Words to Live By – From Catholic Tradition

If We Wish to Choose Christ,
Then We Must Wish to Receive the Hatred of the World

A person refuses to be in the Mystical Body of Christ if he does not wish to receive, along with Christ our Head, the hatred of the world. We ought to patiently receive the hatred of the world out of the love for Christ. For it is necessary for the world to hate us because we resolve to reject what the world loves.

St. Thomas Aquinas, Greatest Doctor of the Church, Quoting St. Augustine, Doctor of the Church, in the Catena Aurea on St. John’s Gospel, ch.15, §5.

Lesson #51: Temperaments – Choleric Temperament – The Cholerics’ Spiritual Combat Part XVI

Philosophy Notes

Catholic Candle note: The article below is part sixteen of the study of the Choleric temperament. The first fifteen parts can be found here:

  1. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #36: About the Temperaments – Beginning our Study of the Choleric Temperament – Part I: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/08/27/lesson-35-about-the-temperaments-the-choleric-temperament/

  2. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #37: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament– Part II: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/09/26/lesson-37-about-the-temperaments-continuation-of-the-choleric-temperament/

  3. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #38: About the Temperaments – Continuing our Study of the Choleric Temperament – Their Spiritual Combat – Part III:: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/10/24/lesson-38-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat/

  4. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #39: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – That Temperament’s Spiritual Combat – Part IV: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/11/26/lesson-39-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat-part-iv/

  5. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #40: Temperaments – Choleric Temperament – Their Spiritual Combat – Part V: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/12/30/lesson-40-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat-part-v/

  6. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #41: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament: a Choleric’s Spiritual Combat — Part VI: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/01/27/lesson-41-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-vi/

  7. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #42: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – a Choleric’s Spiritual Combat – Part VII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/02/21/lesson-42-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-vii/

  8. Mary’s School of Sanctity — Lesson #43: About the Temperaments –Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament — Their Spiritual Combat Part VIII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/03/27/lesson-42-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-viii/

  9. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #44: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – Their Spiritual Combat, Part IX: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/04/23/lesson-44-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-ix/

  10. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #45: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat Part X: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/05/20/lesson-45-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-x/

  11. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #46: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Cholerics’ Spiritual Combat – Part XI: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/06/28/lesson-46-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xi/

  12. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #47: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat – Part XII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/07/24/lesson-47-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xii/

  13. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #48: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat Part XIII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/08/29/lesson-48-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xiii/

  14. Mary’s School of Sanctity — Lesson #49: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat Part XIV: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/09/24/lesson-49-temperaments-choleric-temperament-the-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xiv/

  1. Mary’s School of Sanctity — Lesson #50: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat Part XV: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/10/26/3050/

Mary’s School of Sanctity

Lesson #51: About the Temperaments –
Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament –
The Cholerics’ Spiritual Combat Part XVI

Note: When referring to a person with a choleric temperament in this article, we simply will call him a choleric.

In our last lesson we explained the basics about the passions and how they work in the soul. With this preparation finished, we now begin our look at the passion of fear in particular.

Using St. Thomas Aquinas as Our Guide

Because St. Thomas is so thorough in his treatment of everything, he is called the Doctor Communis, that is, the Common Doctor of the Church, because he is the one, most of all, to guide and instruct us in anything.1 We will let St. Thomas, greatest Doctor of the Church, be our guide in our study. It is very valuable to look at St. Thomas’s explanation because he shows us so clearly how we are affected by our passions – in this case, by fear.

Where do we begin?

First, after showing that fear is indeed a passion in the soul (as we saw in our last lesson), St. Thomas then addresses two important questions, “Whether Fear is a Special Passion?” and “Whether There is a Natural Fear?

To the first question he answers simply that, yes, fear is a special passion – and explains why this is true. Here are his words:

The passions of the soul derive their species2 from their objects; hence, that is a special passion which has a special object. However, fear has a special object, as hope has. For just as the object of hope is a future good, difficult but possible to obtain, so the object of fear is a future evil, difficult and irresistible. Consequently, fear is a special passion of the soul.3

To the second question (Whether There is a Natural Fear), St. Thomas begins by having us first understand what he means by the word “natural” in this context. Summarizing St. Thomas, movements can be called natural in two ways:

  1. A movement is said to be natural simply speaking when the movement occurs without the involvement of the senses or the intellect. Some examples of this are the movement of fire which naturally inclines upward, the movement of a stone which tends to fall downward, and nutritive powers of animals and plants which tend to growth and life.

  2. A movement is also said to be natural when nature inclines in a certain direction but man (or a different animal) does not move invariably. Such movement involves the senses or the intellect. St. Thomas remarks, “In this way, even the acts of the apprehensive power, such as understanding, feeling, and remembering, as well as the movements of the animal appetite, are sometimes said to be natural.”4

In this quote St. Thomas is acknowledging the fact that animals and man both have an animal nature. However, St. Thomas makes an important distinction that, for irrational animals, God put in them the ability to act in an ordered, reasonable way, and this is called instinct. By contrast, God created man to want the good and created man to use his reason to seek the good. Nevertheless, man is able to delude himself about what is good and in this way, St. Thomas tells us, that man is able to pursue the apparent good instead of the true good. So, for example, a tired student is able to pursue the apparent good of sleeping longer in the morning instead of the true good of attending class.

In a future article, we will discuss man’s ability to deceive himself. We will discuss this later, as we proceed with our study of the temperaments in general and in our focus on how fear affects each of the temperaments.

With these basic concepts in mind, let us now turn to St. Thomas’ division of the types of fear and apply them to the temperaments with a special focus on how fear hinders the intellectual life of the soul.

The Types of Fear

St. Thomas divides fear into six kinds. Here are his words:

Fear regards a future evil which surpasses the power of him who fears, so that it is irresistible. However, man’s evil, like his good, may be considered either in his action or in external things.

In his action, he has a twofold evil to fear.

1. First, there is the toil that burdens his nature: and hence arises laziness, as when he shrinks from work for fear of too much toil.

  1. Second, there is the disgrace which damages him in the opinion of others. And thus:

    1. If disgrace is feared in a deed that is yet to be done, there is shamefacedness;

    2. If, however, it be in a deed already done, there is shame.

On the other hand, the evil that consists in external things may surpass man’s faculty of resistance in three ways.

  1. First by reason of magnitude; when, that is to say, a man considers some great evil the outcome of which he is unable to gauge; and then there is amazement.

  2. Second, by reason of its being unwonted;5 because, to wit, some unwonted evil arises before us, and on that account is great in our estimation. And then there is stupor, which is caused by the representation of something unwonted.

  3. Third, by reason of its being unforeseen; thus, future misfortunes are feared, and fear of this kind is called anxiety.6

Some Considerations Regarding the Kinds of Fear Listed and Some Practical Applications

When St. Thomas is speaking of laziness here, he is referring to a man recoiling from the “toil of external work.” This pertains to a person who fears excessive toil. Anyone of any temperament could have this fear. This kind of person does not want to work but rather seeks to have fun or be idle. Of course, there are degrees of this kind of fear. In the worst case scenario, this fear prevents someone from being able to function in society and in his life. This displeases God very much.

We will discuss the various aspects of fear as we proceed with our investigation. In our study of the temperaments, one crucial thing to remember is that, in all of the difficulties people face, God expects man to use his reason to deal with all of his dilemmas. Indeed, when a person uses his reason properly – including when he forces himself to step back to consider his situation – then there is no problem that he cannot solve the way God wishes.

Shamefacedness is the fear of a base action.7 In other words, one anticipates that if he were to act in a low or base manner, he would bring embarrassment upon himself. If one uses shamefacedness properly, he would avoid doing bad deeds.

On the other hand, as St. Thomas explained above, when one does not think ahead concerning the consequences of an action, he is not using shamefacedness and is “leaping” into a bad deed. Then afterwards, he has the shame of having done the disgraceful deed. St. Thomas tells us here that shame is a kind of fear because a person fears that the past deed will be the occasion of future reproach or disgrace.

The amazement and stupor that St. Thomas is speaking about here are in regard to evil. Here are his words.

Not every amazement and stupor are species of fear, but that amazement which is caused by a great evil, and that stupor which arises from an unwonted evil. Or else we may say that, just as laziness shrinks from the toil of external work, so amazement and stupor shrink from the difficulty of considering a great and unwonted thing, whether good or evil: so that amazement and stupor stand in relation to the act of the intellect, as laziness does to external work.8

Here we find how St. Thomas aptly describes the fear of intellectual effort that affects so many people of all temperaments. We had discussed how the choleric who has bad will does not make the necessary efforts to think. One reason for this is because he does not want to take the time necessary to do a good job (by thinking carefully). Yet, the underlying cause is his fear of the mental toil. If he were to build the habit of thinking carefully, then he would no longer fear the effort required. As we will see in future articles, it is not only cholerics that fear intellectual efforts.

The devil certainly does not want anyone to enjoy using his highest faculty, viz., his intellect. Thus, the devil has been tempting man from the time of Adam’s fall until now, to believe that thinking is too hard. Of course, we must counteract this wretched falsehood of the devil and do everything we can to promote careful thinking in ourselves and in others and foster the further development of our minds.

One more consequence of the devil dissuading a person from thinking deeply and carefully about high truths is that he misses a valuable opportunity for humility through considering how ignorant he is, and comparing the little he knows to all the high and wonderful truths that there are to learn. God and His creation are marvelous and should fill us with a sense of awe! We could never learn enough to completely satisfy our natural thirst for knowledge! Therefore, thinking well promotes humility because we can better assess our limitations objectively. This is one reason why Satan does not want humans to think!

Anxiety is the last type of fear mentioned above. This fear certainly wreaks havoc on many fronts in our lives. Countless examples could be found of things that cause man anxiety. There is so much talk of stress in our lives but we rarely consider how our trusting dependence on God is a key remedy to all stress.9 This anxiety also has a direct connection to the concept of thinking deeply (discussed above). When one thinks carefully, he can be more objective in assessing his circumstances and is therefore less prone to anxiety and worry.

Something to Keep in Mind

So as we said in our last lesson, the passions are not bad in themselves. However, they must be used properly. Here we can see that fear in itself is a very important passion and when used well, it helps the moral life, and hence the spiritual life of a man.

A Preview… In our next lesson we will begin considering the Objects of Fear and will apply our understanding of fear to the temperaments.

1 Read this article explaining why faithful and informed Catholics follow Saint Thomas Aquinas more than anyone else: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/why-faithful-and-informed-catholics-especially-follow-the-doctors-of-the-church

2 Note: by “species” of passion, St. Thomas means the kinds of passions.

3 Summa, Ia IIae, Q.41, a.2, Respondeo.

4 Cf., Summa, Ia IIae, Q.41, a.3.

5 Unwonted: being out of the ordinary : rare, unusual. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/unwonted

6 Taken from the Summa, Ia IIae, Q.41, a.4, Whether the Species of Fear Are Suitably Assigned?, Respondeo, (emphasis added; bracketed words added to show the context).

7

This is St. John Damascene’s definition taken from the Summa, IIa IIae, Q.144, a.1, Respondeo.

8 Taken from the Summa, Ia IIae, Q.41, a.4, Whether the Species of Fear Are Suitably Assigned?, ad 4.

The Blessed Virgin Mary Is the Mediatrix of All Graces

Catholic Candle note: The article below pertains to one of the many scandalous errors that Pope Leo XIV has promoted, to date, during his short reign. However, a reader would be mistaken to assume that Pope Leo XIV’s grave errors somehow mean that he is not the pope.

Sedevacantism is wrong and is (material or formal) schism. Catholic Candle is not sedevacantist.

Here is what St. Bernard of Clairvaux, Doctor of the Church, teaches concerning our duty to recognize and respect the authority of a superior – such as the pope – even when he is very bad:

Even should the life of any superior be so notoriously wicked as to admit of no excuse or dissimulation, nevertheless, for God’s sake, Who is the source of all power, we are bound to honor such a one, not on account of his personal merits, which are non-existent, but because of the divine ordination and the dignity of his office.1

However, even while recognizing the pope’s authority and our duty to obey him when we are able, we know we must resist the evil he says and does. Read more about this principle here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/07/24/our-catholic-duty-resist-the-harm-done-by-a-bad-pope-but-of-course-recognize-his-authority/

To learn more about why sedevacantism is wrong and why it is schism, read Sedevacantism: Material or Formal Schism, which is available:

Defending Catholic Doctrine and Our Lady’s Honor
Against Pope Leo XIV and the Conciliar Barbarians

The Catholic Church originally set the feast of Our Lady, Mediatrix of All Graces, on May 31 of each year. In the 1962 Missal (which is inferior to the Missals preceding it), this feast of Our Lady was moved to May 8 by the liturgical barbarian, Annibale Bugnini.


The Conciliar Church Minimizes Our Lady

One of the hallmarks of the ongoing, evil, conciliar revolution is the continual efforts to minimize the honor of the Glorious Mother of God.

For example, Vatican II admonishes us to beware of being excessive in our praise for Our Lady. Here are the council’s words in one place:

[The council] exhorts theologians and preachers of the divine word to abstain zealously both from all gross exaggerations as well as from petty narrow-mindedness in considering the singular dignity of the Mother of God.2

This type of admonishment is sprinkled throughout the council’s documents. Such warnings are not strictly and literally false, because we should always avoid being “excessive” in any way, since anything “excessive” is always bad and unreasonable. However, the council’s admonishment here is a message to people to be less devoted to our Lady and to not emphasize her greatness.

This message is similar to warning people to “avoid excessive trust” in the honesty of a particular man whenever that man’s name is mentioned. That warning would clearly indicate to people that they should trust this man less. Likewise, the conciliar warnings to “zealously” (!) avoid “excessive” devotion to Our Lady tell people to be less devoted to her.

Woe to these men (and all) who insult Our Lord by dishonoring His Mother in this way! Pope St. Pius X condemned this type of false (so-called) “zeal” for Our Lord – which Vatican II promoted – and which is an excuse to minimize the honor of the Blessed Virgin Mary. Here are Pope St. Pius X’s words:

Wretched and unhappy are they who neglect Mary under pretext of the honor to be paid to Jesus Christ! As if the Child could be found elsewhere than with the Mother!3

These conciliar warnings caused true devotion to Mary to plummet and any remaining devotion to her tends to be more shallow and to have a more emotional, less doctrinal foundation. One indication that devotion to her has grown cold, is the fact that true devotion to Mary always comes with an intolerance of heresy, since our Lady crushes heresy. By contrast, intolerance of heresy is almost non-existent in the conciliar church.


Why Does the Conciliar Church Minimize Our Lady?

One reason that the conciliar church minimizes Our Lady is because the conciliar churchmen are ecumenical fanatics. They minimize the role of the Blessed Virgin Mary because that truth irritates the protestants and others who are outside the ark of salvation – which is the Catholic Church. The protestants ignore Our Lady and they vociferously object to the Catholic truth that all of the blessings of God come through the hands of the Blessed Virgin Mary. Thus, Vatican II and the conciliar churchmen minimize the Glorious Mother of God in order to please the enemies of God.

The post-conciliar popes (each in his turn) minimized Our Lady – Pope Francis more than the earlier post-Vatican II popes. Following Pope Francis, Pope Leo XIV continues on that evil conciliar path of minimizing Our Lady’s honor.

Pope Leo XIV Minimizes Our Lady in His Document Entitled Mater Populi Fidelis

Pope Leo XIV is a man of the conciliar revolution and a man of Vatican II. On October 7, 2025, he approved of a new document, Mater Populi Fidelis, which he issued through the Dicastery For The Doctrine of the Faith.

Like Vatican II itself, he warns us that devotion to the Blessed Virgin Mary can distract us from her Son. Here are his words:

[A]ny gaze directed at her that distracts us from Christ or that places her on the same level as the Son of God would fall outside the dynamic proper to an authentically Marian faith.4

So, just like Vatican II itself, Pope Leo XIV warns us to beware of zeal for the honor Our Lady because it could detract from the honor of her Son. He unreasonably warns us that gazing at Our Lady can reduce her Son’s honor. Woe to Pope Leo XIV! He shows himself to fall within Pope St. Pius X’s apt description – “wretched and unhappy” – referring to those who minimize Our Lady’s honor.

Of course, the truth is that it virtually never happens that someone is “excessively” devoted to Our Lady! Instead, the opposite is true. We live in a time of gross disregard for the Blessed Virgin Mary. The remedy for the ills of our time is greater devotion to Our Lady.


Mater Populi Fidelis: a Document Which is Wordy, Ambiguous, and Heretical

Pope Leo XIV’s Mater Populi Fidelis is about 19,000 words and largely cautions the reader to be careful not to praise Our Lady too much or to exaggerate her greatness – as if what Catholics need to hear right now is “Beware of excessively praising Mary!”5

This lengthy document (Mater Populi) is wordy, frequently ambiguous, and contains heresy.6 Its thrust is to minimize the importance of the Blessed Virgin Mary, and devotion to her.

The evils of Mater Populi are too many to cover in a single article. The focus of the present article is the denial of Our Lady’s prerogative and her honor as being the Mediatrix of All Graces.

In this article, we will start by examining the meaning of this title of Our Lady and then review the Catholic Church’s doctrine that Our Lady is truly the Mediatrix of All Graces. After that, we will examine Pope Leo XIV’s evil teachings which are the opposite of this Catholic Dogma.


What Does It mean for Our Lady to Be the Mediatrix of All Graces?

First of all, what is a mediatrix? A mediatrix is a female mediator. Just as we use feminine pronouns for women and girls and male pronouns for men and boys, likewise we use sex-specific suffixes to indicate the gender of a person who has a certain role. For example, a man who delivers food to the tables in a restaurant is called a “waiter” and a woman who does this is called a “waitress”. This “-ress” (or “ess”) ending feminizes the word. There are countless words with such feminized endings, e.g., empress and shepherdess.

A similar Latinized feminine ending to words is “-trix” (instead of “-tress”). Thus:

  • a female executor of a person’s will (and estate) is called an “executrix”.7

  • likewise, Our Lady is called the “Mediatrix of all Graces”.

Ok. So a “Mediatrix” is a Female Mediator. But What Does It Mean for Our Lady to be the Mediatrix of All Graces?

A mediator:

  • is one who helps to resolve a dispute;8

  • occupies a middle position between two parties in disagreement;9 and

  • is a conciliator, an intermediary, a peacemaker, an intercessor.10

So Our Lady is our peacemaker with her Son arising out of mankind’s great offenses against Him. Making peace is accomplished through Sanctifying Grace, as St. Thomas Aquinas teaches:

Sanctifying Grace is given chiefly in order that man’s soul may be united to God by charity.11

This charity is friendship with God and reconciles us with God.12 So Our Lady reconciles us with her Son through Sanctifying Grace.

So Our Lady’s title “Mediatrix of all Graces” refers to her being our help reconciling us with her Son. It is her unique role (and privilege) to assist her Son in distributing to sinners all the graces of His Salvific Act of redemption. By distributing her Son’s graces to men, she is aiding her Son by reconciling mankind to Him.

Our Lady’s assistance to her Son in His work of the sanctification of souls is analogous to a nurse playing a uniquely important role in helping a physician by distributing for him the necessary medicine to his patients. Our Lady uniquely aids her Son although she is not Divine (and although she herself depends on redemption by her Son), just as the nurse is not a physician but can be a unique aid in his work.


