Words to Live By – From Catholic Tradition

Let Us Enter this Lenten Season with All of Our Heart!

The great St. Augustine, Doctor of the Church, urges us to fast generously this Lent, setting before us the many advantages and benefits:

Fasting cleanses the soul, raises the mind, subjects one’s flesh to the spirit, renders the heart contrite and humble, scatters the clouds of concupiscence, quenches the fire of lust, kindles the true light of chastity.

Quoted from the sermon of St. Augustine, On Prayer and Fasting, quoted by St. Thomas Aquinas, greatest Doctor of the Church, in the Summa, IIa IIae, Q.147, a.1, respondeo.


Catholic Candle note: These words are very consoling and show both the power of fasting and also the wisdom of Holy Mother Church urging us to fast generously. Pondering these truths, we should be moved to pity Protestants and worldlings who do no real fasting for a spiritual purpose. Their so-called religion is not only false but empty.

We see the hand of the devil in the conciliar church’s elimination of virtually all fasting. What a moral peril for countless souls!

Let us frequently use the powerful tool of fasting! In this way, we can glorify God and gain strength to serve Him and to make sacrifices for all those confused people who do not fast!

Lent Will Soon Be Upon Us!

Very shortly, it will be Lent! This is a much-needed time to summon all of the generosity we can muster and to make extra efforts to remove our “moral flab” and to “scrape the barnacles” of sin and bad habits off of the “hull” of our soul.

We need to do much penance in order to save our souls. This is true throughout the year but especially during Lent. The Devil is behind the modern elimination of virtually all requirements of fasting and abstaining.

This is not the time to do the minimum! Catholic Candle recommends that you use the pre-Vatican II rules for fasting and abstinence which are found here: https://catholiccandle.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Traditional-Rules-for-Fast-Abstinance.pdf

Let us not be stingy with God! He is never outdone in generosity!

The Blessing of a True, Catholic Liberal Education – Part VI

Catholic Candle note: Below is part 6 of the article concerning the best type of education, which is a Catholic Liberal Education. Do not confuse this education with many university programs called “liberal arts” but which are full of fluff, falsehood, and aimless so-called “cultural enrichment” courses and “humanities”.

A liberal education also does not refer to liberalism, nor is a true liberal education an indoctrination into that error of liberalism or political correctness. In fact, a true Catholic Liberal Education is the best antidote to the errors of liberalism.

Previously, in part 1 of this article,1 we examined the problems we see in modern education:

  • Modern colleges do not improve the quality of their students’ minds (and their thinking ability) much or at all.


  • Most “education” is merely job training, fluff courses, and/or leftist indoctrination.


  • The students are taught to sound like someone in their field but they do more memorizing and little thinking.


  • Grade “inflation” and degree “inflation” is rampant. Grades and academic degrees do not mean much anymore.

In part 2 of this article,2 we examined, in general, what education is. We considered the human soul and the perfection of its highest faculty (power) – the intellect – which is immaterial. We saw that our intellects are perfected through knowing eternal, unchangeable truths and their causes.

In part 3 of this article,3 after having seen what true education is, we examined the question who should perfect his intellect.

In part 4 of this article,4 having seen that modern universities do not provide a true education, we consider whether there is ever any reason for men or women to attend them.

In part 5 of this article,5 having seen that women and girls should pursue a True Catholic Liberal Education – just as men and boys should, too – we then considered what the best environment is in which women and girls should do this.

At the end of part 5 of this series, we recognized that an objection could arise: having seen the great value of a True Catholic Liberal Education), should we be afraid that the great blessing of this education would be a danger to our souls because it might make us proud?

Below, in part 6, we consider this question.


The Blessing of a True, Catholic Liberal Education

Part 6

Objection: Because a Catholic Liberal Education is so Great, It Might Make Us Proud!

From the considerations we have made so far in the first five parts of this series (on the Value of a True Catholic Liberal Education), shouldn’t we be afraid that this great blessing might make us proud?

We are on earth to know, love, and serve God and by this means to save our soul. We know that pride is one of the biggest obstacles to salvation. So, if we receive a true Catholic Liberal Education and if this were to result in our damnation (by making us proud), then shouldn’t we avoid this education in order to save our souls?

Although a person could wrongly suppose that a Catholic Liberal Education can be harmful because it might make a person proud, in fact, a genuine Catholic Liberal Education is never, in itself, a cause of the sin of pride. Rather it is always, in itself, a motive for humility, for five reasons:

  1. It is the occasion, in itself, of comparing ourselves to what is truly great and of seeing how “small” and unimportant we are in comparison to high truths;


  2. A true Catholic Liberal Education takes more effort than mere job training or studying the creations of man, (e.g., computers). These greater efforts humble us because we are aware of the comparative weakness of our minds when studying the high truths of a real education, as contrasted to our false impression that our minds are much stronger, when studying subjects which take less effort to master;


  3. The greatness, in itself, of a true Catholic Liberal Education is a great gift of God for which we should be very grateful to Him, and such gratitude fosters humility in us;


  4. High universal truths are so wonderful that they “lift us out of ourselves” and make us see that we are relatively unimportant and so, seek to devote ourselves to spreading the truth to others; and


  5. We see the greatest examples of humility in others who have a Catholic Liberal Education.

Let us look at each of these reasons.


1. This true education is the occasion, in itself, of comparing ourselves to what is truly great and of seeing how “small” we are.

In a Catholic Liberal Education, one spends his time with the greatest ideas and truths and with the greatest thinkers, e.g., St. Thomas Aquinas, Aristotle, and Euclid. This “company” naturally causes a person to compare his mind to the greatest of truths and to compare himself with the greatest of minds and thereby to see his littleness compared to them.

Similarly, surrounding ourselves with exceedingly tall people, would remind us of our own short stature.

Of course, the attainment of great truths in a Catholic Liberal Education can be abused like any other great blessing and high Good. But we should perfect our intellects with the greatest truth and we should not choose mediocrity or lowness on the excuse that if we were to perfect our intellect (which is the highest talent that God gave to us), it would make us proud.

In his 1920 encyclical, Spiritus Paraclitus, which concerns the magnificent learning of St. Jerome, Doctor of the Church, Pope Benedict XV condemns the false and slothful idea that it is better not to be learned. He cites St. Jerome’s condemnation of the:

“self-righteous lack of education” noticeable in some clerics, who “think that to be without culture and to be holy are the same thing, and who dub themselves ‘disciples of the fisherman’; as though they were holy simply because ignorant!”6

Just as one should never say “don’t pray the rosary” using the excuse that it will afford occasions to compare one’s self to his godless neighbors and thereby make him proud, likewise we should not fail to seek the high truths that perfect our mind – using this same excuse as for not praying the rosary.

In fact, such a lazy excuse has no limit. A person could even say that we should not strive to sanctify our souls at all because this would be a source of pride. Rather, (this excuse continues) we should live a life of sin and great decadence because, by seeing how low we are – wallowing in sin – this will make us humble. This, of course, is putrid rationalization for laziness!

Of course, there are always people who commit more sins than we do, to which we could compare ourselves if we are looking to exalt ourselves. But instead, we should compare ourselves with the great saints and the great thinkers and humbly see our defects in contrast to them. Thus, it would be ludicrous to avoid perfecting our intellects or to seek to do nothing good so that there is no one who is more sinful or more ignorant than we are, using the rationalization that this will make it easier to be humble.

So to summarize, God wills that we perfect our faculties, especially our highest one. It is mere rationalization to suppose that acquiring humility would be easier if we avoid perfecting our intellects and avoid doing good so that there is no one more ignorant, lazy, and sinful than we are.


2. A true Catholic Liberal Education takes more effort than mere job training or studying the creations of man, (e.g., computers). These greater efforts humble us because we are aware of the comparative weakness of our minds when studying the high truths of a real education, as contrasted to our false impression that our minds are much stronger, when studying lower subjects which take less effort to master.

Just as when a man sets out to climb a very tall mountain, he is humbled by seeing his strength and ability less adequate as compared to when that man sets out to climb a small hill. Similarly, a man is humbled when studying the great truths because his own weakness is more obvious and he is less able to conceal his deficiencies than if he were studying lower subjects.


  1. The treasure of a true Catholic Liberal Education is such a great gift of God that it inspires lifelong gratitude to God and this gratitude fosters humility.

A true Catholic Liberal Education is such a blessing which not only greatly perfects our minds but it tends to rectify the will too, thereby fostering true wisdom. This is because we see that the things of the body are unimportant in comparison. A love of the high truths inclines us toward spiritual things and to have contempt for the base things of the world. This is “because He [viz., God] is the guide of wisdom, and the director of the wise”.7

This true education shows us that the great truths are “worth more than kingdoms”. This reality is set forth in the Book of Wisdom:

I preferred her before kingdoms and thrones, and esteemed riches nothing in comparison of her. Neither did I compare unto her any precious stone: for all gold in comparison of her, is as a little sand, and silver in respect to her shall be counted as clay.8

For being blessed with this great gift of truth and wisdom, we see we owe God everything as the source of this great good. Understanding this inspires humility.


  1. High Universal Truths are so Wonderful that They “Lift Us Out of Ourselves” and Make Us See that We Are Relatively Unimportant and the Truth is All-Important.

These high truths make us seek to be selfless missionaries of the truth, seeking to spread the truth, subordinate ourselves to the truth, and promote the truth to our neighbor.

We see that the petty concerns of the material world are trivial. Rather, it is a worthwhile life to help spread the truth for the good of our neighbor. Thus, the wise man in the Book of Wisdom declares the influence of the high things he had learned and how he subordinated himself to spreading the truth:

I have learned without guile, and communicate without envy, and her riches I hide not.9

These words which describe how high and wise truth affects the soul, are used by the Church to describe St. Thomas Aquinas’s own unselfish subordination of himself to the truth.10


  1. We see the greatest examples of humility in others who have had a Catholic Liberal Education.

Another way that people come to believe that a true education makes a person proud, is by seeing some persons who have abused the gift of this true education that God gave to them.

But we should look at persons who did not abuse this gift God gave to them. For example, St. Thomas Aquinas was the greatest of all thinkers and philosophers and yet with the greatest humility.11 As great as St. Thomas was/is, he did not measure himself and his knowledge by a comparison to the “average man” (much less, the lowest man) but he compared himself to the truth of God, especially the truth of the Divine Nature. That comparison is, in itself, an easy motive for humility and the remedy against pride. But a man who seeks to exalt himself will never lack a way to do this, just as a man who seeks to humble himself will never lack a reason to do so.

