The SSPX seminary rector encourages us to desire luxury cars during Passiontide

 

Right before the beginning of the holy time of Passiontide, we received Fr. Yves le Roux’s raffle ticket promotion for a new 2020 Jaguar XE luxury car, offered in a SSPX’s fundraiser.  He included a cover letter with his glossy Jaguar promotion. 

 

Fr. le Roux apparently can’t see the irony of trying to get SSPX followers to desire a rich man’s luxury car, while he also warns (in his cover letter) about the dangers of worldly and sensual objects undermining our souls and creating “insatiable needs” which harm our souls.  Here is a shortened version of Fr. le Roux’s words from his cover letter, followed by the words in his enclosed Jaguar promotion:

 

The constant search for his [viz., man’s] satisfactions, conscious or not, undermines man.  The inclination of his senses to enjoy their pleasing objects immediately exerts upon man a true tyranny.  …  Penance is a remedy.  It dries up the source of the insatiable needs that man himself has created and imposes a calming remedy that allows him to turn towards higher things and thus to leave the infernal decline into which he was sinking.  …  [Jaguar promotion:] Support us.  Win a 2020 Jaguar XE.[1] 

 

Despite some pious words, Fr. le Roux is blinded by the “true tyranny” of “pleasing objects” (to use his own words).  He cannot see that he is promoting this very same “tyranny” in his followers. 

 

As greatly as Fr. le Roux (and the SSPX) are harming the soul of the person who will actually win that rich man’s car, Fr. le Roux also does tremendous harm to all of his followers by promoting worldly desires in them.  (Fr. le Roux wants them all to strongly desire that luxury car so that they will buy many raffle tickets.)

 

Fr. le Roux’s example is the opposite of Our Lord Jesus Christ, Who teaches us to:

 

Be not solicitous therefore, saying, what shall we eat: or what shall we drink, or wherewith shall we be clothed?  For after all these things do the heathens seek.  For your Father knoweth that you have need of all these things.  Seek ye therefore first the kingdom of God, and His justice, and all these things shall be added unto you.

 

St. Matthew’s Gospel, 6:31-33.

 

St. Thomas Aquinas, greatest Doctor of the Catholic Church, approves of and quotes the teaching of the Venerable Bede, Doctor of the Church, who especially warns priests to avoid that worldly focus we see in the “new”, liberal SSPX.  Here are St. Bede’s words:

 

For such should be the preacher’s trust in God, that, though he takes no thought for supplying his own wants in this present world, yet he should feel most certain that these will not be left unsatisfied, lest whilst his mind is taken up with temporal things, he should provide less of eternal things to others.[2]

 

Likewise, St. Thomas Aquinas approves of and quotes the teaching of Pope St. Gregory the Great, Doctor of the Church, who warns priests about the evil of being money-focused.  Here are his words:

 

For the preacher (of the Gospel) ought to have such trust in God, that although he has provided not for the expenses of this present life, he should still be most certainly convinced that these will not fail him; lest while his mind is engaged in his temporal things, he should be less careful for the spiritual things of others.[3]

 

By Fr. le Roux hawking Jaguar raffle tickets, he certainly focuses on temporal concerns, against the warnings given by Our Lord and the Doctors of the Church.

 

It might be that Fr. le Roux thinks he has “no choice” but to regularly ask for money because otherwise his followers would not give it.  But he should compare his money-focus to the instruction given to priests in St. Thomas Aquinas’s work on St. Luke’s Gospel:

 

However small in amount and vile is the food that you are given, ask for nothing more.”[4]

 

 

Conclusion                                                    

 

Truly, Fr. le Roux and the N-SSPX are the blind leading the blind.  As Our Lord warns us, they all fall into the pit. 

 

Above, blind Fr. le Roux incoherently warns about desiring the type of luxury goods that he wants his followers to desire.  As he tells us, these desires cause a man to sink further down the infernal path.

 

More than at any other time of year, Passiontide is a time for a higher focus than Fr. le Roux’s!

 

Let us continue to pity and pray for Fr. le Roux and his worldly SSPX!



[1]           Quoted from Fr. le Roux’s letter dated “Ash Wednesday 2020” but actually received weeks later on March 27, 2020 (emphasis added).

[2]           Words of the Venerable Bede, Doctor of the Church, from Catena Aurea on St. Mark’s Gospel, St. Thomas Aquinas, editor, ch.6, §2.

[3]           Words of Pope St. Gregory the Great, Doctor of the Church, from the Catena Aurea on St. Luke’s Gospel, St. Thomas Aquinas, editor, ch.10, §2 (parenthetical words in the original).


[4]           St. Thomas Aquinas approves of and quotes these words of Bishop Theophylactus, a learned 11th Century Bible scholar, commenting on Our Lord’s instruction to his disciples “Eat such things as are set before you” (St. Luke’s Gospel, 10:8).  Catena Aurea on St. Luke’s Gospel, St. Thomas Aquinas, editor, ch.10, §3.

 

In The Imitation of Christ, the Voice of Christ tell Fr. le Roux and the rest of us: “[D]esire nothing outside of Me.” The Imitation of Christ, Book III, Ch. 25 (emphasis added).

 

 

A compromise group’s Masses and sacraments do not give grace

People should avoid the Masses (and sacraments) of a compromise group, e.g., the N-SSPX[1] or another indult group or “motu proprio”[2] group, or Bishop Williamson’s group,[3] or the sedevacantists[4].  This is true even when that group has valid Masses and sacraments.

The Mass and the sacraments are good in themselves and are themselves causes of grace.[5]  However, this does not mean that valid Masses and sacraments always cause grace.  For sometimes they involve compromises and defects which are sins and are obstacles to grace.[6]

The end does not justify the means.  So, we cannot use sin (a bad means) to obtain grace (a good end).  When it is a sin to attend a particular group’s (or priest’s) Mass or sacraments because of compromises and errors, then those Masses and sacraments cannot do us good because the end does not justify the means and God does not give us grace through our sinning.[7]

Conclusion

When a Mass or sacrament is from a compromise group or is otherwise (objectively) sinful, then no one should attend or receive the Mass/sacrament.  Let us not attend any compromise Masses or receive (or attend) any compromise sacraments, telling ourselves that we “need our sacraments”! 

God knows better than we do what we need and provides for us better than we understand.  “All things work together unto the good for those who love God.”  Romans, 8:28.



[1]           For many articles showing that the SSPX is a compromise group, read the articles in the Society of St. Pius X folder found here: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/

[2]           For twenty reasons the indult (“motu proprio”) Mass is objectively sinful, read this article: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/20-reasons-motu-proprio.html

 

[3]           For many articles showing that Bishop Williamson’s group is a compromise group, read the articles in the Bp. Williamson folder found here: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/

[4]           The sedevacantists are inherently in schism from the Catholic Church, although some of them might not know better and so might not be culpable for their grave sin.  https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/against-sedevacantism.html

 

[5]           The Sacraments are instrumental causes of grace (“ex opere operato”).  See, session VII, canon VIII.  The Council of Trent distinguishes (on the one hand) the seven Sacraments – which cause grace – from other good works and prayers (on the other hand) through which we obtain grace, which are not themselves causes of grace.  Reciting a Hail Mary is not a direct cause of grace.  Rather, it is a pious occasion which disposes us and prompts God to give grace – but not through that prayer as a cause.

 

[6]           One obvious example of this is a satanic Black Mass which, even when it is valid is still sinful and does not give grace.  For further information concerning why a person might not receive grace from a valid mass or sacrament, read this article: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/new-mass-never-grace.html

 


[7]           Here is how St. Thomas Aquinas, greatest Doctor of the Catholic Church, explains that when a (valid) Sacrament is a sin, then “in consequence” it does not give grace:

[S]ome have contended that heretics, schismatics, and the excommunicated, who are outside the pale of the Church, cannot perform this Sacrament [viz., the Holy Eucharist]. But herein they are deceived, because, as Augustine says (Contra Parmen. ii), it is one thing to lack something utterly, and another to have it improperly; and in like fashion, it is one thing not to bestow, and quite another to bestow, but not rightly. … [S]ince the consecration of the Eucharist is an act which follows the power of order, such persons as are separated from the Church by heresy, schism, or excommunication, can indeed consecrate the Eucharist, which on being consecrated by them contains Christ’s true body and blood; but they act wrongly, and sin by doing so; and in consequence they do not receive the fruit of the sacrifice [viz., grace]….

Summa, III, Q.82, a.7, Respondeo (emphasis and bracketed words and letters added).

For a further analysis of this issue, read this article: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/new-mass-never-grace.html

What manner of man am I? Dealing with Typical Human Tendencies – Frustration & Discouragement

 

Objective Truth Series – reflections article #9

 

In our last reflection we considered some methods on how we can be on our guard against pride.  We discussed how the devil can find our weak spot and subsequently attack us.  Two typical ways the devil works against us weak humans with our fallen human nature, is to tempt us with frustration and discouragement.  If we look at the word frustration, it is easy to see how it is precisely a tool of the devil.  The dictionary explains that the word frustration comes from the Latin word frustrare meaning to deceive, and then that frustra means vain, or useless.  The definition of frustrate is “1) to bring to nothing; defeat, also to nullify, and 2) implies a rendering vain or ineffectual all efforts, however feeble or vigorous.”[1] This shows the subtle trap of the devil who wants us to give up making any efforts.

 

This trap can likewise be seen in the following definitions for some synonyms of frustrate.

 

·         Thwart – frustration by running counter to one’s making headway.

 

·         Foil – a repulse that destroys one’s inclination to go further.

 

·         Baffle- a frustration by confusing or puzzling.

 

·         Balk – implies frustration by interposing obstacles or hindrances.

 

It is very interesting to note the thread that all these definitions have in common is that to be frustrated is not for our good.  One can see how frustrations are a diabolical trap to foster demonic pride – precisely because to be frustrated is to not put sole trust in God and His provident care for us.  It is to allow ourselves to get upset or discouraged because something did not turn out the way we wanted, namely, we didn’t get our way in something.  It encourages us to be self-centered and not God-centered which is how pride works.  Likewise, the devil uses frustration to foster discouragement in us so we give up trying to cooperate with God in our salvation.

 

“For if a man be a hearer of the word, and not a doer, he shall be compared to a man beholding his own countenance in a glass.  For he beheld himself, and went his way, and presently forgot what manner of man he was.”  St. James, 1:23-24.