Couldn’t God Have Distributed His Graces to Mankind Without Mary?

God could indeed have distributed His graces to mankind without Mary’s aid. This is like the physician (in the example above, who uses the nurse’s help to distribute the medicine) would be capable of distributing the medicine himself. The fact that Our Lady distributes all of the graces of God does not mean that God could not have accomplished this work differently. However, God chose this way to do His work of sanctification because it is the best way.

Reflect on this: God caused the universe to be the best possible one for His own greater honor and glory.13 As the Holy Ghost teaches in the Book of Proverbs: “The Lord hath made all things for Himself”. Proverbs, 16:4. No other motive (other than His own glory) would be worthy of Him.

God could have caused the universe to be different than it is. Two ways God could have caused the universe to be different are: 1) to not redeem man at all, after his fall; or, 2) after He redeemed man, to not use the help of the Blessed Virgin Mary in distributing the graces which He merited for the redemption of man. However, God did redeem man and He did use the help of the Blessed Virgin Mary in distributing the graces necessary for salvation, because this is the perfect way for God to save the elect and God does all things in the best possible way.14

So, as shown below, the Blessed Virgin Mary IS the Mediatrix of All Graces. The reason for this is because God chose the best way to sanctify man and to save the elect. This is like the fact that God chose to redeem man by dying on the cross not because there was no other way for God to accomplish salvation, but because this was the best, most perfect way.

Here is how St. Louis Marie Grignon de Montfort explains the perfection of God’s plan in making Mary the Mediatrix of All Graces:

God the Holy Ghost entrusted his wondrous gifts to Mary, His faithful spouse, and chose her as the dispenser of all He possesses, so that she distributes all His gifts and graces to whom she wills, as much as she wills, how she wills and when she wills. No heavenly gift is given to men which does not pass through her virginal hands. Such indeed is the will of God, who has decreed that we should have all things through Mary, so that, making herself poor and lowly, and hiding herself in the depths of nothingness during her whole life, she might be enriched, exalted and honored by almighty God. Such are the views of the Church and the early Fathers.15

St. Louis continues:

God in these times wishes his Blessed Mother to be more known, loved and honored than she has ever been. This will certainly come about if the elect, by the grace and light of the Holy Ghost, adopt the interior and perfect practice of the devotion which I shall later unfold. Then, they will clearly see that beautiful Star of the Sea, as much as Faith allows. Under her guidance they will perceive the splendors of this Queen and will consecrate themselves entirely to her service as subjects and slaves of love. They will experience her motherly kindness and affection for her children. They will love her tenderly and will appreciate how full of compassion she is and how much they stand in need of her help. In all circumstances they will have recourse to her as their advocate and mediatrix with Jesus Christ. They will see clearly that she is the safest, easiest, shortest and most perfect way of approaching Jesus and will surrender themselves to her, body and soul, without reserve in order to belong entirely to Jesus. …

All this is taken from St. Bernard and St. Bonaventure. According to them, we have three steps to take in order to reach God. The first, nearest to us and most suited to our capacity, is Mary; the second is Jesus Christ; the third is God the Father. To go to Jesus, we should go to Mary, our mediatrix of intercession. To go to God the Father, we must go to Jesus, our Mediator of redemption.16

Thus, we see that Mary being the Mediatrix of All Graces means that she assists her Son and is our help and our go-between with her Son, not because it was the only way that Our Lord could save souls but because it was the best way and was the way He willed to accomplish this work.

It is Infallible Catholic Doctrine that Mary Is the Mediatrix of All Graces

Mary being Mediatrix of All Graces is an excellent example of a Catholic dogma which was never defined by the Extraordinary Magisterium of the Church but which has always been infallibly taught by the consistent teaching of the Church’s Ordinary Magisterium.

But before we get to some of the principal teachings of this dogma, let us recall some important truths of the catechism concerning the difference between the Church’s infallible Ordinary Magisterium, as compared to the Church’s Extraordinary Magisterium:

  • All that God has divinely revealed to man is called Divine Revelation.

  • Divine Revelation has two founts (i.e., sources): Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition.

  • Since God is its Author, all that is contained in Divine Revelation is certain, true, and is part of the Catholic Faith.

  • The Catholic Church is the guardian and sole interpreter of Divine Revelation, and teaches the Faithful all the contents of Divine Revelation. This teaching authority is called Her Magisterium.

  • God has given the Church the gift of infallibility – the gift of being unable to err when authoritatively teaching the whole Church anything about Faith or morals.

  • All of these truths which she teaches infallibly are called dogmas (i.e., doctrines).

  • She can teach dogmas to the Faithful using either Her extraordinary infallible Magisterium or Her ordinary infallible Magisterium. Both the ordinary and extraordinary magisterial methods faithfully transmit dogmas to the Faithful without error.


  • The easier method to understand, and the one most Catholics are familiar with, is the extraordinary Magisterium. A declaration of the Church’s extraordinary Magisterium is a single declaration which includes the conditions which show that this single declaration itself is infallible.


  • By contrast, the Church’s ordinary Magisterium is not infallible in virtue of one particular declaration. But it is the chain of teachings by Church authorities which show that the same truth was always taught and held by the Church and for this reason it is included in the body of the truths of the Faith because it was always taught and held by the Church since the time of the apostles.


Having now recalled what it means that a truth is taught by the infallible Ordinary Magisterium of the Church, let us now read a sampling of the most important (among countless other) occasions on which the Catholic Church has taught the dogma that Mary is the Mediatrix of All Graces.

We start with some of the many occasions on which the Church taught this doctrine shortly before the Vatican II revolution in the human element of the Church. Then, after these more recent occasions, we will proceed to set forth some of the countless occasions on which this doctrine was taught throughout Church history.

Pope Pius XII – (reigned 1939-1958)

In his encyclical Mediator Dei, Pope Pius XII emphasizes the universality of Mary’s role as dispenser of grace, saying:

She gives us her Son and with Him all the help we need, for God ‘wished us to have everything through Mary’.17

Pope Pius XII declared that the Blessed Virgin Mary is the “the Mediatrix of peace”,18 showing not only that she is mediatrix, but also that her mediation pertains to grace, which is the source of our peace with God (as shown above).

In his Apostolic Exhortation Menti Nostrae, Pope Pius XII declared:

To the Beloved Mother of God, mediatrix of heavenly graces, We entrust the priests of the whole world in order that, through her intercession, God will vouchsafe a generous outpouring of His Spirit which will move all ministers of the altar to holiness and, through their ministry, will spiritually renew the face of the earth.19

Pope Pius XI – (reigned 1922-1939)

When urging the faithful to Eucharistic adoration, Pope Pius XI invokes Our Lady as Mediatrix of All Graces, in the following words:

Let, therefore, this year the Feast of the Sacred Heart be for the whole Church one of holy rivalry of reparation and supplication. Let the faithful hasten in large numbers to the eucharistic board, hasten to the foot of the altar to adore the Redeemer of the world, under the veils of the Sacrament, that you, Venerable Brethren, will have solemnly exposed that day in all churches, let them pour out to that Merciful Heart that has known all the griefs of the human heart, the fullness of their sorrow, the steadfastness of their faith, the trust of their hope, the ardor of their charity. Let them pray to Him, interposing likewise the powerful patronage of the Blessed Virgin Mary, Mediatrix of all graces, for themselves and for their families, for their country, for the Church; let them pray to Him for the Vicar of Christ on earth and for all the other Pastors, who share with him the dread burden of the spiritual government of souls; let them pray for their brethren who believe, for their brethren who err, for unbelievers, for infidels, even for the enemies of God and the Church, that they may be converted, and let them pray for the whole of poor mankind.20

When promoting devotion to the Sacred Heart of Jesus, Pope Pius XI closes with this edifying consideration:

Trusting in her intercession with Christ, who whereas He is the “one mediator of God and men” (1 Timothy ii, 5), chose to make His Mother the advocate of sinners, and the minister and mediatress of grace ….21

Pope Pius XI teaches that Our Lady is the mediatrix of all good that comes to us. Here are his words:

We know, though, that everything comes to us from Almighty God through the hands of Our Lady.22

Pope Benedict XV – (reigned 1914-1922) – (including the authority of St. Dominic)

Pope Benedict XV not only taught that Our Lady makes the decisions and administers [the Latin is “administra et arbitra”] all graces given to mankind, but the pope also taught that St. Dominic knew this same truth too. Here are the pope’s words in an encyclical on St. Dominic:

He [St. Dominic] knew that Mary’s influence with her Divine Son was such that whatever graces He confers on men, it was for her to judge and distribute them.23

(Catholic Candle note: When we read the truth (as here) that it was for Mary to judge what graces to give to men, it “goes without saying” that God gave her the knowledge and wisdom to decide perfectly and that her will was perfectly conformed to His Will.)


Pope St. Pius X (1903-1914) – (including the authority of St. Bernardine of Sienna)

This saintly pope declared that Our Lady merited to be “Dispensatrix of all the gifts that Our Savior purchased for us by His Death and by His Blood.”24 The word “dispensatrix” here describes the same role as “mediatrix” of all graces.

Because all good comes from Our Lord through Mary, Pope St. Pius X calls her the “Neck” of the Mystical Body of Christ. Here are his words, quoting St. Bernardine of Sienna:

It cannot, of course, be denied that the dispensation of these treasures is the particular and peculiar right of Jesus Christ, for they are the exclusive fruit of His Death, who by His nature is the mediator between God and man. Nevertheless, by this companionship in sorrow and suffering already mentioned between the Mother and the Son, it has been allowed to the august Virgin to be the most powerful mediatrix and advocate of the whole world with her Divine Son (Pius IX. Ineffabilis). The source, then, is Jesus Christ “of whose fullness we have all received" (John i., 16), "from whom the whole body, being compacted and fitly joined together by what every joint supplieth, according to the operation in the measure of every part, maketh increase of the body unto the edifying of itself in charity” (Ephesians iv., 16). But Mary, as St. Bernard justly remarks, is the channel (Serm. de temp on the Nativ. B. V. De Aquaeductu n. 4); or, if you will, the connecting portion the function of which is to join the body to the head and to transmit to the body the influences and volitions of the head – We mean the neck. Yes, says St. Bernardine of Sienna, “she is the neck of Our Head, by which He communicates to His mystical body all spiritual gifts” (Quadrag. de Evangel. aetern. Serm. x., a. 3, c. iii.).25

Pope St. Pius X then proceeds to explain in more detail the meaning of Mary being the conduit of all graces from her Son and why this is fitting and is the perfect way for God to accomplish the salvation of the elect:

We are then, it will be seen, very far from attributing to the Mother of God a productive power of grace – a power which belongs to God alone. Yet, since Mary surpasses [praestat] all in holiness and union with Jesus Christ, and has been associated by Jesus Christ in the work of redemption, she merits for us de congruo, in the language of theologians, what Jesus Christ merits for us de condigno,26 and she is the supreme Minister of the distribution of graces. Jesus “sitteth on the right hand of the majesty on high” (Hebrews i. b.). Mary sitteth at the right hand of her Son – a refuge so secure and a help so trusty against all dangers that we have nothing to fear or to despair of under her guidance, her patronage, her protection. (Pius IX. in Bull Ineffabilis).27

Pope Leo XIII (reigned 1878-1903) – (including the authority of St. Bernardine of Sienna)

Pope Leo XIII taught not only that Mary is the distributor of all mercies from God but also that she is the mediatrix between mankind and her Son. Here are the pope’s words:

[B]y the will of God, Mary is the intermediary through whom is distributed unto us this immense treasure of mercies [viz., from Our Lord’s Passion and Death] gathered by God; for mercy and truth were created by Jesus Christ. Thus, as no man goeth to the Father but by the Son, so no man goeth to Christ but by His Mother. … Mary is this glorious intermediary; she is the mighty Mother of the Almighty; but – what is still sweeter – she is gentle, extreme in tenderness, of a limitless loving-kindness.28

The pope elaborates on this doctrine, teaching that she is the continual Mediatrix of All Graces because she is holier and more pleasing to God than all angels and saints. Here are his words:

The recourse we have to Mary in prayer follows upon the office she continuously fills by the side of the throne of God as Mediatrix of Divine grace; being by worthiness and by merit most acceptable to Him, and, therefore, surpassing in power all the angels and saints in Heaven.29

The pope explains that all good comes to us through Mary:

Now may God, “Who in His most merciful Providence gave us this Mediatrix.” and “decreed that all good should come to us by the hands of Mary” (St. Bernard), receive propitiously our common prayers and fulfill our common hopes.30

Adopting the teaching of St. Bernardine of Siena as his own, Pope Leo XIII further teaches that all good comes from God to Christ as Man, and from Christ to His Mother Mary and then from her to us. Here are the pope’s words:

Thus, is confirmed that law of merciful meditation of which We have spoken, and which St. Bernardine of Siena thus expresses: “Every grace granted to man has three degrees in order; for by God it is communicated to Christ [viz., as Man], from Christ it passes to the Virgin, and from the Virgin it descends to us.”31

The pope states that her power is “all but unlimited” and will last forever:

She who was so intimately associated with the mystery of human salvation is just as closely associated with the distribution of the graces which for all time will flow from the Redemption.

The power thus put into her hands is all but unlimited. … Among her many other titles we find her hailed as “our Lady, our Mediatrix,” “the Reparatrix of the whole world,” “the Dispenser of all heavenly gifts.”32

Pope Leo XIII then turns the eyes of his soul to Our Lady and prays:

O Virgin most holy, none abounds in the knowledge of God except through thee; none, O Mother of God, attains salvation except through thee; none receives a gift from the throne of mercy except through thee.”33

Pope Pius IX (1846-1878)

In 1849, in an encyclical on the Immaculate Conception, Pope Pius IX taught that:

God has committed to Mary the treasury of all good things, in order that everyone may know that through her are obtained every hope, every grace, and all salvation. For this is His will, that we obtain everything through Mary.34

Pope Pius IX taught many important truths about the Glorious Mother of God and her mediation for us with her Son. For example:

The Mother of God is the seat of all divine graces and is adorned with all gifts of the Holy Ghost. To them Mary is an almost infinite treasury. … The only one who has become the dwelling place of all the graces of the most Holy Spirit. … [She] stands at the right hand of her only-begotten Son, Jesus Christ our Lord, she presents our petitions in a most efficacious manner. What she asks, she obtains. Her pleas can never be unheard. … who, is the most powerful Mediatrix and Conciliatrix of the whole world with her only-begotten Son.35


St. Alphonsus de Liguori — Doctor of the Church (1696-1787)

Here is the great Doctor of the Church, St. Alphonsus de Liguori, singing the great glories of the Mother of God:

That Mary was more holy in the first moment of her existence than all the Saints together, is founded on the great office of mediatress of men, with which she was charged from the beginning; and which made it necessary that she should possess a greater treasure of grace from the beginning than all other men together.36

St. Alphonsus explains in what way the Blessed Virgin Mary’s role is necessary, that is, in order for God’s Plan to be perfect:

That it is most useful to have recourse to the intercession of Mary can only be doubted by those who do not have the faith. … [T]he intercession of Mary is even necessary to salvation: we say necessary – not absolutely, but morally. This necessity proceeds from the Will of God Itself, that all graces that He dispenses should pass through the hands of Mary ….37

St. Alphonsus explains further the role of God’s Mother:

We acknowledge that Jesus Christ is the only mediator of justice, as we have stated above, who by His merits obtains for us grace and salvation; but we affirm that Mary is the mediatrix of grace, and although whatever she obtains, she obtains through the merits of Jesus Christ, and because she prays and asks for it in the name of Jesus Christ, yet whatever favors we ask are all obtained through her intercession.38 …

He [God] takes great complacency [i.e., satisfaction] in seeing His mother honored, and therefore wishes, as St. Bernard says, that all the graces we receive should pass through her hands.39

St. Peter Canisius – Doctor of the Church (1521-1597) – (including the teaching of St. Fulgentius)

Quoting St. Fulgentius with approval, St. Peter Canisius, Doctor of the Church, poetically proclaims that Mary is the ladder of heaven, by which men are saved. Here are his words:

Mary was made the window of heaven because by her, God gave true light unto the world. Mary was made the ladder of heaven because by her, God descended down to earth, that by her also men may ascend unto heaven.40

St. Peter Canisius here poetically teaches, although in other words, that Our Lady is the Neck of the Mystical Body of Christ, through whom her Son’s blessings come to us and through her we go to her Son.

In the Litany of the Blessed Virgin Mary (also known as the Litany of Loretto) we pray to her as the Gate of Heaven. This invocation has the same meaning, in different poetic words, as calling her our ladder to heaven and the neck of the Mystical Body of Christ. She is our way of getting to heaven and reaching her Son.

St. Thomas Aquinas – Greatest Doctor of the Church (1225-1274)

St. Thomas Aquinas, greatest Doctor of the Church, teaches that Our Lady has so much grace at her disposal that this grace suffices for the salvation of all men and that she is man’s mediatrix with her Son. Here are his words showing how fully endowed Our Lady is with the graces we need:

As much as regards it [viz., grace] overflowing unto all men. For it is a great thing in any saint, when he has so much of grace that it suffices for the salvation of many; but when one has so much that it would suffice for the salvation of all men of the world, this would be the greatest; and this is in Christ, and in the Blessed Virgin. For in every danger, you can obtain salvation from the glorious Virgin Herself.41

Second, here St. Thomas explains that Our Lady fulfills the role of superintending42 the good things we receive from her Son:

At this physical marriage [viz., at Cana, recounted in St. John’s Gospel, Ch.2] some role in the miracle belongs to the mother of Christ, some to Christ, and some to the disciples. When he [viz., St. John the Evangelist] says, When the wine ran out, he indicates the part of each. The role of Christ’s mother was to superintend the miracle; the role of Christ to perform it; and the disciples were to bear witness to it. As to the first, Christ’s mother assumed the role of a mediatrix. Hence she does two things. First, she intercedes with her Son. In the second place, she instructs the servants. As to the first, two things are mentioned. First, his mother’s intercession; secondly, the answer of her Son.43

St. Bonaventure — Doctor of the Church (1221-1274)

St. Bonaventure urges all mankind to praise the Blessed Virgin Mary in these words:

Exalt her and praise her, all the human race: because the Lord my God has given to thee [viz., the human race] such a mediatrix.44

Speaking directly to Our Lady, St. Bonaventure stated:

Thou art the Mediatrix of God, and the lover of men: the heavenly Illuminatrix of mortal men.45

Lastly, St. Bonaventure declares:

Mary is the most faithful mediatrix of our salvation.46

St. Albert the Great – Doctor of the Church (1200-1280)

St. Albert the Great calls Mary the universal dispenser of all of the goods coming from her Son. Here are his words:

The Blessed Virgin Mary is the Queen of all those things of which God is the Lord. In her is known the singular excellence of the true Sun – without corruption, without diminution, or weakening; in which is expressed the special character [viz., Immaculate] of her conception; who is the universal distributor of all goodness.47

St. Anthony of Padua – Doctor of the Church (1195-1231)

St. Anthony of Padua emphasizes Our Lady’s role as mediatrix making peace between God and man:

The Blessed Virgin Mary, our mediatrix, re-established peace between God and the sinner.48

As shown above, Our Lady makes peace between us and her Son by distributing the graces of her Son in order to make us friends of God and no longer His enemies.