Just as any blessing of God can be abused by men who are inclined to be proud (motivated by the wounds of Original Sin which they suffer), a Catholic Liberal Education can be abused in that way too. But we should not “blame” the blessing from God but rather blame the abuse and the twisting of this blessing by man who is so prone to turn any of God’s gifts – especially the best ones – into reasons why he deserves God’s punishments.


To be continued …

6 Spiritus Paraclitus, Pope Benedict XV, 1920, 45.

7 Book of Wisdom, 7:15.

8 Book of Wisdom, 7:8-9.

9 Book of Wisdom, 7:13.

10 Here is the full prayer to St. Thomas Aquinas:

Angelic Doctor, St. Thomas, prince of theologians and model of philosophers, bright ornament of the Christian world, light of the Church and patron of all Catholic schools, who didst learn wisdom without guile and dost communicate it without envy, pray for us to the Son of God, Who is Wisdom Itself, that by the coming of the Spirit of Wisdom upon us, we may clearly understand that which thou didst teach and by imitating thee, may bring to completion that which thou didst do; that we may be made partakers both of thy doctrine and thy holiness, whereby thou didst shine on earth even as the sun; and finally, that we may enjoy with thee in heaven for ever more, the most delectable fruits of the same, praising together with thee Divine Wisdom through endless ages. Amen.

We recommend that everyone pray this prayer every day.

11 Read this article explaining why faithful and informed Catholics follow Saint Thomas Aquinas more than anyone else: https://catholiccandle.org/2017/12/16/why-faithful-catholics-follow-the-doctors-of-the-church/

Lesson #53: Temperaments – Choleric Temperament – Pain and Death Are Objects of Fear for Persons of Any Temperament

Philosophy Notes

Catholic Candle note: The article below is part eighteen of the study of the Choleric temperament. Here are links to the first seventeen parts:

  1. Part I: Beginning our Study of the Choleric Temperament: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/08/27/lesson-35-about-the-temperaments-the-choleric-temperament/

  2. Part II: A general overview of the weaknesses of the Choleric Temperament: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/09/26/lesson-37-about-the-temperaments-continuation-of-the-choleric-temperament/

  3. Part III: A consideration of the pride of the Choleric Temperament: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/10/24/lesson-38-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat/

  4. Part IV: A general discussion of anger as a passion – in order to establish a foundation for studying anger in the Choleric Temperament: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/11/26/lesson-39-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat-part-iv/

  5. Part V: Concerning the motivations for anger: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/12/30/lesson-40-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat-part-v/

  6. Part VI: Concerning what anger does to the body: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/01/27/lesson-41-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-vi/

  7. Part VII: Explaining when anger is sinful: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/02/21/lesson-42-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-vii/

  8. Part VIII: Explaining how being slighted provokes anger: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/03/27/lesson-42-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-viii/

  9. Part IX: Explaining how anger turns into the sin of holding a grudge: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/04/23/lesson-44-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-ix/

  10. Part X: Recommendations to help cholerics to overcome pride: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/05/20/lesson-45-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-x/

  11. Part XI: Explaining how a person sins by not using his reason: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/06/28/lesson-46-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xi/

  12. Part XII: Explaining some reasons why a choleric does not use his reason properly: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/07/24/lesson-47-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xii/

  13. Part XIII: Explaining why the choleric fears to use his reason well: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/08/29/lesson-48-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xiii/

  14. Part XIV: Explaining generally how Satan targets our fallen and weakened intellects: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/09/24/lesson-49-temperaments-choleric-temperament-the-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xiv/

  1. Part XV: Explaining the passions in general, to lay the foundation for our consideration of the passion of fear: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/10/26/3050/

  1. Part XVI: Explaining fear as a passion: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/11/25/lesson-51-temperaments-choleric-temperament-the-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xvi/

  1. Part XVII: Explaining how fear works in the soul and influences all of the temperaments: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/12/29/lesson-52-temperaments-choleric-temperament-the-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xvii/

Mary’s School of Sanctity

Lesson #53 About the Temperaments Part XVIII – Explaining how Pain and Death Are Objects of Fear for Persons of Any Temperament


Note: When referring to a person with a choleric temperament in this article we simply will refer to him as a choleric.

In our last lesson we saw how St. Thomas sets forth the way in which fear works in the soul. We saw that there are three appetitive powers in the soul and how each of these powers is used for the general purpose of pursuing something good (or what appears to be good) and avoiding something evil (or what appears to be evil).

Now let us consider the evil that St. Thomas calls an evil of nature – viz., things that cause pain and/or death and also why it is that man fears these.

St. Thomas quotes the great Philosopher Aristotle, who teaches that “fear is caused by the imagination of a future evil which is either corruptive or painful.”1

St. Thomas Explains What It Means for Something to be an Evil of Nature

St. Thomas teaches that, just as a painful evil is that which is contrary to the will, so similarly a corruptive evil is that which is contrary to nature. This latter evil is properly described as “an evil of nature” because it is opposed to our nature. Just as evil is the absence of a good that something should have, so likewise an evil of nature is the absence of a good that belongs to nature. In this we see that an evil of nature can be the object of fear because it is the absence of something good which belongs to nature.

The evil of nature can arise from either a natural cause or a non-natural cause:

  • When it comes from a natural cause it is called an evil of nature not only from the deprivation of a good of nature, but also because this evil is an effect of nature, such as natural death and other like defects.

  • The evil of nature can arise from a non-natural cause, such as violent death inflicted by an assailant.

In either case the evil of nature is feared to a certain extent, and to a certain extent it is not feared.

For since fear arises from the imagination of future evil, as Aristotle explains,2 whatever removes our imagining of this future evil, removes the fear also. Moreover, if we reflect, we see that there are two ways that a future evil might not be feared – either because it is not considered as an evil or because it is not considered as future:

  1. Because it is remote and far off: for, on account of such distance, a thing is considered as though it were not to be. Hence we either do not fear it, or fear it but little; for, as Aristotle teaches3, we do not fear things that are very far off. This explains why so many people, e.g., most young people, do not fear death or think about it. They know that they will die but death appears to them to be far off so they do not think about it or fear it.

  2. A future evil is considered as though it is present (not future) and thus, as being inevitable and not escapable. As an example of this, Aristotle teaches4 that those who are already on the scaffold, are not afraid because they are on the very point of a death from which there is no escape. This is because, in order that a man be afraid, there must be some hope of escape for him. If there is no hope of escape, the man has sorrow but not fear.

Consequently, evil of nature is not feared if it be not apprehended as something in the future. But if the evil of nature (that is corruptive) be understood as being near at hand, and yet with some hope of escape, then it will be feared.5

Some Further Considerations from St. Thomas

St. Thomas adds that sometimes the evil of nature is an effect of nature and the man cannot avoid it. However, he might try to delay that evil as long as possible. Thus, a man might seek advice and consider how he can defer death and avoid it as long as possible. However, when death does not seem to be near at hand, one does not fear it or consider how to avoid it.

Death and other defects of nature are the effects of the human nature that we have in common. Yet the individual nature rebels against them as far as it can. Accordingly, from the inclination of nature there arises pain and sorrow for such like evils, when present. There arises fear when these evils are imagined in the foreseeable future.6

Further reflection: Of course, it is appropriate to fear death especially in the aspect that with death, we will face our Divine Judge and have to render an account of our lives. This is especially true when we are ill-prepared to obtain a favorable judgment from Him. But, if we focus our efforts on pleasing God and living a just life, then we will be able to foster a filial fear of God and not merely the servile fear of facing God’s just punishments.

A Preview …

In our next lesson, we will continue our study of the objects of fear. We will discuss St. Thomas’s explanation of the next aspect of fear, viz., Whether the Evil of Sin Is an Object of Fear. In that discussion St. Thomas makes the important distinction between pain and sorrow on one hand and fear on the other hand. At that point, we will be able to make some practical applications for the spiritual life.

1 Taken from Summa Ia-IIae Q.42 a. 2 Whether Evil of Nature Is an Object of Fear? Respondeo.

2 Aristotle’s Treatise on Rhetoric, Bk. 2; ch.5 #1382a21.


3 Aristotle’s Treatise on Rhetoric Bk. 2: ch.5, #1382a21.

4 Aristotle’s Treatise on Rhetoric Bk. 2: ch.5, Bk 2. Ch. 5 #1383a5.

5 Summa, Ia IIae, Q.42, a.2, Respondeo, Whether Evil of Nature Is an Object of Fear?

6 Summa, Ia IIae, Q.42, a.2, Reply, ad 2 & 3, Whether Evil of Nature Is an Object of Fear?

We Must Pray for the Pope, Especially at Mass!

Catholic Candle note: Sedevacantism is wrong and is (material or formal) schism. Catholic Candle is not sedevacantist.

Below is the sixteenth article in a series which covers specific aspects of the error of sedevacantism. As context for this sixteenth article, let us recall what we saw in the earlier fifteen articles:

In the first article, we saw that we cannot know whether the pope (or anyone else) is a formal heretic (rather than a material heretic only) – and thus whether he is outside the true Catholic Church based simply on his persistent, public teaching of a heretical opinion.1

Then, in the second article, we saw that we must not judge a man to be a formal heretic if he professes to be Catholic and says he believes what a Catholic must believe now, in order to be Catholic now. When a person professes a heretical opinion, we must judge him in the most favorable light (if we judge him at all). So, we must avoid the sin of rash judgment and we must not judge negatively the interior culpability of the pope and the 1.4 billion2 people who profess to be Catholic. We must not judge they are not “real” Catholics if they tell us that they are Catholics. Instead, we should count them as Catholics who are very confused or are uninformed.3

Thus, we must judge the conciliar popes to have been material heretics, not formal heretics (if we judge them at all), and that each was pope in his turn until his death (or abdication). Regarding any of the world’s 1.4 billion self-described Catholics who hold heresy, we must judge them to be material heretics only (if we judge them at all), unless they themselves tell us that they know they don’t qualify to be Catholics.4

In the third article, we examined briefly the important difference between persons in authority who fulfill their duty to judge those under their charge in the external forum, as contrasted to a sedevacantist or anyone else except God who judges the interior culpability of other persons and (rashly) judges them to be formal heretics.5

In the fourth article, we saw that it does not help us to protect ourselves better from a conciliar pope’s heresy, to declare that we know he is not the pope and is not a Catholic.6

In the fifth article, we saw that it is possible for a pope to teach (or believe) heresy and in fact, popes have taught and believed heresy at various times during Church history.7 We looked especially at the cases of Pope John XXII and Pope Nicholas I, who both taught explicit heresy while pope and nonetheless continued to be the pope. Pope John XXII also taught the same explicit heresy before he became the pope.