 

We forget what manner of man we are, namely, a creature who depends on God.  When we get frustrated, we simply forget our dependence on God and that we can do nothing without Him.  To be frustrated is to really not look for God’s Will in the circumstances at hand.  We must remember God allows circumstances for the greater good – “all things work for the good for those who love God.”  We must remind ourselves, “This is for my good.”

 

Likewise, when we are tempted to discouragement, it is important to note that this discouragement really comes from the devil because he wants us to think that we can accomplish something by ourselves, without God’s help.  And when we fail to succeed, we are disheartened.  This is the method the devil uses to get us to give up.

 

As we discussed in the last reflection, we must do an agere contra [counter–action] immediately in order to combat this trick of Satan.  For example, we must reflect that God wills that we suffer patiently and humble ourselves.  Moreover, the learning of virtue takes practice over time.  Other possible agere contras that we could say within ourselves are: “Everything is in Thy Hands, O Lord”; “Thy will be done, O Lord, not my will,” or “What will this [circumstance] matter after I’m dead?”

 

Another agere contra to use when one is discouraged, is to try to get one’s mind off of himself by thinking of the needs of others. For example, there are so many pagans in the world that need to be converted.  As our Lady of Fatima said that so many souls go to hell because they have no one to pray for them.

 

One could then think how much God has blest him with so many undeserved blessings.  Further, counting one’s blessings is another powerful way to go against Satan’s pomps and works and to foster humility.

 

Last, but not least, is to pray – whether it be an ejaculation or longer prayer – in order to fight against the temptation to be frustrated or discouraged.

 

With the above in mind one sees his great need to beg the Holy Ghost for His Light and His Grace to want God’s Will always to reign in us, and the following may come to mind:

 

 

O Holy Ghost, O Paraclete,

Why do I try, to e’er compete?

Against Thy Will, and what’s in store,

Why do I not, Thy guidance implore?

 

 

 

How could I think, my way is best?

And see events, as only a pest?

Why do I, second guess Thy Will?

And thinking, I know better still?

.

And as a result, I do find,

Only frustration, in my mind,

True peace within, cannot exist,

When I try, Thy Will to resist.

 

Then comes the, “feel sorry for me,”

Getting my fill of self-pity,

Discouragement, then takes its hold,

Shame on me, for being so bold.

 

Let me see, Lord, my only need,

Only with Thy Will, am I freed,

From endless worry in my life,

That there should not be any strife.

 

‘Tis only Thy Will, should be sought,

And only my will, should be fought,

Thou dost send me, what is sublime,

Looking for Thy Will, all the time.

 

There’s only one, true joy for me,

That is to stay, one heart with Thee,

Not for myself, anything seek,

I want to be, like Thee so Meek.

 

For this I pray, that Thou wouldst grant,

 Thy Holy Will, in my heart plant,

So firmly in me, I won’t desire,

To ever leave, Thy Guiding Fire.

 

Then e’er Thy Will, would be my goal.

Filling me, with wonder, in my soul,

Then thou wouldst be, Oh Paraclete,

My happiness, ever complete!



[1] Webster’s 6th New Collegiate Dictionary [emphasis added]

A Traditional Catholic funeral when there is no uncompromising priest available

Catholic Candle note: Recently, Catholic Candle published an article examining the special permission that the Church traditionally gives to a Catholic who is dying, which allows him to confess to a priest to whom he could not otherwise confess because that priest is an apostate, a sedevacantist, a compromiser, or had some other serious problem.  That article is here: https://catholiccandle.org/2020/03/26/using-a-compromised-priest-when-dying/

 

The article below is based on the authors’ experience of assisting at three Traditional Catholic funerals and burials without a priest, because we knew of (and know of) no uncompromising priest to help us.  It seems that funerals and burials without a priest might now become the usual method.  Truly, we seem to be in the time prophesied by Our Lady of La Salette when she predicted in 1846 that “the Church will be in eclipse.”[1]

 

However, it would be an error and overreaction to the evils of our present time, to rashly suppose that we have no pope and hierarchy (as bad as that pope and hierarchy are).  Catholics are not in a time without shepherds.  We are in a time of exceedingly bad shepherds.

 

Sedevacantism is wrong and is (material or formal) schism.  Catholic Candle is not sedevacantist.  On the contrary, we published a series of articles showing that sedevacantism is false (and also showing that former Pope Benedict is not still the pope).  Read the articles here: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/against-sedevacantism.html 

 

 

A Traditional Catholic funeral and burial when there is no uncompromising priest available

 

At our death, we would want a Traditional Requiem Mass, including the hymns of the requiem Mass.  This is good and reasonable.

 

 

We must avoid a compromise wake, funeral, and burial.

 

But God lovingly placed us in this time of Great Apostasy, for His greater glory and for our good.[2]  He does not want us to have a Requiem Mass for our funeral when no uncompromising priest is available.  Such a compromise funeral (viz., with a compromise priest) is a sin.  It would anger God if we were to use a compromising priest – through our rationalizing that “he is the best we can find” and that “we need our funeral Mass”.  Such compromises are sins for us and do not help our dearly departed.

 

If our loved ones told us while alive that they want a funeral which is, in reality, a compromise, we should not agree.  Further, after their death, we should not cooperate with their compromising plan.  This is like our obligation not to consent to their wish for cremation nor to cooperate in carrying out that wish.[3] 

 

Before our loved one died, he might not have understood why we must stand firm and refuse his wish for a compromise funeral and burial.  But after his death he will see we are correct and he will understand then.  Seeing more clearly after death, he would not want us to follow the sinful wishes he expressed while alive. 

 

Our relatives and friends might become upset because we remain firm in the Faith out of love for God.  If our relatives get angry, this might be a Providential opportunity for discussions through which they might learn the truth.  In any event, their negative reaction would be a Cross that our Dear Lord lovingly sends us for our good and for His greater glory.

 

 

The Natural Law[4] shows us the importance of conducting respectful, loving funerals for our dearly departed.

 

Our love for our dearly-departed and the Natural Law require us to respectfully, prayerfully bury them.  St. Augustine, Doctor of the Church, describes the natural piety all men should have, which demands respect for the dead even on the natural level:

 

[I]f the dress of a father, or his ring, or anything he wore, be precious to his children, in proportion to the love they bore him, with how much more reason ought we to care for the bodies of those we love, which they wore far more closely and intimately than any clothing!  For the body is not an extraneous ornament or aid, but a part of man’s very nature.  And therefore, to the righteous of ancient times the last offices were piously rendered, and sepulchers provided for them, and obsequies celebrated; and they themselves, while yet alive, gave commandment to their sons about the burial.[5]

 

All civilized peoples honor their dead and treat the bodies of the dead respectfully.  Not only those persons who live the true Catholic Faith, but even the more civilized pagan peoples wish to keep alive the memory of their dearly departed, even though those same pagans flounder in great error, in other ways.

 

 

Our holy Faith elevates to a supernatural level our obsequies which are prompted by our love for our departed relatives and friends.

 

But our Holy Mother the Church does so much more than foster these natural attentions!  She is a true mother of Her children and She lovingly cares not only for their deceased bodies and their memories but more importantly, for their immortal souls.  Our Faith teaches us that at the moment of our death we are judged and our eternal destiny is fixed.  Although most people go to hell,[6] among those who save their souls most of them must endure the great sufferings of Purgatory. 

 

Holy Mother Church knows their great need and lovingly channels our grief into helping them in their plight.  The Church has us devote ourselves to praying for them.  This is a very consoling aspect of our holy Catholic Faith.

 

 

But what good can we do for our departed loved ones, without obtaining a Requiem Mass for them?

 

When we refuse to accept a Requiem Mass from a compromise priest or group, out of love for God, He will bless our loved one through other means instead.  For example, God has given incredible power to the Holy Rosary in our times since we do not have the Mass and sacraments.[7]

 

God is not abandoning us or our loved ones.  He is merely changing His means of sanctifying us and them, to fit the circumstances into which He lovingly put us. 

 

Out of love for God and the true Faith, Catholics must courageously stand against liberalism and compromise.  But God is never outdone in generosity and in His rewards!

 

Nor is it the first time in history, that faithful Catholics had to bury their dead without a priest and Requiem Mass.  Sometimes, physical persecution caused the absence of a good priest and Requiem Mass.  For example, God called Japanese Catholics to this condition for almost 300 years (1587-1873).[8]  At other times, the sheer expanse of great wilderness meant that faithful Catholics died and were buried without the assistance of a priest.[9]

 

 

How do we conduct a wake, funeral and burial of our loved one, without a priest?

 

Not all wakes, funerals and burials present the same extent of opportunities for our Catholic acts of piety.  Below, we briefly recount our recommendations, some of which are based on what we have done in past wakes, funerals and burials without a priest.  We add some additional recommendations that we will use in the future, according to circumstances.

 

After our loved one’s death, we plan the schedule and invite/announce the schedule in a manner similar to the customary way for any funeral and burial.  Everyone is welcome!  Praying together is an occasion to benefit from our Lord’s promise: “where there are two or three gathered together in My name, there am I in the midst of them”.[10] 

 

We recommend that you combine the wake/visitation and the funeral at the funeral home.  We have found funeral homes to be very accommodating.  Schedule the wake/visitation to occur first, leaving the appropriate number of hours based on the number of people you expect.  Schedule the funeral prayers at the end of that visitation.  Right after those funeral prayers, accompany the body in a funeral procession to the cemetery.

 

 

Funeral prayers

 

We have used the funeral home’s director to announce the beginning of the funeral prayers, similar to the customary way that funeral home directors have often announced that the recitation of the Rosary was about to begin at a wake.  Again, we have found funeral homes to be very accommodating. 

 

Recite the Sorrowful Mysteries of the Rosary.  Reason and Catholic Tradition show that the Sorrowful Mysteries of the Rosary are the fitting set of mysteries for a funeral, whereas the liberals and conciliar Catholics often use the Glorious Mysteries at a wake or the graveside (if they pray the rosary at all) to suggest that the deceased is already in glory and that everyone goes to heaven. 