St. Bernard of Clairvaux – Doctor of the Church (1090-1153)

Praying to Our Lady, St. Bernard of Clairvaux implores her help as mediatrix, to reconcile us to her Son:

Let thy boundless charity cover the multitude of our sins, and thy glorious fruitfulness bring us an abundance of mercies. Our Lady, Our Mediatrix, present us to Thy Son. Speak for us to Thy Son.49

St. Bernard teaches that Our Lady has this role in the salvation of the elect because that is the way God wants it – the best way:

It was given to Mary that thou mightest receive through her hands whatever good was destined for thee – through her hands … because it is the will of God that we should have nothing which has not passed through the hands of Mary.50

Further, in his hymn Daily, Daily, Sing to Mary (which St. Bernard composed and which emphasizes the truth that Mary is the Mediatrix of all graces), he teaches that “All our graces flow through Mary … Advocate … Mediatrix of All Grace … Heaven’s blessings she dispenses … Gate of Heaven …”


St. Germanus of Constantinople – Father of the Church (634-740)

St. Germanus teaches:

For in thee also we have been given a pledge of eternal life, and, through thy going [viz., assumed into heaven], in thee we gain a Mediatrix with God.51

St. Ephrem the Syrian – Doctor of the Church (c. 306-373 A.D.)

St. Ephrem says, addressing the Blessed Virgin Mary : “After the Mediator thou art the mediatrix of the whole world ”.52

St. Ephrem also addresses the Mother of God in these words: “In thee, patroness and mediatrix with God”53

St. Irenaeus – Father of the Church (circa 125-202 A.D.)

St. Irenaeus compares the New Eve, (viz., Our Lady), to the First Eve, the wife of Adam, declaring that Our Lady was a cause of the salvation of all of the elect. Here are his words:

As she [viz., Eve] who had Adam as her husband, but was nevertheless a virgin, was disobedient, and thereby became the cause of death to herself and to the whole of mankind, so also Mary, who had a pre-ordained husband, and was still a virgin, by her obedience became a cause of her own salvation and the salvation of the whole human race.54

Our Lord Taught Us by His Own Example That Mary His Mother is the Mediatrix of the Good Coming from Him

St. John the Evangelist recounts how, at the wedding feast at Cana, Our Lord performed His first miracle at the behest of His mother (who interceded for a bridal couple).

And the wine failing, the mother of Jesus saith to him: They have no wine. And Jesus saith to her: Woman, what is that to Me and to thee? My hour is not yet come. His mother saith to the waiters: Whatsoever He shall say to you, do ye.55

Our Lord does all things perfectly. Here He gives us the perfect example of bestowing His blessings upon people through the intercession (mediation) of His mother. This is how He Wills to bestow His blessings upon us.

As quoted above, commenting on this first of Our Lord’s miracles, St. Thomas teaches that:

The role of Christ’s mother was to superintend the miracle; the role of Christ to perform it; … Christ’s mother assumed the role of a mediatrix. Hence … she intercedes with her Son.56


The Holy Ghost Teaches Us That All Grace Comes Through Mary

In the Book of Ecclesiasticus, it states:

I am the mother of fair love, and of fear, and of knowledge, and of holy hope. In me is all grace of the way and of the truth, in me is all hope of life and of virtue.57

The Catholic Church teaches us that these words are prophetically spoken by Our Lady and the Church uses them – putting these words in her mouth – in the Mass for the Feast of Immaculate Heart of Mary.

The Holy Ghost, Who is the Chief author of these words, teaches us that all grace comes through Our Lady, His Spouse. She is “the mother” and in her “is all grace of [her Son Who is] the Way and the Truth” and the Life (as Our Lord describes Himself).58


So We See the Catholic Dogma is that Our Lady is Mediatrix of All Graces. What Does Pope Leo XIV Teach in Mater Populi Fidelis?

Pope Leo is largely proving himself to be “cut out of the same cloth” as Pope Francis, minus some of Pope Francis’s attention-grabbing stunts.

Pope Leo XIV falsely teaches that Our Lady cannot be the “universal dispenser of grace”. Here are his words:

No human person — not even the Apostles or the Blessed Virgin — can act as a universal dispenser of grace. Only God can bestow grace, and he [sic] does so through the humanity of Christ. … any expression about her “mediation” in grace must be understood as a distant analogy to Christ and his [sic] unique mediation.59

Notice that this quote – approved by Pope Leo XIV, who is supposedly so “zealous” for the honor of Christ even to the point that he is supposedly concerned that Our Lady will detract from her Son’s honor – nonetheless fails to accord to Our Lord even the customary honor of capitalizing the pronouns which refer to Him.

Here is another of Pope Leo XIV’s insulting denials of Our Lady’s prerogatives:

In the perfect immediacy between a human being and God in the communication of grace, not even Mary can intervene.60

Pope Leo XIV makes it worse by saying not only is Our Lady not the Mediatrix of All Graces, but she is not the mediatrix of any graces:

Neither friendship with Jesus Christ nor the Trinitarian indwelling can be conceived of as something that comes to us through Mary ….61

Pope Leo XIV says that Mary’s role is reduced to desiring good for us, praying for us. He says:

[W]hat we can say is that Mary desires this good for us and she asks for it, together with us.62

Pope Leo XIV says she accompanies us (using the fad conciliar jargon):

[Mary’s role is that] “she has accompanied [her children] on their way to the
Lord.
63

Pope Leo XIV says that Our Lady encourages us, and helps us to prepare ourselves. Also, Pope Leo says – blasphemously – that Mary even helps us to see that she is not a mediatrix with her Son! Here are the pope’s words:

Mary’s motherhood in the order of grace must be understood as a help in preparing us to receive God’s sanctifying grace. This can be seen in how, on the one hand, her maternal intercession is the expression of that “maternal help” which allows us to recognize Christ as the sole Mediator between God and humanity. On the other hand, her maternal presence in our lives does not preclude various actions from Mary aimed at encouraging us to open our hearts to Christ’s activity in the Holy Spirit. In this way, she helps us — in various ways — to prepare ourselves to receive the life of grace that only the Lord can pour into us. 64

Pope Leo XIV explicitly rejects the chain of mediation between God and man:

[O]ne should avoid any description that would suggest a Neoplatonic-like outpouring of grace by stages, as if God’s grace were descending through various intermediaries (such as Mary).65

Notice Pope Leo’s mockery of Our Lady as Mediatrix, by scoffing that it would be “Neoplatonic-like”.

Further, by the scope of his statement (and although presumably unintended by him), Pope Leo XIV seems even to reject that any grace from God “descends” to us through the Human Nature of Christ. Of course, Pope Leo intends by these words (above) to reject the mediation by Our Lady and to specifically reject the three-fold steps from God, to the Man Christ, to His Mother, to us, as traditionally taught by the Catholic Church, for example:

All this is taken from St. Bernard and St. Bonaventure. According to them, we have three steps to take in order to reach God. The first, nearest to us and most suited to our capacity, is Mary; the second is Jesus Christ; the third is God the Father. To go to Jesus, we should go to Mary, our mediatrix of intercession. To go to God the Father, we must go to Jesus, our Mediator of redemption.66

Pope Leo XIV continues, citing and quoting Vatican II, and warns Catholics not “to attribute to her some form of a perfective intervention, perfective instrumentality, or secondary causality in the communication of sanctifying grace” 67

The truth, though, is that this secondary causality is exactly what the Church has always infallibly taught about Mary’s role as mediatrix!

Pope Leo XIV denies that Our Lady, is Mediatrix of All Graces, and in this way is God’s tool for our salvation. Here are Pope Leo XIV’s words:

[S]he [viz., Our Lady] does not add anything to Christ’s salvific mediation in the communication of grace, she should not be regarded as the instrumental agent of that free bestowal.68

Further, in the quote below, when denying the dogma of Our Lady, as Mediatrix of All Graces, Pope Leo XIV especially singles out for denial the words of the traditional hymn Hail, Holy Queen Enthroned Above, where the hymn calls Our Lady “The Spring thorough which All Graces Flow”.

Here are Pope Leo’s impious words:

She [viz., Mary] is also frequently portrayed or imagined as a fountain from which all grace flows. If one considers the fact that the Trinitarian indwelling (uncreated grace) and our participation in the divine life (created grace) are inseparable, we cannot think that this mystery depends on a “passage” through Mary’s hands. Such notions elevate Mary so highly that Christ’s own centrality may disappear or, at least, become conditioned.69

Pope Leo XIV’s only “authority” for his denial of the Our Lady, as Mediatrix of All Graces is his fellow conciliar revolutionary and prior conciliar pope, Benedict XVI, before becoming pope:

Cardinal Ratzinger already affirmed that the title “Mary, Mediatrix of All Graces” was not clearly grounded in Revelation.  In line with this conviction, we can recognize the difficulties this title poses, both in terms of theological reflection and spirituality.70

Our Reaction to Pope Leo XIV’s Insults to the Glorious Mother of God

These are wicked words of Pope Leo XIV! These words should make the blood boil of any loyal son of Mary, in a way similar to, but greater than, when a man hears his own earthly mother being ridiculed or insulted.

King St. Louis IX of France advised that attacks on our Holy Catholic Faith are sometimes best answered by deeds:

[N]o man, unless he is a skilled theologian, should debate with Jews.  Instead, when a layman hears the Christian law slandered, he should defend it only with his sword, which he should thrust into the offender’s guts as far as it will go.71

We should respond to Pope Leo XIV’s vile words, not with a sword, but with the spiritual weapon of our Rosaries.

Conclusion

One of the hallmarks of the conciliar revolution is its continual efforts to minimize the Glorious Mother of God. One of the ways we must be counter-revolutionary is by devoting ourselves to her and honoring her at every opportunity, including as the glorious Mediatrix of All Graces!

Truly, Pope St. Pius X’s description – “wretched and unhappy”72 – applies well to Pope Leo XIV with his evil program of minimizing the honor of Our Lady.

Let us pray hard for him and to Our Lady, the Mediatrix of All Graces!

1 Quoted from St. Bernard of Clairvaux, Third Sermon for Advent, entitled: On the Three Advents of the Lord and the Seven Pillars which we ought to erect within us.

2 Vatican II’s document, Lumen Gentium, §67 (emphasis added).

To read further about how Vatican II minimized devotion to the Blessed Virgin Mary, read Lumen Gentium Annotated, by Quanta Cura Press, © 2013, pp.277-301. This book is available at:

3 Pope St. Pius X, Ad Diem Illum Laetissimum (On the Immaculate Conception), February 2, 1904, #15 (emphasis added).

4 Mater Populi Fidelis, Section 66, approved by Pope Leo XIV on October 7, 2025 (emphasis added). This document can be found here; https://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_ddf_doc_20251104_mater-populi-fidelis_en.html

5 To start with, notice that the title of Pope Leo XIV’s document (Mater Populi Fidelis) already shows he is minimizing the honor of Our Lady. The document’s title does not compliment or praise her. Rather, it compliments “us”, that is, the people! The title translates to “Mother of the faithful people”.

6 We cannot know whether the pope (or anyone else) is a formal heretic (rather than a material heretic only) – and thus whether he is outside the true Catholic Church based simply on his persistent, public teaching of a heretical opinion. Read more about this principle here: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/09/26/cc-in-brief-sedevacantist-questions/

Further, we must not judge a man to be a formal heretic if he professes to be Catholic and says he believes what a Catholic must believe now, in order to be Catholic now. When a person professes a heretical opinion, we must judge him in the most favorable light (if we judge him at all). So, we must avoid the sin of rash judgment and we must not judge negatively the interior culpability of the pope and the 1.4 billion people who profess to be Catholic. We must not judge they are not “real” Catholics if they tell us that they are Catholics. Instead, we should count them as Catholics who are very confused or are uninformed.

Thus, we must judge the conciliar popes to have been material heretics, not formal heretics (if we judge them at all), and that each was pope in his turn until his death (or abdication). Regarding any of the world’s 1.4 billion self-described Catholics who hold heresy, we must judge them to be material heretics only (if we judge them at all), unless they themselves tell us that they know they don’t qualify to be Catholics. Read more about this principle here: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/10/24/are-we-allowed-to-decide-that-pope-francis-knows-he-is-not-catholic/

In fact, not only is it possible for a pope to teach (or believe) heresy but popes have taught and believed heresy at various times during Church history and still continued to be pope. To read an analysis of this principle and especially to consider the cases of Pope John XXII and Pope Nicholas I, who both taught explicit heresy while pope and nonetheless continued to be the pope, read this article here: It is Possible for a Pope to Teach Heresy and Remain the Pope?: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/01/27/it-is-possible-for-a-pope-to-teach-heresy-and-remain-the-pope/

11 Summa, IIa IIae, Q.172, a.4, Respondeo.

12 Here is how St. Thomas Aquinas, greatest Doctor of the Church, explains this truth:

It is written (John 15:15): “I will not now call you servants . . . but My friends.” Now this was said to them by reason of nothing else than charity. Therefore, charity is friendship. …

According to the Philosopher (Ethic. viii, 2,3) not every love has the character of friendship, but that love which is together with benevolence, when, to wit, we love someone so as to wish good to him. If, however, we do not wish good to what we love, but wish its good for ourselves, (thus we are said to love wine, or a horse, or the like), it is love not of friendship, but of a kind of concupiscence. For it would be absurd to speak of having friendship for wine or for a horse.

Yet neither does well-wishing suffice for friendship, for a certain mutual love is requisite, since friendship is between friend and friend: and this well-wishing is founded on some kind of communication.

Accordingly, since there is a communication between man and God, inasmuch as He communicates His happiness to us, some kind of friendship must needs be based on this same communication, of which it is written (1 Corinthians 1:9): “God is faithful: by Whom you are called unto the fellowship of His Son.” The love which is based on this communication, is charity: wherefore it is evident that charity is the friendship of man for God.

Summa, IIa IIae, Q.23, a.1, sed contra and respondeo (emphasis added).

13 Here is how St. Thomas explains this truth:

[E]ach and every creature exists for the perfection of the entire universe. Furthermore, the entire universe, with all its parts, is ordained towards God as its end, inasmuch as it imitates, as it were, and shows forth the Divine goodness, to the glory of God.

Summa, Ia, Q.65., a2, respondeo.

14 Here is St. Thomas’ fuller explanation of this truth:

It is the part of the best agent to produce an effect which is best in its entirety; but this does not mean that He makes every part of the whole the best absolutely, but in proportion to the whole; in the case of an animal, for instance, its goodness would be taken away if every part of it had the dignity of an eye. Thus, therefore, God also made the universe to be best as a whole, according to the mode of a creature; whereas He did not make each single creature best, but one better than another. And therefore, we find it said of each creature, “God saw the light, that it was good” (Genesis, 1:4); and in like manner, each one of the rest. But of all together it is said, “God saw all the things that He had made, and they were very good” (Genesis, 1:31).

Summa, Ia, Q.47, a.2, ad 1 (emphasis added).

15 St Louis Marie de Montfort, True Devotion to the Blessed Virgin Mary, No. 25 (emphasis added).

16 St Louis Marie de Montfort, True Devotion to the Blessed Virgin Mary, No. 55 & 86 (emphasis added).

17 Mediator Dei, November 20, 1947, (quoting St. Bernard of Clairvaux, Doctor of the Church; emphasis added).

18 Ad Caeli Reginam, (On Proclaiming The Queenship Of Mary), October 11, 1954, #51.

19 Apostolic Exhortation, Menti Nostrae, September 23, 1950, #143 (emphasis added).

20 Caritate Christi Compulsi (On the Sacred Heart), Encyclical of Pope Pius XI Promulgated On May 3, 1932, #31 (emphasis added).

21 Pope Pius XI, Miserentissimus Redemptor, (On Reparation To The Sacred Heart), May 8th, 1928, #21 (emphasis added).

22 Pope Pius XI, Ingravescentibus malis, September 29, 1937, #32 (emphasis added).

23 Pope Benedict XV, Fausto Appetente Die (On St. Dominic), June 29, 1921, #11.

24 Pope St. Pius X, Ad Diem Illum Laetissimum (On the Immaculate Conception), February 2, 1904, #12.

25 Pope St. Pius X, Acta Romani Pontificis, 1904, p.449, Ad Diem Illum Laetissimum (On the Immaculate Conception), February 2, 1904, #13 (emphasis added).

26 In other words, the distinction made here is that Our Lord merits the fruits of our redemption through strictly meriting these fruits. Our Lady merits these same fruits from a sort of fittingness, according to God’s Will.


27 Pope St. Pius X, Ad Diem Illum Laetissimum (On the Immaculate Conception), February 2, 1904, #14 (emphasis added).

28 Pope Leo XIII, Octobri Mensis, September 22, 1891, #4 (emphasis added).

29 Pope Leo XIII, Iucunda Semper Expectatione (On the Rosary), September 8, 1894, #2 (emphasis added).

30 Pope Leo XIII, Iucunda Semper Expectatione (On the Rosary), September 8, 1894, #11 (emphasis added).

31 Pope Leo XIII, Iucunda Semper Expectatione (On the Rosary), September 8, 1894, #5 (emphasis added; bracketed words added for clarity).

32 Pope Leo XIII, Adiutricem (On the Rosary), September 5, 1895, ##7-8 (emphasis added).

33 Pope Leo XIII, Adiutricem (On the Rosary), September 5, 1895, #9 (emphasis added).

34 Pope Pius IX, Ubi Primum (On the Immaculate Conception), February 2, 1849, #5 (emphasis added).

35 Pope Pius IX, Ineffabilis Deus (On the Immaculate Conception), December 8, 1854 (emphasis added).

36 St. Alphonsus de Liguori, The Glories of Mary, Discourse II on the Birth of Mary (emphasis added).

37 St. Alphonsus de Liguori, The Glories of Mary, Pt.1, ch.5, §1 (emphasis added).

38 St. Alphonsus de Liguori, The Glories of Mary, Pt.1, ch.5, §1 (emphasis added).

39 St. Alphonsus de Liguori, sermon for 5th Sunday after Easter, right at the end (emphasis added; bracketed words added for clarity).

40 Catechism of Christian Doctrine, Ch.2 on the Angelic Salutation (emphasis added).

41 St. Thomas Aquinas, Commentary on the Hail Mary §10 (emphasis added; bracketed words added).

42 “Superintend” means to have or exercise the charge and oversight of. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/superintend

43 St. Thomas Aquinas, Lectures on St. John’s Gospel, Ch.2, Lecture 1, #344 (emphasis added; bracketed words added to show the context).

44 St. Bonaventure, Canticles in Honor of Mary, A Canticle on the Model of Isaias (XII) (emphasis added).

45 St. Bonaventure, Hymn after the model of the “Te Deum” (emphasis added).

46 Lecture 9 on the Blessed Virgin Mary, as quoted in St. Alphonsus de Liguori, The Glories of Mary, Pt.1, ch.5 (emphasis added).

