her shall be counted as clay.15
In fact:
Wisdom is better than all the most precious things: and whatsoever may be desired cannot be compared to it.16
And:
She [i.e., wisdom] is an infinite treasure to men! 17
Therefore, we should pursue wisdom above all of these things. As the wise man teaches us in the Book of Proverbs:
Get wisdom, because it is better than gold.18
What is Wisdom?
St. Thomas Aquinas explains to us (following Aristotle’s teaching) that:
Wisdom is a knowledge of causes.19
This definition fits perfectly with what we saw above about wonder. That is, seeking the true knowledge which is offered in a Catholic Liberal Education begins in wonder. As we saw above, true wonder (as contrasted to mere curiosity) motivates us to seek to understand the things that are, and to know their causes.
The
Wisdom We Discuss Here (and Which We Seek) is Wisdom Simply
Speaking,
not Wisdom in a Restricted
Sense
In this present article, we are considering the nature of wisdom simply, that is, unqualifiedly. Let us contrast this unqualified wisdom to what we could call “wisdom” as that word is used in a narrow or restricted sense.
In a qualified sense – i.e., in some way – we could call something “wisdom” which is the knowledge of causes pertaining to a narrow field or pursuit, such as carpentry (or one of the other manual arts). A man could be called a “wise carpenter” because he has the knowledge of the causes of his art. For example, a “wise carpenter” might reject the use of a particular beam (i.e., plank) which is full of knots because he knows that such a beam would not possess the strength it should have because those knots weaken it.
Such a carpenter is not wise absolutely speaking (unqualifiedly) but is wise in a certain, limited respect (viz., regarding his particular field), because he knows the causes which affect his own special art.
But in this present article, we are considering the wisdom by which we would call a man “wise” without qualification, as opposed to calling him “wise” only in a certain specialized respect (as we would say a “wise carpenter”). In other words, in this article we are examining what wisdom is absolutely, because of which we would call a man “wise” without adding any qualification such as “carpenter”.
This distinction is similar to the difference between a man being called “good” without qualification (because he possesses great virtue) as contrasted to a person being called “good” qualifiedly, such as being a “good plumber” or a “good assassin”. Being a “good assassin” refers to the person possessing a high degree of the assassin’s skill for killing people. We do not call this assassin “good” without qualification (but we could call him “good” in this certain respect).
Likewise, calling a man “wise” with respect to carpentry is not the same as calling him “wise” without qualification. So in this article, we examine the nature of wisdom as it gives a general excellence to a person and because of which he would be called “wise” as a person (and not in a qualified sense such as wise as a carpenter).
There
Are Two Kinds of Wisdom Simply
Speaking
There are two kinds of wisdom simply speaking. They are speculative20 wisdom and practical wisdom. Both of them are the knowledge of causes, but in different ways. They reflect the two kinds of causes that every person should know. Each of these kinds of wisdom causes a person to be called “wise” without qualification:
-
Because of speculative wisdom, a person is called wise as the knower of the deep causes of things, especially the First Cause of all things; and
-
Because of practical wisdom, a person is called wise as a doer, acting well in light of his final end.
Both kinds of wise men we call “wise” simply speaking, without limiting this adjective by a qualifying word such as “carpenter”.
Let us briefly look at each of these types of wisdom.
What
Is Speculative Wisdom?
Speculative wisdom is wisdom in those matters which concern the highest truths21 which are most worth knowing and which most-greatly perfect our intellects.
But in addition to knowing high truths, we must also know the causes of those high truths; (of course, God is uncaused but is the ultimate Cause of everything else). It is important that, in knowing the highest truths, we also know their causes because we do not know something fully if we do not know its causes.
But there is a difference in causes. Some are lower-level, proximate causes which are themselves caused by higher causes. For example, a dog is one of the causes of its own puppies but God is the higher cause of not only those puppies, but also the parent dogs, as well as all other dogs and creatures.
The most complete and most satisfying knowledge of a thing is to know it with all of its causes, even up to (and especially) the Highest Cause, which is the First and Highest Cause of all creatures. This is God.
St. Paul infallibly teaches us that we can know God by natural reason, as the First Cause of all other things. In other words, looking at creatures, we can see God’s work in them and that God is their cause. Here are St. Paul’s words:
[T]he invisible things of Him [viz., God], from the creatures of the world, are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made; His eternal power also, and Divinity.22
St. Thomas refers to speculative wisdom when he explains (following Aristotle’s teaching) that “it belongs to wisdom to consider the Highest Cause.”23
This knowledge of things with their highest causes is the deepest and fullest way to know things and is speculative wisdom.