 

The Sorrowful Mysteries fit with the other signs of sorrow the Church has customarily used on a funeral day, e.g., black is the liturgical color of the day, with ornaments removed from the altar or shrouded in penitential wrappings, purple is the color of the tabernacle veil, symbolizing penance.  Requiem Masses omit the Gloria and other signs of rejoicing.  Clearly, a wake or graveside is not the time for the Glorious Mysteries and for rejoicing.

 

In addition to the Sorrowful Mysteries of the Rosary, say such other prayers as are fitting, for example:

 

·         The Memorare (“Remember, Oh Most Gracious Virgin Mary…”)

 

·         The Hail Holy Queen

 

·         Oh God, Whose Only begotten Son

 

·         The St. Michael the Archangel prayer

 

·         Psalm 129

 

·         Psalm 50

 

·         Various invocations of St. Joseph, patron of a holy death

 

·         Eternal rest grant unto him (or her), Oh Lord …

 

The prayers listed above are the ones we have used to date (based on the length of the funeral prayers requested by the family of the dearly departed).  But perhaps in future funerals we will read the prayers of the requiem Mass.  This could be done slowly and prayerfully, in Latin – this works out surprisingly well.  Meanwhile, everyone else reads the translated prayers in his own missal.  Many of you might choose that the Mass prayers be read out loud in English, although reading them in the Roman Church’s own language (Latin) is a great idea and allows everyone else to use his own missal’s translation.

 

Another idea we have reserved for a possible future use is to have one of the men read a Traditional Catholic sermon for a funeral Mass or On Death, especially one from a Doctor of the Church.[11]  Such a sermon would be a good reminder and source of instruction for the faithful and would be a work of apostolate, “planting seeds” among non-Catholics and conciliar Catholics who are present.  

 

Don’t open the occasion up to everyone offering his own public prayers.  Do not allow people to ad lib “prayers”, protestant style, such as: “Lord, thank you for giving me those years playing basketball with [name]”.  Keep the prayers Catholic!  Keep them Traditional! 

 

In our times of great apostasy, the moral support and consolations from these prayers, which the bereaved family and friends experience, is similar to what customarily occurs at a Catholic funeral and burial.

 

 

Requiem hymns

 

Besides these traditional prayers, sing Traditional Catholic requiem hymns.  As St. Augustine assures us: “He who sings, prays twice.”[12]

 

Our Faith is wonderfully rich in traditional Catholic hymns, especially Gregorian Chant.  Challenge yourself!  Be generous and sing all of the verses.  Our Lord is never out-done in generosity!

 

If possible, put together a schola to sing some of the traditional funeral hymns, e.g., the Dies Irae and the Libera me from the Requiem Mass.  If you don’t know these hymns, then learn them now so you are ready!  They are beautiful and will prepare you to assist in this schola for future funerals “in the catacombs”. 

For the glory of God, if you are learning the requiem hymns, you can use the sheet music here: https://www.scribd.com/document/452943209/Requiem-Mass-Sheet-Music

You can practice these hymns by singing along with these recordings (linked below):

 

 

Gradual from the Requiem Mass

 

·         Audio recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZS23Z94NLM

 

·         Scrolling sheet music and recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zpHs8bf4k4

 

Tract from the Requiem Mass:

 

·         Scrolling sheet music and recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=np_slIOn5Jk

 

·         Audio recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bTJH-vbTY8Y

 

 

Dies Irae, the sequence of the Requiem Mass:

·         Audio recording: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f2/Dies.irae.ogg

·         Alternate sheet music and recording: http://gregorian-chant-hymns.com/hymns-2/dies-ire.html

 

 

Libera me:

 

·         Audio recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S2_pnxN-tes

 

·         Audio recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4sI0gZkYFGk

 

 

In Paradisum:

 

·         Audio recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gu7mM_zqapA

 

·         Audio recording and scrolling sheet music: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S7F-N-Yd8dE

 

These are the Requiem hymns we have used in funerals to date. 

 

The above Catholic prayers and hymns give fitting and traditional channels for our grief.  No one knows how to grieve and to pay his last respects better than a Traditional Catholic.  The Church shows us how to do this – with these prayers and hymns.

 

 

No Eulogy

 

Do not give a eulogy!  Our goal at this funeral is primarily to do good to the deceased.  This means praying for the deceased, not praising him so that people suppose that the deceased does not need prayers, e.g., “He (or she) never said an unkind word in his life.” 

 

Likewise, we should never say the deceased is in heaven: “He is looking down from a better place, smiling upon us”.  That is un-Catholic! It sends the wrong message in three ways:

 

Ø  It falsifies the truth.  Despite our love for the deceased (and, perhaps, our personal admiration for him), we don’t know he is in heaven, so we should not suggest that we know he is there.

 

Ø  It tells people they should not pray for the deceased and he does not need prayers, since he is already in heaven.  For the same reason it is bad for us to say “let us pray for him in case he is not in heaven already.”  This suggests that praying for him is not very important because it is unlikely that he needs the prayers anyway. Some so-called “conservative” conciliar groups, such as the indult groups (including the N-SSPX[13]) incoherently say both that the person is in heaven and also that we should pray for him.[14]  This is not only inconsistent but is also contrary to what the deceased person now would want.  The deceased person does not now care that people think he was wonderful.  He wants and needs prayers for his repose!  Don’t work against what he needs by eulogizing him!

 

Ø  We are not exceptionally holy, nor are our deceased loved ones.  If we suggest by our eulogy that ordinary Catholics (like us and them) go straight to heaven (bypassing Purgatory) so that we know they are in heaven at the time of the funeral, it misleads people into falsely believing that it is easy to go straight to heaven.  Although all of us should explicitly have as our goal to be straight-to-heaven saints, this is difficult to accomplish (although a very worthy goal).  The great saints achieved this goal.  But we mislead people and falsify the difficulty of being straight-to-heaven saints when we suggest ordinary Catholics achieve this goal.

 

 

Burial at the cemetery

 

When the funeral procession arrives at the cemetery, recite the Sorrowful Mysteries of the Rosary again, together, and lower the casket into the grave during the Rosary.  Remember, the Rosary is especially powerful in our times when uncompromising priests are unavailable to us.

 

Continue the Rosary while witnessing the dirt being placed in the hole.  Witnessing the burial itself serves to add further closure to the event and our grief. 

 

At one burial, we placed flowers on the casket before it was lowered into the ground (and before the start of the Rosary).  At another burial, we dropped flowers onto the casket as soon as it was lowered into the ground.  These are pleasing human gestures, symbolizing that our hearts are buried with our loved one’s body.  We used flowers we brought from the funeral.  You could use these gestures if you wish.

 

At two burials, we instructed the cemetery (ahead of time) to provide a pile of dirt and a shovel.  Then one of the men starts by placing a few shovels-full of dirt into the hole, then offering the shovel to other men (especially the close friends and relatives) to follow his example and place shovels of dirt into the hole.  This is literal participation in the Corporal Work of Mercy, To Bury the Dead. 

 

In our experience, the cemeteries have been very accommodating to these requests.  It is not necessary to continue this burial ceremony longer than you deem best.  The cemetery workers will complete the task. 

 

With the burial concluded, we find our souls consoled.  We have the satisfaction of having truly grieved in the way the Catholic Church wants us to grieve and knows we need to.

 

After leaving the cemetery, you can have a post-burial luncheon, as is customary in many places.

 

 

Additional reflections

 

Keep things organized.  Arrange ahead of time for one of the men to lead the prayers, with everyone else answering.  We have found that some conciliar Catholics join in answering too, praying with us, and even some protestants do also.  Although Catholics must never participate in non-Catholic prayer assemblies, the funeral we are describing is a Catholic funeral and the Church does not bar non-Catholics from joining in these Catholic prayers recited by Catholics at a Catholic event.[15]  This is no different than anytime in the history of the Church when a non-Catholic attended a Catholic wake or Catholic funeral or burial and joined in the public (Catholic) prayers recited there.

 

We find that this funeral and burial open up conversations afterwards, with non-Catholics and conciliar Catholics and provide opportunities to inform them about the Catholic Faith.  However, whether non-Catholics and conciliar Catholics react negatively or positively, this funeral and burial are a great opportunity to stand for Christ the King and live our Faith openly and fearlessly.

 

Of course, our attire for the funeral and burial should be our best funeral clothes (church clothes).   This is important.  It reminds us that what we are doing is important and is dedicated to God.  Our fallen human nature inclines to sloth and responds to this idea by saying “we know we’re speaking to God even without dressing up.”  True, but the proper clothes show the proper respect for the dead and, besides that, we need the help of this reminder.  This is just like it is important (and is the Catholic way) for a priest to dress like a priest even among persons who don’t need to be informed by what he wears, that he is a priest.

 

Proper attire also helps us give a good example to others, who often come to funerals in casual, torn and slovenly clothes.

 

Sprinkle holy water on the grave and the casket.

 

Select funeral cards and prayers which pertain to seeking mercy for the deceased.  Pick pictures of the Sacred Heart of Jesus, of the Immaculate Heart of Mary, of the Crucifixion, of the Agony in the Garden, etc.

 

Avoid all suggestion on the funeral card (in the picture and the text) that the deceased is known to be in heaven.  For example, do not select a resurrection picture for the funeral card.  Do not select a conciliar prayer for the back of the card.  Have the funeral card state when the person died, not when he “entered into eternal life” because “entering into eternal life” means he went to heaven.[16]

 

 

Conclusion

 

The best thing we can do for our deceased loved one, is to give him an uncompromising Traditional Catholic funeral and burial.  We must uphold the Faith and not succumb to the sentimentality or human respect of using a compromise priest or group because our dearly departed “needs his Requiem Mass”. 

 

The above article provides ideas how to conduct an uncompromising funeral and burial.  Many of these ideas have been successfully used in three funerals and burials.



[1]           This is a portion of the message of Our Lady of La Salette on September 19, 1846.  Of course, the Church will continue until the end of the world because She is indefectible.

[2]           “All things work together unto the good for those who love God.”  Romans, 8:28.

 

[4]           The Natural Law is what we know we must do by the light of the natural reason God gave us.  One example of the Natural Law is that we must never tell a lie.  We naturally know this because we know that the purpose of speech is to convey the truth and so we naturally know that telling a lie is abusing the purpose of speech. 