47 Quoted from St. Albert the Great, Questions on the Gospels, Q.29, art.2 (emphasis added).

Here is the original Latin (in which it is clear that the “who” refers to Our Lady, by the feminine pronoun “ipsa”):

Ipsa enim omnium quorum Deus dominus est, domina est. In quo notatur singularis excellentia veri solis, sine corruptione, vel diminutione, vel sui degeneratione : in quo exprim.untur proprietates conceptionis. Ipsa enim est divinarum illuminationum inmediate susceptiva, ipsa omnium bonitatum universaliter distributiva. 

48 Sermon on the Annunciation of the Blessed Virgin Mary, section 11 (emphasis added).

49 St. Bernard of Clairvaux, Sermon for the First Sunday of Advent, Quoted from Sunday Sermons of the Great Fathers, Vol. 1 (First Sunday of Advent) (emphasis added).

50 St. Bernard of Clairvaux, Third sermon for the vigil of the Nativity of Our Lord, On the Three Days, on the Three Watches, the Three Winds, and the Three Unions (emphasis added).

51 Sermon for the Feast of the Assumption of Our Lady, by Father of the Church, St. Germanus, in Sunday Sermons of the Great Fathers, Toal, Vol.4, Regnery & Co., Chicago ©1963, p.421 (emphasis added).

52 Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, Ott, Roman Catholic Books, Fort Collins, CO, ©1954, Bk. 3 part three, p.211 (emphasis added).

53 Quoted from Mariolatry: New Phasis of an Old Fallacy, by Henry G. Ganss , Notre Dame Press, 1897, ch.18 (emphasis added). (This is a book against the error of minimizing devotion to Our Lady.)

54 St. Irenaeus, Against Heresies, Book 3, ch. 22 (emphasis added).

55 St. John’s Gospel, Ch. 2, vv. 3-5.

56 St. Thomas Aquinas, Lectures on St. John’s Gospel, Ch.2, Lecture 1, #344 (emphasis added).

57 Ecclesiasticus 24:24-25 (emphasis added).

58 Our Lord teaches that He is the Way, the Truth, and the Life. St. John’s Gospel, Ch.14, v.6 (emphasis added).

59 Mater Populi Fidelis, §53 (emphasis added).

60 Mater Populi Fidelis, §54.

61 Mater Populi Fidelis, §54.

62 Mater Populi Fidelis, §54.

63 Mater Populi Fidelis, §66.

64 Mater Populi Fidelis, §46 (emphasis added).

65 Mater Populi Fidelis, §55 (parenthetical words in the original).

66 St Louis Marie de Montfort, True Devotion to the Blessed Virgin Mary, No. 55 & 86 (emphasis added).

67 Mater Populi Fidelis, §65 (emphasis added).

68 Mater Populi Fidelis, §65 (emphasis added).

69 Mater Populi Fidelis, §45 (emphasis added).

70 Mater Populi Fidelis, §45.

71 These words of King St. Louis IX are quoted in the biography of St. Louis, written by John of Joinville, a courtier and fellow-crusader, Part I, Ch. 53, page 155, of the 2008 Penguin Classics edition which is called Chronicles of the Crusades, translated by Caroline Smith.

72 Pope St. Pius X, Ad Diem Illum Laetissimum (On the Immaculate Conception), February 2, 1904, #15.

Words to Live By – From Catholic Tradition

Spiritual Blindness Characterizes Our Times – Let Us Beware!

The sin of impurity brings with it blindness and obstinacy. Every vice produces darkness of understanding; but impurity produces it in a greater degree than all other sins.

St. Alphonsus de Liguori Sermon 45 – 16th Sunday after Pentecost – On Impurity, Point 1, section 2.

The Blessing of a True, Catholic Liberal Education – Part V

Catholic Candle note: Below is part 5 of the article concerning the best type of education, which is a Catholic Liberal Education. Do not confuse this education with many university programs called “liberal arts” but which are full of fluff, falsehood, and aimless so-called “cultural enrichment” courses and “humanities”.

A liberal education also does not refer to liberalism, nor is a true liberal education an indoctrination into that error of liberalism or political correctness. In fact, a true Catholic Liberal Education is the best antidote to the errors of liberalism.

Previously, in part 1 of this article,1 we examined the problems we see in modern education:

  • Modern colleges do not improve the quality of their students’ minds and their thinking ability much or at all.


  • Most “education” is merely job training, fluff courses, and/or leftist indoctrination.


  • The students are taught to sound like someone in their field but they do more memorizing and little thinking.


  • Grade “inflation” and degree “inflation” is rampant. Grades and academic degrees do not mean much anymore.

In part 2 of this article,2 we examined, in general, what education is. We considered the human soul and the perfection of its highest faculty (power) – the intellect – which is immaterial. We saw that our intellects are perfected through knowing eternal, unchangeable truths and their causes.

In part 3 of this article,3 after having seen what true education is, we examined the question who should perfect his intellect?

In part 4 of this article,4 having seen that modern universities do not provide a true education, we consider whether there is ever any reason for men or women to attend them.

However, even though women and girls should pursue a True Catholic Liberal Education – just as men and boys should, too – what is the best environment in which women and girls should do this? Below, in Part 5, we will consider this question.


The Blessing of a True, Catholic Liberal Education

Part 5

What Would Be the Best Environment in which Women Could Pursue a True Catholic Liberal Education?

We saw above that men and women should strive to obtain a formal Catholic Liberal Education, if possible, which would be a strong beginning of their duty and high calling to perfect their intellects throughout their lives. Ideally, this true education should be obtained at the beginning of adulthood as the beginning of a lifelong adult pursuit of the truth (especially the truths of our Faith).

Although women should obtain the treasure of this education, too, (as we saw above), it is better for them to do so at an all-women’s college when this is possible, instead of a mixed “co-educational” institution.

Here is how Pope Pius XI taught this truth:

False also and harmful to Christian education is the so-called method of “coeducation”.5

There are five reasons why it is better to separately educate the sexes. These five reasons (below) show that separate education (when possible) is advantageous for both sexes, although these advantages are even greater for women and girls, compared to men and boys. These reasons reflect Church teaching, the Natural Law, and Common Sense:

1. For a Man to Compete Against Ladies is Not Gentlemanly

God made men wiser, more aggressive, and clearer and more abstract in their thinking. A true gentleman would not want to compete with ladies in the classroom and it would not be a fair competition. This is similar to how it would not be fair or decent to have men and women compete against each other in a foot race.

Thus, it is only common sense and decency that women should have their own classrooms and schools. Women and girls should have their own feminine academic environment in which to develop their minds and pursue the truth.


2. Co-Education Sends the Wrong Message by Inherently Tending to Posture Women as Men’s Competitors

Further, it is better that women and men not be educated together because it sends the wrong message, i.e., it symbolizes the wrong thing for them to be class competitors. God did not make women to be man’s competitor but to be man’s helpmate and companion in the great work of raising a family.6


3. Co-Education is a Distraction from Academic Pursuits

God made men and women to be naturally attracted toward one another. This attraction is ordered toward marriage and raising a family. This is good and appropriate but must be limited to the correct occasions for this because this attraction is an obstacle to a focus on the intellectual life.

Just as women must cover their heads in church not only as a sign of submission,7 but also to assist in avoiding their becoming a distraction during prayer which can result from their beauty, because her hair is a woman’s glory8 and women are the more beautiful sex.

Similarly, in an academic environment – which should be devoted to the truth and the life of the intellect – mixing the sexes is a distraction which impedes that intellectual life.

Here is one way that Pope Pius XI taught this important truth of the Catholic Faith and the Natural Law:


Co-education … is founded upon [the heresy of] naturalism and the denial of original sin [as well as] upon a deplorable confusion of ideas that mistakes a leveling promiscuity and equality for the legitimate association of the sexes.9


4. Men and Women Learn Somewhat Differently and so the Teaching Methods Should Be Somewhat Different


Both men and women are rational but, to some extent, do not think the same way. God made men wiser, more aggressive, clearer in their reasoning and more abstract in their thinking. Women are more emotional – they are more inclined to bring personality and feeling into their reasoning. Thus, teaching methods for men and women should be adapted to their differences in the way they learn, through educating men and women separately.


Here is one way that Pope Pius XI describes how these differences show the benefit of using differences in teaching methods for the two sexes:


[T]here is not in nature itself, which fashions the two quite different in organism [viz., men and women], in temperament, in abilities, anything to suggest that there can be or ought to be promiscuity [viz., inappropriate mingling], and much less equality, in the training of the two sexes.10



5. The Catholic Church Shows the Better Way of Providing College-Level Education for Women by Founding so many Women’s Colleges

The practice of the Holy Catholic Church shows that it is better for women (and men) to be educated in separate schools and universities, where possible.

There are countless examples of women’s colleges, showing not only the Catholic Church’s commitment to perfecting women’s minds, but also the commitment to do it the better way, in separate institutions of learning.

Here are two of countless examples:

  • The Catholic Church founded St. Mary’s College in South Bend, Indiana. This Catholic women’s college was founded before 1920 by the Sisters of the Holy Cross, with the help of Fr. Edward Sorin (the founder of Notre Dame) and the priests of the Congregation of the Holy Cross. This college is near Notre Dame University which was founded as an all-men’s college.


  • Alverno College, a Catholic college in Milwaukee, was founded in 1936 as an all-women’s college. It is near Marquette University which was founded as an all-men’s college.

Notice in these examples that the wisdom of the Church not only caused Her to found countless women’s colleges but also countless men’s colleges, since it is better for men and boys – as well as for women and girls – to be educated in single sex educational institutions.


Conclusion

We see as a matter of Church teaching, of the Natural Law, and of Common Sense that, where possible, women and girls should receive their education in separate classrooms and institutions of learning.


But an Objection Arises to the Idea of Anyone Receiving this Type of Education!

From the considerations we have made so far in this series (on the Value of a True Catholic Liberal Education), shouldn’t we be afraid that this great blessing might make us proud?

We are on earth to save our souls and we know that pride is one of the biggest obstacles to salvation. So, if we receive a True Catholic Liberal Education and this were to result in our damnation, then shouldn’t we avoid this education in order to save our souls?

We will consider this issue in a future article.


To be continued …

5 Divini Illius Magistri, (On Christian Education), Pope Pius XI, 1929, §68.


6 Here is one way St. Thomas Aquinas, greatest Doctor of the Catholic Church, explains this truth that woman is not man’s competitor but should be his helpmate in the great work of her life (raising a family):

It was necessary that woman be made, as Scripture says, as a helpmate to the male; not indeed as a helpmate in some other work, as some have said, since in any other work a male can be more conveniently helped by another male than by woman; but as a helper in generation.

Summa, Ia, Q.92, a.1, respondeo.

God willed woman to be man’s helpmate. Sacred Scripture infallibly explains why God created woman, in these words:

[T]he Lord God said: It is not good for man to be alone: let Us make him a help like unto himself.

Genesis, 2:18.

Sacred Scripture infallibly says the same thing in other ways too, e.g.: “[M]an was not created for the woman: but the woman for the man” (1 Corinthians, 11:9), namely, to help him raise a family.

The Summa touches upon these different roles as follows:


Although the father ranks above the mother, the mother has more to do with the offspring than the father has, or we may say that woman was made chiefly in order to be man’s helpmate in relation to the offspring, whereas the man was not made for this purpose.


Summa Suppl., Q.44, a.2 ad 1 (emphasis added).

7 St. Paul teaches infallibly:


But I would have you know, that the head of every man is Christ; and the head of the woman is the man; and the head of Christ is God. … But every woman praying or prophesying with her head not covered, disgraceth her head: for it is all one as if she were shaven. For if a woman be not covered, let her be shorn. But if it be a shame to a woman to be shorn or made bald, let her cover her head. The man indeed ought not to cover his head, because he is the image and glory of God; but the woman is the glory of the man. For the man is not of the woman, but the woman of the man. For the man was not created for the woman, but the woman for the man. Therefore, ought the woman to have a power over her head ….


1 Corinthians, 11:3-10 (emphasis added).


8 “But if a woman nourish her hair, it is a glory to her; for her hair is given to her for a covering.” 1 Corinthians, 11:15.

9 Divini Illius Magistri, (On Christian Education), Pope Pius XI, §68.


Here is the full quote:


False also and harmful to Christian education is the so-called method of “co-education”. This, too, by many of its supporters, is founded upon [the heresy of] naturalism and the denial of original sin; but by all, upon a deplorable confusion of ideas that mistakes a leveling promiscuity and equality, for the legitimate association of the sexes. The Creator has ordained and disposed perfect union of the sexes only in matrimony, and, with varying degrees of contact, in the family and in society. Besides there is not in nature itself, which fashions the two quite different in organism, in temperament, in abilities, anything to suggest that there can be or ought to be promiscuity, and much less equality, in the training of the two sexes. These, in keeping with the wonderful designs of the Creator, are destined to complement each other in the family and in society, precisely because of their differences, which therefore ought to be maintained and encouraged during their years of formation, with the necessary distinction and corresponding separation, according to age and circumstances. These principles, with due regard to time and place, must, in accordance with Christian prudence, be applied to all schools, particularly in the most delicate and decisive period of formation, that, namely, of adolescence; and in gymnastic exercises and deportment, special care must be had of Christian modesty in young women and girls, which is so gravely impaired by any kind of exhibition in public.”


Divini Illius Magistri, (On Christian Education), Pope Pius XI, §68 (emphasis added; bracketed words added for clarity).


10 Divini Illius Magistri, (On Christian Education), Pope Pius XI, §68 (bracketed comment added for clarity).


Sedevacantism is Un-Catholic Because it is Revolutionary

Catholic Candle note: Sedevacantism is wrong and is (material or formal) schism. Catholic Candle is not sedevacantist.

Below is the fourteenth article in a series which covers specific aspects of the error of sedevacantism. As context for this fourteenth article, let us recall what we saw in the earlier thirteen articles:

In the first article, we saw that we cannot know whether the pope (or anyone else) is a formal heretic (rather than a material heretic only) – and thus whether he is outside the true Catholic Church based simply on his persistent, public teaching of a heretical opinion.1

Then, in the second article, we saw that we must not judge a man to be a formal heretic if he professes to be Catholic and says he believes what a Catholic must believe now, in order to be Catholic now. When a person professes a heretical opinion, we must judge him in the most favorable light (if we judge him at all). So, we must avoid the sin of rash judgment and we must not judge negatively the interior culpability of the pope and the 1.4 billion2 people who profess to be Catholic. We must not judge they are not “real” Catholics if they tell us that they are Catholics. Instead, we should count them as Catholics who are very confused or are uninformed.3

Thus, we must judge the conciliar popes to have been material heretics, not formal heretics (if we judge them at all), and that each was pope in his turn until his death (or abdication). Regarding any of the world’s 1.4 billion self-described Catholics who hold heresy, we must judge them to be material heretics only (if we judge them at all), unless they themselves tell us that they know they don’t qualify to be Catholics.4

In the third article, we examined briefly the important difference between persons in authority who fulfill their duty to judge those under their charge in the external forum, as contrasted to a sedevacantist or anyone else except God who judges the interior culpability of other persons and (rashly) judges them to be formal heretics.5

In the fourth article, we saw that it does not help us to protect ourselves better from a conciliar pope’s heresy, to declare that we know he is not the pope and is not a Catholic.6

In the fifth article, we saw that it is possible for a pope to teach (or believe) heresy and in fact, popes have taught and believed heresy at various times during Church history.7 We looked especially at the cases of Pope John XXII and Pope Nicholas I, who both taught explicit heresy while pope and nonetheless continued to be the pope. Pope John XXII also taught the same explicit heresy before he became the pope.

In the sixth article, we saw that the Church infallibly assures us that we will have a pope at all times until the end of the world, except during very short interregnums between papal reigns, during which the Church is in the process of electing a new pope and during which the Church’s unified government continues to function.8 In this sixth article, we saw that we are not presently in an interregnum (even though the sedevacantists absurdly claim we are in a many-decades-long interregnum).

In the seventh article of this series, we saw that the Catholic Church is a visible Body and remains visible to all. The Catholic Church has a visible monarchical government and the pope is visible to all. Thus, we know we have a pope and that the one who is pope is visible (known) to all as the pope.9

In the eighth article, we saw that the necessary visibility of the Catholic Church and the pope, requires as a corollary that the one who virtually all Catholics see (believe) is the pope must be the pope, since the pope must be visible to all.

In the ninth article, we addressed the superficial “argument” of sedevacantists (addressed to Catholics) saying that “if you think we have a pope, then you have to obey him in whatever he tells you to do”. We examined the true Catholic virtue of obedience and saw that we must not obey the commands of even a real superior like our pope, if/when he commands us to do something evil.10

In the tenth article, we saw more deeply what schism is and how sedevacantism is inherently schism.11

In the eleventh article of this series, we saw more deeply how we should respond to a pope (or other superior) who does harm – viz., we should recognize his authority as pope but resist the evil of his words or deeds.12

In the twelfth article of this series, we saw how we ordinary Catholic laymen can know what the Catholic Truth is and how we can know when the pope (or anyone) is promoting error.13

In the thirteenth article of this series, we saw the falsehood of a related sedevacantist error (or “half-truth”), claiming that we have no pope because the conciliar popes had doubtful consecrations and/or ordinations.14

Now, in the fourteenth article in this series, we consider another way to see that sedevacantism is wrong and sinful, viz., because it is the sin of revolution.


Sedevacantism is Un-Catholic
Because it is Revolutionary

Resistance is different from revolt. When someone in authority commands something evil, it is one thing to resist that command, but it is a further step to use that evil command as a basis for rejecting the ruler’s authority as such. This further step is to revolt.

For example, the American revolutionaries considered it evil that King George III imposed taxes on them without their consent, and that he did many other things to which they objected. But the American revolutionaries not only resisted such commands of King George but also used the commands as a (purported) “justification” for their revolution.

In their Declaration of Independence, the revolutionaries objected to many things such as their king “quartering large bodies of armed troops among us”; “imposing taxes on us without our consent”; and “depriving us in many cases, of the benefits of trial by jury”.

After listing their grievances, the American revolutionaries then did what all revolutionaries do: they said that their ruler was to blame for their own revolution because his conduct caused him to lose his status as their king. The American revolutionaries declared that King George III “whose character is thus marked by every act which may define a tyrant, is unfit to be the ruler of a free people.”

The American revolutionaries did what revolutionaries always do: they declared that their ruler had lost all authority over them. Here are their words:

[T]hese United Colonies are, and of right ought to be, free and independent states; that they are absolved from all allegiance to the British Crown, and that all political connection between them and the State of Great Britain, is and ought to be totally dissolved.

Finally, the American revolutionaries then did something else which revolutionaries always do: they declared that it was their right (or duty) to revolt:

[W]hen a long train of abuses and usurpations … evinces a design to reduce them under absolute despotism, it is [the colonies’] right, it is their duty, to throw off such government.

This is what it is to be a revolutionary: to reject and resist not just particular (perhaps evil) commands but to also reject the very authority of one’s ruler.

The American revolutionaries followed the same pattern as countless other revolutionaries, e.g., in France, Russia, Latin America, and the Protestant revolutionaries. In all human history – civil as well as religious – there is not even one revolution15 which the Catholic Church recognizes to have been praiseworthy and not sinful.16

In summary, revolutionaries (including the sedevacantists) follow a common pattern:

  1. they assert that their ruler committed wrongs (whether actual wrongs or merely imagined); and then


  2. they use such wrongs as a basis to declare that their ruler’s own conduct has resulted in his losing his authority to rule them.