In the sixth article, we saw that the Church infallibly assures us that we will have a pope at all times until the end of the world, except during very short interregnums between papal reigns, during which the Church is in the process of electing a new pope and during which the Church’s unified government continues to function.8 In this sixth article, we saw that we are not presently in an interregnum (even though the sedevacantists absurdly claim we are in a many-decades-long interregnum).

In the seventh article of this series, we saw that the Catholic Church is a visible Body and remains visible to all. The Catholic Church has a visible monarchical government and the pope is visible to all. Thus, we know we have a pope and that the one who is pope is visible (known) to all as the pope.9

In the eighth article, we saw that the necessary visibility of the Catholic Church and the pope, requires as a corollary that the one who virtually all Catholics see (i.e., believe) is the pope must be the pope, since the pope must be visible to all.10

In the ninth article, we addressed the superficial claim of sedevacantists (addressed to Catholics) saying that “if you think we have a pope, then you have to obey him in whatever he tells you to do”. We examined the true Catholic virtue of obedience and saw that we must not obey the commands of even a real superior like our pope, if/when he commands us to do something evil.11

In the tenth article, we saw more deeply what schism is and how sedevacantism is inherently schism.12

In the eleventh article of this series, we saw more deeply how we should respond to a pope (or other superior) who does harm – viz., we should recognize his authority but resist the evil of his words or deeds.13

In the twelfth article of this series, we saw how we ordinary Catholic laymen can know what the Catholic Truth is and how we can know when the pope (or anyone) is promoting heresy or other error.14

In the thirteenth article of this series, we saw the falsehood of a related sedevacantist error (or “half-truth”), claiming that we have no pope because the conciliar popes had doubtful consecrations and/or ordinations.15

In the fourteenth article of this series, we considered another way to see that sedevacantism is wrong and sinful, viz., because it is the sin of revolution.16

In the fifteenth article of this series, we saw that even though Pope Leo XIV is objectively a very bad pope, all Catholics are in communion with him, since this is an essential condition of being Catholic and not schismatic.

Further, some sedevacantists (and a smaller number of other confused persons) make a related false argument directed against Catholics. They say that we must not pray for the pope in the Canon of the Mass because doing so would mean that we adopt his errors.

Traditional Catholics who have never heard of this error, might be tempted to think the error is so “far-fetched” that a non-sedevacantist could never really think it was wrong to pray for the pope at Mass. However, tragically, some persons have been fooled by the claim that praying for the pope in the Canon of the Mass somehow means that we adopt his errors. In fact, one non-sedevacantist priest in Canada was fooled into not praying for the pope in the Canon of the Mass and subsequently succumbed to the error of sedevacantism.

Below, we address the question whether praying for the pope in the Canon of the Mass indicates that we adopt the pope’s errors.

We Must Pray for the Pope, Especially at Mass!17


An examination of the erroneous argument claiming that we should not insert the pope’s name in the Canon of the Mass


It is our duty to pray for others. When we pray the Mass, this is an especially perfect time to do this, since it is the infinitely meritorious sacrifice of Our Lord Jesus Christ. Further, every pope has the frighteningly grave responsibility for the souls of everyone in the world, especially for Catholics. Thus, we should continually pray for the pope, and most especially when we pray the Mass. (Of course, in our current times, where most faithful and informed Catholics do not have access to an uncompromising priest, these prayers for the pope should be offered while sanctifying the Sunday without a priest.)18


In a previous article (#15) we saw that we Catholics are in communion with the pope – whether he is good or bad – and we are also in communion with all other Catholics – whether they are good or bad.


The devil knows the importance of praying for the pope and greatly fears this, especially the efficacious intercession for him at a non-compromised Mass. Satan knows that if God reforms the pope through prayers offered for him, this reformed pope could spiritually transform (the human element of) the Church. Thus, the devil uses every lie and trick he has to discourage prayer for the pope, especially in the Canon of the True Traditional Mass.


One trick the devil uses, is to make priests and people afraid to pray for the pope when they pray the Canon of the Mass, fearing that somehow mentioning the pope’s name in the Canon causes us to affirm we agree with the pope’s errors.19


For a priest not to pray for the pope during the Canon of the Mass is objectively a sin (since he is required to do so), even if no one ever knew the priest made this sinful omission.20


This objective sin is increased if people do find out that the priest does not pray for the pope at Mass, because this omission is an objective sin of scandal, since all priests (and all Catholics) have a solemn duty to pray for the hierarchy, especially the pope.


Also, this scandal is gravely aggravated if anyone is led to conclude that the priest is a sedevacantist (because such a priest – like the sedevacantists – does not pray for the pope).



The Text of the Prayer for the Pope at the Beginning of the Canon of the Mass


Latin English


Te igitur, clementissime Pater, per Jesum Christum Filium tuum, Dominum nostrum, supplices rogamus ac petimus uti accepta habeas, et benedicas haec dona, haec munera, haec sancta sacrificia illibata; in primis quae tibi offerimus pro Ecclesia tua sancta catholica; quam pacificare, custodire, adunare, et regere digneris toto orbe terrarum: una cum famulo tuo Papa nostro N., et Antistite nostro N. et omnibus orthodoxis, atque catholicae et aostolicae fidei cultoribus.

Therefore, most gracious Father, we humbly beg of Thee and entreat Thee through Jesus Christ Thy Son, Our Lord. Hold acceptable and bless + these gifts, these + offerings, these + holy and unspotted oblations which, in the first place, we offer Thee for Thy Holy Catholic Church. Grant her peace and protection, unity and guidance throughout the world, together with Thy servant [name], our Pope, and [name], our Bishop; and all Orthodox believers who cherish the Catholic and Apostolic Faith.


Memento, Domine, famulorum, famularumque tuarum N. et N. et omnium circumstantium, quorum tibi fides cognita est, et nota devotio, pro quibus tibi offerimus. vel qui tibi offerunt hoc sacrificium laudis pro se, suisque omnibus, pro redemptione animarum suarum, pro spe salutis, et incolumitis suae; tibique reddunt vota sua aeterno Deo, vivo et vero.


Remember, O Lord, Thy servants and handmaids, [name] and [name], and all here present, whose faith and devotion are known to Thee. On whose behalf we offer to Thee, or who themselves offer to Thee this sacrifice of praise for themselves, families and friends, for the good of their souls, for their hope of salvation and deliverance from all harm, and who offer their homage to Thee, eternal, living and true God.

(Emphasis added.)



Una cum Papa nostro Leone


When we pray in the Canon of the Mass: “una cum famulo tuo Papa nostro, [name]”, this phrase is part of the same sentence in which we offer the oblation for the Church because we offer this oblation for the Church and also (i.e., together) for the pope (and the bishop, etc.).


Some people mistakenly think “together with” means that we declare we are together in mind with the pope in whatever he teaches. In other words, such a false claim asserts that putting the pope’s name in the Canon declares we are united (“together”) with the pope in whatever he believes. There are six reasons why this is false:


  1. In this prayer, the pope is mentioned in the middle of a longer “list”. The prayer offers the oblation for the Church, then there is mention of the pope, then the bishop, then all Catholics and finally in the next prayer, we recall the people near and dear to us “on whose behalf we offer” this same oblation. This list has a clear order. We pray for the Church, then those governing the Church, then all members of the Church and lastly, those near and dear to us whether or not our loved ones are Catholics.

    This grouping and the whole progression of thought shows that the reference to the pope and bishop is our prayer for them and is offering the oblation for them. It is unreasonable to understand this prayer as a declaration of solidarity: viz., as if the prayer were to state that we offer this oblation for the Church, then we declare we believe whatever the pope and others believe, and lastly we offer the oblation for those people dear to us.


If we were to wrongly assume (as this false claim does) that we break up the series of persons for whom we offer up the oblation, in order to declare sameness in beliefs with the pope, why wouldn’t we declare that we believe what the
Church teaches, rather than only the pope? Whatever the holy and infallible Catholic Church teaches, we must always believe because it is always true. By contrast, we believe what the pope teaches only when he teaches what the Church teaches. (Any errors that the pope teaches are not the teaching of the Church nor are they worthy of belief.21) Plainly, it is wrong to think this prayer of the Canon unites us to whatever the pope teaches.

The Canon is the perfect time to pray for the pope, when we mention him immediately after we pray for the Church. Because the Canon of the Mass is perfect, we would expect the perfection of the Canon to include both the prayer for the Church and for the pope. This is a further reason to understand the prayer this way.

  1. That the oblation is offered for all of these listed persons is further shown by this prayer (in the Canon) where it says the offering is made for the Church “in the first place”, and then proceeds to mention the pope, bishop, all Catholics and lastly those near and dear to us. This prayer’s phrase “in primis” (i.e., “in the first place”) shows that the offering will also then be made for others, the pope being the very next one listed.

  2. That this reference to the pope (and bishop) is a prayer for him (rather than joining in his ideas), is shown by what the pope and bishops themselves say when they offer Mass. As the 1913 Catholic Encyclopedia explains:


A diocesan bishop in saying Mass changes the form “et Antistite nostro N.” into “et me indigno servo tuo” [
i.e., “and me thy unworthy servant”]. The pope naturally uses these words instead of “una cum famulo tuo Papa nostro N.”, and omits the clause about the bishop.22


In other words, the pope and bishop pray for themselves and offer the oblation for themselves. They plainly are not saying that they unite with themselves and believe whatever they themselves believe. As they pray for themselves in the Canon, likewise we pray for them in the same place, by inserting their names (and we are not declaring that we believe whatever they teach).

  1. This groundless fear (viz., the fear of adding the pope’s name in the Canon) also ignores Church history. From the earliest days of the Church, the Canon of the Mass has included a prayer interceding for the Church, the pope, the bishop and Catholics generally, as well as (in some earlier manuscripts) also intercession for the emperor and for the priest celebrating the Mass.23 The prayer was worded in various ways but always had this same intercessory meaning. That same meaning continues in the wording of the traditional missal we use.


By contrast, throughout the history of the Mass, in all the various formulations of the prayers in early manuscripts, the Mass has never included a declaration of solidarity in belief with the pope, as is baselessly feared by those who fear to include the pope’s name in the Canon.


  1. There have been popes at different times of Church history who had problems in word or deed. If each person were supposed to decide whether to withdraw the pope’s name from the Canon of the Mass and not pray for him, this would create chaos. To take only two examples:


  1. Pope Innocent VIII (1484 -1492) had illegitimate children whom he publicly acknowledged.24 Pope Innocent VIII was so shameless that while his own illegitimate son was at the papal court and in the immediate papal circle, this son “paraded the streets at night … forced his way into the houses of citizens for evil purposes” and similarly led a life of avarice and debauchery.25

Should Catholics have not prayed for Pope Innocent VIII in the Canon of the Mass under the theory that the pope’s open shamelessness was equivalent to showing that the virtue of purity is optional and therefore this pope was unworthy of prayers in the Canon of the Mass?