 

Here is how St. Thomas explains what the Natural Law is:

 

[L]aw, being a rule and measure, can be in a person in two ways: in one way, as in him that rules and measures; in another way, as in that which is ruled and measured, since a thing is ruled and measured, in so far as it partakes of the rule or measure.  Wherefore, since all things subject to Divine providence are ruled and measured by the eternal law, as was stated above [in Summa, Ia IIae, Q.91, a.1]; it is evident that all things partake somewhat of the eternal law, in so far as, namely, from its being imprinted on them, they derive their respective inclinations to their proper acts and ends.  Now among all others, the rational creature is subject to Divine providence in the most excellent way, in so far as it partakes of a share of providence, by being provident both for itself and for others.  Wherefore it has a share of the Eternal Reason, whereby it has a natural inclination to its proper act and end: and this participation of the eternal law in the rational creature is called the natural law.  Hence the Psalmist after saying (Psalm 4:6): "Offer up the sacrifice of justice," as though someone asked what the works of justice are, adds: "Many say, Who showeth us good things?" in answer to which question he says: "The light of Thy countenance, O Lord, is signed upon us": thus implying that the light of natural reason, whereby we discern what is good and what is evil, which is the function of the natural law, is nothing else than an imprint on us of the Divine light. It is therefore evident that the natural law is nothing else than the rational creature’s participation of the eternal law.

 

Summa, Ia IIae, Q.91, a.2, respondeo.

[5]           City of God, St. Augustine, Bk. 1, Ch. 13.

 

[6]           Our Lord tells us that most people go to hell.  For example:

 

Enter ye in at the narrow gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way that leadeth to destruction, and many there are who go in thereat.  How narrow is the gate, and strait is the way that leadeth to life: and few there are that find it!

 

St. Matthew’s Gospel, 7:13 (emphasis added).

 

See also, the sermon of St. Leonard of Port Maurice, On the Small Number of those who are Saved, in which he quotes a long string of Doctors of the Church and other sacred writers who teach that most people damn themselves.


[7]           There is an Increased Power of the Holy Rosary during the present Great Apostasy, when an uncompromising Requiem Mass is unavailable, at least in most places.  Sister Lucy, seer at Fatima, revealed to Fr. Fuentes:

 

God is giving two last remedies to the world: the Holy Rosary and devotion to the Immaculate Heart of Mary.  …  Prayer and sacrifice are the two means to save the world.  As for the Holy Rosary, Father, in these last times in which we are living, the Blessed Virgin has given a new efficacy to the praying of the Holy Rosary.  This in such a way that there is no problem that cannot be resolved by praying the Rosary, no matter how difficult it is – be it temporal or above all spiritual ….

 

Words of Sister Lucy, seer at Fatima, from her December 26, 1957 interview by Fr. Augustin Fuentes, vice-postulator of the cause of beatification for Francisco and Jacinta.  (Emphasis added.)  This interview can be found at: http://radtradthomist.chojnowski.me/2019/03/is-this-interview-that-caused-her.html


[8]           See, 1917 Catholic Encyclopedia, article: Japanese Martyrs. 

 

[9]           For example, there was an acute priest shortage in the vast expanses of Ecuador in the 1800s.  Read about this here: Latin America, A Sketch of its Glorious Catholic Roots and a Snapshot of its Present, by the Editors of Quanta Cura Press, p.119, © 2016.


[10]         St. Matthew’s Gospel, 18:20.

[11]         St. Alphonsus de Liguori’s Preparation for Death would be an excellent source.

[12]         Although this quotation is very often attributed to St. Augustine, we cannot find where this quote is in his works in this exact form.  However, St. Augustine teaches the substance of this quote in his Commentary on the Psalms, Ps., 73, §1.

 

[13]         The N-SSPX is correctly counted among the indult groups because Pope Francis has given the liberal SSPX two indults: for confessions and marriages.

[14]         Read, e.g., the N-SSPX’s declaration that one of their deceased priests is known to have entered heaven on the day he died: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/priests/sspx-travels-the-conciliar-path-toward-promoting-universal-salvation.html

[15]         From the beginning of the Church, She has forbidden Her children to take part in ecumenical prayer groups with non-Catholics.  Pope Pius XI reflected this consistent prohibition when he declared:

 

So, Venerable Brethren, it is clear why this Apostolic See has never allowed its subjects to take part in the assemblies of non-Catholics: for the union of Christians can only be promoted by promoting the return to the one true Church of Christ.

 

Pope Pius XI, Mortalium Animos, January 6, 1928. ¶10. 

 

For more information regarding the Church’s prohibition on praying in ecumenical or non-Catholic assemblies, read Lumen Gentium Annotated, by Quanta Cura Press, p.141, footnote #147, © 2013, available at:

v  https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B49oPuI54eEGbzRhdmQ3X0Z6RFE/view (free) and

v  https://scribd.com/doc/158994906 (free)

 

v  at Amazon.com https://www.amazon.com/dp/1492107476?tag=duckduckgo-ffab-20&linkCode=osi&th=1&psc=1 (sold at cost).

 

[16]         The phrase “Eternal Life” means heaven. For example, here are Our Lord’s words, when He is describing how at the Final Judgment, at the end of the world, everyone will go to either hell or heaven:

 

And these [viz., the wicked] shall go into eternal punishment: but the just, into

Eternal Life.

 

St. Matthew’s Gospel, 25:46 (emphasis added).

 

Here is another example of Eternal Life meaning heaven – i.e., the Beatific Vision which Our Lord describes here:

 

Now this is Eternal Life:  That they may know thee, the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom thou hast sent. 

 

St. John’s Gospel, 17:3.

Strategies for Lightening the Crosses You Now Have

Catholic Candle note: The article below might seem as if it were addressed to only a select few people.  But it is mainly aimed at helping us ordinary people more easily carry the crosses we currently have.  Although the strategies (of thanking God for our crosses and praying for more of them) might seem counterintuitive when we struggle so hard even to carry the crosses we already have, these strategies do work in a marvelous way!

 

 

We want to go to heaven.  But we know that the road to heaven is narrow and few people even find the road, much less, travel along it.[1]

 

We know that we must not only passively receive the cross placed on our backs but we must take up the cross ourselves and place it willingly on our own backs.[2]  But this is very difficult to do!

 

First, let us remember that the cross is much more valuable than we realize. 

 

St. John Chrysostom, Doctor of the Church, taught us the value of crosses in these words:

 

If God were to grant you the gift of raising the dead, He would be giving you much less than when He permits you to suffer.  In fact, with the gift of miracles He makes you His debtor, but with sufferings He makes Himself your debtor.[3]

 

Here is how the Imitation of Christ extolls the value of crosses:

 

In the cross is salvation; in the cross is life; in the cross is protection from thy enemies.  

 

In the cross is infusion of heavenly sweetness; the cross is strength of mind; in the cross is joy of spirit.

 

In the cross is the height of virtue; in the cross is the perfection of sanctity.

 

There is no health of soul nor hope of eternal life but in the cross.  …

 

If, indeed, there had been anything better and more beneficial to man’s salvation than suffering, Christ certainly would have showed it by word and example.[4]

 

The Venerable Sr. Mary Victoria Angelini described the value of crosses in this way:

 

An ounce of crosses is worth more than a thousand pounds of prayer; a day of crucifixion is more valuable than one hundred years of all other holy exercises.  It is of more value to stay one moment on the cross than to enjoy all the delights of paradise.[5]

 

 

The Church tells us that it is advantageous for us to seek more crosses

 

Further, not only are crosses extremely valuable, but the great spiritual masters tell us to seek more crosses.

 

Here is how the Imitation of Christ teaches us that we should seek crosses:

 

Thou errest, thou errest, if thou seekest any other thing than to suffer tribulations ….

 

            You deceive yourself, you are mistaken, if you seek anything but to

            suffer.

 

Alas!  How few there are that desire to suffer![6]

 

The Imitation of Christ points out that it is a defect in man that he does not desire to suffer for Christ:

 

Jesus has now many lovers of His heavenly kingdom, but few that are willing to bear His cross.  He has many that are desirous of comfort, but few of tribulation.  He finds many companions of His table, but few of His abstinence.[7]

 

The Imitation of Christ teaches that Christ wants us to love to die on the cross:

 

He died for thee upon the cross thou mayst also bear thy cross and love to die on the cross.[8]

 

In 1522, in a cave at Manresa, Spain, Our Lady revealed to St. Ignatius of Loyola that she desired everyone to prefer poverty and dishonor, to riches and honor.[9]  In other words, Our Lady instructed St. Ignatius that people should seek to have more crosses.

 

The great Mystical Doctor, St. John of the Cross, also teaches us that we should prefer and seek additional crosses.  Here are his words:

 

Strive always to prefer, not that which is easiest, but that which is most difficult;

 

Not that which is most delectable, but that which is most unpleasing;

 

Not that which gives most pleasure, but rather that which gives least;

 

Not that which is restful, but that which is wearisome;

 

Not that which is consolation, but rather that which is disconsolateness;

 

Not that which is greatest, but that which is least;

 

Not that which is loftiest and most precious, but that which is lowest and most despised;

 

Not that which is a desire for anything, but that which is a desire for nothing;

 

Strive to go about seeking not the best of temporal things, but the worst.

 

Strive thus to desire to enter into complete detachment and emptiness and poverty, with respect to everything that is in the world, for Christ’s sake.[10]  …

 

He who seeks not the cross of Christ seeks not the glory of Christ.[11]

 

 

Strategies for lightening our current crosses 

 

But how can we seek extra crosses when we find it is so difficult to even carry the (smaller) ones we now have – and when the crosses we now have seem so large?

 

Here are two strategies to use to lighten the crosses we now have (and to carry them better).

 

1.    Thank God for each cross[12] you have (even though you don’t feel thankful).  When you receive a cross, immediately sing a Gloria for the cross (or thank God for it in another way).  Be generous in how you thank Him for the Cross.  Do it on your knees, if that is possible.  But don’t delay your thanksgiving.
Do this every time you receive a cross, although you don’t feel like thanking Him.  This practice is meritorious and has an amazing power to lighten the crosses!  Try it and you will see!  It works! 

 

2.    Ask God for more crosses, unless He decides that it better serves Him not to send you more.[13] 
Don’t be afraid to pray for crosses.  God wants your happiness more than you do.  He will not “trick” you.  God teaches you (through His Church) that He wants you to seek crosses, and wants you to trust Him.  (Of course, also pray for the grace to carry well the crosses God sends you). 