The Cristeros were Not Revolutionaries

On a superficial level, a person might have the false impression that the Mexican Cristeros were revolutionaries because they took up arms against their anti-Catholic ruler in the early 20th Century. But the Cristeros’ goal was to defend their priests, their churches, and the Catholicism of their families. The Cristeros resisted the many wrongs committed by their anti-Catholic government. By successfully taking up arms, the Cristeros prevented the anti-Catholic government from unjustly harming them (arresting them, killing them, etc.).

But unlike persons who are revolutionaries, the Cristeros never used their government’s wrongs as a basis to declare that their government had lost all authority over them.17 Instead, by taking up arms, the Cristeros merely prevented their lawful (but anti-Catholic) government from doing the harm it intended.


Sedevacantists are Revolutionaries

Unlike the Cristeros, sedevacantists are revolutionaries. Sedevacantists correctly recognize that the pope has committed many wrongs. Instead of resisting only the pope’s wrongs, the sedevacantists follow the pattern of other revolutionaries by using these wrongs as a basis for denying that the pope has his authority and office. Like other revolutionaries, they blame the pope for their own revolt, saying that his words and actions have caused him to lose his authority over them.

Some sedevacantists vainly attempt to avoid their status as revolutionaries, by saying they are not revolting against their ruler (the pope) because his conduct caused him to lose his status as their ruler (pope). But they fail to see how they beg the question. This would be like the American revolutionaries saying they are not revolting against their ruler (King George III) because his conduct makes him not their real ruler. Such circular “reasoning” merely assumes their conclusion as a premise for their “argument” that they are not revolutionaries. In other words, they would claim that they do not deny the authority of the ruler over them because they deny he has the authority of the ruler over them.

Of course, the Church has had several rulers (popes) in a row since the beginning of the sedevacantist revolution. Having revolted against Pope John XXIII, sedevacantists take as a “matter of course” the rejection of the subsequent popes’ authority, just as the American Revolutionaries took as a “matter of course” that King George III’s successors had no authority over them.

A person might wrongly believe that sedevacantists are not revolutionaries, based on the superficial supposition that revolution must involve physical fighting. But what is essential to revolution is for persons to declare that their ruler has lost his authority to rule them. A revolution need not involve physical fighting. For example, the Hawaiian Revolution of 1893 did not involve any physical fighting. Likewise, any physical fighting was not essential to the Protestant Revolution against the Catholic Church.

Also, a person might wrongly believe sedevacantism is not revolutionary, based on the superficial supposition that revolution must involve deposing a ruler from his throne or office. However, what is essential to revolution is the rejection of a ruler’s authority, but this might pertain to only certain persons or places. For example, in the American Revolution, the colonists did not cause King George III to lose his throne entirely. They succeeded merely in revolting against his authority in the thirteen American colonies. Similarly, the Protestant Revolution did not depose the pope from his throne but the Protestant revolutionaries merely rejected his authority among certain persons or in certain places.


Revolution is Always Wrong

It is un-Catholic to be a revolutionary. All authority comes from God, regardless of the method by which a ruler is chosen to wield civil or religious power. Here is how St. Paul teaches this truth:

[T]here is no power [whether civil or religious] but from God: and those [powers] that are, are ordained of God. Therefore, he that resisteth the power [whether civil or religious], resisteth the ordinance of God. And they that resist, purchase to themselves damnation. … For [the ruler] is God’s minister. … Wherefore, be subject of necessity, not only for [the ruler’s] wrath, but also for conscience’s sake.18

Pope Pius IX faithfully echoed St. Paul:

[A]ll authority [whether civil or religious] comes from God. Whoever resists authority resists the ordering made by God Himself, consequently achieving his own condemnation; disobeying authority [whether civil or religious] is always sinful except when an order is given which is opposed to the laws of God and the Church.19

Pope Pius IX taught this same doctrine in his infallible condemnation of the following erroneous proposition:

It is permissible to refuse obedience to legitimate rulers [whether civil or religious], and even to revolt against them.20

Pope Leo XIII taught the same doctrine as St. Paul and Pope Pius IX. Here are Pope Leo XIII’s words:

If, however, it should ever happen that public power [whether civil or religious] is exercised by rulers rashly and beyond measure, the doctrine of the Catholic Church does not permit rising up against them on one’s own terms, lest quiet and order be more and more disturbed, or lest society receive greater harm therefrom.21

Because it is sinful to even willfully desire to sin, Pope Leo XIII taught that even the “desire for revolution” is a “vice”. Auspicato Concessu, §24.

St. Ambrose, Doctor of the Church, teaches this same truth, viz., that Catholics are not revolutionaries and must obey their rulers in those matters that are not sinful. Here are his words:

It is a great and spiritual lesson, which teaches Christians submission to the sovereign power, so that no one will allow himself to break the edicts of a king of the earth.22

Although, as we saw earlier,23 we are not allowed to commit a sin regardless of who commands us to commit the sin, St. Ambrose here teaches us that we are bound in conscience to otherwise submit to the edicts of the ruler. Thus, even more so, we cannot revolt against him.

Because revolution is always wrong, that is why Pope St. Pius X taught that revolutionaries could not possibly be the true friends of the people. Here are his words:

The Church, which has never betrayed the happiness of the people by consenting to dubious alliances, does not have to free herself from the past; that all that is needed is to take up again, with the help of the true workers for a social restoration, the organisms which the Revolution shattered, and to adapt them, in the same Christian spirit that inspired them, to the new environment arising from the material development of today’s society. Indeed, the true friends of the people are neither revolutionaries, nor innovators: they are traditionalists.24


If We Cannot Revolt, Then What Should We Do When We Have Bad Rulers?

Although revolution is forbidden, Pope Leo XIII gave us the remedies of patience, prayer, and resistance to the particular evil commands of a bad ruler. Here are his words:

Whenever matters have come to such a pass that no other hope of a solution is evident, [the doctrine of the Catholic Church] teaches that a remedy is to be hastened through the merits of Christian patience, and by urgent prayers to God.

But if the decisions of legislators and rulers should sanction or order something that is contrary to divine and natural law, the dignity and duty of the Christian name and the opinion of the apostles urge that “we ought to obey God, rather than men” (Acts 5:29).25

St. Thomas offers the same remedy to persons who suffer the evil of a bad ruler:

[S]ometimes God permits evil rulers [whether civil or religious] to afflict good men. This affliction is for the good of such good men, as St. Paul says above [ch.8, v.28]: “All things work for the good, for those who love God.”26

St. Peter, the first pope, infallibly gives the same remedy (prayer and patience) – not revolution – when subjects have a bad ruler. Here are his words:

Be ye subject therefore to every human creature for God’s sake: whether it be to the king as excelling; or to governors as sent by him … Honor the king. … For this is thankworthy, if for conscience towards God, a man endure sorrows, suffering wrongfully. … [I]f doing well you suffer patiently; this is thankworthy before God.27

Notice that the revolutionaries intend the opposite of what St. Peter instructs us to do. They intend not to honor the king but to dishonor him by revolting against him. This is the most extreme way possible to dishonor him in so far as he is their ruler.

Further, St. Peter instructs us to “endure sorrows”, and to “suffer patiently” when we have a bad ruler. By contrast, revolutionaries seek the opposite, viz., to avoid enduring the sorrow of a bad ruler and avoid suffering patiently under him.

Plainly, revolutionaries seek the opposite of what St. Peter instructs us to seek.

The Examples of the Saints Show Revolution is Wrong

Look at the example of Catholics, including great saints like St. Sebastian, who served bravely and faithfully even in the army of the pagan emperors of Rome. They did not revolt, even when their emperor openly sought to kill all Catholics (although, of course, those soldier-saints did not aid in the persecution of Catholics).

Here is Pope Gregory XVI’s praise for those Roman soldier-saints, who were faithful to God first but also to their emperor (whenever the emperor’s commands were not themselves evil):

[T]he early Christians … deserved well of the emperors and of the safety of the state even while persecution raged. This they proved splendidly by their fidelity in performing perfectly and promptly whatever they were commanded which was not opposed to their religion, and even more by their constancy and the shedding of their blood in battle. “Christian soldiers”, says St. Augustine, “served an infidel emperor. When the issue of Christ was raised, they acknowledged no one but the One who is in heaven. They distinguished the eternal Lord from the temporal lord, but were also subject to the temporal lord for the sake of the eternal Lord.”

St. Mauritius, the unconquered martyr and leader of the Theban legion had this in mind when, as St. Eucharius reports, he answered the emperor in these words: “We are your soldiers, Emperor, but also servants of God, and this we confess freely . . . and now this final necessity of life has not driven us into rebellion.” …

Indeed, the faith of the early Christians shines more brightly, if we consider with Tertullian, that since the Christians were not lacking in numbers and in troops, they could have acted as foreign enemies. “We are but of yesterday”, he says, “yet we have filled all your cities, islands, fortresses, municipalities, assembly places, the camps themselves, the tribes, the divisions, the palace, the senate, the forum. … For what war should we not have been fit and ready even if unequal in forces – we who are so glad to be cut to pieces – were it not, of course, that in our doctrine we would have been permitted more to be killed rather than to kill? … [Y]ou have fewer enemies because of the multitude of Christians.”

These beautiful examples of the unchanging subjection to the rulers necessarily proceeded from the most holy precepts of the Christian religion.28

Summary of this Article so Far

As shown above, it is Catholic dogma that revolution is always wrong but that resisting the particular evil commands of our ruler is permitted and sometimes necessary. When resisting is just, such resistance might include taking up arms and fighting the government soldiers who seek to enforce the ruler’s evil orders. The Cristeros did this in Mexico.

If the evil is great enough, the resisters may even place themselves beyond the reach of the harm which the ruler seeks to unjustly inflict on them. The Cristeros did this, succeeding in defending three quarters of Mexico from the anti-Catholic harm attempted by Mexico’s government.29

However, even when strong resistance is justified by the greatness of the evil attempted by the ruler, those persons resisting the evil are not permitted to revolt, i.e., to declare that the ruler has ceased to be their ruler. The ruler does not lose his authority in principle, even when the resisters prevent him by force of arms from accomplishing in practice the evil he wishes to do. This is the meaning of Pope Pius IX’s infallible condemnation of the assertion that “It is permissible … to revolt”. (See above.)

Regarding the early soldier-saints fighting in the Roman army (see above) even while the emperor martyred Catholics: those Catholic soldier-saints faithfully served their emperor in other activities which were honorable and never aided the Roman persecution of Catholics. Those soldier-saints of Rome did not choose to do what the Cristeros did, viz., defend themselves (without revolting). As quoted above, St. Augustine, Pope Gregory XVI and the other authorities do not address the option of armed resistance, while they praise those soldier-saints for not revolting.


A Note About a Different but Related Issue: How Can We Determine Whether a Ruler is the Legitimate Ruler?

Above, we see that Catholics must never revolt against their legitimate ruler (although they may resist his evil commands). However, a person can ask: “How do we know when a ruler is legitimate?”

This article does not lay out principles from which we can know in all cases if a ruler is legitimate. There are many ways a ruler might not be the legitimate ruler. Here is an easy case of a ruler being illegitimate:

When the head of a foreign, attacking army first lands on a country’s soil and immediately declares himself the legitimate ruler of the country simply because he is there and is strong, this seems like an easy case that he is a usurper and not a rightful, legitimate ruler of the country he is attacking. The people of that country can deny his authority over them and fight against him to try to expel him from the country.

In this article, we don’t treat the various possible ways in which a ruler might be illegitimate since we don’t need to do that because the sedevacantists began their revolution against a pope whom they recognize as having been elected at the conclave. The sedevacantists do not raise a doubt about Pope John XXIII’s becoming pope. For example, the sedevacantists do not claim that the papal conclave did not conduct a proper vote. The sedevacantists reject the pope’s authority because of what he did and said, not because he had never been their ruler (pope) in the first place.

This is like the American revolutionaries, who did not say that King George III was never their king, e.g., because he was not the proper heir to the throne of England. Instead, sedevacantists and the American revolutionaries declare that their ruler lost his legitimacy (his authority) because of what he said and did. For this reason, the sedevacantists are revolutionaries.

Thus, although there are many circumstances in which it would not be revolution to deny that a particular ruler was legitimate and had authority because of how he (supposedly) received his office, that is not an issue either with the American revolutionaries or with the sedevacantists who claim their ruler (the king and the pope respectively) lost his authority by his actions.30


Prohibition Against All Revolution Especially Forbids Rebellion Against the Pope’s Authority as Such.

Since the Catholic Church’s ruler, above all others, has authority from God, the prohibition against revolution most of all applies to revolt against the pope’s authority, as such. Thus, St. Robert Bellarmine, Doctor of the Church, explains that:

[I]t is licit to resist the Pontiff who … tries to destroy the Church.  I say that it is licit to resist him by not doing what he orders and by impeding the execution of his will; it is not licit, however, to judge him, to punish him, or depose him, for these are acts proper to a superior.31

Sedevacantism is an Over-Simplification of the Truth.

A Catholic Dictionary characterizes the traits of revolution in this way:

The methods of the Gospel are not revolutionary; they do not deal in those sweeping general assertions which fuller experience always shows to be but half-truths.32

A sedevacantist exhibits such revolutionary traits. He “leaps” from the truth that the pope has taught and done much evil, to the declaration that we have no pope. Thus, the sedevacantist over-simplifies the truth through sweeping general assertions and half-truths about his ruler (the pope).


Conclusion of This Article

Without judging sedevacantists’ interior culpability, it is nonetheless plain that sedevacantists follow the objectively sinful pattern of revolutionaries. They assert that the wrongs committed by the pope – who is their ruler – are (purported) justification both for declaring he has lost his authority to rule them and that he is not the pope. Thus, we see that, in addition to the other reasons why the sedevacantists are wrong, they are also wrong because they are revolutionaries.


But a Question Arises: If We Cannot Deny that Leo XIV is Pope, Does that Mean We Are in Communion with Him?

Sedevacantists attempt to show that their own Catholicism is “exalted and pure” by saying that they are not, and would never be, connected with that man (who is our pope) because his words and deeds are often so problematic, scandalous, and heterodox.

So these sedevacantists attempt to pressure Catholics into becoming schismatics by urging those Catholics: “Don’t be in communion with that man (the pope)!”, suggesting that somehow it is un-Catholic to be in communion with a bad pope.

So the question arises: Are we Catholics really in communion with the pope, even when he is a bad, scandalous pope or teaches heresy? We will examine that question in a future article.


To be continued …

2 The Vatican estimates that the number of Catholics worldwide is about 1.375 billion. https://www.vaticannews.va/en/church/news/2023-10/fides-catholic-church-statistics-world-mission-sunday.html


7 Read this article here: It is Possible for a Pope to Teach Heresy and Remain the Pope?: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/01/27/it-is-possible-for-a-pope-to-teach-heresy-and-remain-the-pope/


8 Read this article here that the Catholic Church’s unified government always continues, even during an interregnum: The Catholic Church Will Always Have a Pope: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/02/21/the-catholic-church-will-always-have-a-pope/

9 Read this article showing that The Catholic Church Will Always be Visible, and Will Always Have a Pope Who is Visible to All, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/03/27/the-catholic-church-will-always-be-visible-with-a-pope/


10 Read this article examining false obedience, entitled, The False “Obedience” of Cowardly and Weak Catholics, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/05/20/the-false-obedience-of-cowardly-and-weak-catholics/


11 Read this article showing that Sedevacantism is Inherently Schism, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/06/28/sedevacantism-is-inherently-schism/


12 Our Catholic Duty: Resist the Harm Done by a Bad Pope But (Of Course) Recognize His Authority: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/07/24/our-catholic-duty-resist-the-harm-done-by-a-bad-pope-but-of-course-recognize-his-authority/


13 Judging the Pope’s Words & Deeds According to Catholic Tradition: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/08/29/judging-the-popes-words-deeds-according-to-catholic-tradition/

14

A Man Need Not Be Consecrated a Bishop or Ordained a Priest to Be a Valid Pope — An Explanation How the Catholic Church Continues to Possess A Full Hierarchy even in these Times of Great Apostasy: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/09/24/a-man-need-not-be-consecrated-a-bishop-or-ordained-a-priest-to-be-a-valid-pope/

15 Generally, political revolt is called by the name “sedition”, and revolt against the Church, by the name “schism”. But at the root of all such revolts, there is the same “non serviam!” which echoes that of Satan, the father of all revolutionaries.


16 If there could ever have been a place and circumstances where revolution could have appeared justified, it would have been a civil revolution by Catholics in newly-apostate England, where the English government inflicted horrors and injustices of every type upon the Catholics. The torture, imprisonment, extreme suffering, and martyrdom inflicted on Catholics and the outrageous confiscation of Catholic property seemed unbearable to many. See, e.g., Chapters 1-3 of Narrative of the Gunpowder Plot, by Fr. John Gerard, S.J., Quanta Cura Press. This book is a fascinating contemporaneous account of the Anglican and Puritan persecutions of Catholics during the reign of King James I, as the context of the Gunpowder Plot.


Because of the Anglicans’ and Puritans’ shocking treatment of Catholics, Guy Fawkes and a few other Catholics devised the Gunpowder Plot to blow-up the parliament building when King James I was there with the rest of England’s leaders. However, the two consecutive popes of the time, as well as all of the Jesuit superiors and priests in England all strongly forbade Catholics to take part in such plots or otherwise to revolt against their rightful King, James I.


In his contemporaneous account of the Gunpowder Plot and the savage persecutions leading up to this plot, Fr. John Gerard explains:


All Catholics received strict commandment from the See Apostolic, that in no case they should stir or attempt anything against His Majesty [viz., King James I of England] or the State [viz., England], and this both from Pope Clement VIII, of pious memory, and from Paulus Vtus [viz., Pope Paul V] that now sitteth in the Chair, who both before and since his assumption to that supreme dignity of governing the Church of Christ, hath showed [sic] himself most earnest to procure the quiet, safety, and security of our Sovereign [viz., King James I], … [and by ordering] that no Catholic people should go about to interrupt or trouble the same [viz., King James I of England] by their impatient proceedings ….


Id., page 120 (bracketed words added to show the context).

17 To read more on the Cristeros, read Latin America: A Sketch of its Glorious Catholic Roots and a Snapshot of its Present, by the Editors of Quanta Cura Press, pp. 40-42, ©2016.

18 Romans, ch.13, vv. 1-2 & 4-5 (bracketed words added; emphasis added).


Also, in another place in Sacred Scripture, God declares: “By Me kings reign, and lawgivers decree just things; by Me princes rule, and the mighty decree justice.” Proverbs, 8:15-16.


19 Qui Pluribus, November 9, 1846, §22 (emphasis added; bracketed words added).


20 Quanta Cura, proposition #63 (emphasis added; bracketed words added).


Pope Pius IX used his ex cathedra (infallible) authority to condemn this error as part of a list of errors contained in the syllabus of Quanta Cura. Regarding these condemnations, the pope said:


We, truly mindful of Our Apostolic duty, and especially solicitous about our most holy religion, about sound doctrine and the salvation of souls divinely entrusted to Us, and about the good of human society itself, have decided to lift our voice again. And so all and each evil opinion and doctrine individually mentioned in this letter, by Our Apostolic authority We reject, proscribe and condemn; and We wish and command that they be considered as absolutely rejected, proscribed and condemned by all the sons of the Catholic Church.