The science which treats of the first causes (including naturally knowable truths about God Himself, such as His existence and some of His perfections) in the light of the natural capacity of human reason is called metaphysics – which is a type of speculative wisdom – as this wisdom is attainable by the power of human reason. The science which studies God in the higher light of what He has revealed about Himself is also called speculative wisdom, but it is wisdom as attainable by the greater light of the Catholic Faith. Thus, Catholic theology is the highest wisdom and is the principal satisfaction of wonder on this side of the grave.
What
Is Practical Wisdom?
The other kind of wisdom is called practical wisdom and is also called prudence. It is one of the four Cardinal Virtues. It is also a Gift of the Holy Ghost, as well as an infused moral virtue (infused into the souls of those who are in the state of Sanctifying Grace).
Practical wisdom is concerned with right reason as it applies to our active life. This wisdom regulates the passions and appetites which move us. Practical wisdom does this by ordering all of our actions (and our life) to our Final End. This Final End is also called the Final Cause of our actions because our end (that is, the goal) is the ultimate cause (reason) why we do what we do.
For example, suppose that a man has an urgent need to travel to an adjoining city immediately. He might go into his bedroom, for the sake of getting his car keys. His obtaining his keys is for the sake of driving his car, which is for the sake of going to the gas station, which is for the sake of filling his empty gas tank, which is for the sake of being able to drive to that adjoining city without running out of gas, all for the sake of making the urgent journey. The Final Cause (the ultimate reason) for each of those activities was in order to arrive in the adjoining city. In other words, finally, the cause of all of those activities was the arriving there. By contrast, if the man stopped to read a novel, the Final Cause of that pastime would not be the urgent trip to the adjoining city.
Likewise, any part of our life which does not promote our Final Cause, is vain. Anything we do which will not help us to achieve the goal for which we have been created (and for which are on earth) is ultimately foolishness that we will regret. That is why one way in which practical wisdom can be summed up is as follows:
It is Practical Wisdom (Prudence) to live every minute of our lives in the way that, at our Judgment, we will want to have lived.
Here is how St. Ignatius of Loyola teaches this practical wisdom:
Man is created to praise, reverence, and serve God Our Lord, and by this means to save his soul. All other things on the face of the earth are created for man to help him fulfill the end for which he is created. From this it follows that man is to use these things to the extent that they will help him to attain his end. Likewise, he must rid himself of them insofar as they prevent him from attaining it.
Therefore, we must make ourselves indifferent to all created things, insofar as it is left to the choice of our free will and is not forbidden. Acting accordingly, for our part, we should not prefer health to sickness, riches to poverty, honor to dishonor, a long life to a short one, and so in all things we should desire and choose only those things which will best help us attain the end for which we are created.24
St. Paul urged his flock to live according to practical wisdom when he taught them that they should:
Walk with wisdom towards them that are without.25
St. Paul is teaching us that (practical) wisdom should guide our actions, i.e., our “walk”.
Following St. Augustine, Doctor of the Church, St. Thomas Aquinas teaches that prudence, i.e., practical wisdom, “judges of human acts by Divine things, and directs human acts according to Divine rules.”26
We see that practical wisdom should cause us to order our lives fearing the Lord so that we can live a life obeying Him and living in His friendship. Here is one way in which the Book of Proverbs teaches this truth:
The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom.27
As we saw in an earlier part of our current investigation of The Blessings of a True Catholic Liberal Education,28 we should study the truths of Ethics and Politics to attain this practical wisdom.
Both
Types of Wisdom Have the Same Ultimate Object: God
We see, by looking at both speculative wisdom and practical wisdom, that God is the beginning and end. That is, both kinds of wisdom ultimately are knowledge of God but in different aspects.
Speculative wisdom starts with all of the various truths around us and traces them back to their First Cause, Who is God. By contrast, through Ethics and Politics, practical wisdom considers our Final End (Who is God) as the reason and guiding principle for all of our actions and makes sure that all of our actions are for the sake of Him, Who is our Last End and our Final Cause (to use the proper philosophical term).
Thus, we see more fully the literal truth of what Our Lord says in the Apocalypse:
I am Alpha and Omega, the beginning and the end.29
Our Lord is the Beginning and First Cause of all that exists; He is the End and Highest Principle to which all of our actions and our lives should conform.
So in all of the studies of a true education, God is the ultimate subject of study – as the First Beginning (the First Cause) of the speculative sciences, and as the Last End of the practical sciences of Ethics and true Political Science.
This
Lifetime Pursuit of Wisdom Is The Life of a Free Man
Now through the efforts of a lifetime of study, a man can more fully acquire deeper and broader wisdom. But such precious wisdom nonetheless is indeed the work of a lifetime.