  1. Pope Nicholas I taught the heresy “that baptism was valid, whether administered in the name of the three Persons or in the name of Christ only.”26 Should each person at the time have decided if Pope Nicholas’ heresy meant he should be cut off from the prayers he greatly needed?


How great a division it would sow among Catholics if this wedge of discord and chaos were permitted to exist among the faithful! This would mean that faithful Catholics would shun priests who refused to pray for the pope during the Canon and confused Catholics would refuse priests who prayed for the pope in the Canon.



  1. The pre-Vatican II commentators unanimously explain this passage of the Canon as a prayer (intercession) for the pope, not a declaration of united belief with the pope. Here is a small sample of such commentaries:


  • The 1913 Catholic Encyclopedia explains: “The priest prays first for the Church, then for the pope and diocesan ordinary by name.”27


  • The book entitled The Holy Sacrifice of the Mass explains: “[We have] a special and express offering and prayer for the Pope and for the chief pastor of the diocese in which the holy Mass is celebrated. … It is proper that, throughout the entire Church, the Pope should be prayed for and the Sacrifice be offered for him …”.28


  • The book entitled The Mass, A Study of the Roman Liturgy explains: “The Intercession (from “in primis”) … begins by praying for the Church, Pope, bishop and the faithful.”29


  • The commentator in The St. Andrew’s Daily Missal notes at the Canon’s “in primis” that the priest “prays for the living heads and members of the Church Militant”.30

Conclusion: for all six reasons, it is plain that we insert the pope’s name in the Canon in order to pray for him (not to declare we believe whatever he believes). The pope is the only one on earth who can authoritatively reform the (human element of the) Church. Although we reject the pope’s errors, we must pray for him unceasingly (especially when praying the Mass), that he reverses his own course and leads souls back to the traditions of the Church.



The Devil Uses a Second False Reason to Eliminate Prayers for the Pope at Mass


Some Catholics plainly see that this prayer in the Canon is a prayer for the pope (not a declaration that we believe whatever he believes). Yet they do not pray for the pope at Mass. Their reason for this is that they are troubled by the scruple that somehow it is a sin to pray for a bad pope in the Canon of the Mass because this prayer is the Church’s public prayer, and that it would be a scandal to pray for any bad man (including a bad pope) in the Church’s public prayer. (These misguided people think it is fine to pray for a bad pope in private prayer, but not the Church’s public prayer.)


But this scruple ignores Common Sense, Church history, and Ecclesiastic Tradition.


First, common sense: our prayers for anyone beg God’s help for the person. Those prayers don’t show the person is perfect but are asking God to change and perfect him. So it is the most natural thing for loyal sons of the Church to pray publicly for bad leaders, especially when praying the Mass.


Second, Church history: through many hundreds of years, it was the practice of good priests, bishops and laymen to publicly pray in the Canon of the Mass, for the emperor – not only for a good emperor but for whoever was the emperor, good or bad. Similarly, when we pray the Mass, our prayers for the pope are not conditioned on the spiritual condition of his soul.


Third, Ecclesiastical Tradition: the prayers of Good Friday (going back almost 1800 years31) not only pray for the pope (for any pope, whether good or bad) but also publicly pray for the worst of men: heretics, schismatics, Jews, and pagans, who are inherently bad because they oppose Our Lord and His Church.



Conclusion


It is plain that, however much evil the pope is doing, we should pray hard for him, including public prayers and especially at Mass. Let us unite in fervent prayer for the pope – especially when praying the Mass – that God change his heart and enlighten his mind.

2 The Vatican estimates that the number of Catholics worldwide is about 1.375 billion. https://www.vaticannews.va/en/church/news/2023-10/fides-catholic-church-statistics-world-mission-sunday.html


7 Read this article here: It is Possible for a Pope to Teach Heresy and Remain the Pope?: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/01/27/it-is-possible-for-a-pope-to-teach-heresy-and-remain-the-pope/


8 Read this article here that the Catholic Church’s unified government always continues, even during an interregnum: The Catholic Church Will Always Have a Pope: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/02/21/the-catholic-church-will-always-have-a-pope/

9 Read this article showing that The Catholic Church Will Always be Visible, and Will Always Have a Pope Who is Visible to All, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/03/27/the-catholic-church-will-always-be-visible-with-a-pope/


10 Read this article: The Man Whom the Whole Church Accepts as Pope, IS the Pope: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/04/23/the-man-whom-the-whole-church-accepts-as-pope-is-the-pope/

11 Read this article examining false obedience, entitled, The False “Obedience” of Cowardly and Weak Catholics, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/05/20/the-false-obedience-of-cowardly-and-weak-catholics/


12 Read this article showing that Sedevacantism is Inherently Schism, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/06/28/sedevacantism-is-inherently-schism/


13 Our Catholic Duty: Resist the Harm Done by a Bad Pope But (Of Course) Recognize His Authority: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/07/24/our-catholic-duty-resist-the-harm-done-by-a-bad-pope-but-of-course-recognize-his-authority/


14 Judging the Pope’s Words & Deeds According to Catholic Tradition: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/08/29/judging-the-popes-words-deeds-according-to-catholic-tradition/

15

A Man Need Not Be Consecrated a Bishop or Ordained a Priest to Be a Valid Pope — An Explanation How the Catholic Church Continues to Possess A Full Hierarchy even in these Times of Great Apostasy: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/09/24/a-man-need-not-be-consecrated-a-bishop-or-ordained-a-priest-to-be-a-valid-pope/

17 Of course, in our current times, where most faithful and informed Catholics do not have access to an uncompromising priest, these prayers for the pope should be offered while sanctifying the Sunday without a priest.

18 We at Catholic Candle don’t know of any uncompromising priest or group, although that does not mean that there is not one (we just don’t know about him). https://catholiccandle.org/2021/07/02/the-reckless-claim-that-there-are-no-good-priests-left/


We recommend that you do what we do: we sanctify the Sunday at home. https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/sanctifying-sunday-no-mass.html


Even if we don’t "feel" content with our feelings, nonetheless with our will and intellect (the important faculties) we should be perfectly content without the Mass and Sacraments when they are not available without compromise. 

https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/complete-contentment-without-the-mass-when-it-is-not-available-without-compromise.html


Our times are times of great blessings! We hold that this is a glorious time to be Catholic and to live for Christ the King! https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/it-is-a-blessing-to-live-during-this-great-apostasy.html


We must continually guard ourselves against having a “go along” mentality. https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/we-must-neither-follow-bad-catholics-nor-rashly-judge-them


We must have hope because God is in charge and everything that happens that is truly out of our control is God’s Will for us. We keep in the front of our memory that all things “work together unto the good, for those who love God”.  Romans, 8:28. 

https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/hope-during-the-current-great-apostasy


19 Although no sedevacantists pray for our pope at Mass (because they deny he is pope), even some sedevacantists correctly understand that putting the pope’s name in the Canon is praying for him, not declaring that we believe and adopt whatever errors he teaches.

20 We don’t judge the interior, subjective culpability of such a priest or anyone else who holds this error. See, the Catholic Candle article against the sin of rash judgment: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/10/24/are-we-allowed-to-decide-that-pope-francis-knows-he-is-not-catholic/

21 Previously, we saw (in the fifth article of this series) that it is possible for a pope to teach (or believe) heresy and in fact, popes have taught and believed heresy at various times during Church history. Read this article here: It is Possible for a Pope to Teach Heresy and Remain the Pope?: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/01/27/it-is-possible-for-a-pope-to-teach-heresy-and-remain-the-pope/

We looked especially at the cases of Pope John XXII and Pope Nicholas I, who both taught explicit heresy while pope and nonetheless continued to be the pope. Pope John XXII also taught the same explicit heresy before he became the pope.



22 1913 Catholic Encyclopedia, article Canon of the Mass, vol. 3, p.262.

23 See, e.g., The Mass, A Study of the Roman Liturgy, by Adrian Fortescue, Longmans, Green & Co., London, © 1930, pp. 153 & 157 & Ch. III (entitled The Origin of the Roman Mass).

24 Popes Through The Ages, by Joseph Brusher, Van Nostrand ,Princeton, N.J., ©1959, article under Pope Innocent VIII, available here: https://www.ewtn.com/catholicism/library/popes-through-the-ages-13701



25 History of the Popes, Ludwig Pastor, edited by Frederick Ignatius Antrobus, Vol. 5 p.354. This quote comes from a 28 volume set written between 1886 and 1930. The volumes of the English translation contain no copyright dates.

26 Cardinal Henry Newman’s treatise On The True Notion of Papal Infallibility. Cardinal Newman cites this example quoting St. Robert Bellarmine in De Rom. Pont., iv. 12.

27 1913 Catholic Encyclopedia, article Canon of the Mass, vol. 3, article Canon of the Mass, p.262.


28 Rev. Dr. Nicholas Gihr, Herder, St. Louis, 1941, pp. 596-97.

29 The Mass, A Study of the Roman Liturgy, by Adrian Fortescue, Longmans, Green & Co., London, © 1930, p.329 (parenthetical comment in original).

30 The St. Andrew’s Daily Missal, Dom Gaspar Lefebvre, O.S.B., Lohmann © 1945, p.972.

31 The Mass of the Roman Rite, Josef Jungmann, Benzinger Brothers, New York, 1955, English Edition, translator Francis Brunner C.SS.R., Volume I pp. 481-2.

The Crosses that God Sends Us are Very Precious and Highly Desirable!

Our life on earth is a “vale of tears”. We know this. In the Hail Holy Queen prayer (the Salve Regina), we pray, addressing our Dear Mother Mary: “to thee do we send up our sighs, mourning and weeping in this valley of tears”.

So, we must expect Crosses.

  • In fact, we must expect God to send us Crosses every day.


  • Not only that, we must not simply tolerate the Crosses that are being placed on our shoulder but we must actively grasp those Crosses that God sends to us.

Here is one way Our Lord teaches us this truth:

If any man will come after Me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross daily, and follow Me.1

So, Crosses are inevitable. However, Crosses are truly a great gift from God and are more precious than we can fully understand! As we will see below, God sends Crosses to us for our benefit and to help us. We should rejoice in this help!

In St. John’s Gospel, Our Lord gives the parable of the vine, the husbandman, and the branches. Here are Our Lord’s words:

I am the true vine; and my Father is the husbandman. Every branch in Me, that beareth not fruit, He will take away. And every one that beareth fruit, He will purge it, that it may bring forth more fruit. Now you are clean by reason of the word, which I have spoken to you. Abide in Me, and I in you.