Thus, Pope Pius IX’s condemnation fulfills the conditions for infallibility set out in Vatican I’s document, Pastor Aeternus, because the pope was: 1) carrying out his duty as pastor and teacher of all Christians; 2) in accordance with his supreme apostolic authority; 3) on a matter of faith or morals; 4) to be held by the universal Church.

21

Encyclical, Quod Apostolici muneris, December 28, 1878, §7 (emphasis added; bracketed words added).


22 St. Ambrose, Doctor of the Church, Commentary on St. Luke, 5:1-11.


23 Read this article examining false obedience, entitled, The False “Obedience” of Cowardly and Weak Catholics, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/05/20/the-false-obedience-of-cowardly-and-weak-catholics/


24 Pope St. Pius X, encyclical Our Apostolic Mandate, (1910).

25 Quod Apostolici muneris, December 28, 1878, §7 (bracketed words added to show context).

26 St. Thomas Aquinas, Commentary on Romans, ch.13, lect.1 (bracketed words added).


27 Here is the full quote:


Be ye subject therefore to every human creature for God’s sake: whether

it be to the king as excelling; Or to governors as sent by him for the punishment of evildoers, and for the praise of the good: For so is the will of God, that by doing well you may put to silence the ignorance of foolish men: As free, and not as making liberty a cloak for malice, but as the servants of God. Honor all men. Love the brotherhood. Fear God. Honor the king. Servants, be subject to your masters with all fear, not only to the good and gentle, but also to the froward. For this is thankworthy, if for conscience towards God, a man endure sorrows, suffering wrongfully. For what glory is it, if committing sin, and being buffeted for it, you endure? But if doing well you suffer patiently; this is thankworthy before God. For unto this are you called: because Christ also suffered for us, leaving you an example that you should follow his steps. Who did no sin, neither was guile found in his mouth. Who, when he was reviled, did not revile: when he

(Footnote continued on the next page.)
(Footnote continued from the previous page.)

suffered, he threatened not: but delivered himself to him that judged him unjustly. Who his own self bore our sins in his body upon the tree: that we, being dead to sins, should live to justice: by whose stripes you were healed. For you were as sheep going astray; but you are now converted to the shepherd and bishop of your souls.


1 Peter, 2:13-25 (emphasis added).

28 Encyclical Mirari Vos, August 15, 1832, §§ 18-19 (emphasis added), quoting and relying on the teaching of St. Augustine (Doctor and Father of the Church), as well as St. Mauritius, and Tertullian (a Father of the Church).

29 Latin America: A Sketch of its Glorious Catholic Roots and a Snapshot of its Present, by the Editors of Quanta Cura Press, p.41, ©2016.

30 Of course, as noted above, having revolted against Pope John XXIII, sedevacantists now take as a “matter of course” the rejection of all subsequent popes’ authority, just as the American revolutionaries took as a “matter of course” that King George III’s successors had no authority over them.

31

De Summo pontifice Book II, Ch. 29 (emphasis added).

St. Robert Bellarmine is here pointing out that whereas the pope can depose the bishop of a diocese because the pope is that bishop’s superior, we cannot depose the pope because no one, including us, is his superior (besides God).


32 A Catholic Dictionary, Addis & Arnold, Article: Slavery, The Catholic Publication Society, New York, 1884, pp.767-68 (emphasis added).

Lesson #50: Temperaments – Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat – Part XV

Philosophy Notes

Catholic Candle note: The article immediately below is part thirteen of the study of the Choleric temperament. The first twelve parts can be found here:

  1. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #36: About the Temperaments – Beginning our Study of the Choleric Temperament – Part I: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/08/27/lesson-35-about-the-temperaments-the-choleric-temperament/

  2. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #37: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament– Part II: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/09/26/lesson-37-about-the-temperaments-continuation-of-the-choleric-temperament/

  3. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #38 — About the Temperaments – Continuing our Study of the Choleric Temperament – Their Spiritual Combat – Part III:: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/10/24/lesson-38-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat/

  4. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #39 About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – That Temperament’s Spiritual Combat – Part IV: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/11/26/lesson-39-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat-part-iv/

  5. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #40: Temperaments – Choleric Temperament – Their Spiritual Combat – Part V: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/12/30/lesson-40-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat-part-v/

  6. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #41 – About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament: a Choleric’s Spiritual Combat — Part VI: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/01/27/lesson-41-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-vi/

  7. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #42: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – a Choleric’s Spiritual Combat – Part VII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/02/21/lesson-42-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-vii/

  8. Mary’s School of Sanctity — Lesson #43 About the Temperaments –Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament — Their Spiritual Combat Part VIII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/03/27/lesson-42-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-viii/

  9. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #44 About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – Their Spiritual Combat, Part IX: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/04/23/lesson-44-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-ix/

  10. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #45 About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat Part X: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/05/20/lesson-45-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-x/

  11. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #46 About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Cholerics’ Spiritual Combat – Part XI: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/06/28/lesson-46-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xi/

  12. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #47 About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat – Part XII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/07/24/lesson-47-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xii/

  13. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #48 About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat Part XIII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/08/29/lesson-48-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xiii/


  14. Mary’s School of Sanctity — Lesson #49 About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat Part XIV: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/09/24/lesson-49-temperaments-choleric-temperament-the-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xiv/

Mary’s School of Sanctity

Lesson #50 About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat – Part XV

Note: In this article, when referring to a person with a choleric temperament we simply will call him a “choleric”.

In our last lesson, we considered how we are all affected by the wounds of Original Sin and, in addition to this, we have our own personal inclinations and disinclinations which arise from our genetic (material, bodily) dispositions. We saw that one could have a natural disinclination to think deeply and how, ultimately, this disinclination stems back to the passion of fear.

The Passions Influence Us

We know that the passions are part of our human nature. We know that we all have them. In general, the passions work in our souls in the same way. However, what is unique to each of us is the strength of those passions and the particular ones which influence us most. We might not notice how each person, with his own particular temperament, has his own propensities and, therefore, his own unique battle to fight in order to train and discipline his passions to conform to his reason.

As we consider the four temperaments, one crucial aspect of our investigation is to understand how the passions are involved in the way people behave. Because we want to better understand how the passion of fear, in particular, affects each temperament, we first consider, more generally, what a passion is. Then, with this foundation, we will be better able to understand the role of the passion of fear in our lives. Thus, in this lesson we will discuss what, in general, a passion is and then look at the two types of passions, namely the concupiscible and the irascible.

What a Passion Is

St. Thomas Aquinas, the greatest doctor of the Church, treats the passions thoroughly. He begins by explaining the meaning of the word “passion” itself. St. Thomas explains that a passion is a type of receiving or “suffering”. One way that the word “passion” is used is to receive something that is a perfection of the receiver and this perfection (which is received) does not replace anything that had previously been present in the receiver; the second way passion is used it to receive something better, which is an improvement – replacing something worse than what is received; and the third and most proper way “passion” is used is to receive something worse which is a “downgrade” compared to that better thing which is replaced. Here are St. Thomas’ words:

The word passion is used in three ways:

First, in a general way, according as whatever receives anything is passive, even though nothing is taken from the receiver. Thus, we may say that the air is passive when it [viz., the air] is lit up. But this is to be perfected rather than to be passive.

Secondly, the word passive is employed in its proper sense, when something is received, while something else is taken away: and this happens in two ways.

  1. For sometimes that which is lost is unsuitable to the thing: thus, when an animal’s body is healed, the body is said to be passive because it receives health, and loses sickness.

  2. At other times the contrary occurs: thus, “to ail” is to be passive; because the ailment is received and health is lost. And here we have passion most properly. For a thing is said to be passive from its being drawn to the agent: and when a thing recedes from what is suitable to the receiver, then especially does it appear to be drawn to something else. Moreover, in De Generatione, Bk 1, ch.3 318b2, it is stated when a more excellent thing is generated from a less excellent thing, we have generation simply, and corruption in a particular respect: whereas the reverse is the case, when from a more excellent thing, a less excellent thing is generated. [That is, when a less excellent thing is generated, then this is corruption simply speaking and is generation in a particular respect.]

In these three ways it happens that passions are in the soul. For in the sense of mere reception [viz., the first meaning St. Thomas gives above], we speak of “feeling and understanding as being a kind of passion” (De Anima Bk1, ch.5 410a25). But passion, accompanied by the loss of something, is only in respect of a bodily transmutation [viz., a physical change occurring in the body]; wherefore passion properly so called cannot be in the soul, save accidentally, in so far as the composite1 is passive. But here again we find a difference; because when this transmutation is for the worse, it [the transmutation] has more of the nature of a passion, than when it [the transmutation] is for the better: hence sorrow is more properly a passion than joy.2

Next, St. Thomas gives us St. John Damascene’s definition of passion.

Passion is a movement of the sensitive appetite when we imagine good or evil; in other words, passion is a movement of the irrational [part of the] soul, when we think of good or evil.”3

Where Do We Find the Passions? Are They in Our Bodies (In Our Sensible Part)? Or in Our Souls (the Will)?

St. Thomas answers these questions in the following words:

[P]assion is properly to be found where there is corporeal transmutation [viz., physical change]. This corporeal transmutation is found in the act of the sensitive appetite [desire], and is not only spiritual, as in the sensitive apprehension [understanding through our senses], but also natural.

Now there is no need for corporeal transmutation in the act of the intellectual appetite [i.e., the will – N.B. “appetite” is another word for “desire”]: because this appetite is not exercised by means of a corporeal organ. It is therefore evident that passion is more properly in the act of the sensitive appetite, than in that of the intellectual appetite; and this is again evident from the definitions of Damascene quoted in the sed contra [above].4

Looking at the Two Classes of Passions that We Possess

St. Thomas explains that there are two groups of passions – the concupiscible and the irascible. Here are his words:

The acts of different powers differ in species [that is in kind]; for instance, to see, and to hear. But the irascible and the concupiscible are two powers, into which the sensitive appetite is divided, as was said [earlier in the Summa, in Ia, Q.81, a.2]. Therefore, since the passions are movements of the sensitive appetite, as stated in Q.22, a.3, the passions of the irascible faculty are specifically distinct from those of the concupiscible part.5 …

[T]he passions of the irascible part differ in species from those of the concupiscible faculty. For since the different powers have different objects, the passions of different powers must, of necessity, be referred to different objects.

In order, therefore, to discern which passions are in the irascible, and which are in the concupiscible, we must take the object of each of these powers. As was stated above [in Ia, Q.81, a.2], the object of the concupiscible power is sensible good or evil [simply apprehended as such], which causes pleasure or pain. But, since the soul must, of necessity, experience difficulty or struggle at times, in acquiring some such good, or in avoiding some such evil, in so far as such good or evil is more than our animal nature can easily acquire or avoid; therefore, this good or evil itself, inasmuch as it is of an arduous or difficult nature, is the object of the irascible faculty. Therefore, whatever passions consider good or evil absolutely, belong to the concupiscible power; for instance, joy, sorrow, love, hatred, and such like: whereas those passions which consider good or bad, as arduous, through being difficult to obtain or avoid, belong to the irascible faculty; such as daring, fear, hope and the like.6

A Short Summary Concerning the Passions and Their Respective Movements

What is good (or perceived as good) causes the soul to incline toward it and this inclination is the passion of love. Similarly, what is evil (or perceived as evil) causes the soul to incline away from it and this disinclination is the passion of hatred.

If the good be not yet possessed, then this good object causes the soul to seek to possess this good. This inclination of the soul is the passion of desire or concupiscence. If the evil can be avoided (or can be avoided in the future, even if it is possessed now) then the soul seeks to avoid it and this is the passion of dislike or aversion.

When the good is obtained, it causes the appetite to rest in that good which has been obtained. This rest in the good which has been obtained is the passion of delight or joy. Similarly, when an evil is present in the soul which is (at least for now) unavoidable, then that possession of the evil is the passion of sorrow or sadness.

Concerning the irascible passions, they pertain to obtaining a good which is difficult to obtain or to avoiding an evil which is difficult to avoid. For the good which is difficult to obtain, the soul’s seeking of this good is hope and the soul’s not seeking it because the difficulty is too great, is despair. With respect to an evil which is difficult to avoid, the soul’s seeking to avoid this evil which is difficult to avoid is daring and the soul’s anticipation of suffering the evil which is difficult to avoid, is fear. There is no irascible passion with respect to the good obtained because it is not a subject of difficulty. But concerning an evil already possessed, the soul’s reaction is anger.

Therefore, we see that there are three pairs of passions in the concupiscible appetites: namely, love and hatred; desire and aversion; joy and sorrow. Likewise, there are three “pairs” in the irascible: namely, hope and despair; fear and daring; and anger, which passion has no opposite. Therefore, there are in all 11 different passions: six which are concupiscible, and five which are irascible; in which all the animal passions are contained.7

A Preview… Having now considered the passions more generally, in our next lesson we will begin looking at the passion of fear in particular. In this way, we will be able to see how fear influences all the temperaments and especially how the passion of fear can hinder the intellectual life of a soul.

1 Here St. Thomas is referring to the composition of body and soul because the soul is the form of the body. In other words, the soul is what makes the body able to live and to be the type of living creature that it is.

2 Taken from the Summa, Ia IIae, Q.22, a.1, Whether Any Passion is in the Soul? Respondeo. The works St. Thomas is citing are Aristotle’s work about the generation and corruption/dying of animals (De Generatione et Corruptione), and his work on the soul (De Anima) (bracketed words added for clarity).

3 This is taken from the Summa, Ia IIae, Q.22, a.3, Sed Contra, where St. Thomas quotes St. John Damascene’s work De Fide Orthodox, that is Concerning the Orthodox Faith, Book 2, chapter 22 (bracketed words added to show the context).

4 This is taken from the Summa Ia IIae, Q.22, a.3, Whether Passion Is in the Sensitive Appetite Rather Than in the Intellectual Appetite, Which Is Called the Will?, Respondeo, (bracketed words added to show context).

5 Summa, Ia IIae, Q.23, a.1, Whether the Passions of the Concupiscible Part are Different from Those of the Irascible Part?, Sed Contra. When St. Thomas mentions “specifically distinct,” he means that they differ in kind.

6 Summa, Ia IIae Q.23, a.1, Whether the Passions of the Concupiscible Part are Different from Those of the Irascible Part?, Respondeo.

7 This summary is based on Summa, Ia IIae, Q.23, a.4, Whether in the Same Power, There Are Any Passions, Specifically Different, but Not Contrary to One Another?

Words to Live by – from Catholic Tradition

We Must Have Self-knowledge!

He who knows himself well is mean in his own eyes and is not delighted with being praised by men.

My Imitation of Christ by Thomas à Kempis, (c)1982, Confraternity of the Precious Blood, 5300 Fort Hamilton Parkway, Brooklyn, N.Y. 11219, Bk.1 ch.2.

The Blessing of a True, Catholic Liberal Education — Part IV

Catholic Candle note: Below is part 4 of the article concerning the best type of education, which is a Catholic Liberal Education. Do not confuse this education with many university programs called “liberal arts” but which are full of fluff, falsehood, and aimless so-called “cultural enrichment” courses and “humanities”.

A liberal education also does not refer to liberalism, nor is a true liberal education an indoctrination into that error of liberalism or political correctness. In fact, a true Catholic Liberal Education is the best antidote to the errors of liberalism.

Previously, in part 1 of this article,1 we examined the problems we see in modern education:

  • Modern colleges do not improve the quality of their students’ minds and their thinking ability much or at all.


  • Most “education” is merely job training, fluff courses, and/or leftist indoctrination.


  • The students are taught to sound like someone in their field but they do little thinking and more memorizing.


  • Grade “inflation” and degree “inflation” is rampant. Grades and academic degrees do not mean much anymore.

In part 2 of this article,2 we examined, in general, what education is. We considered the human soul and the perfection of its highest faculty (power) – the intellect – which is immaterial. We saw that our intellects are perfected through knowing eternal, unchangeable truths and their causes.

In part 3 of this article,3 after having seen what education is, we examined the question who should perfect his intellect?

But since modern universities do not provide a true education, is there ever any reason for men or women to attend them? Below, in part 4 of this article, we will consider that question.

The Blessing of a True, Catholic Liberal Education

Part 4

Is There Ever Any Reason for Anyone to Attend a Modern University?

Because a true education is a Catholic Liberal Education, and because modern universities do not provide this, is there ever any reason for anyone to attend a modern university? We will first look at that issue in the case of men; then, we will consider this question regarding women.

Of course, every person’s priority should be to perfect his mind with a true education. This is what God made us to do (viz., perfect our highest faculty) and we should all do this to the best of our ability and circumstances throughout our life.

For some persons, this beginning of a lifelong pursuit of truth and of further perfecting of our intellects would involve attending a college or university to obtain a true Catholic Liberal Education (if/when such an education is available there).

Even if/when there were a Catholic Liberal Education available at the university/college level, some persons could not attend such institution of higher learning because their abilities or opportunities do not allow this. For these persons, the best they can do would be to proceed on their lifelong journey of perfecting their intellects in other settings, according to their abilities.

Although we all have a duty to continue to prefect our minds throughout life, especially studying our Catholic Faith,4 the ability of different persons will not be the same. Some persons will advance much further and faster than others and, over the course of their lives will perfect their minds much more. But everyone should do it according to the ability that God has given him.

Even those who have the blessing of a formal, genuine, college-level, Catholic Liberal Education – which is the best way for adults to begin their lifelong journey pursuing truth – they still must at some point transition from this blessed full-time activity to then obtaining the practical preparation they need in order to answer God’s call to their vocation.

For men called to marry and to start a family, this means preparing to provide for the material needs of their future family. To do this, some men might need college-level or even post-graduate level job training, (in engineering, medicine, law, etc.)

This job training has little or nothing of true perfection of the mind but involves matters such as building codes, construction standards, surgical techniques, applicability of commercial laws, pharmacological contraindications, etc.

Universities and colleges can have a role in training those persons who have a practical need for this advanced job training, although that training is a much lower pursuit than a genuine Catholic Liberal Education.

Of course, other men, who do not need such advanced job training, can prepare to provide for the material needs of their future families in other ways, such as through apprenticeships, on-the-job-training, etc.

So, in the case of men, a modern university could play a role in their life’s material vocational preparations. Of course, those men must be appropriately vigilant against all of the contamination present there, because this moral and intellectual contamination seeks to derail them from leading the life that God intends for them to live on earth and from the happiness that God intends for them in heaven.


Is There Ever Any Reason for a Woman to Attend a Modern University?

Having considered whether there could be a reason for men to attend a modern university – hopefully after a strong beginning in their lifelong pursuit of high truth – now let us consider the question of whether there is ever any reason for a woman to attend a modern university – i.e., an institution that does not offer a true education (viz., a Catholic Liberal Education).

We already saw that women (and men) should get a true and genuine college-level Catholic Liberal Education if they are able to do so. We saw that this true education is not merely for a few elite men who would benefit the very most. Rather, this education is for women as well, and for everyone who is capable of benefiting from it in some amount.