The great spiritual masters (above) assure us that God desires us to pray for crosses.  It is astonishing how praying for more crosses lightens the crosses you now have!  Try it and you will see it is true!

 

St. John of the Cross assures us that seeking crosses will lighten the ones we already have.  Here are his words:

 

[I]t is meet [i.e., fitting] that the soul embrace these acts [viz., the ones quoted above from St. John of the Cross, preferring crosses] with all its heart and strive to subdue its will thereto.  For, if it performs them with its heart, it will very quickly come to find in them great delight and consolation, and to act with order and discretion.[14]

 

The Imitation of Christ warns us that the contrary is also true, viz., that the more we are unwilling to carry our crosses, the heavier they will be for us:

 

If thou carry it [viz., your cross] unwillingly, thou makest it a burden to thee and loadest thyself the more ….[15]

 

Again, although it is counterintuitive, when we thank God for our crosses and pray for more of them, this makes the crosses we already have lighter and easier.  The opposite attitude makes them heavier and harder to bear.

 

 

Conclusion                                           

 

Thank God for each cross he sends you (and thank Him each day when you continue to carry the same cross as the day before).

 

Pray also for more crosses (and, of course, pray for the grace to carry them well).  In praying for more crosses, we follow the mind of the Church, we gain merit and the help of Heaven (and we certainly need this help!). 

 

But also, thanking God for our crosses and praying for more of them, has a marvelous way of lightening the crosses we already have.  Try it and you will see!

 



[1]           “Enter ye in at the narrow gate:  for wide is the gate, and broad is the way that leadeth to destruction, and many there are who go in thereat.  How narrow is the gate, and strait is the way that leadeth to life: and few there are that find it!”  St. Matthew’s Gospel, 7:13 (emphasis added).


[2]           “If any man will come after Me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow Me.”  St. Matthew’s Gospel, 16:24 (emphasis added).

[3]           Spiritual Diary, p.82, St. Paul’s Editions ©1962, Boston, MA.

[4]           Imitation of Christ, Thomas a Kempis, Book II, Ch. 12.

 

[5]           Spiritual Diary, p.81, St. Paul’s Editions, Boston, MA, ©1962.

[6]           Imitation of Christ, Thomas a Kempis, Book II, Ch. 12.

[7]           Imitation of Christ, Thomas a Kempis, Book II, Ch. 11.

 

[8]           Imitation of Christ, Thomas a Kempis, Book II, Ch. 12.


[9]           Spiritual Exercises of St. Ignatius of Loyola, The Three Degrees of Humility. 

Our Lady summarized the first state of soul (degree of humility), which is necessary for salvation.  The second degree of humility is better and the third degree is best of all for us to seek.  Here are these three degrees of humility:

 

First Degree of Humility. The first manner of Humility is necessary for eternal salvation; namely, that I so lower and so humble myself, as much as is possible to me, that in everything I obey the law of God, so that, even if they made me lord of all the created things in this world, nor for my own temporal life, I would not be in deliberation about breaking a Commandment, whether Divine or human, which binds me under mortal sin.

 

Second Degree of Humility. The second is more perfect Humility than the first; namely, if I find myself at such a stage that I do not want, and feel no inclination to have, riches rather than poverty, to want honor rather than dishonor, to desire a long rather than a short life – the service of God our Lord and the salvation of my soul being equal; and so not for all creation, nor because they would take away my life, would I be in deliberation about committing a venial sin.

 

Third Degree of Humility. The third is most perfect Humility; namely, when – including the first and second, and the praise and glory of the Divine Majesty being equal – in order to imitate and be more actually like Christ our Lord, I want and choose poverty with Christ poor, rather than riches; opprobrium with Christ replete with it, rather than honors; and to desire to be rated as worthless and a fool for Christ, Who first was held as such, rather than wise or prudent in this world.

 

Id.

[10]         Ascent of Mount Carmel, Book I, ch.13, #6.

 

[11]         Sayings of Light and Love, St. John of the Cross, Maxim #102.

[12]         St. Francis of Assisi used this strategy.  He lightened his own heavy crosses by thanking God for them.  For example, one time while he was suffering severely during an illness, it is recorded that he prayed:

 

O God, I thank You for this trial which I am undergoing …. 

 

Spiritual Diary, p.82, St. Paul’s Editions ©1962, Boston, MA.

 

[13]         St. Francis of Assisi used this strategy.  He lightened his own heavy crosses by praying for more crosses.  For example, one time while he was suffering severely during an illness, it is recorded that he said:

 

O God, … I beg You, if it pleases You, to increase my pains.

 

Spiritual Diary, p.82, St. Paul’s Editions ©1962, Boston, MA.

[14]         Ascent of Mount Carmel, St. John of the Cross, Book I, ch.13, #7.

 

[15]         Imitation of Christ, Thomas a Kempis, Book II, Ch. 12.

 

St. Bernard of Clairvaux teaches the same truth in these words:

 

He who places himself entirely in the arms of Divine Providence and lets himself be carried by God, travels in a carriage, so to speak, and hardly feels the weight of his crosses.  He who does the opposite goes on foot, dragging his crosses weariedly and painfully.

 

Quoted in Spiritual Diary, Daughters of St. Paul Press, Boston, © 1962, p.220-21.

The N-SSPX Urges its Followers to Join the Pope in Praying with False Religions

 

On March 23, 2020, the “new”, liberal SSPX reported that Pope Francis has called for Catholics to jointly pray with non-Catholics.  Below, are the words of the N-SSPX’s report (typos in the original report), describing the pope’s ecumenical call to prayer:

 

A Call to United [sic] in Prayer

 

Pope Francis also took the occasion of his Angelus message to invite “the heads of the churches[1] and the leaders of all the Christian[2] communities, together with all Christians of the various confessions, to invoke the Almighty, the All Powerful God, by reciting contemporaneously the prayer that Our Lord Jesus has taught us.”  The Pope continued:

 

I therefore invite everyone to recite the Our Father at midday [noon Rome time] on March 25 next, on the day when many Christians recall the annunciation to the Virgin Mary of the Incarnation of the Word, so that the Lord may listen to the unanimous prayer of all his [sic] disciples that are preparing to celebrate the victory of the Risen Christ.[3]

 

In the N-SSPX’s report, the “new” SSPX encouraged its followers to join in the pope’s prayer with the heretical and schismatic groups.  Here are the N-SSPX’s words encouraging participation:

 

Pope Francis called on the world to unite in prayer to end the COVID-19 (“Coronavirus”) pandemic and stated he will offer an extraordinary blessing.

 

Those faithful who attend chapels administered by the United States District of the Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX) are encouraged to unite themselves in prayer with the Pope.[4]

 

By encouraging its followers to join in this prayer with the false (anti-Catholic) religions, the N-SSPX is promoting the conciliar church’s false ecumenism.  As Vatican II says: “[I]t is allowable, indeed desirable, that Catholics join in prayer with their separated brethren.”  Unitatis Redintegratio, §8.

 

The N-SSPX’s ecumenism contradicts Catholic Tradition and is a mortal sin.  The Catholic Church “has constantly forbidden Her children to hold any communication, in religious matters, with those who are separated from her communion”.[5]

 

From very ancient times, the Church has forbidden joining with heretics to pray: “If any bishop, or priest, or deacon, shall join in prayers with heretics, let him be suspended from communion”.[6]

 

Further, the Council of Laodicea decreed: “No one shall pray in common with heretics or schismatics”.  Council of Laodicea, Canon 33.

 

A reader might wrongly suppose that the only problem with joining the heretics or schismatics in prayer is that the wording of the prayers themselves might be heretical.  But the Catholic Church has always forbidden joining with heretics and schismatics in prayer even if the words of the prayer are good in themselves, such as the psalms.  Here are the words of Bishop Hay, teaching us about the Council of Carthage’s declaration which forbids Catholics to pray even the psalms with heretics:

 

[I]n one of Her [viz., the Catholic Church’s] most respected councils, held in the year 398, at which the great St. Augustine was present, She speaks thus:

None must either pray or sing psalms with heretics; and whosoever shall communicate with those who are cut off from the communion of the Church, whether clergyman or laic [i.e., layman], let him be excommunicated ….[7]

 

The Catholic Church’s constant prohibition against praying with heretics and schismatics makes perfect sense because those outside the Church maintain the posture of being enemies of God.[8]  It would be complete stupidity (as well as a great scandal) to join with God’s enemies to attempt to be heard by Him.  For “God doth not hear sinners: but if a man be a server of God, and doth His will, him He heareth.”  St. John’s Gospel, 9:31.[9]

 

 

Conclusion

 

The “new” SSPX has joined the conciliar church.  Whereas Archbishop Lefebvre rightly condemned the ecumenical joint prayer initiatives of the conciliar church, (e.g., at Assisi), the N-SSPX encourages its followers to pray with the heretics and schismatics, along with Pope Francis.



[1]           Like Pope Francis, the ecumenical “new” SSPX frequently uses the conciliar lingo of (falsely) calling the heretical sects by the term “churches”.  See one of countless N-SSPX examples here:  http://sspx.org/en/news-events/news/think-lent-tough-take-look-medieval-lenten-practices

 

This is un-Catholic!  The truth is that heretical and schismatic sects are not real churches.  They are merely lost sheep that have gone astray in one particular direction, e.g., over the same cliff or into the same swamp.  However, even such lost sheep who have wandered in a particular direction, do not thereby constitute another flock.

 

For more information regarding the truth that heretical and schismatic sects are not real churches, read Lumen Gentium Annotated, by Quanta Cura Press, p.135, footnote #142, © 2013, available at:

v  https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B49oPuI54eEGbzRhdmQ3X0Z6RFE/view (free) and

v  https://scribd.com/doc/158994906 (free)

 

v  at Amazon.com https://www.amazon.com/dp/1492107476?tag=duckduckgo-ffab-20&linkCode=osi&th=1&psc=1 (sold at cost).

