Catholic
Candle
note:
Sedevacantism
is wrong and is (material or formal) schism. Catholic
Candle
is not sedevacantist.
Below
is the sixteenth article in a series which covers specific aspects of
the error of sedevacantism. As context for this sixteenth article,
let us recall what we saw in the earlier fifteen articles:
In
the first article,
we saw that we cannot know whether the pope (or anyone else) is a
formal heretic (rather than a material heretic only) – and thus
whether he is outside the true Catholic Church based
simply on his persistent, public teaching of a heretical opinion.
Then,
in the second article,
we saw that we must not judge a man to be a formal heretic if he
professes to be Catholic and says he believes what a Catholic must
believe now, in order to be Catholic now. When a person professes a
heretical opinion, we must judge him in the most favorable light (if
we judge him at all). So, we must avoid the sin of rash judgment and
we must not judge negatively the interior culpability of the pope and
the 1.4 billion
people who profess to be Catholic. We must not judge they are not
“real” Catholics if they tell us that they are Catholics.
Instead, we should count them as Catholics who are very confused or
are uninformed.
Thus,
we must judge the conciliar popes to have been material heretics, not
formal heretics (if we judge them at all), and that each was pope in
his turn until his death (or abdication). Regarding any of the
world’s 1.4 billion self-described Catholics who hold heresy, we
must judge them to be material heretics only (if we judge them at
all), unless they themselves tell us that they know they don’t
qualify to be Catholics.
In
the third article,
we examined briefly the important difference between persons in
authority who fulfill their duty to judge those under their charge in
the
external forum,
as contrasted to a sedevacantist or anyone
else except God
who judges the interior
culpability of other persons and (rashly) judges them to be formal
heretics.
In
the fourth article,
we saw that it does not help us to protect ourselves better from a
conciliar pope’s heresy, to declare that we know he is not the pope
and is not a Catholic.
In
the fifth article,
we saw that it is possible for a pope to teach (or believe) heresy
and in fact, popes have taught and believed heresy at various times
during Church history.
We looked especially at the cases of Pope John XXII and Pope
Nicholas I, who both taught explicit heresy while pope and
nonetheless continued to be the pope. Pope John XXII also taught the
same explicit heresy before he became the pope.
In
the sixth article,
we saw that the Church infallibly assures us that we will have a pope
at all times until the end of the world, except during very short
interregnums between papal reigns, during
which the Church is in the process of electing a new pope and during
which the Church’s unified government continues to function.
In this sixth article, we saw that we are not presently in an
interregnum (even though the sedevacantists absurdly claim we are in
a many-decades-long interregnum).
In
the seventh article
of this series, we saw that the Catholic Church is a visible Body and
remains visible to all. The Catholic Church has a visible
monarchical government and the pope is visible to all. Thus, we know
we have a pope and that the one who is pope is visible (known) to all
as the pope.
In
the eighth article,
we saw that the necessary visibility of the Catholic Church and the
pope, requires as a corollary that the one who virtually all
Catholics see (i.e.,
believe) is the pope must be
the pope, since the pope must be visible to all.
In
the ninth article,
we addressed the superficial claim of sedevacantists (addressed to
Catholics) saying that “if you think we have a pope, then you have
to obey him in whatever he tells you to do”. We examined the true
Catholic virtue of obedience and saw that we must not obey the
commands of even a real superior like our pope, if/when he commands
us to do something evil.
In
the tenth article,
we saw more deeply what schism is and how sedevacantism is inherently
schism.
In
the eleventh article of this series,
we saw more deeply how we should respond to a pope (or other
superior) who does harm – viz.,
we should recognize his authority but resist the evil of his words or
deeds.
In
the twelfth article of this series,
we saw how we ordinary Catholic laymen can know what the Catholic
Truth is and how we can know when the pope (or anyone) is promoting
heresy or other error.
In
the thirteenth article of this series,
we saw the falsehood of a related sedevacantist error (or
“half-truth”), claiming that we have no pope because the
conciliar popes had doubtful consecrations and/or ordinations.
In
the fourteenth article of this series,
we considered another way to see that sedevacantism is wrong and
sinful, viz.,
because it is the sin of revolution.
In
the fifteenth article of this series,
we saw that even though Pope Leo XIV is objectively a very bad pope,
all Catholics are in communion with him, since this is an essential
condition of being Catholic and not schismatic.