As the branch cannot bear fruit of itself, unless it abide in the vine, so neither can you, unless you abide in Me. I am the vine; you the branches: he that abideth in Me, and I in him, the same beareth much fruit: for without me you can do nothing.

If anyone abide not in Me, he shall be cast forth as a branch, and shall wither, and they shall gather him up, and cast him into the fire, and he burneth. If you abide in Me, and My words abide in you, you shall ask whatever you will, and it shall be done unto you. In this is My Father glorified; that you bring forth very much fruit, and become My disciples.2

Commenting on this parable, St. Thomas Aquinas, Greatest Doctor of the Church,3 explains how Our Lord helps the good branches. Here are St. Thomas’ words:

[God’s] interest in the good branches is to help them so they can bear more fruit. So, He says, “Every branch that bears fruit [My Father] prunes, that it may bear more fruit.4

St. Thomas then explains what this pruning of the branches is:

Considering the literal sense, we see that a natural vine with branches that have many [i.e., superfluous] shoots bears less fruit, because the sap is spread out through all the shoots. Thus, the vinedresser prunes away the superfluous shoots so that the vine can bear more fruit.

It is the same with us. For if we are well-disposed and united to God, yet diffuse our love over many [i.e., superfluous] things, our virtue becomes weak and we become less able to do good. This is why, in order that we may bear fruit, God will frequently remove such obstacles [viz., our diffuse loves] and prune us by sending troubles and temptations, which make us stronger.

Accordingly, [Our Lord] says that [the Father] prunes, even though a person may be clean, for in this life no one is so clean that he does not need to be cleansed more and more: “If we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us” (1 Jn 1:8). And [the Father] does this so that [we] may bear more fruit, that is, grow in virtue, so that the more pruned or cleansed, the more fruitful a person is: “Let the just still be justified, and the holy still be sanctified” [Apoc. 22:11]; “The Gospel is bearing fruit and growing” (Col. 1:6); “They go from strength to [greater] strength” (Ps. 84:7).5

So, we see with our intellect that we should be grateful with our will, for the Crosses that God sends because He sends Crosses to help us. We should thank God with our whole heart (i.e., our will) even if we don’t “feel” grateful with our emotions.

These Crosses are precious and are an essential help to us that we may more abundantly bear the fruit of virtue.6

St. John Chrysostom, Doctor of the Church, teaches us the value of crosses in these words:

If God were to grant you the gift of raising the dead, He would be giving you much less than when He permits you to suffer.  In fact, with the gift of miracles He makes you His debtor, but with sufferings He makes Himself your debtor.7


Conclusion

So let us be grateful for our Crosses and earnestly thank God for each one as soon as He sends it!

Let us carry our Crosses willingly and even joyfully, knowing that they are precious and are God’s helps so that we grow in virtue!

1 St. Luke’s Gospel, 9:23.

2 Ch.15, vv. 1-8, (emphasis added).

3 Read this article: Why Faithful and Informed Catholics Especially Follow the Doctors of the Church and Most Especially St. Thomas Aquinas, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2017/12/16/why-faithful-catholics-follow-the-doctors-of-the-church/


4 St. Thomas Aquinas, Lectures on St. John’s Gospel, Ch.15, #1985 (emphasis added).

5

St. Thomas Aquinas, Lectures on St. John’s Gospel, Ch.15, #1985 (emphasis added; bracketed words added to show the context).

6

Read this article: Strategies for Lightening the Crosses You Now Have, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2020/04/01/77/


7 Spiritual Diary, p.82, St. Paul’s Editions, Boston, MA, ©1962.

Words to Live By – From Catholic Tradition

Our Life on Earth is Warfare!
We Must Fight Tirelessly for Christ the King!

Nothing is so incongruous in a Christian, and nothing so foreign to his character, as to seek ease and rest. To be engrossed in the present life is foreign to our profession and enlistment [as Soldiers of Christ]. Thy Master was crucified, and dost thou seek ease? Thy Master was pierced with nails, and dost thou live delicately? Do these things become a noble soldier?

St. John Chrysostom, Doctor of the Church, quoted from his sermon #13 on Philippians, 3:18-21 (bracketed words added to show the context).

Are You in Desolation, “Stuck in a Rut” Making No Spiritual Progress?

What Can I Do When My Spiritual Life Feels Dry and Boring, and I Feel Like I Am Only “Going Through the Motions” of Practicing My Faith?


This condition is a description of a classic case of spiritual desolation. Here is how the great spiritual master, St. Ignatius of Loyola, defines this desolation:


I call desolation everything contrary to the consolation explained in the third rule, such as darkness of soul, disturbance in it, movement to things low and earthly, the unquiet of different agitations and temptations, moving to lack of confidence, without hope, without love, when one finds oneself all lazy, tepid, sad, and as if separated from his Creator and Lord. Because, as consolation is contrary to desolation, in the same way the thoughts which come from consolation are contrary to the thoughts which come from desolation.1


Although God can (and sometimes does) give desolation in order to test even a very holy soul, the most usual reason for desolation is because of the person’s sins and his negligence in his spiritual duties.

Here is St. Ignatius’ advice for the person in desolation:

Although in desolation we ought not to change our good resolutions, it is very helpful to intensify our good efforts against the temptations that come during desolation, by insisting more on prayer, meditation, on much examination, and more penance.2

We can do this – viz., intensify our good efforts – even when we are in desolation! And God will help us!


How Can I Make Spiritual Progress?

So how does one advance in the spiritual life? Well, there are a lot of very important parts of this program. And we should strongly desire to make great efforts to attain spiritual progress. Our future happiness is determined by this progress in the spiritual life. The greater a person’s future holiness is, the greater will be his future happiness.

The secret of holiness is a person’s generosity with God. If a person asks himself: “What do I need to do to avoid sin and hell?”, that is a stingy goal! Looking at things that way, the spiritual life is a burden and most people fail (and go to Hell) because they aim so low and the result is even lower.

The spiritual life is Divine Friendship3 and so we should seek to be generous with our Divine Friend. We don’t have to feel generous but nonetheless we should resolve with our will to be generous.

How many times has a parent done what he should do (such as take care of a sick child in the middle of the night), not because of feelings, but because of a will to do good! That is how our love and friendship with Christ should be – generous and willed by us regardless of feelings.

Remember, sin is an offense against our Divine Friend Whom we should never want to offend! Therefore, we must avoid occasions of sin, including persons who make it more likely that we will sin. We humans easily fool ourselves and have many excuses to continue to expose ourselves to our past occasions of sin. We must be unshakably firm in avoiding bad companions and other occasions of sin.

We should associate with persons who will influence us with greater generosity toward our Divine Friend! We should avoid persons who influence us toward greater ease, less sacrifice, and less generosity with Christ our Lord. Even if such people do not explicitly lead us into sin, their influence on us is “in the wrong direction” and that fact makes them bad for us.

We must pray more4 – much more – every day – especially when we are in desolation. We should especially pray the rosary5 – ideally all 15 decades every day. We should implement a daily meditation.6

We must avoid bad music. We should not watch TV, movies or use the internet for entertainment. We should avoid most things on the internet, especially “social media”.7 Even aside from the many sins involved, these weaken us and make the spiritual life (and prayer) distasteful to us.

We should avoid “smart” phone use as much as we can. If we must use a “smart” phone, we should use it only for necessary tasks. We should not scroll or shop on our phone as a form of “recreation”.

We should study our Catholic Faith every day. We should do some spiritual reading every day without fail, e.g., a chapter from the Imitation of Christ.

Do some extra penances every day. A generous amount! Three really good ones are to take totally-cold showers, don’t eat in-between meals, and abstain from junk food, desserts and alcohol, especially outside of social occasions and when we are alone.8

Again, Dear Reader, we can do this! God will help!

1 Quoted from Spiritual Exercises of St. Ignatius of Loyola, Rule #4 for the Discernment of Spirits, First Week.

2 Quoted from Spiritual Exercises of St. Ignatius of Loyola, Rule #6 for the Discernment of Spirits, First Week.

3 This all-important love of God is Divine Friendship. Here is how St. Thomas Aquinas, greatest Doctor of the Church, explains this truth:


It is written (John 15:15): “I will not now call you servants . . . but My friends.” Now this was said to them by reason of nothing else than charity. Therefore, charity is friendship. …


According to the Philosopher (Ethic. viii, 2,3), not every love has the character of friendship, but that love which is together with benevolence, when, to wit, we love someone so as to wish good to him. If, however, we do not wish good to what we love, but wish its good for ourselves, (thus we are said to love wine, or a horse, or the like), it is love not of friendship, but of a kind of concupiscence [i.e., the seeking of the pleasures of the senses]. For it would be absurd to speak of having friendship for wine or for a horse.


Yet, neither does well-wishing suffice for friendship, for a certain mutual love is requisite, since friendship is between friend and friend: and this well-wishing is founded on some kind of communication.


Accordingly, since there is a communication between man and God, inasmuch as He communicates His happiness to us, some kind of friendship must needs be based on this same communication, of which it is written (1 Corinthians 1:9): “God is faithful: by Whom you are called unto the fellowship of His Son.” The love which is based on this communication, is charity: wherefore it is evident that charity is the friendship of man for God.


Summa, IIa IIae, Q.23, a.1, sed contra and respondeo (emphasis added).



4 Here is a brief explanation about what prayer is essentially: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/08/10/cc-in-brief-essence-of-prayer/

5 Read this article about how to properly pray the rosary: https://catholiccandle.org/2019/12/23/the-rosary-how-why/

6 Here is a brief explanation about how to do a meditation and why it is important to mediate: https://catholiccandle.org/2021/09/03/lesson-2-meditation-how-why/

7 Read this article, especially the section about social media: https://catholiccandle.org/2023/12/12/the-connection-between-virtue-and-happiness-part-2/

There are many noxious effects of “social media”. It is very unwholesome, is unsocial, and fosters the antithesis of real, deep friendship (especially a profound friendship with God – which is our reason for living).


Beyond the very obvious mortal sins which are virtually everywhere on the internet, e.g., sins against the holy virtue of purity, additionally the sins of worldliness, superficiality, immodesty, time-wasting, and many other types of sin are endemic and pervasive there. This is evident to faithful and informed Catholics whose goal is to live every day the way that, at their judgment they would want to have lived.