However, this man’s whole “journey” – even the earlier part – should be characterized by the pursuit of this great good, and this work of his entire life is rightly called philosophy – which means the love of wisdom. For every study such a man undertakes is for the sake of wisdom.
And insofar as he lives for wisdom, his whole life is devoted to that which in itself makes life worth living. Thus, he is not a slave but a free man. Accordingly, only the kind of education which introduces a man to the philosophical life is properly named liberal.
Conclusions
of this Present Part of the Article (viz.,
Part 10)
A true, Catholic Liberal Education begins in wonder and aims at wisdom. God made us to wonder at the world around us and to perfect our minds seeking the causes of things. This is speculative wisdom. He instilled this healthy sense of wonder in us precisely so that we would seek Him, the Cause of causes.
Practical wisdom is acting according to our final end (i.e., goal), which is the Final Cause of all of our actions (i.e., the ultimate reason why we act).
Both types of wisdom ultimately lead back to God, the First Cause and Last End (that is, the Final Cause).
Looking
Ahead
We seek wisdom through perfecting our
highest faculty – viz., our intellect – with the highest
truths. But there are many authors of many books written on the
subjects which are studied in a Catholic Liberal Education.
Which ones are best to use in these studies?
To Be Continued …
1 Part 1 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/06/28/the-blessings-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education/
2 Part 2 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/07/24/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-ii/
3 Part 3 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/08/28/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-iii/
4 Part 4 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/09/24/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-iv/
5 Part 5 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/10/26/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-v/
6 Part 6 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/01/26/3129/
7 Part 7 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/02/26/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-vii/
8 Part 8 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/03/10/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-viii/
9 Part 9 of this article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/06/26/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-viii-2/
11 In this article, we are treating “scientific curiosity” which motivates inventing useful machines, experimenting to achieve quicker results or more efficient, successful processes and methods, etc. These investigations are generally not evil in themselves but are a lower, practical goal, as compared to the truth about the causes of things.
But the word “curiosity” is also used to mean something sinful and lower than the “scientific curiosity” discussed here. This lower curiosity is the useless and idle desire to know about people or things that do not concern one’s self. This is also called “nosiness” and refers to things such as the desire to know one’s neighbor’s private affairs, or seeking to discover the gossipy details of the private lives of celebrities. Such idle curiosity, which is a sin, is not the type of curiosity which is contrasted with wonder in this article.
12 Of course, there is nothing to prevent a man from having both wonder and curiosity about the same subject. So, by wonder, a man could want to know the causes of lightning; and by curiosity, also want to harvest its power, protect himself from it, etc. Or, curiosity could eventually cause wonder, or we suppose, wonder could degrade into mere curiosity.
13 However, some developments caused by curiosity can be evil, such as many aspects of bio-engineering, stem-cell research, vaccines developed using the bodies of murdered babies, etc.
14 Ecclesiasticus, 1:1.
15 Book of Wisdom, 7:8-9.
16 Book of Proverbs, 8:11.
17 Book of Proverbs, 7:14.
18 Book of Proverbs, 16:16.
19 St. Thomas Aquinas, Commentary on Aristotle’s Metaphysics, Bk 1, Ch 2.
20 The word “speculative” comes from the Latin word, “speculari”, meaning “to observe”. The word “speculative” here refers to matters which are studied and learned because of their intrinsic value and without seeking practical application leading to action.
This is the original meaning of the word and is very different from the modern usage of the word “speculative” which means “doubtful or based on conjecture”.
21 Here is one way that St. Thomas Aquinas, Greatest Doctor of the Church, explains this point:
Man’s good [unqualifiedly] consists in the knowledge of truth; yet man’s sovereign [i.e., chief] good consists, not in the knowledge of any truth whatever, but in the perfect knowledge of the sovereign truth [i.e., God], as the Philosopher [Aristotle] states (Ethic. x, 7, 8).
Summa, IIa IIae Q. 167. A1, ad 1 (bracketed words added for clarity).
22 Romans, 1:19-20 (bracketed content added to show context).
23 Summa, IIa IIae, Q.45, a.1, Respondeo.
24 Principle and Foundation of the Spiritual Exercises of St. Ignatius.
25 Colossians, 4:5.
26 Summa, IIa IIae, Q.45 a.3, respondeo.
27 Book of Proverbs, 9:10.
28 For a fuller explanation of the importance of studying true Ethics and Politics, read this article: https://catholiccandle.org/2026/06/10/the-blessing-of-a-true-catholic-liberal-education-part-ix/
29 Apocalypse, 1:8 (emphasis added).