Further,
some sedevacantists (and a smaller number of other confused persons)
make a related false argument directed against Catholics. They say
that we must not pray for the pope in the Canon of the Mass because
doing so would mean that we adopt his errors.
Traditional
Catholics who have never heard of this error, might be tempted to
think the error is so “far-fetched” that a non-sedevacantist
could never really
think it was wrong to pray for the pope at Mass. However,
tragically, some persons have been fooled by the claim that praying
for the pope in the Canon of the Mass somehow means that we adopt his
errors. In fact, one non-sedevacantist priest in Canada was fooled
into not praying for the pope in the Canon of the Mass and
subsequently succumbed to the error of sedevacantism.
Below,
we address the question whether praying for the pope in the Canon of
the Mass indicates that we adopt the pope’s errors.
We
Must Pray for the Pope, Especially at Mass!
An
examination of the erroneous argument claiming that we should not
insert the pope’s name in the Canon of the Mass
It
is our duty to pray for others. When we pray the Mass, this is an
especially perfect time to do this, since it is the infinitely
meritorious sacrifice of Our Lord Jesus Christ. Further, every pope
has the frighteningly grave responsibility for the souls of everyone
in the world, especially for Catholics. Thus, we should continually
pray for the pope, and most especially when we pray the Mass. (Of
course, in our current times, where most faithful and informed
Catholics do not have access to an uncompromising priest, these
prayers for the pope should be offered while sanctifying the Sunday
without a priest.)
In
a previous article (#15) we saw that we Catholics are in communion
with the pope – whether he is good or bad – and we are also in
communion with all other Catholics – whether they are good or bad.
The
devil knows the importance of praying for the pope and greatly fears
this, especially the efficacious intercession for him at a
non-compromised Mass. Satan knows that if God reforms the pope
through prayers offered for him, this reformed pope could spiritually
transform (the human element of) the Church. Thus, the devil uses
every lie and trick he has to discourage prayer for the pope,
especially in the Canon of the True Traditional Mass.
One
trick the devil uses, is to make priests and people afraid to pray
for the pope when they pray the Canon of the Mass, fearing that
somehow mentioning the pope’s name in the Canon causes us to affirm
we agree with the pope’s errors.
For
a priest not to pray for the pope during the Canon of the Mass is
objectively a sin (since he is required to do so), even if no one
ever knew the priest made this sinful omission.
This
objective sin is increased if people do
find out that the priest does not pray for the pope at Mass, because
this omission is an objective sin of scandal, since all priests (and
all Catholics) have a solemn duty to pray for the hierarchy,
especially the pope.
Also,
this scandal is gravely aggravated if anyone is led to conclude that
the priest is a sedevacantist (because such a priest – like the
sedevacantists – does not pray for the pope).
The
Text of the Prayer for the Pope at the Beginning of the Canon of the
Mass
Latin
English
|
Te
igitur, clementissime Pater, per Jesum Christum Filium tuum,
Dominum nostrum, supplices rogamus ac petimus uti accepta habeas,
et benedicas haec dona, haec munera, haec sancta sacrificia
illibata;
in
primis quae tibi offerimus pro Ecclesia
tua sancta catholica; quam pacificare, custodire, adunare, et
regere digneris toto orbe terrarum: una
cum famulo tuo Papa nostro N.,
et Antistite nostro N.
et omnibus orthodoxis, atque catholicae et aostolicae fidei
cultoribus.
|
Therefore,
most gracious Father, we humbly beg of Thee and entreat Thee
through Jesus Christ Thy Son, Our Lord. Hold acceptable and bless
+
these
gifts, these +
offerings, these +
holy and unspotted oblations
which, in the first place, we offer Thee for Thy Holy Catholic
Church.
Grant her peace and protection, unity and guidance throughout the
world, together
with Thy servant [name], our Pope, and [name], our Bishop; and all
Orthodox believers who cherish the Catholic and Apostolic Faith.
|
|
Memento,
Domine, famulorum, famularumque tuarum N.
et N.
et omnium circumstantium,
quorum tibi fides cognita est, et nota devotio, pro
quibus tibi offerimus.
vel qui tibi offerunt hoc sacrificium laudis pro se, suisque
omnibus, pro redemptione animarum suarum, pro spe salutis, et
incolumitis suae; tibique reddunt vota sua aeterno Deo, vivo et
vero.
|
Remember,
O Lord, Thy servants and handmaids, [name] and [name], and all
here present,
whose faith and devotion are known to Thee. On
whose behalf we offer
to Thee, or who themselves offer to Thee this sacrifice of praise
for themselves, families and friends, for the good of their souls,
for their hope of salvation and deliverance from all harm, and who
offer their homage to Thee, eternal, living and true God.
|
(Emphasis
added.)