Of course, there are countless mainstream studies also, which discover what faithful and informed Catholics already know, viz., that “social media” makes a person unhappier and more isolated. Here are just a few of those mainstream studies:







Lastly, the Government and Big Tech use “social media” (and many other activities on the internet) to spy on us and to amass huge dossiers on us for their future commercial exploitation and political use against us. Here is a small sampling of articles on this subject:








8 Read this article about the ideal penance of not eating for pleasure when you are alone: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/the-spiritual-benefits-of-not-consuming-sweets-and-junkfood-when-you-are-alone


Lesson #52: Temperaments – Choleric Temperament – The Cholerics’ Spiritual Combat Part XVII

Philosophy Notes

Catholic Candle note: The article below is part seventeen of the study of the Choleric temperament. The first sixteen parts can be found here:

  1. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #36: About the Temperaments – Beginning our Study of the Choleric Temperament – Part I: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/08/27/lesson-35-about-the-temperaments-the-choleric-temperament/

  2. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #37: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament– Part II: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/09/26/lesson-37-about-the-temperaments-continuation-of-the-choleric-temperament/

  3. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #38: About the Temperaments – Continuing our Study of the Choleric Temperament – Their Spiritual Combat – Part III: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/10/24/lesson-38-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat/

  4. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #39: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – That Temperament’s Spiritual Combat – Part IV: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/11/26/lesson-39-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat-part-iv/

  5. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #40: Temperaments – Choleric Temperament – Their Spiritual Combat – Part V: https://catholiccandle.org/2024/12/30/lesson-40-temperaments-choleric-temperament-their-spiritual-combat-part-v/

  6. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #41: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament: a Choleric’s Spiritual Combat — Part VI: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/01/27/lesson-41-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-vi/

  7. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #42: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – a Choleric’s Spiritual Combat – Part VII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/02/21/lesson-42-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-vii/

  8. Mary’s School of Sanctity — Lesson #43: About the Temperaments –Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament — Their Spiritual Combat Part VIII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/03/27/lesson-42-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-viii/

  9. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #44: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – Their Spiritual Combat, Part IX: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/04/23/lesson-44-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-ix/

  10. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #45: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat Part X: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/05/20/lesson-45-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-x/

  11. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #46: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Cholerics’ Spiritual Combat – Part XI: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/06/28/lesson-46-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xi/

  12. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #47: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat – Part XII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/07/24/lesson-47-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xii/

  13. Mary’s School of Sanctity – Lesson #48: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat Part XIII: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/08/29/lesson-48-temperaments-choleric-temperament-a-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xiii/

  14. Mary’s School of Sanctity — Lesson #49: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat Part XIV: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/09/24/lesson-49-temperaments-choleric-temperament-the-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xiv/

  1. Mary’s School of Sanctity — Lesson #50: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat Part XV: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/10/26/3050/

  1. Mary’s School of Sanctity — Lesson #51: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Cholerics’ Spiritual Combat Part XVI: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/11/25/lesson-51-temperaments-choleric-temperament-the-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xvi/

Mary’s School of Sanctity

Lesson #52 – About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Choleric’s Spiritual Combat Part XVII: the Objects of Fear1


Note: In this article, when referring to a person with a choleric temperament, we will simply refer to him as a “choleric”.

Now that we have examined the types of fear,2 let’s now consider with St. Thomas the object of fear – which logically comes next. The object of fear is simply what we fear. But there is a lot to be said about this!

Humans of all temperaments are afflicted with fear. All of us have felt fear. But have we ever stopped to ponder deeply what it is that we fear? Again we have the blessing of St. Thomas’ guidance when answering this question.

St. Thomas probes all subjects deeply and takes each one to its foundation, so when inquiring about the object of fear he begins by asking the question, Whether the Object of Fear is Good or Evil?

As always, St. Thomas examines this question humbly and methodically. He does not assume that the great thinkers who preceded him cannot help him with the inquiry. As with other inquiries, St. Thomas searches what the Fathers and Doctors of the Church teach on this question.

First, he informs us that St. John Damascene, Doctor of the Church, teaches that, “Fear is of a future evil.”3


St. Thomas explains how fear works in the soul

St. Thomas explains that fear is a movement of the appetitive power. By “appetitive power”, he means the power of the soul by which it desires.

There are three types of appetitive powers:

  • The natural appetite – which seeks what is suitable according to nature. An example of this is a tree naturally seeking the sunlight and so a tree which is always in the deep shade of other trees will grow sideways in order to obtain un-shaded sunlight;

  • The sensitive appetite – which seeks what is desirable in relation to the power of sensation of a man’s (or other animal’s) soul. One example of a sensitive appetite is an animal’s hunger for food; and

  • The intellectual (or rational) appetite – otherwise known as the will. This appetite desires the good known by the intellect in a way analogous to the sensitive appetite desiring the good which is sensed by man or another animal.

St. Thomas explains what is involved with this appetitive movement in the soul. Here are his words:

It belongs to this [viz., appetitive] power to:

  • Pursue the good. Consequently, whatever movement of the appetitive power that implies pursuit, has some good for its object; and

  • Avoid the evil. Consequently, whatever movement implies avoidance, has, for its object, some evil.

However, fear can regard good also, in so far as referable to evil. This can be in two ways.

  1. Inasmuch as an evil causes privation of a good. A thing is evil from the very fact that the evil thing is a privation of some good. Wherefore, since evil is shunned because it is evil, it follows that evil is shunned because it deprives a person of a good that one pursues through love. St. Augustine explains that there is no cause for fear except the loss of a good that we love; and

  2. Good can be related to evil as its cause in a way: viz., in so far as some good can, by its power, bring harm to another good that we love. And so, fear regards things in two ways, namely,

  1. The evil from which it shrinks; and

  1. That good which by its power can inflict that evil [on us]. In this way God is feared by man [although God is All-Good], inasmuch as He can inflict punishment, spiritual or corporal. In this way, too, we fear the power of man; especially when the power of the man has been thwarted, or when the power of the man is unjust because then that power is more likely to do us harm.

In like manner one fears a person who is over him or that has the power to do him harm. Thus, a man fears another who knows him to be guilty of a crime, lest he reveal the crime to others.4

Therefore, we can see that the passion of fear is a good thing when it is used properly – when we fear the appropriate things, e.g., when we fear sin or anything that displeases God, and when we fear something else which is truly harmful and so this fear can help us to avoid the evil. By contrast, when we fear inordinately, that is, irrationally in any way, then we are not using fear as God intended.

We must remember that God created the passions in us and they are good. But we must use fear (and the other passions) correctly because fear (and all things created by God) can be abused, resulting in sin and chaos in our lives.

If we reflect well, we see that there are many things that we are accustomed to fear. But we must learn to distinguish – by using our reason – exactly what is appropriate for us to fear and what is not.


A Preview …

In our next lesson we will continue our study of the objects of fear. We will discuss what St. Thomas calls the evil of nature – viz., things that cause pain and/or death, and how it is that man fears these. We will also make some practical considerations concerning how we should handle our fears.

1 Fear influences all temperaments but not in the same way. Later, when we study the other temperaments, we will draw upon the teaching of St. Thomas about fear which we now set out in the context of the choleric temperament.

2 See Lesson #51, found here: Mary’s School of Sanctity — Lesson #51: About the Temperaments – Continuing Our Study of the Choleric Temperament – The Cholerics’ Spiritual Combat Part XVI: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/11/25/lesson-51-temperaments-choleric-temperament-the-cholerics-spiritual-combat-part-xvi/

3 Taken from St. John Damascene, De Fide Orthodox ii,12, as quoted in the Summa, Ia IIae, Q.42, a.1, Whether the Object of Fear is Good or Evil?

4 Taken from Summa Ia-IIae Q. 42 a. 1 Whether the Object of Fear is Good or Evil? Respondeo [Bracketed words added for clarity.]

The Comfort of the Catholic Faith and God’s Care During Our Perilous Times

Catholic Candle note: This article below was written by one of Catholic Candle’s more senior editors, who has a wealth of experience and wisdom.


The Comfort and Security of the True Catholic Faith and God’s Providential Care, Living During Our Perilous Times

It’s a pretty scary world out there.

Nuclear war, cancer, street crime, heart attacks, the steady decline of public morals, the decaying of educational standards, the subversion of the human element of the Church … there are so many other things that could be added to this catalogue of perils in our modern life.  

If one chose to dwell on what could happen to us at any time, he might be paralyzed and unwilling to even get out of bed in the morning.  And to carry this a step further, he may then wonder how he could possibly survive the dangers that threaten to prevent his death from being a happy and holy death – which would be the ultimate tragedy for him.

That is, and should be our biggest concern: whether we have the fortitude to make it safely through the “minefield” of our life on earth to the safe harbor of heaven.

Some time ago, I found the answer.  Not that it was unique to me.  Undoubtedly many of you have long known what it is:

Nothing that happens to me today can hurt me because God allowed it to happen.1 And if the God who loves me allows it, then it must be for my good.2

How can we argue with that?  This is comforting and reassuring, especially when we lose a job, get unhappy news from the doctor, are deceived by a friend or relative, suffer a financial loss, or experience any other of the wide variety of the travails of this life. 

Of course, this trust in God pertains to all things – including all evils – which are out of our control, as shown by the few examples listed above: (e.g., nuclear war, cancer, street crime). It should “go without saying” that we should not rashly suppose that God will protect us from all of the consequences of our own sins and the decisions which we make without seeking His will.

For example, it would be folly to get drunk and, because of this, to miss work and be fired from our job, on the excuse that “Nothing that happens to me today can hurt me because God allowed it to happen.” Rather, we are speaking of the complete trust we should have in God regarding what happens to us beyond our control and through no culpability on our own part.3


Conclusion


Let us have complete security and confidence in Divine Providence!4 He will take perfect care of our needs, both spiritual and temporal!

1 Here is how St. Thomas Aquinas explains this important truth:


It is impossible to trust too much in the Divine assistance.

Summa, IIa IIae, Q.17, a.5, ad 2 (emphasis added; capitalization added).


2 As St. Paul teaches us: “All things work together unto the good, for those who love God”. Romans, 8:28.

3 For an explanation of the crucial difference between the Theological Virtue of Hope and the vice of presumption, read this article: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/priests/sspx-the-new-sspx-teaches-the-vice-of-presumption-as-if-it-were-the-virtue-of-hope

All Catholics are in Communion with the Pope

Catholic Candle note: Sedevacantism is wrong and is (material or formal) schism. Catholic Candle is not sedevacantist.

Awhile back, a reader forwarded to us a question (below) which he found posted on a sedevacantist website. The question (which was directed to non-sedevacantists) troubled him. He asked how Catholics should respond to this question. We answer below, but change the name (Pope Francis) to reflect the current pope (Pope Leo XIV).