Of course, as we saw, everyone should continue to prefect his mind throughout his entire life – especially studying the Catholic Faith more deeply. However, just as men who obtain a college-level Catholic Liberal Education, must leave off from the full-time pursuit of high truth at some point to take time to prepare for the practical aspects of the vocation to which God is calling them, this is true of women too.

After obtaining a college-level Catholic Liberal Education, she could pursue a reasonable amount of job training to help her to support herself while (patiently) waiting for God to send to her the husband that He wills for her.

If it happens that a woman finds that she needs to provide for her own support for a more extended time before God sends her the man that He intends her to marry, then she might possibly need college-level job training such as to become a nurse or otherwise get a job in one of the “helping professions”. However, in all but unusual circumstances, this job training would not mean that she needs to earn an additional degree (viz., in addition to her Catholic Liberal Education).

Hopefully, such academic job training would occur – if at all – only after her Catholic Liberal Education because, commonly, the young woman who is capable of obtaining a college nursing degree would also be capable of using that same opportunity (viz., time and money) to perfect her mind with a true Catholic Liberal Education. Such genuine education would benefit her and her future family far more than her job training. Further, by the time she has had that blessed education, she would often find herself at the age and stage where God is calling her to marry now and to start a family with her husband.

This is because, if God is calling her to be a wife and mother (instead of a professed religious), then He would usually send the right man to her without her spending an extended period of time getting specialized job training and then using it in the workforce – assuming that she does her part to make herself available so her future husband can find her.5

In any event, in addition to all of this, the woman must spend the time while she is waiting for her future spouse, continuing to cultivate the womanly arts. For it is an important preparation for marriage for women to master the arts which they will practice as wives, mothers, homemakers, and the homeschool teachers of their children (as is usually necessary nowadays). In other words, women must prepare themselves to respond to the call of their vocations to be the future hearts of their respective homes and families.

But there are many jobs which she should neither train for nor engage in. She should not be a doctor, a lawyer6, or practice a similar profession, for four reasons:

  1. The years of this training and the cost would rarely “pay off” because she would usually meet her husband and get married before she finished her studies or at least before paying off her additional school debts.


  2. The increased debt she incurred, as well as her time and effort obtaining this job training, might easily create (or increase) the temptation to work outside of the home after marriage.7


  3. These types of professional employment are suited to only the most clear-thinking men, since such professions principally require the greatest prudence and the most careful thinking.8


  4. Such professions are detrimental to her God-given role as man’s helpmate and assistant, rather than man’s boss and an authority over him.9 Such employment is both against the natural role God gave her as a woman and also will make it harder for her to be an obedient and submissive wife when she gets married.

Likewise, a woman should not obtain academic job training in order to seek political office, or to become a police officer, a soldier, or have a similar job for two reasons:

  1. The above types of jobs oppose the way God made her because she would be wielding authority over men10; and

  1. Such work opposes her God-given nature as a nurturer, compassionate, a comforter, etc. Being a policeman, soldier, etc., would require a woman to be aggressive, to harden herself, twisting and distorting the way God made women, to her detriment and the detriment of the crucial work11 of her life, viz., being her husband’s helpmate and raising children well.12


Let us contrast these two scenarios:

  1. A woman marrying shortly after finishing a university job training degree; and

  2. That woman marrying shortly after finishing a college-level, true Catholic Liberal Education.

Generally, it makes no sense to undertake very expensive, years-long training for a job which she will hold for only a short time before the time comes when God sends to her the husband she should marry.

In contrast to the imprudence (generally) of obtaining such expensive and lengthy practical job training, a Catholic Liberal Education is directed toward perfecting the mind that God gave to her, not primarily for outside employment and so such true education is not a “waste of money” even if she never “uses” it for outside employment, since that is not the point of a true education. The true perfection of her mind is a lifelong asset for her to use in every aspect of her life and vocation.

So, we see that, although Bishop Williamson is wrong in other respects, his words (quoted here13) have a correct element: that “true universities are for ideas”.14 But such “true universities” are nearly non-existent now. Modern universities are not devoted to ideas which perfect the mind with high truth. Rather, these universities are dens of iniquity, leftist indoctrination, leftist social conformity, and job training. Availing themselves of the opportunity to obtain very expensive, years-long job training would usually be a mistake for “true girls” (to use his words), since these women need to remain available to answer God’s call to their vocation. So, Bishop Williamson would have been more correct to have said “expensive university job training is not for true girls”.

But to the extent that “true universities” do exist, at which a person could obtain a true Catholic Liberal Education, Bishop Williamson’s words are false that “universities are not for true girls”.15 Women should obtain as much good as they are able to obtain from such a true education, striving for higher-level perfection for their intellects.


A Question Arises

Having seen that women and girls, as well as men and boys have a duty to perfect their minds in the best way that they can do so, what is the best environment in which women and girls could pursue a true Catholic Liberal Education?


To be continued …

4
After St. Thomas states that a person (the Latin word is “homo”) “desires to the highest extent to have knowledge of the truth”, he then adds “the truth is especially considered as regards God.” Quoted from a sermon by St. Thomas Aquinas, Ecce Rex Tuus, Collatio in Sero, preached in the evening of the 1st Sunday of Advent, November 29, 1271, to the faculty and students of the University of Paris, §3.1.


5 In our corrupt times, it is a real challenge to find the spouse God wishes to send. But this challenge should not be discouraging! God can do all things and He wants each person to respond to His vocational call with great courage, prudence, generosity, patience, and complete trust in Him.


Of course, not only in our corrupt times, but in every time, both the young lady and the young man must do “his (or her) part” to find the right (future) spouse. For the young man, he must actively seek out all gentlemanly opportunities to find his future wife, including his availing himself of opportunities which are “out of his comfort zone”. He should act like a man and not like a coward or a lady, waiting for others to do his “work” for him – that is, seeking and meeting her.


The young lady does not have the same role. She should not approach the young man and introduce herself, ask for his phone number, call him, etc. But without being “forward”, she should arrange to be available in many ways so that the young man has a way of meeting her, etc.

6 Here is one way that St. Thomas teaches this common-sense truth of both nature and religion:


If therefore they [viz., women] ask and dispute in public, it would be a sign of shamelessness, and this is shameful to them. Hence it also follows that in law the office of advocate is forbidden to women [viz., in the better civilization in which St. Thomas lived, which more closely followed the Natural Law and Catholic teaching].


St. Thomas Aquinas, Lectures on 1 Corinthians, 14, lect. 7, n. 881, (bracketed words added for context).

7 Luring mothers to leave their homes and children to join the workforce of businesses is one of the chief tools of communism and is one of the main ways Russia has spread its errors. Here is how Pope Pius XI explained this truth:


Communism is particularly characterized by the rejection of any link that binds woman to the family and the home, and her emancipation is proclaimed as a basic principle. She is withdrawn from the family and the care of her children, to be thrust instead into public life and collective production under the same conditions as man. The care of home and children then devolves upon the collectivity.


Divini Redemptoris – On atheistic communism, Pope Pius XI, §11.


Pope Pius XI condemns married women working outside the home, in the following words:


Neither this emancipation of the woman is real, nor is it the reasonable and worthy [Footnote continued on the next page.]

[Footnote continued from the prior page.]


liberty convenient to the Christian and noble mission of the woman and wife. It is the corruption of the feminine nature and maternal dignity, as well as the perversion of all the family, since the husband lacks his wife, the children their mother, and the entire family her vigilant guard.


On the contrary, this false liberty and unnatural equality with man is harmful for the woman herself, because at the moment that she steps down from the royal domestic throne to which she was raised by the Gospel, quickly she will fall into the ancient slavery of Paganism, becoming a mere instrument of man.


Pope Pius XI, Casti connubii, #75 (emphasis added).


Anyone who thinks a mother’s work outside the home is more important than her family and homemaking duties, fails to understand the Great Work of her life, for which God created her. Considering anyone else as an acceptable substitute for the mother being at home with her children, is a failure not only to understand Catholic teaching, but is also a failure to understand the family on even a natural level (although this natural truth was accepted and was obvious even to non-Catholics, until a few decades ago).

8 Here is one way St. Thomas Aquinas states this truth:


[M]en are wiser and more discerning and not so readily deceived as women are. … Man is the head and counselor of the woman.


St. Thomas Aquinas, Lectures on St. Matthew’s Gospel, Ch.23, #1859.


9 The reason is that it is not woman’s role to lead (exercise leadership) in society. This is why St. Paul explained that “I suffer not a woman to teach, nor to use authority over the man: but to be in silence.” 1 Timothy, 2:12.


10 Isaiah mentions the rule of women as a way to measure how corrupt a society (viz., Israel) is. Here are Isaiah’s words: “As for my people, their oppressors have stripped them, and women have ruled over them”. Isaias, 3:12.


Summarizing the Divine Law (from St. Paul) and Natural Law (from Aristotle) concerning the perversity of a woman being in charge of a government, the Summa teaches:


According to the Apostle (1 Tim., 2:11; Titus, 2:5), woman is in a state of subjection: wherefore she can have no spiritual jurisdiction, since the Philosopher [Aristotle] also says (Ethic. viii) that it is a corruption of public life when the government comes into the hands of a woman.


Supp. Q.19, a.3, ad 4 (emphasis added; bracketed word added for clarity).


This corruption of having a woman rule is obvious from the fact that she must not even rule her own family. Rather, she must obey her husband. St. Paul commands: “Wives, be subject to your husbands”. Colossians, 3:18. Therefore, how much more perverse it is for a woman to have authority over, and be the head of, all of the families of a country by being the head of the country!


Here is how Pope St. Pius X taught this same truth:


Women in war or parliament are outside their proper sphere, and their position there would be the desperation and ruin of society … .”


Quoted from Pope St. Pius X’s 1909 Address to Delegation of the Union of Italian Catholic Ladies.


11 Read this article: The Role and Work that God Gave to Woman, found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2019/12/02/the-role-and-work-that-god-gave-to-woman/


12 A man’s role is to protect his family in both spiritual and temporal matters. A woman’s role is to nurture her children and be a helpmate for her husband.


Raising her children well, not other works, is the Great Work for which God intended [Footnote continued on the next page.]


[Footnote continued from the prior page.]

women. In other works, in works such as being a partner in business, men help other men better than women do. Here is one way St. Thomas Aquinas, greatest Doctor of the Catholic Church, explains this truth:


It was necessary that woman be made, as Scripture says, as a helpmate to the male; not indeed as a helpmate in some other work, as some have said, since in any other work a male can be more conveniently helped by another male than by woman; but as a helper in generation.


Summa Ia, Q.92, a.1, respondeo.


Sacred Scripture infallibly says the same thing in many ways. For example, here is one way St. Paul states this truth:


[S]he [viz., woman] shall be saved through childbearing; if she continues in faith, and love, and sanctification, with sobriety.”


1 Timothy 2:15.

14 Quoted from Girls at the University, Bishop Richard Williamson’s Letter to Friends and Benefactors of St. Thomas Aquinas Seminary, Winona, September 1, 2001.

15 Quoted from Girls at the University, Bishop Richard Williamson’s Letter to Friends and Benefactors of St. Thomas Aquinas Seminary, Winona, September 1, 2001.

A Man Need Not Be Consecrated a Bishop or Ordained a Priest to Be a Valid Pope

Catholic Candle note: Sedevacantism is wrong and is (material or formal) schism. Catholic Candle is not sedevacantist.

Below is the twelfth article in a series which covers specific aspects of the error of sedevacantism. As context for this twelfth article, let us recall what we saw in the earlier eleven articles:

In the first article, we saw that we cannot know whether the pope (or anyone else) is a formal heretic (rather than a material heretic only) – and thus whether he is outside the true Catholic Church based simply on his persistent, public teaching of a heretical opinion.1

Then, in the second article, we saw that we must not judge a man to be a formal heretic if he professes to be Catholic and says he believes what a Catholic must believe now, in order to be Catholic now. When a person professes a heretical opinion, we must judge him in the most favorable light (if we judge him at all). So, we must avoid the sin of rash judgment and we must not judge negatively the interior culpability of the pope and the 1.4 billion2 people who profess to be Catholic. We must not judge they are not “real” Catholics if they tell us that they are Catholics. Instead, we should count them as Catholics who are very confused or are uninformed.3

Thus, we must judge the conciliar popes to have been material heretics, not formal heretics (if we judge them at all), and that each was pope in his turn until his death (or abdication). Regarding any of the world’s 1.4 billion self-described Catholics who hold heresy, we must judge them to be material heretics only (if we judge them at all), unless they themselves tell us that they know they don’t qualify to be Catholics.4

In the third article, we examined briefly the important difference between persons in authority who fulfill their duty to judge those under their charge in the external forum, as contrasted to a sedevacantist or anyone else except God who judges the interior culpability of other persons and (rashly) judges them to be formal heretics.5

In the fourth article, we saw that it does not help us to protect ourselves better from a conciliar pope’s heresy, to declare that we know he is not the pope and is not a Catholic.6

In the fifth article, we saw that it is possible for a pope to teach (or believe) heresy and in fact, popes have taught and believed heresy at various times during Church history.7 We looked especially at the cases of Pope John XXII and Pope Nicholas I, who both taught explicit heresy while pope and nonetheless continued to be the pope. Pope John XXII also taught the same explicit heresy before he became the pope.

In the sixth article, we saw that the Church infallibly assures us that we will have a pope at all times until the end of the world, except during very short interregnums between papal reigns, during which the Church is in the process of electing a new pope and during which the Church’s unified government continues to function.8 In this sixth article, we saw that we are not presently in an interregnum (even though the sedevacantists absurdly claim we are in a many-decades-long interregnum).

In the seventh article of this series, we saw that the Catholic Church is a visible Body and remains visible to all. The Catholic Church has a visible monarchical government and the pope is visible to all. Thus, we know we have a pope and that the one who is pope is visible (known) to all as the pope.9

In the eighth article, we saw that the necessary visibility of the Catholic Church and the pope, requires as a corollary that the one who virtually all Catholics see (believe) is the pope must be the pope, since the pope must be visible to all.

In the ninth article, we addressed the superficial “argument” of sedevacantists (addressed to Catholics) saying that “if you think we have a pope, then you have to obey him in whatever he tells you to do”. We examined the true Catholic virtue of obedience and saw that we must not obey the commands of even a real superior like our pope, if/when he commands us to do something evil.10

In the tenth article, we saw more deeply what schism is and how sedevacantism is inherently schism.11

In the eleventh article of this series, we saw more deeply how we should respond to a pope (or other superior) who does harm – viz., we should recognize his authority as pope but resist the evil of his words or deeds.12

In the twelfth article of this series, we saw how we ordinary Catholic laymen can know what the Catholic Truth is and how we can know when the pope (or anyone) is promoting error.13

Below, in the thirteenth article of this series, we will examine a related sedevacantist error, claiming we that we have no pope because the conciliar popes had doubtful consecrations and/or ordinations.



An Explanation How the Catholic Church Continues to Possess A Full Hierarchy even in these Times of Great Apostasy

Against the Sedevacantist Argument that only a Valid Bishop Can Be Pope because He is Bishop of Rome

From the many prior articles in this series (linked above), it is plain that sedevacantism is wrong. However, some sedevacantists use a different, more indirect attack on our present pope’s possession of his office. They assert that because one of the pope’s titles is “Bishop of Rome”,14 he cannot be pope because he is not a valid bishop. These sedevacantists then declare that, because conciliar ordinations and consecrations are definitely invalid (so they assert), the more recent conciliar popes cannot be real popes because they are not valid bishops.

While those sedevacantists are rash15 to the extent they claim certitude that conciliar consecrations are invalid, it is true that conciliar consecrations and ordinations are inherently doubtful, and that doubtful sacraments should be treated as invalid (because they might be invalid).16

However, as shown below, a more careful examination of this sedevacantist argument (viz., that the pope must be a valid bishop because he is the Bishop of Rome) shows that even if the pope is a layman (i.e., not a bishop or priest), this is not an obstacle to his valid papacy.

The papacy is a monarchy, giving the pope jurisdiction (i.e., governing authority) over the entire Catholic Church, as Vicar of Christ. But this jurisdiction which is the essence of the papal office, does not require the pope to be a bishop or even a priest, to validly hold the papal office. Certainly, the Catholic Church has good reason for Her custom that the pope be a bishop, because it is very fitting that the ruler over even the bishops, would himself be a bishop.

However, to hold the papal office and possess this universal jurisdiction which the pope has, does not require him to be a bishop as an essential condition which would otherwise prevent him from being pope.

A pope must be a male Catholic17 who has use of his reason when elected. To become pope, any such male Catholic18 only needs to be elected and to consent.19 By being elected and consenting, this male would immediately become the pope but he would have the moral obligation to seek Episcopal consecration so he could fulfill the sacramental duties of a pope.20

But once a male Catholic is elected and consents to be pope, he is the pope without any need of ceremony, coronation, or confirmation in office.21

Thus, because all conciliar popes have been Catholic males who had the use of reason, each of them, in his turn, was a valid pope with full papal jurisdiction (to govern), even if he were not a valid bishop (or even a priest) and did not have Episcopal powers to perform sacraments.

With full papal jurisdictional powers, he governs not only the universal Church but he also governs Rome as Bishop of Rome,22 although, again, he could not ordain priests or otherwise exercise Episcopal sacramental powers without himself being first validly consecrated a bishop.


This same principle (which allows a layman to be pope) applies to local ordinaries throughout the world, who exercise true jurisdictional power over their dioceses, even if they are laymen.

For the same reason that the pope does not have to be consecrated a bishop or even ordained a priest, in order to wield universal jurisdiction to govern the Catholic Church as pope, likewise the Ordinary of a diocese does not need to be consecrated a bishop or even ordained a priest to govern his diocese.

Being the Ordinary of a diocese is an office of jurisdiction (viz., of governing). The Ordinary receives jurisdiction from the pope by being appointed by the pope. He is like the “king” of the diocese (under the pope) and wields jurisdictional power (under the pope) in that particular diocese.23 As is the custom of the Church, it is very fitting that the local Ordinary be a bishop, since the Ordinary will govern the Church in that diocese, including any auxiliary bishops and diocesan priests there.


Conclusion One of this Article: The Catholic Church has a full, worldwide hierarchy (not only a pope), even though that (post conciliar) hierarchy abuses its power and promotes error.

The Catholic Church not only has a Pope but also a full worldwide hierarchy of diocesan Ordinaries possessing true jurisdiction to govern those dioceses (portions of the Catholic Church) even if they are laymen (and even though they abuse their authority).

Each Ordinary around the world has been appointed by the pope to govern his diocese. Even if he is a layman, he has the jurisdiction to govern.


Conclusion Two of this Article: The Catholic Church has in place the structure to elect future popes.

When the pope dies, it is the cardinals’ duty to elect another pope. A cardinal does not need to be a bishop (just as Cardinal John Henry Newman was not). The recent popes have used their jurisdictional power to continue appointing cardinals (even supposing they are laymen) to elect future popes, leaving in place the structure for papal succession.

By contrast, sedevacantists speculate that God will somehow miraculously intervene to raise up a pope, although they deny the Church has had any pope, cardinals, or hierarchy for decades.