 

[2]           Like Pope Francis, the ecumenical “new” SSPX frequently uses the conciliar lingo of (falsely) calling the heretical and schismatic sects by the name “Christian”.  See one of countless N-SSPX examples here: https://fsspx.news/en/news-events/news/moscow-and-constantinople-head-toward-schism-over-ukraine-41318

 

This is un-Catholic!  The truth is that heretical and schismatic sects are not real Christians because they do not really follow Christ and do not belong to His Church.  For a more complete explanation why heretics and schismatics are not really Christians, read this article: https://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/heretics-are-not-christians.html

 

[3]           https://sspx.org/en/news-events/news/pope-invites-faithful-unite-him-prayer-march-25-56461 (bracketed words in the N-SSPX’s report).

 

[4]           https://sspx.org/en/news-events/news/pope-invites-faithful-unite-him-prayer-march-25-56461 (parenthetical words in the N-SSPX’s report).


[5]           Quoted from The Sincere Christian, by Bishop George Hay, William Blackwood & Sons, Edinburgh, 1871, vol.2, p.373.

 

[6]           The Sincere Christian, by Bishop George Hay, William Blackwood & Sons, Edinburgh, 1871, vol.2, p.373, quoting Canon 44 of the apostolical canons.

[7]           The Sincere Christian, by Bishop George Hay, William Blackwood & Sons, Edinburgh, 1871, vol.2, p.373, quoting the Council of Carthage, iv, §§72 & 73.

[8]           God never gives the supernatural gift of the Catholic Faith without also giving Sanctifying Grace, which is the cause of supernatural Faith.  Summa, IIa IIae, Q.4, a.4, ad 3.  Therefore, if we suppose a person outside the visible Catholic Church were to receive Sanctifying Grace, he would thereby become a Catholic (and have the Catholic Faith) even if he were somehow not to realize he is Catholic.

 

[9]           “If I have looked at iniquity in my heart, the Lord will not hear me.”  Psalm, 65:18.  God is not moved by the prayers of those who are not in the state of Sanctifying Grace.  Summa, IIa IIae, Q.178, a.2, ad 1. 

Words to Live by – from Catholic Tradition

 

Try to live now in such a manner that at the moment of death you may be glad rather than fearful.

 

My Imitation of Christ, by Thomas a Kempis, Book I, Chapter 23.

Few Appreciate the Benefits from Our Lord’s 33 Years on Earth

God was not obliged to redeem man.  But having willed to do so, God the Father did not have to send Jesus to Earth for the salvation of mankind, as noted below from the 1912 Catholic Encyclopedia, volume 13, article: Salvation, page 407:

 

He [i.e., God the Father] might have done so [viz., redeemed man] by pardoning man’s sins without having recourse to the Incarnation of the Second Person of the Most Holy Trinity.

 

As the human race increased in number, the Father, in order to help souls reach Heaven, sent powerful leaders such as Moses, Abraham, Noah, and Isaac, and instructed man through the Old Testament and the Ten Commandments.  Because of man’s weakness, concupiscence, and pride which promoted countless evils, God had to chastise man in the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah and to chastise the world with the great flood.

 

But with a great love for man, God did send His only-begotten Son to spend 33 years on earth.  (The following is also taken from the 1912 Catholic Encyclopedia, volume 13, article: Salvation, page 407:

 

As Teacher, He established the reign of truth; as King, He supplied strength to His subjects; as Priest, He stood between Heaven and earth, reconciling sinful man with his angry God.

 

Over 33 years, He personally demonstrated what was necessary to save our souls.

 

Our Lord was sent to earth, born in poverty, and spent those 33 years teaching and personally living day-by-day, practicing many virtues: the Intellectual virtues of truth, wisdom, science, understanding; the Moral virtues of justice, fortitude, prudence, temperance, humility, meekness, modesty, patience; and the theological virtue of Charity and taught the theological virtues of Faith and Hope.  This Life of virtue is how Our Lord lived His daily life demonstrating complete perfection of the above virtues.  All to show us how to live day-to-day under all circumstances. 

 

Our Lord did not only show us how to live, He also gave us an integral “gauge” to tell us how well we are doing toward saving our souls.  It’s called a conscience.  Wow!  What a gift!

 

Because of Our Lord’s example, and using our conscience, man cannot excuse his poor behavior by claiming he cannot do better because he has no perfect example to use as a model for his conduct.  Our Lord is that perfect example, demonstrating day-after-day, for 33 years, what is required of man for his salvation.

 

Consider what the world would be like without the above virtues being lived in practice, but instead with only pride, selfishness, aggression, greed, and physical strength dominating everywhere, much as the world was at the time of Our Lord’s Passion and Death.  It would be a world where few would want to live and where no one would be happy or save his soul.

 

That is a great reason why we should thank God daily that He sent His only Son to earth to demonstrate just how we must live to achieve our goal of Heaven, after a happy life on earth.  There can be no excuses (i.e., “no one showed us how to live”).  He didn’t leave it only to verbal instruction.  He showed us the way, the truth, and the life.

 

The following is from The Imitation of Christ, Book III, chapter 18.

 

The Voice of Christ:

 

My child, I came down from heaven for your salvation and took upon Myself your miseries, not out of necessity but out of love, that you might learn to be patient and bear the sufferings of this life without repining.

 

The Disciple:

 

Oh, what great thanks I owe You, Who have shown me and all the faithful the good and right way to Your everlasting kingdom!  …  Had You not gone before and taught us, who would have cared to follow?  …

 

Behold even we who have heard of Your many miracles and teachings are still lukewarm; what would happen if we did not have such light by which to follow You?

The N-SSPX’s Liberal Slide Continues

The N-SSPX’s Liberal Slide Continues

      The N-SSPX promotes a conciliar speaker who is an expert in Pope John Paul II’s heretical “Theology of the Body”.

The SSPX’s 2019 doctrinal conference includes so-called “Father” Sean Kilcawley as a speaker.[1] He is a conciliar (supposed) “priest” who was “ordained” by the Diocese of Lincoln, NE in 2005 and is now employed there.[2]

The conciliar Lincoln Diocese tells us that “Kilcawley is a nationally recognized speaker on Theology of the Body” who “completed a License in Sacred Theology at the John Paul II institute for marriage and family” in 2013.[3]

  1. Here is the SSPX’s conference promotional announcement: https://web.cvent.com/event/a227e593-2d5c-4426-88dc-2c3d6c3c2134/websitePage:4a9f1ae7-fd5e-40ea-a47b-8748de11f650 ↑
  2. https://www.lincolndiocese.org/family-life/2052-about-fr-sean-kilcawley ↑
  3. https://www.lincolndiocese.org/family-life/2052-about-fr-sean-kilcawley ↑

The “new” liberal SSPX calls the new mass “Catholic worship”

 

In an article about a cathedral in Spain which had been a mosque until the year 1236 A.D., the “new” SSPX says that this cathedral has had “Catholic worship … exclusively and uninterruptedly” ever since the year 1236.  Here are the N-SSPX’s words:

 

This ancient church, built in 584 in honor of the martyr St. Vincent of Saragossa, had been transformed into a mosque during the Arab occupation, but was re-consecrated as a cathedral in 1236.  Since that date, Catholic worship has been exclusively and uninterruptedly celebrated in it.[1]

 

In this way, the N-SSPX indicates that the new mass is “Catholic worship”, since the new mass is said there – as shown in photographic evidence.[2]

 

Notice also that the N-SSPX refers to the Mass using the term “worship”.  Although the (Traditional) Mass is worship, the term “worship” is more general than the term “Mass” and is the term used by the conciliar church and by protestants to name what they do at church.  “Worship” is a more ecumenical term because it appears to include the “prayer services” of the protestants, which are certainly not the Mass.  The N-SSPX’s transition into the conciliar church becomes smoother by adopting the conciliar manner of speaking.



[2]           To see a picture of this cathedral set up for the new mass, with a table “altar” and president’s chair in the center, see this photo: https://cdn.britannica.com/700×450/45/181045-004-DC3231EE.jpg which comes from this Britannica.com article: https://www.britannica.com/topic/Mosque-Cathedral-of-Cordoba

 

 

Feminism is Anarchy in the Family

 

Anarchy is the “lack of obedience to an authority; insubordination: the anarchy of his rebellious teenage years.”[1]

 

Rebellion is anarchy.  Here are some examples of anarchy:

 

➢  Lucifer at creation

➢  Adam and Eve in the Garden

➢  Collegiality in the Church after Vatican II

➢  Feminism in the family 

 

Feminist propaganda glorifies selfish independence of women, rejecting the need for

a husband in the family, and certainly never accepts him as the family’s head.  These anti-Catholic feminist seeds produce a dysfunctional and miserable family

for all involved.  Thus, feminism is anti-family.

 

Our fallen human nature inclines toward disobedience, and feminism is simply one variation of Lucifer’s cry “non serviam!”  The Holy Ghost knew this and moved St. Paul to plainly set down God’s unchangeable Law (infallibly taught by the Catholic Church as well as the Natural Law):

 

Let women be subject to their husbands, as to the Lord: because the husband is the head of the wife, as Christ is the head of the Church.  He is the savior of His Body.  Therefore, as the Church is subject to Christ, so also let the wives be to their husbands in all things.  …  [L]et the wife fear her husband.[2]

 

Tragically, feminist propaganda is the new norm in the Western World and is a poison absorbed in various degrees by most wives in the conciliar church and by many in the Catholic Church.  Because of the liberalism all around us, we are all imbued by this spirit of liberalism and rebellion.

 

A central, anti-family, feminist idea is that all women, to be “fulfilled,”

must work outside the home, have a career, and be dependent on no one, least

of all, on a husband.  It is easy to see this idea is directly against Catholic dogma and the Natural Law.  The “new” SSPX is an enabler of this family-destroying propaganda when it hires wives/mothers (as it does), who have children and responsibilities at home.

 

From the beginning, the husband is the head, i.e., the leader of the family.  He is the one who proposed marriage.  He is most responsible for the family’s salvation, protection, financial well-being, and discipline when needed.  The wife is the heart

of the family, bringing generosity, love, support, humility, respect, loyalty,

modesty, etc.  They work as a team doing God’s will.

 

The husband, although the head, has the grave duty to love and cherish his wife and sacrifice for her like for his own body. 