Below is the fifteenth article in a series which covers specific aspects of the error of sedevacantism. As context for this fifteenth article, let us recall what we saw in the earlier fourteen articles:

In the first article, we saw that we cannot know whether the pope (or anyone else) is a formal heretic (rather than a material heretic only) – and thus whether he is outside the true Catholic Church based simply on his persistent, public teaching of a heretical opinion.1

Then, in the second article, we saw that we must not judge a man to be a formal heretic if he professes to be Catholic and says he believes what a Catholic must believe now, in order to be Catholic now. When a person professes a heretical opinion, we must judge him in the most favorable light (if we judge him at all). So, we must avoid the sin of rash judgment and we must not judge negatively the interior culpability of the pope and the 1.4 billion2 people who profess to be Catholic. We must not judge they are not “real” Catholics if they tell us that they are Catholics. Instead, we should count them as Catholics who are very confused or are uninformed.3

Thus, we must judge the conciliar popes to have been material heretics, not formal heretics (if we judge them at all), and that each was pope in his turn until his death (or abdication). Regarding any of the world’s 1.4 billion self-described Catholics who hold heresy, we must judge them to be material heretics only (if we judge them at all), unless they themselves tell us that they know they don’t qualify to be Catholics.4

In the third article, we examined briefly the important difference between persons in authority who fulfill their duty to judge those under their charge in the external forum, as contrasted to a sedevacantist or anyone else except God who judges the interior culpability of other persons and (rashly) judges them to be formal heretics.5

In the fourth article, we saw that it does not help us to protect ourselves better from a conciliar pope’s heresy, to declare that we know he is not the pope and is not a Catholic.6

In the fifth article, we saw that it is possible for a pope to teach (or believe) heresy and in fact, popes have taught and believed heresy at various times during Church history.7 We looked especially at the cases of Pope John XXII and Pope Nicholas I, who both taught explicit heresy while pope and nonetheless continued to be the pope. Pope John XXII also taught the same explicit heresy before he became the pope.

In the sixth article, we saw that the Church infallibly assures us that we will have a pope at all times until the end of the world, except during very short interregnums between papal reigns, during which the Church is in the process of electing a new pope and during which the Church’s unified government continues to function.8 In this sixth article, we saw that we are not presently in an interregnum (even though the sedevacantists absurdly claim we are in a many-decades-long interregnum).

In the seventh article of this series, we saw that the Catholic Church is a visible Body and remains visible to all. The Catholic Church has a visible monarchical government and the pope is visible to all. Thus, we know we have a pope and that the one who is pope is visible (known) to all as the pope.9

In the eighth article, we saw that the necessary visibility of the Catholic Church and the pope, requires as a corollary that the one who virtually all Catholics see (i.e., believe) is the pope must be the pope, since the pope must be visible to all.10

In the ninth article, we addressed the superficial “argument” of sedevacantists (addressed to Catholics) saying that “if you think we have a pope, then you have to obey him in whatever he tells you to do”. We examined the true Catholic virtue of obedience and saw that we must not obey the commands of even a real superior like our pope, if/when he commands us to do something evil.11

In the tenth article, we saw more deeply what schism is and how sedevacantism is inherently schism.12

In the eleventh article of this series, we saw more deeply how we should respond to a pope (or other superior) who does harm – viz., we should recognize his authority as pope but resist the evil of his words or deeds.13

In the twelfth article of this series, we saw how we ordinary Catholic laymen can know what the Catholic Truth is and how we can know when the pope (or anyone) is promoting error.14

In the thirteenth article of this series, we saw the falsehood of a related sedevacantist error (or “half-truth”), claiming that we have no pope because the conciliar popes had doubtful consecrations and/or ordinations.15

In the fourteenth article of this series, we considered another way to see that sedevacantism is wrong and sinful, viz., because it is the sin of revolution.16

In the fifteenth article of this series, we address a question which arises because we see that Leo XIV is Pope:

Does that mean we are in communion with him?

Below, we address that question.

All Catholics are in Communion with the Pope

Sedevacantists attempt to show that their own Catholicism is “exalted and pure” by saying that they are not, and would never be, connected with that man (who is our pope) because his words and deeds are often so problematic, scandalous, and heterodox.

So these sedevacantists attempt to pressure Catholics into becoming schismatics (like themselves), by urging those Catholics: “Don’t be in communion with that man (viz., the pope)!”, suggesting that somehow it is un-Catholic to be in communion with a bad pope.

So the question arises: Are we Catholics really in communion with the pope, even when he is a bad, scandalous pope or teaches heresy? In this article, we examine that question.


Answering a Sedevacantist Question

The sedevacantists’ question:

Are you in communion with “Pope” Leo and his religion?

Catholic Candle note: the quotation marks (around the word “Pope”) are in the sedevacantists’ original question, indicating they don’t believe he is a real pope. Again, though, the sedevacantists’ original question said “Francis” not “Leo”.

The sedevacantists’ question is deceptively-framed in two ways

  1. We interpret the question’s reference to his religion, as a reference to the new conciliar religion (not Catholicism). Through this reference, the question sneaks in the assumption that Pope Leo has a single religion and it is not Catholicism. This sedevacantist ploy tricks an unwary Catholic into conceding this falsehood and participating in the sedevacantists’ rash judgment.17

  2. The question is compound; that is, it is really two questions in one. Thus, it is deceptive (either intentionally or carelessly). The question seeks a single “yes or no” answer, but either answer would be false (see below our two-part, short answer).


Beware of sedevacantist traps for the unwary!


Two-part, short answer to the sedevacantists’ question

  • Part one: All Catholics are in communion with Pope Leo.

However …

  • Part two: No faithful and informed Catholics are members of (i.e., in communion with) the conciliar church (which is a false religion).


Summary of our full explanation below

  1. Although Pope Leo does much evil, he is truly the pope and a member (as well as the head) of the Catholic Church.

  2. To save our souls, we must be members of the Catholic Church.

  3. Because all Catholics are joint members of the Catholic Church along with Pope Leo, all Catholics are in communion with him and with each other.

  4. Although Catholics are joint members of the Catholic Church along with Pope Leo, this does not also make us members of whatever other groups he belongs to, including the conciliar church.

Below, we discuss each of these four points.

  1. Although Pope Leo does much evil, he is truly the pope and a member of the Catholic Church.

As we have seen in past Catholic Candle articles, the Catholic Church infallibly teaches that we will always have a pope and we are not in a 67-year papal interregnum (as most sedevacantists pretend).18 (An interregnum is a period during which the papal throne is briefly vacant between the death (or abdication) of one pope and the election of a new pope).

Presently, our pope is Pope Leo XIV because he is visible to all (as a pope must be)19 and because virtually all Catholics accept him as pope (as is true of every pope).20

Pope Leo is a bad pope and a bad father.21 We must oppose the evil he does22 but must avoid the sedevacantists’ (objective) mortal sins of rashly judging his interior culpability and of denying that he is the pope or is even Catholic.23

This is like a child who has a bad father denying the paternal relationship. That would be wrong. Instead, if the father is bad, then the child must still recognize the paternal relationship and his father’s authority but also refuse to be led astray if his father attempts to cause him to sin.


  1. To save our souls, we must belong to the Catholic Church.

The Catholic Church infallibly teaches that Outside the Church there is no Salvation.24 Thus, to save our souls, it is absolutely necessary that we are members of the Catholic Church.

  1. Because all Catholics are joint members of the Catholic Church, with Pope Leo, we are in communion with him.

“Communion” is the mutual connection between members of the Catholic Church.25

All Catholics are in communion with the pope and with each other because we are all mutually connected as members of the Church under one head, the pope. Id.26

A person can only belong to the Catholic Church by being in communion with all Catholics, under one head, viz., the reigning pope.27 Without being in communion with the pope and all other Catholics, a man is in schism and is outside the Catholic Church.28

  1. Although Catholics are joint members of the Catholic Church with Pope Leo, this does not make us members of whatever other groups he belongs to, including the conciliar church.

Everyone is a member of many groups. For example, at the same time, a person can be:

  • a son in one group (a particular family);

  • a father in another group (a different family);

  • an employee in another group (his corporate employer);

  • a coach in another group (a sports team);

  • a parishioner in another group (a parish);

  • a member of a civic orchestra group;

  • a member (i.e., resident) of his state or province;

  • a member (i.e., citizen) of his country;

  • a member of volunteer civic or religious organization;

  • perhaps a member of the true Catholic Church;

  • perhaps a member of the conciliar church or some other false religion29; and

  • perhaps a member of the Freemasons.

Pope Leo, like everyone else, is a member of many groups. Because we are members of the Catholic Church with Pope Leo and acknowledge that he is pope, this does not make us members of any other group to which he belongs. So, for example, we do not become Americans, Peruvians, Chicagoans, Augustinians, or White Sox fans, merely because he is a member of those groups. Similarly, we are not members of (in communion with) the conciliar church30 simply because he is.31


Conclusion

All Catholics are in communion with Pope Leo because we are members of the Church which he governs as pope. Every Catholic is also in communion with all other Catholics, including mainstream “new mass” Catholics.

Our joint membership with Pope Leo XIV in the Catholic Church does not make us joint members (with Pope Leo) of the conciliar church.


To be continued …


Catholic Candle Addendum:

There is No Such Thing as “Partial Communion” with the Catholic Church

From the above article, we see that all persons who are members of Christ’s Mystical Body are Catholics and only they can go to heaven, since There is No Salvation Outside the Catholic Church.

We see from the above article that all Catholics are in communion with all other Catholics and with the Pope, since this is what it means to be Catholic and not be a schismatic.

As St. Thomas teaches:

Now the unity of the Church consists in two things; namely, in the mutual connection or communion of the members of the Church, and again in the subordination of all the members of the Church to the one head, according to Col. 2:18, 19: “Puffed up by the sense of his flesh, and not holding the Head, from which the whole body, by joints and bands, being supplied with nourishment and compacted, groweth unto the increase of God.” Now this Head is Christ Himself, Whose viceregent in the Church is the Sovereign Pontiff. Wherefore schismatics are those who refuse to submit to the Sovereign Pontiff, and to hold communion with those members of the Church who acknowledge his supremacy.

Summa, IIa IIae, Q.39, a.1, respondeo (emphasis added).

Noah’s Ark is a figure of the Catholic Church, since all persons outside the Ark perished – just as all persons outside the Catholic Church perish and do not go to heaven. Just as no persons were “partially” in Noah’s Ark, likewise there are no persons who are partially in Christ’s Mystical Body or in “partial communion” with the Catholic Church.