Una
cum Papa nostro Leone
When
we pray in the Canon of the Mass: “una
cum famulo tuo Papa nostro, [name]”,
this phrase is part of the same sentence in which we offer the
oblation for the Church because we
offer this oblation for the Church and also
(i.e., together) for the pope
(and the bishop, etc.).
Some
people mistakenly think “together with” means that we declare we
are together in mind with the pope in whatever he teaches. In other
words, such a false claim asserts that putting the pope’s name in
the Canon declares we are united (“together”) with the pope in
whatever he believes. There are six
reasons
why this is false:
-
In
this prayer, the pope is mentioned in the middle of a longer “list”.
The prayer offers the oblation for the Church, then there is
mention of the pope, then the bishop, then all Catholics and finally
in the next prayer, we recall the people near and dear to us “on
whose
behalf we offer” this same oblation.
This list has a clear order. We pray for the Church, then those
governing the Church, then all members of the Church and lastly,
those near and dear to us whether or not our loved ones are
Catholics.
This grouping and the whole progression of
thought shows that the reference to the pope and bishop is our
prayer for
them and is offering the oblation for
them.
It is unreasonable to understand this prayer as a declaration of
solidarity: viz.,
as if the prayer were to state that we
offer this oblation for the Church, then we declare we believe
whatever the pope and others believe, and lastly we offer the
oblation for those people dear to us.
If
we were to wrongly assume (as this false claim does) that we break up
the series of persons for whom we offer up the oblation, in order to
declare sameness in beliefs with the pope, why wouldn’t we declare
that we believe what the Church
teaches, rather than only the pope? Whatever the holy and infallible
Catholic Church teaches, we must always believe because it is always
true. By contrast, we believe what the pope teaches only when
he teaches what the Church teaches.
(Any errors that the pope teaches are not the teaching of the Church
nor are they worthy of belief.)
Plainly, it is wrong to think this prayer of the Canon unites us to
whatever the pope teaches.
The
Canon is the perfect time to pray for
the pope, when we mention him immediately after we pray for
the Church. Because the Canon of the Mass is perfect, we would
expect the perfection of the Canon to include both the prayer for the
Church and for the pope. This is a further reason to understand the
prayer this way.
-
That
the oblation is offered for
all of these listed persons is further shown by this prayer (in the
Canon) where it says the offering is made for
the Church “in
the first place”,
and then proceeds to mention the pope, bishop, all Catholics and
lastly those near and dear to us. This prayer’s phrase “in
primis” (i.e.,
“in the first place”) shows that the offering will also then be
made for others, the pope being the very next one listed.
-
That
this reference to the pope (and bishop) is a prayer for him (rather
than joining in his ideas), is shown by what the pope and bishops
themselves say when they offer Mass. As the 1913 Catholic
Encyclopedia explains:
A
diocesan bishop in saying Mass changes the form “et Antistite
nostro N.” into “et me indigno servo tuo” [i.e.,
“and me thy unworthy servant”]. The pope naturally uses these
words instead of “una cum famulo tuo Papa nostro N.”, and omits
the clause about the bishop.
In
other words, the pope and bishop pray for themselves and offer the
oblation for themselves. They plainly are not saying that they unite
with themselves and believe whatever they themselves believe. As
they pray for themselves in the Canon, likewise we pray for them in
the same place, by inserting their names (and we are not declaring
that we believe whatever they teach).
-
This
groundless fear (viz.,
the fear of adding the pope’s name in the Canon) also ignores
Church history. From the earliest days of the Church, the Canon of
the Mass has included a prayer interceding for the Church, the pope,
the bishop and Catholics generally, as well as (in some earlier
manuscripts) also intercession for the emperor and for the priest
celebrating the Mass.
The prayer was worded in various ways but always had this same
intercessory meaning.
That same meaning continues in the wording of the traditional missal
we use.