 

Just as St. Paul counteracted a wife’s fallen tendency to disobey her husband, St. Paul also counteracted a husband’s fallen tendency to not love and sacrifice for his wife with complete generosity.  St. Paul infallibly taught:

 

Husbands, love your wives, as Christ also loved the church, and delivered himself up for it: that he might sanctify it, cleansing it by the laver of water in the word of life: that he might present it to himself a glorious church, not having spot or wrinkle, or any such thing; but that it should be holy, and without blemish.  So also, ought men to love their wives as their own bodies.  He that loveth his wife, loveth himself.  For no man ever hated his own flesh; but nourisheth and cherisheth it, as also Christ doth the church: because we are members of his body, of his flesh, and of his bones.  For this cause shall a man leave his father and mother, and shall cleave to his wife, and they shall be two in one flesh.  Nevertheless, let every one of you in particular, love his wife as himself ….[3]

 

Notice that these laws are not contingent on the other spouse fulfilling his/her own duty.  If one spouse fails to do his/her duty, that is no excuse for the other one.  St. Paul does not command a wife to obey her husband provided he loves her and delivers himself up for her.  St. Paul simply commands: “as the Church is subject to Christ, so also let the wives be to their husbands in all things”. 

 

A wife acts against God and Nature when she does not obey her husband.  She acts perversely.  A faithful Catholic woman (and one following Nature), wants to lean on her husband and have him provide for, protect, and guide her.

 

Likewise, St. Paul does not command a husband to love his wife and sacrifice himself for her provided she is loveable and that she obeys him.  A man acts against God and Nature who does not love, cherish, and sacrifice himself for his wife as for his own body.  Doing anything less is perverse.  Simply, a husband must be chivalrous, must love his wife and must sacrifice himself for her with complete generosity. 

 

A Catholic husband must love his family as Christ loves His Church.  A Catholic wife must obey her husband as the Blessed Virgin Mary obeyed St. Joseph.  For love of God (and following Nature), both must love and sacrifice for their family.  Doing this, the Catholic family is happy, harmonious, and holy.  Otherwise, the family is a failure. 

 

In contrast to this happy, harmonious family, a family infected with feminism forms the next generation to also be anarchists.  Thus, feminist anarchy in the home is a disaster which travels from one generation to the next, causing damnation.  One of the reasons for the General Judgment (at the end of the world), is so that we can see how our actions (such as having a matriarchal family), destroy the generations after we are in the grave.

 

 

Conclusion

 

Feminism denies the God-given and Natural order and authority in the family.  This is anarchy!  Anarchy means the family is a house divided against itself.  A house divided against itself will not stand.[4]  Thus, feminism destroys the family.

 

Because we are Catholic and are Soldiers of Christ, we must fight feminism!



[1]           See, e.g., http://www.dictionary.com/browse/anarchy

 

[2]           Ephesians, ch.5, vv. 22-33 (emphasis added).

[3]              Ephesians, ch.5, vv. 25-33 (emphasis added).

 

[4]           St. Matthew, 12:25.

The New Mass does not give grace

 

We must always judge the claims people make, according to our Traditional Catholic Principles.  As one example: it is a core, unshakable Traditional Catholic Principle that Vatican II is a bad tree which can only bear bad fruit.  . 

 

In his war against Our Lord, the devil has endless false arguments which seek to deceive Catholics that bad fruit is really good fruit.  One such Satanic attempt to deceive Catholics is the following superficial “argument” that falsely concludes that the new mass gives Grace:

 

➢  The new mass is a Mass.

 

➢  The Mass gives Grace.

 

➢  Therefore, the new mass gives Grace.

 

Our Catholic Common Sense (judging according to Traditional Catholic Principles) causes us to know immediately that the hand of Satan is in this “argument”, because the new mass is a bad fruit of a bad tree.  No bad fruit is good and something evil cannot be a source of Grace.  Our Catholic Common Sense immediately “smells” the work of Satan, even if a Traditional Catholic leader or an “angel of light”[1] were to insist otherwise.

 

We know that the new mass always offends God and is inherently evil.[2]  God never uses something inherently evil as a source of Grace.  (However, when a person is ignorant and witnesses evil, God might use that particular time and place as the occasion to give His Grace, to help that person see the evil and make changes in his life.)

 

Further, if every mass gave Grace, then all evil (but valid) masses would give Grace.  This cannot be!  This would mean all (valid) masses of heretics and schismatics give Grace and thus, are good because they (supposedly) sanctify souls! 

 

We would also be forced to conclude that the (valid) masses of Satanists give Grace and are good, even though they are designed and conducted to mock our Lord and offend him as greatly as possible through the gravest possible sacrileges.  Our Catholic Common Sense knows immediately that this is Satan’s “argument” and that it must be false to say all valid masses give Grace.

 

That argument (above) no more proves the new mass gives Grace, than does the following (false) “argument” prove that all prayer pleases God:

 

➢  The Pharisee’s prayer[3] is a prayer.

 

➢  Prayer pleases God.

 

➢  Therefore, the Pharisee’s prayer pleases God.

 

Through our Catholic Common Sense, we know immediately that this argument is false, and Our Lord told us that God did not hear the Pharisee’s prayer.

 

The devil knows we have Catholic Common Sense and that this “argument” won’t fool us if we judge (and reject) this argument according to our Traditional Catholic Principles.

 

For this reason, the devil has additional “layers” of false arguments so that he can attempt to deceive by a subsequent “layer” of argument any persons who had managed to remain undeceived by his earlier fallacy.  His next “layer” of false argument involves presenting his fallacious “reasoning”, adding something like “Archbishop Lefebvre said this” or “St. Pius X taught this”.

 

A striking (and unfortunate) example of this type of demonic “argument”, is the one which currently deceives Bishop Williamson (and, tragically, which he is spreading).

 

Bishop Williamson used to say the new mass is inherently evil and no one should ever attend it.[4]  He now says that the Council of Trent’s infallible teaching shows that the new mass gives Grace.  Here are Bishop Williamson’s recent words:

 

I’m sure you ask yourselves: “What kind of world are my children going to have to grow up in? How are they going to keep the Faith?”  Very good question.  By prayer and Charity and by frequenting the sacraments, so long as they are still available, so long as it’s at all still possible to reach the sacraments.  And some Novus – I’ve got into quite a lot of controversy for saying this, but it’s true – there is no question that some Novus Ordo Masses are valid.[5]  And if they’re valid, then it’s defined by the Council of Trent that grace passes, “ex opere operato”, is the strict phrase.[6]

 

However much this superficial invocation of the Council of Trent deceives Bishop Williamson himself, the fact remains that our Catholic Common Sense immediately “smells the rat” despite mention of Trent.  Despite Traditional-sounding buzzwords, we know that the new mass is evil and cannot be a source of Grace.

 

To unmask this false argument, let us look more closely than Bishop Williamson did (in the conference quoted above), at his claim that the Council of Trent shows that the new mass gives Grace.

 

The Council of Trent truly states that Sacraments are instrumental causes of Grace (“ex opere operato”).  See, session VII, canon VIII.  The Council of Trent distinguishes (on the one hand) the seven Sacraments – which cause Grace – from other good works and prayers (on the other hand) through which we obtain Grace, which are not themselves causes of Grace.  Reciting a Hail Mary is not a direct cause of Grace.  Rather, it is a pious occasion which disposes us and prompts God to give Grace – but not through that prayer as a cause.

 

However, although Catholics know that the Sacraments cause Grace, it is against Catholic Teaching and Catholic Common Sense to wrongly jump to the conclusion that every valid Sacrament gives Grace, as Bishop Williamson asserts.  In other words, although the Sacraments are causes of grace, this does not mean that there aren’t obstacles which sometimes serve to prevent a valid Sacrament from giving Grace. 

 

Bishop Williamson’s superficial “reasoning” misses three key distinctions: 

 

1.    No “Grace passes” (to use Bishop Williamson’s expression) to a person receiving the Holy Eucharist in mortal sin, even when the Host is validly consecrated;

 

2.    No “Grace passes” when the Holy Eucharist is validly consecrated by a heretic or schismatic; and

 

3.    No “Grace passes” when the Holy Eucharist is validly consecrated but the rite of the Mass is sinful.

 

Below we examine these distinctions which show the falsehood of Bishop Williamson’s rash, overly broad claim that every time there is a valid Sacrament, “Grace passes” (i.e., is given).

 

 

1.       No “Grace Passes” to a Person in Mortal Sin Even When the Holy

          Eucharist is Validly Consecrated.

 

When Bishop Williamson says that, if a Sacrament is “valid, then it’s defined by the Council of Trent that grace passes”, he distorts the Council of Trent and makes a false, overly broad “rule” that a valid Sacrament always gives Grace.  If his rule were correct, then to receive the Holy Eucharist in mortal sin would give Grace.  But such Communion is a mortal sin of sacrilege, not a source of Grace.  Thus, Bishop Williamson’s rule is false (because it is overly broad) that every valid Sacrament gives Grace.

 

 

2.       No “Grace Passes” When the Holy Eucharist is Validly Consecrated

          by a Heretic.

 

Bishop Williamson’s second crucial omission is failing to consider valid Sacraments performed by heretics and schismatics.  Such (valid) Sacraments are mortal sins and God does not give His Grace through those Sacraments.  Here is how St. Thomas Aquinas explains this important truth:

 

[S]ome have contended that heretics, schismatics, and the excommunicate, who are outside the pale of the Church, cannot perform this Sacrament [viz., the Holy Eucharist]. But herein they are deceived, because, as Augustine says (Contra Parmen. ii), “it is one thing to lack something utterly, and another to have it improperly”; and in like fashion, “it is one thing not to bestow, and quite another to bestow, but not rightly.” … [S]ince the consecration of the Eucharist is an act which follows the power of order, such persons as are separated from the Church by heresy, schism, or excommunication, can indeed consecrate the Eucharist, which on being consecrated by them contains Christ’s true body and blood; but they act wrongly, and sin by doing so; and in consequence they do not receive the fruit of the sacrifice [viz., Grace]….

 

Summa, III, Q.82, a.7, Respondeo. 

 

This is a second reason Bishop Williamson is plainly wrong in his superficial misuse of the Council of Trent to support his assertion that “Grace passes” with every valid Sacrament. 

 

For any reader interested in further enumerations of the Catholic teaching that no “Grace passes” when valid Sacraments are given by heretics, see the teaching of St. Augustine, Pope Gregory XVI, St. Fulgentius, St. Bonaventure and St. Jerome, quoted (with citations) in Lumen Gentium Annotated, by Quanta Cura Press, pp. 117, 135 & 138, © 2013, available at: scribd.com/doc/158994906 (free) & at Amazon.com (sold at cost).