The conciliar church promotes the heresy that a person can be in “partial communion” with the Catholic Church. Vatican II promotes this heresy in many places, for example:

For men who believe in Christ and have been properly baptized are put in some, though imperfect, communion with the Catholic Church. Without doubt, the differences that exist in varying degrees between them and the Catholic Church whether in doctrine and sometimes in discipline, or concerning the structure of the Church do indeed create many obstacles, sometimes serious ones, to full ecclesiastical communion. The ecumenical movement is striving to overcome these obstacles. … But even in spite of them it remains true that all who have been justified by faith in baptism are incorporated into Christ.

Unitatis Redintegratio, §3, (emphasis added).

But there is no partial communion with the Church! “Whosoever … is not united with the Body is no member thereof, neither is he in communion with Christ its Head.” Pius XI, Mortalium Animos Jan. 6, 1928, §15.


Conclusion

Thus, we see that the same dogma that teaches us that all Catholics are in communion with the pope, also shows us that the conciliar church teaches heresy when it teaches that persons in heretical sects can be in “partial communion” with Christ and His Mystical Body.

2 The Vatican estimates that the number of Catholics worldwide is about 1.375 billion. https://www.vaticannews.va/en/church/news/2023-10/fides-catholic-church-statistics-world-mission-sunday.html


7 Read this article here: It is Possible for a Pope to Teach Heresy and Remain the Pope?: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/01/27/it-is-possible-for-a-pope-to-teach-heresy-and-remain-the-pope/


8 Read this article here that the Catholic Church’s unified government always continues, even during an interregnum: The Catholic Church Will Always Have a Pope: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/02/21/the-catholic-church-will-always-have-a-pope/

9 Read this article showing that The Catholic Church Will Always be Visible, and Will Always Have a Pope Who is Visible to All, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/03/27/the-catholic-church-will-always-be-visible-with-a-pope/


10 Read this article: The Man Whom the Whole Church Accepts as Pope, IS the Pope: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/04/23/the-man-whom-the-whole-church-accepts-as-pope-is-the-pope/

11 Read this article examining false obedience, entitled, The False “Obedience” of Cowardly and Weak Catholics, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/05/20/the-false-obedience-of-cowardly-and-weak-catholics/


12 Read this article showing that Sedevacantism is Inherently Schism, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/06/28/sedevacantism-is-inherently-schism/


13 Our Catholic Duty: Resist the Harm Done by a Bad Pope But (Of Course) Recognize His Authority: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/07/24/our-catholic-duty-resist-the-harm-done-by-a-bad-pope-but-of-course-recognize-his-authority/


14 Judging the Pope’s Words & Deeds According to Catholic Tradition: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/08/29/judging-the-popes-words-deeds-according-to-catholic-tradition/

15

A Man Need Not Be Consecrated a Bishop or Ordained a Priest to Be a Valid Pope — An Explanation How the Catholic Church Continues to Possess A Full Hierarchy even in these Times of Great Apostasy: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/09/24/a-man-need-not-be-consecrated-a-bishop-or-ordained-a-priest-to-be-a-valid-pope/

16 Sedevacantism is Un-Catholic Because it is Revolutionary: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/10/26/sedevacantism-is-un-catholic-because-it-is-revolutionary/

17 Sedevacantism’s main error is rash judgment, viz., confusing these two things:

  • our duty to judge a pope’s (or anyone’s) objective error on a matter of Faith (i.e., material heresy); and

  • our duty not to judge that person’s subjective, interior culpability for his error (which would be rash judgment).

Sedevacantists rashly presume that the pope believes some error or heresy which he knows is incompatible with being Catholic now and so he “knows” he is not Catholic but he “won’t admit it”. Concerning the sedevacantists’ error of rash judgment, read the full explanation here:

and

18 Read this article here, showing that the Catholic Church’s unified government always continues, even during an interregnum: The Catholic Church Will Always Have a Pope: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/02/21/the-catholic-church-will-always-have-a-pope/

19 Read this article showing that The Catholic Church Will Always be Visible, and Will Always Have a Pope Who is Visible to All, which can be found here: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/03/27/the-catholic-church-will-always-be-visible-with-a-pope/


20 Read this article: The Man Whom the Whole Church Accepts as Pope, IS the Pope: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/04/23/the-man-whom-the-whole-church-accepts-as-pope-is-the-pope/

21 See, for example, this article: The Blessed Virgin Mary Is the Mediatrix of All Graces – Defending Catholic Doctrine and Our Lady’s Honor Against Pope Leo XIV and the Conciliar Barbarians: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/11/25/the-blessed-virgin-mary-is-the-mediatrix-of-all-graces/


22 Our Catholic Duty: Resist the Harm Done by a Bad Pope But (Of Course) Recognize His Authority: https://catholiccandle.org/2025/07/24/our-catholic-duty-resist-the-harm-done-by-a-bad-pope-but-of-course-recognize-his-authority/


23 Sedevacantism’s main error is rash judgment, viz., confusing these two things:

  • our duty to judge a pope’s (or anyone’s) objective error on a matter of Faith (i.e., material heresy); and

  • our duty not to judge that person’s subjective, interior culpability for his error (which would be rash judgment).

Sedevacantists rashly presume that the pope believes something (viz., an error) which he knows is incompatible with being Catholic now. Concerning the sedevacantists’ error or rash judgment, read the full explanation here:

and

24 Here is how Pope Boniface VIII infallibly declares this dogma:

With Faith urging us, we are forced to believe and to hold the one, holy, Catholic Church and that, apostolic, and we firmly believe and simply confess this (Church) outside which there is neither salvation, nor remission of sin.

Unam Sanctam, 1302, Denz. 468.

For more information and more of the Church’s declarations of this dogma, read this article: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/priests/williamson-bishop-williamson-promotes-vatican-ii-heresy-that-people-can-be-saved-outside-the-catholic-church.html

25This article (linked immediately above) discusses Vatican II’s and Bishop Richard Williamson’s heresy denying that there is No Salvation Outside the Catholic Church. This is one of very many heresies of Vatican II and of Bishop Williamson.

Here is how St. Thomas Aquinas admirably explains this truth:

Accordingly, schismatics properly so called are those who, willfully and intentionally separate themselves from the unity of the Church; for this is the chief unity, and the particular unity of several individuals among themselves is subordinate to the unity of the Church, even as the mutual adaptation of each member of a natural body is subordinate to the unity of the whole body. Now the unity of the Church consists in two things; namely, in the mutual connection or communion of the members of the Church, and again in the subordination of all the members of the Church to the one head, according to Col. 2:18, 19: “Puffed up by the sense of his flesh, and not holding the Head, from which the whole body, by joints and bands, being supplied with nourishment and compacted, groweth unto the increase of God.” Now this Head is Christ Himself, Whose viceregent in the Church is the Sovereign Pontiff. Wherefore schismatics are those who refuse to submit to the Sovereign Pontiff, and to hold communion with those members of the Church who acknowledge his supremacy.

Summa, IIa IIae, Q.39, a.1, respondeo (emphasis added).

26 In other words, “communion” is the union which binds together the members of the Church. Here is how Addis & Arnold explain this meaning of “communion”, in their very large, 1884 Catholic Dictionary:

Communion of Saints is mentioned in the ninth article of the Apostle’s Creed, where it is added, according to the Roman Catechism [i.e., the Council of Trent Catechism], as an explanation of the foregoing words, “I believe in the holy Catholic Church.” The communion of saints consists in the union which binds together the members of the Church on earth, and connects the Church on earth with the Church suffering in Purgatory and the triumphant in heaven.

(1) The faithful on earth have communion with each other because they partake of the same sacraments, are under one head, and assist each other by their prayers and good works.

A Catholic Dictionary, Addis & Arnold, The Catholic Publication Society, New York, 1884, under the entry, Communion of Saints (bracketed words and emphasis added).

27 Here is how Pope Boniface VIII declares this truth:

We declare, state, define, and pronounce that it is absolutely necessary for the salvation of every human creature to be subject to the Roman Pontiff.

Bull Unam Sanctam.

Here is how Pope Pius IX declares this truth:

There is only one true, holy, Catholic Church, which is the Apostolic Roman Church. There is only one See founded in Peter by the word of the Lord, outside of which we cannot find either true faith or eternal salvation. He who does not have the Church for a mother cannot have God for a father, and whoever abandons the See of Peter on which the Church is established trusts falsely that he is in the Church.

Singulari Quidem, §4 (emphasis added).

28 Here is how St. Thomas Aquinas admirably explains this truth:

Schismatics are those who refuse to submit to the Sovereign Pontiff, and to hold communion with those members of the Church who acknowledge his supremacy.

Summa, IIa IIae, Q.39, a.1, respondeo.

All Catholics have a duty to recognize that the current pope has authority over us. Even though we frequently cannot do what the pope commands us or hold what he teaches, we must “acknowledge his supremacy”, as St. Thomas teaches we must (in the quote above).

We must do what the pope commands us to do and believe what he teaches, when we can do so in good conscience. Thus, for example, if Pope Leo XIV commanded Catholics to recite at least five decades of the rosary each day, under pain of sin, we would be bound in conscience to do this, under pain of sin.

29 An objection could be made here that a Catholic cannot (at the same time) also be a member of a false religion or of the freemasons. A faithful and informed Catholic knows that being a Catholic is incompatible with belonging to these groups. However, in our time of ecumenism and religious ignorance, much is scandalously permitted that is evil. Catholics are allowed to largely do what they want to do and might not know the truth or might do what they want to despite it being sinful. Do they know better? God will judge. Even though this dual membership (viz., in the Catholic Church and in some false “church” or freemasonic lodge) is an objective mortal sin, we must not judge the sins on their hearts.


It would be the sin of rash judgment for us to decide the subjective culpability of a particular person who tries to, at the same time, be a member of the Catholic Church and also be a member of an anti-Catholic group. Thus, for example, we do not make the determination that Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart was no longer a Catholic (although he professed to be Catholic) based on the fact that he was also a freemason at the same time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolfgang_Amadeus_Mozart

30

The conciliar church is not merely a mindset or a set of opinions, but is a real, organized group of persons. Read the full explanation here: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/priests/sspx-faithful-and-informed-catholics-reject-even-the-concept-of-recognition-by-modernist-rome.html

31 Of course, it would objectively be a mortal sin for a Catholic to join a false religion. However, suppose a very confused Catholic thinks the Catholic Church allows this dual membership (in the Catholic religion and also some other religion). Suppose also he believes he continues to fulfill all conditions for being Catholic. We should not rashly judge that we know he is not Catholic and that if he dies as he is, we would be certain he will go to hell (as would be true if we knew he were not Catholic). Giving him (and everyone else) the benefit of the doubt, we suppose he could possibly be inculpably ignorant and God will judge this, not us.