By
contrast, throughout the history of the Mass, in all the various
formulations of the prayers in early manuscripts, the Mass has never
included a declaration
of solidarity in belief
with the pope, as is baselessly feared by those who fear to include
the pope’s name in the Canon.
-
There
have been popes at different times of Church history who had
problems in word or deed. If each person were supposed to decide
whether to withdraw the pope’s name from the Canon of the Mass and
not pray for him, this would create chaos. To take only two
examples:
-
Pope
Innocent VIII (1484 -1492) had illegitimate children whom he
publicly acknowledged.
Pope Innocent VIII was so shameless that while his own
illegitimate son was at the papal court and in the immediate papal
circle, this son “paraded the streets at night … forced his way
into the houses of citizens for evil purposes” and similarly led a
life of avarice and debauchery.
Should
Catholics have not prayed for Pope Innocent VIII in the Canon of the
Mass under the theory that the pope’s open shamelessness was
equivalent to showing that the virtue of purity is optional and
therefore this pope was unworthy of prayers in the Canon of the Mass?
-
Pope
Nicholas I taught the heresy “that
baptism was valid, whether administered in the name of the three
Persons or in the name of Christ only.”
Should each person at the time have decided if Pope Nicholas’
heresy meant he should be cut off from the prayers he greatly
needed?
How
great a division it would sow among Catholics if this wedge of
discord and chaos were permitted to exist among the faithful! This
would mean that faithful Catholics would shun priests who refused to
pray for the pope during the Canon and confused Catholics would
refuse priests who prayed for the pope in the Canon.
-
The
pre-Vatican II commentators unanimously explain this passage of the
Canon as a prayer (intercession) for
the pope, not a declaration of united belief with the pope. Here is
a small sample of such commentaries:
-
The
book entitled The
Holy Sacrifice of the Mass
explains:
“[We have] a special and express offering and prayer for the Pope
and for the chief pastor of the diocese in which the holy Mass is
celebrated. … It is proper that, throughout the entire Church,
the Pope should be prayed for and the Sacrifice be offered for him
…”.
-
The
book entitled The
Mass, A Study of the Roman Liturgy
explains:
“The Intercession (from “in primis”) … begins by praying for
the Church, Pope, bishop and the faithful.”
Conclusion:
for all six reasons, it is plain that we insert the pope’s name in
the Canon in order to pray for him (not to declare we believe
whatever he believes). The pope is the only one on earth who can
authoritatively reform the (human element of the) Church. Although
we reject the pope’s errors, we must pray for him unceasingly
(especially when praying the Mass), that he reverses his own course
and leads souls back to the traditions of the Church.
The
Devil Uses a Second False Reason to Eliminate Prayers for the Pope at
Mass
Some
Catholics plainly see that this prayer in the Canon is a prayer for
the pope (not a declaration that we believe whatever he believes).
Yet they do not pray for the pope at Mass. Their reason for this is
that they are troubled by the scruple that somehow it is a sin to
pray for a bad pope in the Canon of the Mass because this prayer is
the Church’s public
prayer, and that it would be a scandal to pray for any bad man
(including a bad pope) in the Church’s public
prayer. (These misguided people think it is fine to pray for a bad
pope in private
prayer, but not the Church’s public
prayer.)
But
this scruple ignores Common Sense, Church history, and Ecclesiastic
Tradition.
First,
common
sense:
our prayers for
anyone beg God’s help for the person. Those prayers don’t show
the person is perfect but are asking God to change and perfect him.
So it is the most natural thing for loyal sons of the Church to pray
publicly for bad leaders, especially when praying the Mass.
Second,
Church
history:
through many hundreds of years, it was the practice of good priests,
bishops and laymen to publicly pray in the Canon of the Mass, for the
emperor – not only for a good emperor but for whoever
was the emperor, good or bad. Similarly, when we pray the Mass, our
prayers for the pope are not conditioned on the spiritual condition
of his soul.
Third,
Ecclesiastical
Tradition:
the prayers of Good Friday (going back almost 1800 years)
not only pray for the pope (for any pope, whether good or bad) but
also publicly
pray for the worst of men: heretics, schismatics, Jews, and pagans,
who are inherently bad because they oppose Our Lord and His Church.
Conclusion
It
is plain that, however much evil the pope is doing, we should pray
hard for him, including public prayers and especially at Mass. Let
us unite in fervent prayer for the pope – especially when praying
the Mass – that God change his heart and enlighten his mind.