The sedevacantists’ false, unfounded supposition that God will revive the Church by Divine intervention, would really be a new, second founding of the Church (or founding of a new church). This (false) sedevacantist theory is un-Traditional because God founded His Church once, with the Church perpetually handing down Her doctrine and Her hierarchical authority.

It is as baseless for the sedevacantists to assert that God will miraculously choose a new pope as it would be for God to miraculously establish a new doctrine.


Conclusion Three of this Article: Because a Man Elected Pope must also Voluntarily accept his Election (in order for the Papal Office to vest in him), this further Refutes the False Theory that Cardinal Siri Was the Real Pope in Place of one (or more) of the Conciliar Popes.

One small, confused sedevacantist group denies the real pope because they believe that Cardinal Siri was validly elected in one or more of the conclaves after the death of Pope Pius XII. This group variously speculates either that Cardinal Siri was pressured not to accept the office or pressured to resign during the conclave, after he first (but very briefly) accepted his election as pope.

In fact, if it were true (hypothetically) that Cardinal Siri had been elected but had been pressured to not accept the office, then (as shown above) he would never have been pope, since the man who has been elected does not become pope without accepting this office.

If (hypothetically) Siri accepted his election and then decided to resign almost immediately (e.g., because he was threatened), then having resigned, the conclave could elect another pope (and so Siri would have been the real pope for only a few minutes).

Further, some members of this small, confused group of Siri advocates somehow suppose that Cardinal Siri continued to be pope but that the oath of secrecy prevented him from revealing that he was elected pope. However, this oath pertains to the secrecy of deliberations and to inconclusive votes.

There is obviously nothing to prevent a cardinal from disclosing his own election or any other person’s election after it occurs. This is obvious because all the cardinals swear this oath of secrecy. If they could never reveal the successful election of a pope, then a successful election could never be disclosed and no one outside the conclave would ever know who the new pope is.

Thus, if (hypothetically) Siri were elected pope, had accepted his election, and continued in office, he would have had a duty (as would everyone else in the conclave) to state this “fact”. Yet, in the decades after these conclaves, Siri never claimed to be pope nor did any other member of the conclave proclaim him as pope. Instead, Cardinal Siri recognized those same popes recognized by everyone else. Plainly, the Siri hypothesis is unworthy of belief.

2 The Vatican estimates that the number of Catholics worldwide is about 1.375 billion. https://www.vaticannews.va/en/church/news/2023-10/fides-catholic-church-statistics-world-mission-sunday.html


7 Read this article here: It is Possible for a Pope to Teach Heresy and Remain the Pope?: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/01/27/it-is-possible-for-a-pope-to-teach-heresy-and-remain-the-pope/


8 Read this article here that the Catholic Church’s unified government always continues, even during an interregnum: The Catholic Church Will Always Have a Pope: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/02/21/the-catholic-church-will-always-have-a-pope/

9 Read this article showing that The Catholic Church Will Always be Visible, and Will Always Have a Pope Who is Visible to All, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/03/27/the-catholic-church-will-always-be-visible-with-a-pope/


10 Read this article examining false obedience, entitled, The False “Obedience” of Cowardly and Weak Catholics, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/05/20/the-false-obedience-of-cowardly-and-weak-catholics/


11 Read this article showing that Sedevacantism is Inherently Schism, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/06/28/sedevacantism-is-inherently-schism/


12 Our Catholic Duty: Resist the Harm Done by a Bad Pope But (Of Course) Recognize His Authority: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/07/24/our-catholic-duty-resist-the-harm-done-by-a-bad-pope-but-of-course-recognize-his-authority/


13 Judging the Pope’s Words & Deeds According to Catholic Tradition: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/08/29/judging-the-popes-words-deeds-according-to-catholic-tradition/

14 Traditionally, one of the pope’s titles is “Bishop of Rome”, because he is the Ordinary who exercises ecclesiastical jurisdiction over that diocese, as other bishops exercise jurisdiction over other dioceses.

15 We Catholics do not take upon ourselves the authority to “declare” conciliar ordinations and consecrations definitely invalid. We simply protect ourselves by staying away from conciliar ordinations and consecrations because we see there is good reason to doubt the validity of conciliar consecrations and ordinations.

16 Because doubtful ordinations and consecrations should be treated as invalid, this is why conditional ordinations and consecrations are required for all conciliar consecrations and ordinations. For a thorough explanation of the doubts about their validity, see these Catholic Candle articles:




17 Sedevacantists rashly judge that the pope is interiorly culpable for his material heresy (i.e., his errors on matters of Faith) and that he is not “really” a Catholic, although he claims to be. We treat this sedevacantist error here: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/10/24/are-we-allowed-to-decide-that-pope-francis-knows-he-is-not-catholic/

But, when a male with the use of reason is elected pope and he says he is Catholic, none of his errors should cause people to rashly declare he is not a “real” Catholic. Id.


However, we are presently considering a different issue, viz., whether a man can be pope without being a bishop.

18 This is how Father John F. Sullivan explains this point, in his book The Externals of the Catholic Church:


Who may be chosen to fill the office of Pope? Strictly speaking, any male Catholic who has come to the age of reason – even a layman. Strange to say, it would be legally possible to elect even a married man.


The Externals of the Catholic Church, by Rev. John F. Sullivan, Kennedy & Sons, New York, 1918, p.6.


19 In his book defending the papacy, Bishop Kenrick explains this truth as follows: “After the election of the Pope, his consent is demanded”. The Primacy of the Apostolic See Vindicated, by Bishop Francis Kenrick, 3rd Ed., 1848, Dunigan & Bro., New York, p.300.

Pope Pius XII explained that becoming pope did not require a man to be a bishop:


Even if a layman were elected pope, he could accept the election only if he were fit for ordination and willing to be ordained. But the power to teach and govern, as well as the divine gift of infallibility, would be granted to him from the very moment of his acceptance, even before his ordination.


Pope Pius XII, Speech to the participants in the 2nd World Congress for the Apostolate of the Laity, October 5, 1957 (emphasis added).

[Footnote continued on the next page.]

[Footnote continued from the prior page.]

In his book The Externals of the Catholic Church, Fr. Sullivan explains this point in more detail:


When a candidate is found to have the necessary number of votes and has manifested his willingness to accept the office, he is thereby Pope. He needs no ceremony of consecration to elevate him to the Papacy.


It would be possible, though far from probable [Note: this book was written in 1918], that a person might be elected Pope who is not already a Bishop. He would become Pope as soon as he was lawfully chosen, and could then perform all the duties of the Papacy which pertain to jurisdiction [i.e., governing]; but he could not ordain or consecrate until he himself had been raised to the episcopate by other Bishops.


The Externals of the Catholic Church, by Rev. John F. Sullivan, Kennedy & Sons, New York, 1918, pp. 7-8 (bracketed words added for clarity).


20 Outlines of Dogmatic Theology explains this truth as follows: “[I]f the person elected [pope] has not already received episcopal consecration, it is his duty to seek it.” Outlines of Dogmatic Theology, Sylvester J. Hunter, S.J., 2nd ed., vol. 1, p. 394, Benziger Brothers, N.Y. 1894.

21 In Outlines of Dogmatic Theology, Fr. Hunter explains:


[J]urisdiction vests immediately on the completion of the election, for the Pope has no superior to confirm him in his office.


Outlines of Dogmatic Theology, Sylvester J. Hunter, S.J., 2nd ed., vol. 1, p. 393, Benziger Brothers, N.Y. 1894.


As the Summa explains: “jurisdiction is not something sacramental”. Summa Supp., Q.25, a.2, ad 1.

22

When a man is appointed as bishop of a diocese, he has jurisdiction (i.e., ruling power) over the diocese even before he is consecrated as a bishop. This applies to the pope, when elected, with respect to being Bishop of Rome (as well as being pope over the universal Church).

That new pope, even if a layman, could even be called a “bishop” in some respect, just as the Catholic Encyclopedia calls a layman a “bishop” when he possesses Episcopal jurisdiction even before he is consecrated. Here is the Catholic Encyclopedia’s explanation:


[F]or the exercise of external jurisdiction the power of orders is not necessary. A bishop, duly appointed to a see, but not yet consecrated, is invested with external jurisdiction over his diocese …


1917 Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 3, article: Church, §VIII (2), p.755.


In the same way, a pope who is a layman, could be truly called the Bishop of Rome in some respect, even without Episcopal consecration and without Episcopal powers to perform Sacraments. But obviously, calling a layman “bishop” (referring to possession of Episcopal jurisdiction) could mislead some people into believing he was validly consecrated as a bishop. For this reason, it seems better to generally use quotation marks around the title “bishop”, or in some other way distinguish such a layman with Episcopal jurisdiction, from a sacramentally-consecrated bishop.

23 As the 1917 Catholic Encyclopedia’s explains:


Internal jurisdiction is that which is exercised in the tribunal of penance. It differs

[Footnote continued on the next page.]

[Footnote continued from the last page.]


from the external jurisdiction of which we have been speaking, in that its object is the welfare of the individual penitent, while the object of external jurisdiction is the welfare of the Church as a corporate body. …

[F]or the exercise of external jurisdiction the power of orders is not necessary. A bishop, duly appointed to a see [i.e., a diocese], but not yet consecrated, is invested with external jurisdiction over his diocese …


1917 Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 3, article: Church, §VIII (2), p.755 (bracketed words added).


Further, a man appointed as Ordinary of a diocese is mentioned in the Canon of the Mass even if he has not received sacramental consecration. As Fr. Adrian Fortescue explains:


The bishop must be canonically appointed and confirmed, otherwise he is not mentioned [in the Canon of the Mass]. But he need not yet be consecrated.


1917 Catholic Encyclopedia, article Canon of the Mass, author: Fr. Adrian Fortescue, vol. 3, article Canon of the Mass, p.262 (bracketed words added).


Here is how the Summa explains a “bishop elect” wielding Episcopal jurisdiction without having been sacramentally consecrated a bishop:


There are two kinds of key [Note: The Summa here refers to the “Keys to the Kingdom of Heaven” that Our Lord gave to St. Peter]:

One key reaches to heaven itself directly, by remitting sin and thus removing the obstacles to the entrance into heaven; and this is called the key of “order” [i.e., Holy Orders]. Priests alone have this key, because they alone are ordained for the people in the things which appertain to God directly.

The other key reaches to heaven, not directly but through the medium of the Church Militant. By this key a man goes to heaven, since, by its means, a man is shut out from or admitted to the fellowship of the Church Militant, by excommunication or absolution. This is called the key of “jurisdiction” in the external court, wherefore even those who are not priests can have this key, e.g., archdeacons, bishops elect, and others who can excommunicate. But it is not properly called a key of heaven, but a disposition thereto.


Summa Supp. Q.19, a.3, Respondeo (bracketed words added for clarity).

Lesson #49: Temperaments – Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat – Part XIV

Philosophy Notes

Catholic Candle note: The article immediately below is part thirteen of the study of the Choleric temperament. The first twelve parts can be found here:

  1. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #36: About the Temperaments – Beginning our Study of the Choleric Temperament – Part I: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/08/27/lesson-35-about-the-temperaments-the-choleric-temperament/

  2. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #37: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament– Part II: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/09/26/lesson-37-about-the-temperaments-continuation-of-the-choleric-temperament/

  3. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #38 — About the Temperaments – Continuing our Study of the Choleric Temperament – Their Spiritual Combat – Part III:: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/10/24/lesson-38-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat/

  4. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #39 About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – That Temperament’s Spiritual Combat – Part IV: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/11/26/lesson-39-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat-part-iv/

  5. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #40: Temperaments – Choleric Temperament – Their Spiritual Combat – Part V: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/12/30/lesson-40-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat-part-v/

  6. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #41 – About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament: a Choleric’s Spiritual Combat — Part VI: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/01/27/lesson-41-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-vi/

  7. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #42: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – a Choleric’s Spiritual Combat – Part VII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/02/21/lesson-42-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-vii/

  8. Mary’s School of Sanctity — Lesson #43 About the Temperaments –Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament — Their Spiritual Combat Part VIII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/03/27/lesson-42-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-viii/

  9. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #44 About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – Their Spiritual Combat, Part IX: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/04/23/lesson-44-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-ix/

  10. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #45 About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat Part X: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/05/20/lesson-45-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-x/

  11. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #46 About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Cholerics’ Spiritual Combat – Part XI: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/06/28/lesson-46-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xi/

  12. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #47 About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat – Part XII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/07/24/lesson-47-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xii/

  13. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #48 About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat Part XIII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/08/29/lesson-48-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xiii/

Mary’s School of Sanctity

Lesson #49 About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat – Part XIV

Note: When referring to a person with a choleric temperament in this article we simply will label him as a choleric.

In our last lesson we discussed how Satan hates the fact that humans are created with intellects and are capable of knowing universal truth. This archenemy of mankind has launched his major attack on man’s highest faculty, namely, his intellect.

We saw how Satan tempts us humans to believe that making efforts to think carefully puts a damper on our enjoyment. We saw how this is a lie and that man’s highest delights come when he engages his mind in the pursuit of truth.

Now we will consider another snare that Satan uses – he inclines people to believe that they do not have the ability necessary for careful thinking. However, in order to understand how it is false to believe that we do not have the ability to think carefully, we must first reflect more about human nature itself.

Satan Preys on Fallen Human Nature

As we stated above, one of the devil’s tricks is to tempt humans into supposing that they do not have the necessary ability to think carefully and deeply. Someone could claim that thinking deeply was easy for Adam but ever since the fall of man, man does not have the ability to think. This is an old deception of Satan.

St. Thomas Aquinas explains the effects of original sin as follows:

Original justice was forfeited through the sin of our first parent [Adam], as already stated above (I-II Q. 81 a. 2); so that all the powers of the soul are left, as it were, destitute of their proper order, whereby they are naturally directed to virtue; which destitution is called a wounding of nature.

Again, there are four of the powers that can be the subject of virtue, as stated above (I-II Q. 61 a. 2), viz. the reason, where prudence resides, the will, where justice is, the irascible [passions], the subject of fortitude, and the concupiscible [passions], the subject of temperance. Therefore, in so far as the reason is deprived of its order to the true, there is the wound of ignorance, in so far as the will is deprived of its order to the good, there is the wound of malice; in so far as the irascible is deprived of its order to the arduous, there is the wound of weakness; and in so far as the concupiscible is deprived of its order to the delectation moderated by reason, there is the wound of concupiscence.

Accordingly, these are the four wounds inflicted on the whole of the human nature as a result of our first parent’s sin. But since the inclination to the good of virtues is diminished in each individual on account of actual sin, as was explained above (in I-II Q. 85 a.1& 2), these four wounds are also the result of other sins, in so far as, through sin, the reason is obscured especially in practical matters, the will hardened to evil, good actions become more difficult, and concupiscence more impetuous.1

Personal Sins Increase the Effects of These Wounds

In the above text from St. Thomas, he explains that not only the wounds of original sin are evident in man, but also that one’s personal, actual sins increase the effect of these wounds of original sin for him. We can readily guess that Satan and all of his fellow demons know the strengths and weaknesses of each individual, so of course, they know exactly what temptations to use on each individual soul.

Natural Inclinations Affect All Humans

Although the wounds of original sin influence all humans, each person is unique in his material dispositions, and from this it is easy to see how each person can be uniquely affected by the wounds of original sin. In other words, each person has his own individual degree of the wounds of original sin. In the vast number of humans that have ever lived, there is a wide spectrum of strengths and weaknesses. For example, some races of people seem to be naturally strong in their mental acuity whereas other races seem to be stronger in their physical prowess.2 We can observe that God certainly has created a variety of humans and we must take many things into consideration in our relations with our neighbor. We will discuss this aspect of relationships in more detail at a future time.

Personal Dispositions and the Seven Capital Sins

The demons make ready use of tempting humans to the seven capital sins. Here is what the Concise Catholic Dictionary tells us about these sins:

The so-called “deadly sins” seven in number, called “capital” because they are the source of most other sins: called “deadly” because they easily lead to mortal sins. They need not be separate acts but can exist as habits or vices. The seven capital sins are: pride, covetousness, lust, anger, gluttony, envy, and sloth.3

Just as humans have natural tendencies connected to their material make-up, they have natural weaknesses and strengths. There is not a perfect balance between the strengths and weaknesses. Some may have far more weaknesses than they have strengths. Some may have only weaknesses and, seemingly, no strengths. Furthermore, there are souls who may have more strengths and fewer weaknesses.

The demons know that humans share the wounds of original sin. The demons also know that one capital sin often leads a soul to the other capital sins, and because the demons know the inclinations of souls, including their strengths and weaknesses, they strive to drag the soul into the capital sin to which that soul is most prone.

In addition to this common condition of the wounds of original sin and the particular genetic (i.e., material, bodily) disposition4, human nature also includes the passions. In Lesson #39 we reflected how the passions work in order to get a better understanding of the passion of anger. We studied anger and how the choleric is prone to this passion. We also saw how anger is one of the capital sins which the choleric is prone to commit.

A Genetic (Material, Bodily) Disinclination toward the Effort to Think Carefully

Thus, there can be a genetic (material, bodily) disinclination to make the effort to think carefully. A person can be ill-disposed to do the mental work involved in deeper thinking. St. Thomas goes so far as to call the fear of mental work, stupor. He adds, “just as laziness shrinks from the toil of external work, so amazement and stupor shrink from the difficulty of considering a great and unwonted thing, whether good or evil; so that amazement and stupor stand in relation to the act of the intellect, as laziness does to external work.”5

So when a person has not previously made habitual efforts to think deeply or carefully, he is not accustomed to the task. In this way, the work involved is unusual to him and viewed by him as “unwonted”.6 Such a person “shrink[s] from the difficulty of considering” a “great and unwonted thing”, as St. Thomas explains.

The Attitude that “I don’t have the ability”, Stems from Fear.

Ultimately this kind of attitude is caused by fear. In order to give this topic a thorough treatment and to gain a clearer understanding of how this problem is not exclusively a choleric one, we will need to consider further the passion of fear.

A Preview…

In our next lesson we will begin our study of the passion of fear because this passion affects all the temperaments. We will then be able to see how deep-thinking is really perceived by the choleric.

1 Summa Ia IIae Q. 85 a.3 Respondeo (bold and italic and bracketed words added for emphasis or clarity).

2 Read this article: God Wills the Natural Inequalities between Different Persons and between Different Peoples. This article can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2019/09/22/god-wills-the-natural-inequalities-between-different-peoples/


3 Concise Catholic Dictionary compiled by Robert C. Broderick, M.A. ©1944, the Bruce Publishing Company, Milwaukee.


4 A soul is created by God at the instant of the particular person’s conception. That soul, as such, is identical to every other rational (human) soul created by God. The differences between persons are on the part of the person’s matter. Thus, e.g., a baby girl differs from a baby boy not in the type of soul she has, but in her material part. Likewise, one person’s strengths and weaknesses, as compared to another person, are not because God created them with differences in their souls, but because of differences in their bodily, material parts.

5 Summa, Ia IIae, Q.41, a.4, ad. 4.


6 The Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines wont as a noun meaning custom; habit; usage or as a verb meaning- to be accustomed; to be used. Merriam-Webster Dictionary ©1949.