 

Concluding this section: Plainly, our Catholic Common Sense is confirmed by the teachings of the Catholic Faith, viz., even if a particular evil mass were valid, it is false and rash to judge that this mass gives Grace (as Bishop Williamson asserts).  This truth applies to all heretics and adherents to any false religions, including the new conciliar religion.[7]

 

 

3.       No “Grace Passes” When the Holy Eucharist is Validly Consecrated

          But the Rite of the Mass is Sinful.

 

Even when a Sacrament is valid, the Council of Trent nonetheless infallibly declares it is a mortal sin to omit the Catholic rites surrounding that Sacraments’ Matter and Form.  Here are the Council’s words:

 

If anyone saith, that the received and approved rites of the Catholic Church, wont to be used in the solemn administration of the sacraments, may be contemned, or without sin be omitted … let him be anathema.

 

Session VII, canon XIII.[8]

 

Thus, the Council of Trent verifies our Catholic Common Sense that a valid sacrament can be a mortal sin (and thus, not give Grace), because of omissions from (or additions to) the Catholic sacramental rite.  This is precisely the case of the new mass, which changes the Catholic rite surrounding the Sacrament’s Matter and Form so that it is inherently a mortal sin of sacrilege and thus, cannot cause Grace (even if we were to suppose the consecration were valid).

 

Let us pray for Bishop Williamson that he correct his grave errors promoting the new mass.  He has done great good in the past and it is possible for him to still do great good in the future.

 

 

 

 



[1]           “But though … an angel from heaven preach a gospel to you besides that which we have preached to you, let him be anathema.”   Galatians, 1:8.  St. Paul further explains that this “angel of light” is the devil: “Satan himself transformeth himself into an angel of light.”  II Cor. 11:14.

 

[2]           http://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/attendance-at-new-mass.html

[3]           “The Pharisee standing, prayed thus with himself:  ‘O God, I give thee thanks that I am not as the rest of men, extortioners, unjust, adulterers, as also is this publican.  I fast twice in a week:  I give tithes of all that I possess.’”  St. Luke, 18:11-12.

 

[5]           Bishop Williamson here supposes that if a new mass were to have a valid consecration, this would automatically mean that the new mass is a valid mass.  For purposes of this article, we leave aside – but do not grant – this unsupported assumption. 

 

Church law treats the Mass’s Offertory as one of the three main parts of the Mass without attending which, a Catholic has not attended Mass.  Thus, even if a person were to assume that a new mass’s consecration were valid, this does not allow us to conclude that such a new mass would be a valid mass as such, since the conciliar “offertory” is so radically different and might properly be called the very antithesis of the Catholic Offertory.  Thus, even if a person were to suppose that a new mass were to have a valid consecration, this is not enough to show that it is a valid mass because the new mass contains an “anti-Offertory”.

Also, Bishop Williamson here implicitly makes the unsupported assumption that some conciliar ordinations and consecrations are known to be valid – which is a necessary assumption to support his supposition that some new masses have definitely valid consecrations.  But the truth is that the validity of all conciliar “ordinations” and “consecrations” is inherently doubtful.  For a thorough explanation of this, see:

 

➢  http://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/new-ordination-doubtful.html

 

➢  https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B49oPuI54eEGd2RRcTFSY29EYzg/view

➢  https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B49oPuI54eEGZVF5cmFvMGdZM0U/view

 

[6]           May 20, 2016 conference available here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=GGcr24n8fJo begin at minute 22:00 (emphasis added).

[7]           We reject the new mass and all other aspects of new conciliar religion, just as we reject all aspects of all other false religions.  Although we reject their objective errors, we do not judge other persons’ subjective culpability for holding those grave errors.

 

For a thorough explanation of our Catholic duty to judge objective errors but not judge other persons’ subjective culpability, see the discussion of the moral sin of rash judgment here: http://catholiccandle.neocities.org/faith/against-sedevacantism.html#section-5

[8]           For a thorough treatment of the evil of changing the Catholic rite of the Mass and thereby causing a valid Mass to be a mortal sin, not a source of Grace, see Summa Theologiae Moralis, vol. III, De Sacramentis, H. Noldin, S.J., p.245 et seq., Oeniponte, 1920.

Why is the indult Mass accepted by the compromising “trads”?

The answer, I believe, is that most people don’t realize the damage caused by the indult Mass, or they falsely believe the indult Mass is better than no Mass at all, (i.e., they must have a Mass).  Or it is easier to accept the indult Mass to go along to get along.  By attending the indult Mass a person implicitly shows that he accepts the new mass because the indult is only allowed under this condition.

Attending an indult Mass gives bad example, as does approval of the indult Mass by the N-SSPX, Bishop Williamson’s group, and other compromise groups.

Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre stated in a letter of Mar. 18, 1989, to Father Daniel Couture, “These Masses are scams which lead the faithful to compromise their principles!  Many have already abandoned them.”

If you attend the indult, you get a Faith-destroying sermon.  Who can believe a priest trained in Modernist schools and seminary for his whole life would give a Faith-strengthening sermon?  Not a chance.  This puts your Faith in jeopardy.  It’s all a plan to liberalize the faithful to accept the conciliar church.  It is offered as a “treat” but is actually a “trick.”

Archbishop Lefebvre understood that the enemies of Christ’s Kingship occupying Rome would not blush at using this Most Sacred Gift of God, the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, in order to lure the resisting Catholics into the conciliar church.[1]  So, his warnings ring true for all the congregations and clergy who compromise (in any way!) with Vatican II, the new mass, the new Code of Canon Law, the new Profession of Faith and other conciliar changes!  Archbishop Lefebvre initiated a Catholic Resistance; we simply must continue resisting modernist Rome, “until we have a perfectly Catholic successor of Peter.”  (Letter of Archbishop Lefebvre to Four Bishops of SSPX, Aug. 20, 1987.)

To improve relations with Rome, the N-SSPX publicly thanked Rome for a (false) “freeing” of the Mass, (the July 2007 motu proprio), which can be used only by a priest who accepts the new mass.  Because of this and many other N-SSPX compromises, including unnecessary sacramental indults (for confession and marriage), uncompromising traditional Catholics should not attend N-SSPX Masses or support the N-SSPX.

By attending the indult Mass wherever it is offered, or by supporting the groups who approve attending it (e.g., the N-SSPX and Bishop Williamson’s group), you put your Faith in jeopardy.

Further, former Pope Benedict XVI wrote:

The faithful who ask for the celebration of the forma extraordinaria [i.e., the Latin Tridentine Mass] must not in any way support or belong to groups which show themselves to be against the validity or legitimacy of the Holy Mass [i.e., the conciliar mass] or the Sacraments celebrated in the forma ordinaria.[2]

I believe attendance at the indult Mass would be down if the priest saying the indult would start out by explaining each time that “If you are attending this Latin Mass under the Motu Proprio, you acknowledge that you accept the new mass.  If not, please leave and don’t come back.”

Not only did the N-SSPX thank Rome for the (false) "freeing" the Mass, they explicitly accept 95% of VC II.  Yet, many still overlook this, believing God will understand.  He is certainly merciful, but He is also just.

Below are other reasons for staying far away from the indult.  Would you attend the indult Mass offered by a priest who also offers a Black Mass?  If not, then why accept a priest who offers the sacrilegious new Mass?  The new mass is inherently harmful to souls and to the Catholic Faith.  Thus, it is a sacrilege because it fits the definition of sacrilege: viz., the “irreverent treatment of the sacred.”[3]

If a person attends an indult Mass in a church that is also used for the new mass, then he willingly uses for worship a place which is also set aside for the commission of sacrilege.  A place used for sacrilege is far more unfitting for Divine worship than a “neutral” place, like a rented meeting hall. 

Thus, when traditional Catholics compromise by choosing an indult Mass, they accept the conciliar hierarchy’s bait and they presume they will be strong enough and wise enough to discern and reject the accompanying conciliar poison.

 

That is the exact excuse friends of ours made to us in the late 1960s, when we left our local diocese parish in order to remain traditional Catholics.  They felt we should stay to fight on the inside and help the parish reject liberalism.  However, absolutely none who stayed on the inside remained faithful to the Catholic Faith.  None.

The question arises as to whether or not the indult Mass gives grace.  Although we know that God gives grace to whomever He pleases, whenever He pleases, He does not give grace because we offend Him (as we would offend Him by attending an indult Mass).

In conclusion, Archbishop Lefebvre called the indult Mass a scam, i.e., “a fraudulent or deceptive act or operation; to deceive and defraud.”[4]  He also stated in his Aug. 29, 1987, letter to the four new bishops of the SSPX that Rome permitted the indult Mass “in order to lure the resisting Catholics into the conciliar church!” 

So, let’s heed the faith-saving advice of Archbishop Lefebvre and stay completely away from all indult Masses and all compromise groups accepting indult Masses, like the N-SSPX.



[1]           The Vatican has clearly said that it continues on the course of post-conciliar errors and that these motu proprio (indult) Masses are designed to integrate traditional Catholics into the conciliar church. See, e.g., this article, where the Vatican calls the traditional Mass an “ecumenical bridge” and outlines the plan for using it as a step to blending the new mass and the traditional Mass.  http://www.zenit.org/article-32593?l=english – see also, http://www.catholicnews.com/data/stories/cns/1101922.htm.

 

Cardinal Mayer (former president of the Ecclesia Dei Commission in charge of indult groups) candidly admitted the conciliar trap: “Sometimes a temporary solution may be necessary, such as allowing them [viz., conservative Catholics] the possibility of celebrating the Holy Mass [of Pope St. Pius V].” See, Letter of Cardinal Mayer to Msgr. May, L’Homme Nouveau, March 19, 1989 (emphasis added), quoted at: http://www.sspx.org/motu_proprio/attendance_at_the_indult_vanes.htm

[2]           May 13, 2011 Instruction “Universae Ecclesiae” on the implementation of the Motu Proprio “Summorum Pontificum”, ¶19 [bracketed words added for clarity].

 

[3]           Summa, IIa IIae, Q. 99, a.1.

 

[4]           Quoted from the Merriam-Webster Dictionary https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/scam